Abstract
Context
Hydrological and land use changes for human purposes, have resulted in the increased fragmentation of river landscapes and the loss of aquatic habitats, leading to profound changes in fish diversity and productivity.
Objectives
In the fluvial Lake Saint-Pierre (St. Lawrence River, Canada), we studied how agricultural practices and water-flow regulation have impacted the area and connectivity of spawning habitats of northern pike (Esox lucius).
Methods
Northern pike spawning and nursery habitats were modelled over a 49-year period (1965–2013) to estimate effective spawning area under four contrasting hydrological conditions.
Results
Simulations coupled with land cover analyses revealed that natural flow conditions historically favourable for fish reproduction (high and stable water flows) have been lost due to human activities. The highest potential for reproduction and habitat connectivity have been lost due to (1) intensive agriculture and ploughing of natural vegetation in the upper floodplain that overlaps suitable spawning areas for northern pike, and (2) flow regulation that has lowered and shortened spring floods and dried spawning grounds more frequently.
Conclusions
To restore the St. Lawrence River functions, we propose to reconvert the portion of the floodplains that is vital to fish, but is currently used by intensive agriculture, into natural wetlands or perennial crops and to restore a more natural flow regime by extending the duration of floods between spawning and nursery periods. The highest priority for habitat restoration should target the most effective and recurrent spawning habitats, ditch and stream networks, and connected managed wetlands.
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
Introduction
In unaltered rivers, floodplains are highly productive and dynamic environments at the interface between aquatic and terrestrial ecosystems. They provide a mosaic of temporary habitats required by a large number of freshwater fish species to complete their life cycle. Given the high mortality rate in the early life stages of fishes, quality spawning and nursery habitats are crucial for fish recruitment (Bayler 1991; Gorski et al. 2011). However, floodplains are under increasing anthropogenic pressure around the world (Tockner and Stanford 2002) and their connectivity level highly affects their response to human disturbances (Wohl 2017). Impacts of water flow regulation and agricultural expansion are major threats to floodplain ecosystems (Beesley et al. 2014; Fernandes et al. 2015), where potential spawning habitats can turn into mortality traps (e.g. Jeffres and Moyle 2012; Sheaves et al. 2014) and lead to significant fish recruitment failures (e.g. Goto et al. 2015).
The natural flow regime in floodplains (i.e. magnitude, duration and periodicity of water levels) is highly variable in space and time, which impacts fish habitat area and connectivity (Junk et al. 1989; Wiens 2002). Although the flooding of large areas for extended periods of time can improve recruitment success of riverine fish, a rapid decrease in water discharge during early development can suddenly isolate spawning and nursery habitats, resulting in high egg and larval mortality (Bayler 1991; Gorski et al. 2011). In addition, water-flow regulation has significantly altered natural flow regimes in many river systems around the world, which can be critical for overall fish production (Nilsson et al. 2005). Reduction in spring water discharges has limited the duration of floods and their inter-annual variability, which has affected the quality of river habitat and resulted in a decline in fish abundance (e.g. Mingelbier et al. 2008; Farrell et al. 2010; Goto et al. 2015).
Land cover change is one of the most important factors altering habitat quality and connectivity of floodplains (Tockner and Stanford 2002). The conversion of large areas of natural floodplains to intensive agriculture has resulted in a net loss of fish habitat (Baber et al. 2002), a reduction in overall productivity (Matsuzaki et al. 2011), and threatened the long-term persistence of several fish species (Fernandes et al. 2015). In addition, transportation infrastructure, such as roads along rivers, can isolate portions of the floodplain, reducing access to critical habitats (Van der Ree et al. 2011; Blanton and Marcus 2014). Alternatively, landscape features such as ditch networks (Washitani 2007) can facilitate larval dispersal via passive transport at low water velocities (Schiemer et al. 2003). Such alternative use of man-made structure can help maintain floodplain connectivity in an anthropized landscape.
The northern pike (Esox lucius) has often been used as a model species because it is an early-spring spawner and is typical of the floodplain (Casselman and Lewis 1996; Mingelbier et al 2008; Farrell et al 2010). Pike recruitment is positively influenced by the abundance and quality of spawning habitat, defined by high water temperatures and high water levels maintained for several weeks after egg deposition on favourable types of vegetation (Johnson 1957; Casselman and Lewis 1996). Pike abundance has been declining in several major river systems for decades (Boët et al. 1999; Raat 2001), including the St. Lawrence River (Smith et al. 2007). Spawning habitats and nursery habitats of northern pike have been studied over the past 50 years in the floodplain of the St. Lawrence River (Canada) to determine how habitat connectivity and hydrological variability interact to modify the distribution of effective spawning habitats (Foubert et al. 2018). The effective spawning habitats of northern pike was defined as habitats that permit survival of eggs and larvae, while affording larvae access to nursery areas that are essential for successful recruitment to the adult population. As the simulations in Foubert et al. (2018) were carried out in a reconstructed "unaltered" landscape to measure the intrinsic natural variability of the river, they provided a way to compare a simulated pristine environment with a present-day landscape altered by human activities.
In this study, we hypothesised that effective spawning habitat for northern pike gradually changed over the twentieth century, as water flows were regulated and extensive agricultural practices developed. More specifically, in Lake Saint-Pierre (St. Lawrence River, Canada), we will first assess the changes in pike spawning and nursery habitats since 1965 with changes in local agriculture practices, secondly we will test the effects of water flow and land cover changes on connectivity between spawning and nursery habitats under four contrasting hydrological conditions, and thirdly, we will estimate the loss of connected habitat due to changes in land cover to identify current effective spawning habitat and the areas most valuable to protect and restore. These three objectives are represented in a conceptual diagram that describes the methodological steps leading to the main results of the study (Fig. 1).
Method
Study Area
Lake Saint-Pierre is the largest fluvial lake of the St. Lawrence River (Fig. 2), one of the largest river systems in the world in terms of length (~ 1200 km), watershed area (1,344,200 km2), and average annual discharge (10,270 m3 s−1 at Sorel; Morin and Bouchard 2000). Since the beginning of the industrial era, cumulative anthropogenic pressures have altered the Lake Saint-Pierre ecosystem. The gradual excavation of the navigation channel (now 11.3 m deep and ~ 250 m wide) between Montreal and Quebec City began around 1840 and was completed in 1998. Water regulation in the St. Lawrence River began in 1911 with the harnessing of the Ottawa River, its main tributary, for hydroelectric power generation, flood control, and navigation purposes. The regulation of the St. Lawrence River was further enhanced by the construction in 1958 of the Moses-Saunders and Beauharnois Power Dams that control the Lake Ontario—St. Lawrence River system (Morin and Bouchard 2000; Carpentier 2003). In addition, the development of large urban centres (e.g. Montréal, Trois-Rivières, and Québec City), intensive agriculture along the river and in the floodplain, and transportation infrastructure along the St. Lawrence River have had serious impacts on fish habitat availability and quality. Over time, perennial cover (e.g. pasture), which constitutes potential fish habitat in the floodplain, has been replaced by annual crops (e.g. corn, soy beans) with no potential for fish spawning; this phenomenon has accelerated since the early 1990s (Fecteau and Poissant 2001; de la Chenelière et al. 2014). To compensate for the loss of fish habitat, approximately 1300 ha of the Lake Saint-Pierre floodplain have been managed since the 1980s (Mingelbier and Douguet 1999). Managed wetlands are surrounded by dikes and partially controlled to maintain high and stable water levels, extend the duration of spring floods, and accelerate water warming. During spring floods, fish use these managed wetlands to spawn. They are subsequently drained in early June to Lake Saint-Pierre.
Lake Saint-Pierre and its archipelago were included on UNESCO’s World Heritage Biosphere List in 2000. The shallow depth (< 3 m), slow lateral slope, and low current velocity (< 0.5 m s−1) contributes to the formation of extensive macrophyte beds (Centre Saint-Laurent 1998). The annual variability of spring water discharge, ranging between 6500 and 17,500 m3 s−1 at Sorel, is a key mechanism for maintaining wetland vegetation in floodplains (Morin et al. 2005).
Data collection
Potential habitat modelling in an unaltered floodplain (1965–2013)
Several high resolution hydrodynamic and biological models have been developed in the St. Lawrence River by Environment Canada to simulate the vegetation composition of the floodplain (e.g. deep marshes, shallow marshes and shrub) in Lake Saint-Pierre under various hydrological conditions (Morin et al. 2000, 2003; Turgeon and Morin 2005). As a result, natural plant succession in the littoral zone can be reconstructed annually for the period 1965 to 2013. As these simulations exclude anthropogenic effects, we used them to estimate the full spawning or nursery habitat potential of northern pike in a natural environment annually for the period 1965 to 2013. Habitat suitability indices (HSIs) were developed to map the maximum spawning habitat (i.e., Week0: the date varies every year according to water temperature, see Mingelbier et al. 2008) and nursery habitat 5 weeks after the start of the free-swimming stage (HSInursery at Week5, see Foubert et al. 2018).
Land cover categories
Land cover in the Lake Saint-Pierre floodplain was described for three reference years using aerial photographs taken in 1964 and 1997 (Richard et al. 2011), and satellite images from 2014 (ECCC and MDDELCC 2018). Land cover classes distinguish landscape features such as lakes, streams, pastures, soybeans, corns, roads, forests, marshes, swamps, bare ground etc. (see detailed land cover classes in ECCC and MDDELCC 2018). In the present study, land cover classes were aggregated in six categories for the Lake Saint-Pierre floodplain, from most suitable to least suitable for pike spawning: (1) suitable wetlands (e.g. wet meadows, swamps and marshes), (2) ditch and stream networks, (3) perennial cover (e.g. pasture and forage crops), (4) unsuitable wetlands and wooded areas (e.g. peatlands and coniferous stand), (5) roads and urban areas, and (6) annual crops (i.e. soybeans, corn, wheat, vegetables, oats, barley and other grains; see land cover categories and their associated land cover classes in Online Resource 1). Only tree swamps differed in quality between spawning and nursery habitats. We considered tree swamps were suitable for nurseries (e.g. food supply) but unsuitable for spawning due to the lack of appropriate substrate for egg deposition. In addition, the managed wetlands were included in the analysis because they are used by pike and other fish species during their early stages of development (Mingelbier and Douguet 1999 updated with field observations).
The next three sections explain the analyses performed (Fig. 1).
Historical habitat changes related to agriculture practices (objective 1)
As annual crop production gradually increased between 1964, 1997, and 2014, we conducted a linear interpolation using these three reference years to estimate annual habitat area changes between 1965 and 2013. The spawning and nursery habitat changes related to annual crop production was calculated for each year by overlaying the corresponding land uses and potential habitats modelled in a reconstructed "unaltered" landscape. Spearman’s Rank correlation coefficients were used to assess: (1) the relationship between total potential spawning habitat change due to annual crop production and water discharge at spawning (Week0), and (2) the relationship between total potential nursery habitat change due to annual crops and water discharge when larvae became free-swimming (Week5).
Habitat connectivity for four hydrological profiles (objective 2)
Selected hydrological profiles
Since the flow regime of the Lake Saint-Pierre floodplain varied over the study period (1965–2013), the evolution of water discharge between the maximum spawning time (Week0) and the free-swimming stage (Week5) was classified into four distinct hydrological profiles: (1) stable-low, (2) stable-high, (3) increasing, and (4) decreasing. Four years of the 1965–2013 period were chosen to represent the four profiles to assess their influence on pike habitats (1965, 1973, 1983, and 1998, respectively; Table1). An analysis covering the 1965–2013 period revealed that the profile recurrences were 16% for stable-low, 16% for stable-high, 14% for increasing and 53% for decreasing discharges. During the unregulated period of 1883–1910, preceding the Ottawa River regulation, profiles were only increasing (61%) or stable (39%) (Le Pichon et al. 2018; Morin and Bouchard 2000).
Connectivity estimate
A least-cost approach to modelling movement across landscapes (Adriaensen et al. 2003) was used to quantify connectivity between spawning habitat at Week0 and nursery habitat at Week5. Using this model, every landscape element was assigned a ‘resistance’ value based on its restricting/facilitating effects on animal movements and functional distances were calculated using the Minimal Cumulative Resistance concept in both upstream and downstream directions (Le Pichon et al. 2006a; Caldwell and Gergel 2013; Hanke et al. 2013; Roy and Le Pichon 2017).
We assigned resistance values to landscape features that affect larval dispersal capacities or mortality when they leave spawning habitats. Factors driving floodplain permeability were water depth, current velocities and hydro-resistance of some land cover types (e.g. “dense vegetation” which was defined as marshes, wet meadows and swamps in shallow water depths < 20 cm). Resistance values ranged from 0.1 to 10,000 depending on whether they facilitate (R < 1), are neutral (R = 1) or impede movement and decrease survival (R > 1). Downstream resistance values < 1 were assigned to classes of current velocities ranging from 2 to 10 cm s−1, which reflected habitats with current-assisted drift. Rx were calculated as inversely proportional to the mean current velocity of each class (Rx = 1/Vx, Table 2). A neutral resistance value of 1 was assigned to (1) ditches and stream networks, (2) permanent structures such as culverts and water control structures allowing larvae to cross roads and managed wetlands dikes, and (3) current velocities below 2 cm s−1 in both directions. Maximum resistance values, acting as non-passable barriers (R = 10,000), were assigned to (1) dewatered areas (water depth ≤ 0 cm), (2) current velocities > 10 cm s−1 in downstream direction (Peake 2004) and > 2 cm s−1 in upstream direction (larval are not able to swim against current), (3) emerged roads and managed wetland dikes and (4) “dense vegetation”, which inhibit larval dispersal (Table 2). Emerged roads and “dense vegetation” for contrasting hydrological conditions in the lake were identified using simulated water depths and 1-m resolution topography provided by LiDAR data (Fortin et al. 2002). Agricultural crop types in the contemporary landscape (i.e. 2014) were not included in connectivity estimates as they are not believed to restrict connectivity or cause mortality during larval movement.
Functional distance maps between spawning and nursery habitats were performed using the freeware Anaqualand 2.0 (Le Pichon et al. 2006b). The functional distance is defined as the sum of the resistance*distance the larvae will encounter along their path. Since the functional distance incorporates resistance values, it could be lower or higher than the physical instream distance for the same path (i.e. minimum distance within the limits of the watercourse).
Connected and disconnected spawning habitats
The mobility coefficient is derived from the stage-specific larval swimming capacities and the potential passive transport facilitated by local currents at the beginning of the free-swimming stage (Week5). The maximal value was set to α = 6000 m which corresponds to the maximum distance travelled at 1 cm s−1 by a neutral particle in the water column over a one-week period in the St. Lawrence River (see sensitivity analyses in Online Resource 2). When the functional distance between a spawning habitat and a nursery was ≤ 6000 mfunctional (i.e. the maximal α), the spawning habitat was considered to be connected (Foubert et al. 2018); whereas, when the functional distance exceeded 6000 mfunctional, the spawning habitat was considered disconnected. Connected and disconnected spawning habitats were mapped in ArcGIS 10.1 and their surfaces were quantified (surface expressed in ha) for the four selected hydrological profiles (1965, 1973, 1983, and 1998).
In addition, the effects of each hydrologic and land cover characteristics added successively on connectivity estimate (i.e. water depth, current speed, dense vegetation, and roads/managed wetland dikes) were quantified (Table 3). Direct losses correspond to potential spawning habitats spatially overlaid on restricted landscape features. Technically, spawning habitats were overlaid on landscape features in ArcGIS 10.1 to estimate spawning habitat loss due to: (1) dewatering occurring between Week0 and Week5 (water depth ≤ 0, Table 2), (2) increased current velocities (> 10 cm s−1), (3) emerged roads, and (4) dense vegetation. Indirect losses were considered as potential spawning habitats that were not connected to a nursery because of limited landscape features that act as physical barriers to larval dispersal.
Effective spawning habitats (objective 3)
For the four selected hydrological profiles (stable-low, stable-high, increasing and decreasing water discharges), the total area of connected spawning habitats (i.e. including the effects of water depth, current velocity, dense vegetation, ditch and stream networks, and emerged roads/managed wetland dikes) was overlaid on the six land cover categories of the contemporary description (i.e. 2014, see Online Resource 1) in ArcGIS 10.1. This allowed us to quantify and differentiate the area of (1) effective spawning habitat, which corresponds to the overlap of connected spawning habitats with suitable land cover categories (i.e. suitable wetlands, perennial crops and drainage ditches), and (2) ineffective spawning habitat that overlaps with inadequate land cover categories (i.e. unsuitable wetlands and wooded, annual crops, and roads and urban areas). Finally, the effective spawning habitat areas obtained for the four hydrological profiles were spatially overlaid to identify the most recurrent effective spawning habitats.
Results
Historical habitat changes related to agriculture practices
With the expansion of annual crops, up to 2446 ha of potential spawning habitat and 1188 ha of potential nursery habitat have been lost in the Lake Saint-Pierre floodplain between 1965 and 2014 (Fig. 3). The impacts of agriculture have been particularly severe since 1990, from when the total spawning habitat area did not exceed 5500 ha. The total loss of both spawning and nursery habitats was positively correlated with water discharges at Week0 and at Week5, respectively (P < 0.05, Spearman’s rank correlation). The impact of agriculture on potential spawning and nursery habitats occurred at modelled discharges > 12,000 m3 s−1 with the largest losses at discharges > 14,000 m3 s−1 (Fig. 3).
Habitat availability and connectivity
Potential habitats during contrasting hydrological profiles
The total area of potential spawning and nursery habitats available annually was determined based on hydrological conditions (Table 1, Fig. 4). High spring water discharges resulted in a large area of potential spawning (1998) and nursery habitats (1983), while low water discharge resulted in the smallest areas of potential spawning habitat (1965), and a decreasing profile led to the smallest areas of potential nursery habitats (1998). At medium to high water discharge, managed wetlands generated up to 571 ha and 722 ha of potential spawning and nursery habitats, respectively, which represented between 10 and 13% of the maximum habitat available in Lake Saint-Pierre.
Connected and disconnected spawning habitats
Due to the impact of hydrological variability and anthropogenic landscape characteristics on habitat connectivity, 8–68% of potential spawning habitat was lost (dewatering or disconnected nurseries; Table 3). First, the largest disconnected spawning areas appeared during the decreasing profile between the maximum spawning time (Week0) and the free-swimming stage (Week5) due to the dewatering of 62% of potential spawning areas. Second, the increase in water currents above the 10 cm s−1 thresholds after spawning has transformed high-quality habitats into low-quality habitat and appeared frequently during the increasing profile. These fast water currents acting as physical barriers prevented access to 2% of spawning habitats during the increasing profile. Third, the dense vegetation slightly reduced the total area of potential spawning habitats (1%) during the stable-high and decreasing profiles and acted as a physical barrier during the decreasing profile. Finally, 2% of potential spawning habitat disappeared in stable-high and decreasing profiles due to the surface occupied by emerged roads. Although spawning habitat losses were small, emerged roads also served as physical barriers during stable-high profiles.
The largest area of connected spawning habitat occurred during the stable-high profile, one-third resulting from the overlap between potential spawning and nursery habitats, and two-thirds related to the larval mobility coefficient (α = 6000 mfunctional), connecting potential spawning areas to distant nursery areas (Fig. 5). The overlap between potential spawning and nursery habitats generated large areas of connected spawning habitats, especially when water discharge remained stable between Week0 and Week5. The overlapping habitat areas reached 55% of the total connected spawning area in the stable-low profile, 28% in the stable-high profile, 0.2% in the increasing profile and 10% in the decreasing profile (see dark blue in Fig. 5). Moreover, larval mobility (α) allowed attaining distant nursery habitats (1) where potential spawning and nursery habitats overlapped, and (2) when hydrological conditions did not dewater spawning areas and created large nursery habitats (Fig. 5). The total area of connected spawning habitat increased by 61% in the stable-high profile and by 81% in the increasing profile due to larval mobility. When fewer spawning habitat areas were available at the beginning of the free-swimming stage (Week5), α increased the surface of connected spawning habitat by 36% (stable-low profile) and by 21% (decreasing profile). During the decreasing profile, ditch and stream networks in dewatered areas further increased the area of connected spawning habitats by 14% (252 ha) (Online Resource 2). Finally, managed wetlands generated 463 ha (10%) of total connected spawning habitat during the stable-high profile, 439 ha (12%) during the increasing profile and 216 ha (11%) during the decreasing profile.
Effective spawning habitats
Considering the most recent description of the Lake Saint-Pierre floodplain (e.g. satellite images taken in 2014; ECCC and MDDELCC 2018), 0–47% of the [potential] connected spawning habitats were not effective for egg deposition due to unsuitable land cover categories (Fig. 6). The largest loss of connected spawning habitat was observed for the stable-high profile with 32% of non-effective surfaces related to agricultural practices, mostly used for corn and soybean production. When water discharges reached average (~ 11,000 m3 s−1) to high (~ 15,000 m3 s−1) discharges during the first five weeks of ontogeny (i.e. in 1973, 1983 and 1998), unsuitable wetlands and wooded areas reduced the area of connected spawning habitat by 11% to 14%. Less than 1% of connected spawning area was lost due to the presence of submerged roads and urban areas in the four hydrologic profiles. Finally, only 0.4% of connected spawning area was affected by land cover during the stable-low profile.
Considering contemporary land cover changes in connected spawning habitats, the increase in water discharge between the maximum spawning time (Week0) and the free-swimming stage (Week5), which ranges from medium to high, was found to be the most favourable hydrological conditions for northern pike habitats in Lake Saint-Pierre (increasing profile in Fig. 7). In this case, 3218 ha, corresponding to 70% of the initial potential spawning area, were connected to nursery areas and were not modified by unsuitable land cover (= effective spawning habitats). During the stable-low profile, almost all the potential spawning areas were effective for northern pike recruitment (i.e. 2549 ha or 91% of potential habitats). During the stable-high profile, similar potential spawning areas remained effective (i.e. 2463 ha), but represent only 47% of the potential spawning area. This significant decrease is due to agricultural practices. During the decreasing profile, potential habitats altered by the land cover had already been lost due to hydrological constrains on habitat connectivity. Although 27% (1628 ha) of the potential spawning habitats remained effective, only 15% (279 ha) of connected spawning habitats were altered by the land cover. Finally, 332 ha of effective spawning habitats were spatially recurrent over the four contrasting hydrological profiles (dark green in Fig. 7).
Discussion
This study shows that anthropogenic alterations to the floodplain and hydrological regime can have major effects on the availability and the connectivity of habitats for early life stages of fishes. The various habitat and connectivity models, carried out under highly contrasting hydrological conditions over the past 50 years and combined with a description of land use for several reference periods, have proven to be very effective in identifying regions of Lake Saint-Pierre most impacted by human alterations. In the present study, the modelling was carried out in a recent landscape (2014) altered by two main anthropogenic pressures that have dramatically reduced the range of natural conditions favourable to fish reproduction in the St. Lawrence River. First, intensive agriculture in the floodplain (annual crops) overlapping with suitable natural habitats for fish, is leading to destruction of natural vegetation by ploughing. Such intensive agriculture has increased over time with significant reduction of spawning habitat and its connectivity for species such as northern pike and other fish species that use the floodplain to complete their life cycle. Second, the highest natural reproductive potential for northern pike, usually associated with high and stable water flows (Johnson 1957; Casselman and Lewis 1996), has been lost due to flow regulation that leads to lower and shorter spring floods and more frequent drying of spawning grounds resulting in egg mortality.
In a context of global climate change, where spring water discharge is expected to decrease and extreme hydrological conditions to increase in frequency (Mortsch et al. 2000; Boyer et al. 2010), effective spawning habitats in Lake Saint-Pierre could be further reduced, which could make it impossible to maintain fish abundance at their past levels. Hence, restoring habitat quality and connectivity in floodplains coupled with better flow regime management will play an important role in conserving biodiversity and maintaining sustainable populations.
Land cover changes and potential habitat loss
Land cover changes have profoundly altered fish habitat abundance and distribution in productive floodplains (e.g. Baber et al. 2002; Blanton and Marcus 2014; Fernandes et al. 2015), including the Lake Saint-Pierre floodplain, which has been progressively occupied by agricultural practices. While perennial crops dominated the landscape (≈ 45% cover, ≈ 21,000–22,000 ha) and annual crops accounted for only 10 to 15% of the territory (≈ 5000 to 7000 ha) in 1950, the situation completely reversed in the 1990s. More recently, annual crops have dominated the landscape, occupying 32% of the Lake Saint-Pierre (16,000 ha) compared to 15% (7000 ha) for perennial crops. Although perennial crops (i.e. pasture and forage crops) can represent potential fish habitat, ploughing annual crops removes vegetation cover and creates bare fields without substrate for egg laying in the next spring. Based on the results of our models, annual crops have negative effects on northern pike habitat especially when the water flow exceeds 14,000 m3 s−1, which happens very often in the spring (annually or biannually; Morin and Bouchard 2000). Indeed, large potential habitat losses were observed during high water discharges because fish habitats overlapped with unsuitable land cover due to agricultural practices that are mainly located in the upper part of the floodplain.
Habitat connectivity
In large floodplains, not all potential spawning habitats are connected to a nursery area, and therefore become mortality traps (Jeffres and Moyle 2012; Sheaves et al. 2014). Although transportation infrastructure (i.e. roads) has impacted habitat connectivity in the Lake Saint-Pierre floodplain (Le Pichon et al. 2018), rapid dewatering during the five first weeks of ontogeny appears to be the main factor limiting connectivity between northern pike spawning and nursery habitats (Foubert et al. 2018). Rapid dewatering after pike eggs were laid revealed large areas of spawning habitat in mortality traps (3758 ha or 62% of potential habitats). In addition, a decreasing profile can transform moderately dense vegetation associated with high quality spawning and nursery habitats (Casselman and Lewis 1996; Timm and Pierce 2015) into very dense low oxygen macrophyte beds (Casselman 1978; Holland and Huston 1984). Although only increasing (61% of all years) or stable (39%) hydrological profiles were observed before water-flow regulation (1883–1910; Le Pichon et al. 2018), the most recurrent condition since 1965 has been a steadily decreasing profile between the spawning time (Week0) and the larval free-swimming period (Week5). The regulation of the Ottawa River, considered the main tributary of the St. Lawrence River with a water discharge ranging from 570 to 9200 m3 s−1 (Carpentier 2003), has now generated large disconnected spawning areas in Lake Saint-Pierre (e.g. Brodeur et al. 2006). Indeed, the duration of the flood has been shortened by three weeks and the maximum annual water discharge has decreased significantly by nearly 2500 m3 s−1, a decrease exacerbated by the regulation of Lake Ontario outflows since 1958 (i.e. reduction of 1020 m3 s−1; Morin and Bouchard 2000).
In large floodplains characterized by recurrent dewatering profiles where intensive agricultural practices are covering large expanse of the landscape, managed wetlands and ditch/stream networks appear to be key landscape features facilitating habitat connectivity due to their permanent aquatic characteristic (e.g. Washitani 2007). Our results highlighted the role of these two anthropogenic landscape features in maintaining connected spawning habitats in the upper part of the Lake Saint-Pierre floodplain, where potentially flooded areas have become vulnerable to dewatering and agricultural expansion (e.g. in 1998 and 1973 in Saint-Barthélemy Bay). Although managed wetlands are accessible only at medium to high water discharges (Brodeur et al. 2004), they promote spatial overlap of spawning and nursery habitats that improve larval growth and survival (Schiemer et al. 2001; Ospina-Alvarez et al. 2012). In addition, when spawning and nursery habitats are spatially separated, ditch and stream networks can be used by mobile individuals to connect nursery habitats (e.g. Ishiyama et al. 2014). Although young pike larvae have limited swimming capacities, low current velocities in large floodplains favour dispersal of larvae to nurseries (Schiemer et al. 2003; Miehls and Dettmers 2011). Several independent observations in Lake Saint-Pierre confirmed the presence of northern pike larvae in ditch and stream networks and managed wetlands considered effective spawning and nursery habitats in this study (Brodeur et al. 2016).
Effective spawning habitats
Natural hydrological conditions, that are favourable for fluvial fish recruitment in large unaltered floodplains (Junk et al. 1989; Gorski et al. 2011) have lost their benefits due to anthropogenic pressures. Although a stable-high hydrological profile (> 14,000 m3 s−1) in Lake Saint-Pierre generated large areas of potential spawning habitats connected to nurseries (4665 ha), only 47% were effective when land cover was considered. The expansion of intensive agriculture, particularly annual crops, has profoundly altered spawning habitat that were previously connected to nurseries. Historically, 1517 ha of these habitats were effective for northern pike during favourable hydrological conditions (i.e. stable-high profile represented by 1973). Furthermore, water-flow regulation has dramatically reduced the frequency of these favourable hydrological conditions (Le Pichon et al. 2018), which have naturally generated large interconnected habitats. As a result, the possibility for stable-high hydrological profiles that could produce high potentials for northern pike reproduction was rare and the habitats in the upper floodplain systematically eliminated by intensive agricultural practices, especially since 1990 (Martin and Létourneau 2011).
Under specific hydrological conditions, human-altered floodplains can still generate large effective spawning habitat for freshwater fishes. In Lake Saint-Pierre, 3218 ha of effective spawning habitat was estimated during the increasing profile—i.e. when the water discharge increased from medium to high between the maximum spawning time (Week0) and the free-swimming stage (Week5). Potential spawning habitat generated by medium water discharge were not disconnected by hydrological variability during the increasing profile and not altered by land cover activities in the upper floodplain. In addition, in years of low water discharges, fish habitat, which is small in area, is less affected by intensive agriculture because it is located lower in the uncultivated floodplain. Nevertheless, the increasing profile and the stable profile, which produce the largest effective spawning habitat areas in the anthropised floodplain of Lake Saint-Pierre, has been greatly reduced by the regulation of water flow (Le Pichon et al. 2018).
Management implications
In conclusion, the loss of conditions favouring the formation of spawning habitats for northern pike caused by intensive agricultural practices in the floodplain and flow regulation can be critical to recruitment success, as several fish populations show a significant decline in the St. Lawrence River. This study highlights important new opportunities to improve fish habitat and connectivity in major river systems such as the St. Lawrence River, and identifies the following priority management measures (Wohl et al. 2015).
First, to regain production potential in years with high water flows, the priority would be to convert large intensive annual crops located in the floodplain to natural wetlands, or at least to perennial crops that represent potential fish habitat. Such actions are much needed for improving the health of the St. Lawrence River ecosystem (e.g. Washitani 2007; Gagliardi and Pettigrove 2013) and for increasing the species dispersal in landscape dominated by agriculture (e.g. Volk et al. 2018). Field crop conversions should target areas where large connected habitats are altered by annual crops such as the Saint-Barthélemy Bay (Figs. 2, 7).
Second, existing structures such as ditches and stream networks should be maintained as they represent effective fish habitat and contribute to habitat connectivity (Beier and Noss 1998). In some particular cases, additional structures could be installed if required by local needs. Although transportation infrastructure (roads) can limit connectivity in floodplains (Doyle et al. 2008; Blanton and Marcus 2014), structures such as culverts have proven to be useful in maintaining connectivity in human-altered floodplains (Douven et al. 2012; Le Pichon et al. 2018).
Third, managed wetlands created in the Lake Saint-Pierre floodplain show great potential to increase the survival of early-life stages of fishes. Indeed, these managed marshes are surrounded by dikes that could extend the duration of the flood, as was the case during the non-regularized period of the St. Lawrence system, while maintaining connectivity between spawning and nursery habitats, which is also positive for the survival of young fish. Our findings indicate that protected areas provide valuable frameworks for maintain and enhancing habitat connectivity (such as in Bishop-Taylor et al. 2015).
Finally, the water discharge regulation of the Ottawa River since 1911 has altered the natural flow regime of the St. Lawrence River, decreasing the average water level of spring floods in Lake Saint-Pierre by ~ 0.75 m and reducing its duration by about 3 weeks (Morin and Bouchard 2000). Our simulations suggest that a revision of flow management guidelines in the Ottawa River to restore a more natural spring flow regime could benefit species that use the floodplains of the St. Lawrence River, for example by extending the duration of spring floods to ensure better connectivity between spawning and nursery habitats. Similar revision of guideleines was conducted in the Lake Ontario-St. Lawrence River basin by the International Joint Commission (IJC), established under the 1909 Boundary Waters Treaty Act between the United States and Canada, which approved a new management plan in 2016 that allowed for more natural water level variations. In comparison, the changes induced by the regulation of the Ottawa River are much less well known and receive little consideration.
References
Adriaensen F, Chardon JP, De Blust G, Swinnen E, Villalba S, Gulinck H, Matthysen E (2003) The application of ‘least-cost’ modelling as a functional landscape model. Landsc Urban Plan 64(4):233–247
Baber MJ, Childers DL, Babbitt KJ, Anderson DH (2002) Controls on fish distribution and abundance in temporary wetlands. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 59(9):1441–1450
Bayler PB (1991) The flood pulse advantage and the restoration of river-floodplain systems. Regulat Rivers Res Manag 6:75–86
Beesley L, King AJ, Gawne B, Koehn JD, Price A, Nielsen D, Amtstaetter F, Meredith SN (2014) Optimising environmental watering of floodplain wetlands for fish. Freshw Biol 59:2024–2037
Beier P, Noss R (1998) Do habitat corridors provide connectivity? Conserv Biol 12:1241–1252
Bishop-Taylor R, Tulbure MG, Broich M (2015) Surface water network structure, landscape resistance to movement and flooding vital for maintaining ecological connectivity across Australia’s largest river basin. Landsc Ecol 30:2045–2065
Blanton P, Marcus WA (2014) Roads, railroads, and floodplain fragmentation due to transportation infrastructure along rivers. Ann Assoc Am Geogr 104:413–431
Boyer C, Chaumont D, Chartier I, Roy AG (2010) Impact of climate change on the hydrology of St. Lawrence tributaries. J Hydrol 384(1–2):65–83
Boët P, Belliard J, Berrebi-dit-Thomas R, Tales E (1999) Multiple human impacts by the City of Paris on fish communities in the Seine river basin, France. Hydrobiologia 410:59–68
Brodeur P, Mingelbier M, Morin J (2004) Impacts des variations hydrologiques sur les poissons des marais aménagés du Saint-Laurent fluvial. Le Naturaliste Canadien 128(2):66–77
Brodeur P, Mingelbier M, Morin J (2006) Impact de la régularisation du débit des Grands Lacs sur l’habitat de reproduction des poissons dans la plaine inondable du fleuve Saint-Laurent. Le Naturaliste Canadien 130:60–68
Brodeur P, Simard A, Théberge M, Bacon R (2016) Suivi du segment 8 du complexe d’aménagement de Baie-du-Febvre / Nicolet Sud Bilan des activités 2009–2014. Direction de la gestion de la faune de la Mauricie et du Centre-du-Québec, Ministère des Forêts de la Faune et des Parcs, Trois-Rivières, p 69
Caldwell IR, Gergel SE (2013) Thresholds in seascape connectivity: influence of mobility, habitat distribution, and current strength on fish movement. Landsc Ecol 28(10):1937–1948
Carpentier A (2003) La régularisation du Saint-Laurent. Le Naturaliste Canadien 127:102–113
Casselman JM (1978) Effects of environmental factors on growth, survival, activity, and exploitation of northern pike. Am Fish Soc Spec Publ 11:114–128
Casselman JM, Lewis CA (1996) Habitat requirements of northern pike (Esox lucius). Can J Fish Aquat Sci 53:161–174
Centre Saint-Laurent (1998) Le fleuve en bref: capsules-éclair sur l'état du Saint-Laurent. Environnement Canada, Région du Québec: Saint-Laurent Vision 2000, Québec, p 121
de la Chenelière V, Brodeur P, Mingelbier M (2014) Restauration des habitats du lac Saint-Pierre: un prérequis au rétablissement de la perchaude. Le Naturaliste Canadien 138:50–61
Douven W, Buurman J, Beevers L, Verheij H, Goichot M, Nguyen NA, Truong HT, Ngoc HM (2012) Resistance versus resilience approaches in road planning and design in delta areas: Mekong floodplains in Cambodia and Vietnam. J Environ Plan Manag 55:1289–1310
Doyle MW, Stanley EH, Havlick DG, Kaiser MJ, Steinbach G, Graf WL, Galloway GE, Riggsbee JA (2008) Aging infrastructure and ecosystem restoration. Science 319:286–287
ECCC and MDDELCC (2018) Land cover mapping of the St. Lawrence Lowlands, circa (2014) Environment and Climate Change Canada and Ministère du Développement durable, de l’Environnement et de la Lutte contre les changements climatiques. St. Lawrence Action Plan, Québec, p 49
Farrell JM, Murry BA, Leopold DJ, Halpern A, Beland Rippke M, Godwin KS, Hafner SD (2010) Water-level regulation and coastal wetland vegetation in the upper St. Lawrence River: inferences from historical aerial imagery, seed banks, and Typha dynamics. Hydrobiologia 647:127–144
Fecteau M, Poissant L (2001) Survol des impacts environnementaux potentiels liés à la production de maïs à des fins énergétiques au Québec. Environnement Canada, Saint-Laurent Vision 2000, Montréal, p 78
Fernandes I, Penha J, Zuanon J (2015) Size-dependent response of tropical wetland fish communities to changes in vegetation cover and habitat connectivity. Landsc Ecol 30:1421–1434
Fortin P, Martin S, Plante A (2002) Post-traitement, validation et intégration des données LIDAR dans le modèle numérique de terrain du fleuve Saint-Laurent. Rapport technique SMC Québec-Section Hydrologie RT-120, Environnement Canada, Sainte-Foy, préparé par le Groupe en Besoin de Données Communes du Groupe d'étude international sur le lac Ontario et le fleuve Saint-Laurent (Commission mixte internationale), pp 30 + annexes
Foubert A, Le-Pichon C, Mingelbier M, Farrell JM, Morin J, Lecomte F (2018) Modeling the effective spawning and nursery habitats of northern pike within a large spatiotemporally variable river landscape (St. Lawrence River, Canada). Limnol Oceanogr 64(2):803–819
Gagliardi B, Pettigrove V (2013) Removal of intensive agriculture from the landscape improves aquatic ecosystem health. Agric Ecosyst Environ 176:1–8
Gorski K, De Leeuw JJ, Winter HV, Vekhov DA, Minin AE, Buijse AD, Nagelkerke LAJ (2011) Fish recruitment in a large, temperate floodplain: the importance of annual flooding, temperature and habitat complexity. Freshw Biol 56(11):2210–2225
Goto D, Hamel MJ, Hammen JJ, Rugg ML, Pegg MA, Forbes VE (2015) Spatiotemporal variation in flow-dependent recruitment of long-lived riverine fish: Model development and evaluation. Ecol Model 296:79–92
Hanke MH, Lambert JD, Smith KJ (2013) Utilization of a multicriteria least cost path model in an aquatic environment. Int J Geogr Inf Sci 28(8):1642–1657
Holland LE, Huston ML (1984) Relationship of young-of-the-year northern pike to aquatic vegetation types in backwaters of the upper Mississippi River. N Am J Fish Manag 4:514–522
Ishiyama N, Akasaka T, Nakamura F (2014) Mobility-dependent response of aquatic animal species richness to a wetland network in an agricultural landscape. Aquat Sci 76(3):437–449
Jeffres C, Moyle P (2012) When good fish make bad decisions: Coho Salmon in an ecological trap. N Am J Fish Manag 32(1):87–92
Johnson FH (1957) Northern pike year-class strength and spring water levels. Trans Am Fish Soc 86:285–293
Junk WJ, Bayley PB, Sparks RE (1989) The flood pulse concept in river-floodplain systems. Can. Spec. Publ. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 12:110–127
Le Pichon C, Gorges G, Boët P, Baudry J, Goreaud F, Faure T (2006a) A spatially explicit resource-based approach for managing stream fishes in riverscapes. Environ Manag 37(3):322–335
Le Pichon C, Gorges G, Faure T, Boussard H (2006b) Anaqualand 2.0: freeware of distances calculations with frictions on a corridor. Cemagref, Antony. https://www6.rennes.inra.fr/sad/Outils-Produits/Outils-informatiques/Anaqualand. Accessed 30 Mar 2020
Le Pichon C, Mingelbier M, Legros M, Foubert A, Brodeur P (2018) Effets du réseau routier sur la connectivité des frayères du grand brochet (Esox lucius) au lac Saint-Pierre (fleuve Saint-Laurent, Canada). Le Naturaliste Canadien 142:78–91
Martin J, Létourneau G (2011) Changements dans les milieux humides du fleuve Saint-Laurent de 1970 à 2002. Environnement Canada, Direction générale des sciences et de la technologie, Monitoring et surveillance de la qualité de l'eau au Québec, Rapport technique numéro 511, p 302
Matsuzaki S-IS, Terui A, Kodama K, Tada M, Yoshida T, Washitani I (2011) Influence of connectivity, habitat quality and invasive species on egg and larval distributions and local abundance of crucian carp in Japanese agricultural landscapes. Biol Conserv 144(8):2081–2087
Miehls SM, Dettmers JM (2011) Factors influencing habitat shifts of age-0 yellow perch in Southwestern Lake Michigan. Trans Am Fish Soc 140(5):1317–1329
Mingelbier M, Brodeur P, Morin J (2008) Spatially explicit model predicting the spawning habitat and early stage mortality of Northern pike (Esox lucius) in a large system: the St. Lawrence River between 1960 and 2000. Hydrobiologia 601(1):55–69
Mingelbier M, Douguet T (1999) Répertoire-synthèse des aménagements fauniques de la plaine inondable du lac Saint-Pierre. Direction de la faune et des habitats, Société de la faune et des parcs du Québec, p 37
Morin J, Champoux O, Martin S, Turgeon K (2005) Modélisation intégrée de la réponse de l’écosystème dans le fleuve Saint-Laurent: Rapport final des activités entreprises dans le cadre du Plan d’étude sur la régularisation du lac Ontario et du fleuve Saint-Laurent Rapport scientifique - RS-108. SMC-Hydrologie, Environnement Canada, Québec, p 139
Morin J, Leclerc M, Secretan Y, Boudreau P (2000) Integrated two-dimensional macrophytes-hydrodynamic modeling. J Hydraul Res 38:163–172
Morin J, Mingelbier M, Bechara JA, Champoux O, Secretan Y, Martin J, Frenette JJ (2003) Emergence of new explanatory variables for 2D habitat modelling in large rivers: The St. Canadian Water Resources Journal, Lawrence Experience, p 28
Morin J, Bouchard A (2000) Les bases de la modélisation du tronçon Montréal / Trois-Rivières. Rapport scientifique SMC-Hydrométrie RS-100. Environnement Canada, p 56
Mortsch L, Hengeveld H, Lister M, Lofgren B, Quinn F, Slivitky M, Wenger L (2000) Climate change impacts on the hydrology of the great lakes—St. Lawrence. Syst Can Water Ressour J 25(2):153–179
Nilsson C, Reidy CA, Dynesius M, Revenga C (2005) Fragmentation and flow regulation of the world's large river systems. Science 308:405–408
Ospina-Alvarez A, Parada C, Palomera I (2012) Vertical migration effects on the dispersion and recruitment of European anchovy larvae: from spawning to nursery areas. Ecol Model 231:65–79
Peake S (2004) Effect of approach velocity on impingement of juvenile northern pike at water intake screens. N Am J Fish Manag 24(2):390–396
Raat AJP (2001) Ecological rehabilitation of the Dutch part of the River Rhine with special attention to the fish. Regul Rivers Res Manag 17(2):131–144
Richard G, Côté D, Mingelbier M, Jobin B, Morin J, Brodeur P (2011) Utilisation du sol dans la plaine inondable du lac Saint-Pierre (fleuve Saint-Laurent) durant les périodes 1950, 1964 et 1997: interprétation de photos aériennes, numérisation et préparation d’une base de données géoréférencées. Ministère des Ressources naturelles et de la Faune, Gouvernement du Québec, Québec, p 42
Roy M, Le Pichon C (2017) Modelling functional fish habitat connectivity in rivers: a case study for prioritizing restoration actions targeting brown trout. Aquat Conserv Mar Freshw Ecosyst 27:927–937
Schiemer F, Keckeis H, Kamler E (2003) The early life history stages of riverine fish: ecophysiological and environmental bottlenecks. Comp Biochem Physiol 133:439–449
Schiemer F, Keckeis H, Reckendorfer W, Winkler G (2001) The "inshore retention concept" and its significance for large rivers. River Systems 12(2–4):509–516
Sheaves M, Baker R, Nagelkerken I, Connolly RM (2014) True value of estuarine and coastal nurseries for fish: incorporating complexity and dynamics. Estuar Coasts 38(2):401–414
Smith BM, Farrell JM, Underwood HB, Smith SJ (2007) Year-class formation of upper St. Lawrence river northern pike. N Am J Fish Manag 27(2):481–491
Timm AL, Pierce RB (2015) Vegetative substrates used by larval northern pike in Rainy and Kabetogama Lakes. Minn Ecol Freshw Fish 24(2):225–233
Tockner K, Stanford JA (2002) Riverine flood plains: present state and future trends. Environ Conserv 29:3
Turgeon K, Morin J (2005) Modelling submerged macrophytes distribution: evaluation of models transferability in three St. Lawrence River sections scientific report MSC Québec –Hydrology Section RS-105. Environment Canada, Sainte-Foy, p 61
Van der Ree R, Jaeger JAG, Van der Grift EA, Clevenger AP (2011) Effects of roads and traffic on wildlife populations and landscape function: road ecology is moving towards larger scales. Ecol Soc 16(1):48
Volk XK, Gattringer JP, Otte A, Harvolk-Schoïning S (2018) Connectivity analysis as a tool for assessing restoration success. Landsc Ecol 33:371–387
Washitani I (2007) Restoration of biologically-diverse floodplain wetlands including paddy fields. Glob Environ Res 11:135–140
Wiens JA (2002) Riverine landscapes: taking landscape ecology into the water. Freshw Biol 47:501–515
Wohl E (2017) Connectivity in rivers. Prog Phys Geogr 41(3):345–362
Wohl E, Lane SN, Wilcox AC (2015) The science and practice of river restoration. Water Resour Res 51:5974–5997
Acknowledgements
This study would not have been possible without the contribution of John Farrell and the members of the Thousand Islands Biological Station for conducting field experiences and Sylvain Martin for kindly providing hydrological data. A special thank goes to Dr. Mathieu Cusson and Julian J. Dodson for revisions of earlier version of the manuscript. This study is part of A.F.’s Ph.D. thesis. Financial support was provided by grants from the “Chaire de Recherche sur les Espèces Aquatiques Exploitées”, the Ministère des Forêts, de la Faune et des Parcs du Québec (MFFP), the “Ressources Aquatiques Québec”, and the “Commission permanente de coopération franco-québécoise”.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Contribution to the “Chaire de Recherche sur les Espèces Aquatiques Exploitées” 20 (CREAE).
Electronic supplementary material
Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Foubert, A., Lecomte, F., Brodeur, P. et al. How intensive agricultural practices and flow regulation are threatening fish spawning habitats and their connectivity in the St. Lawrence River floodplain, Canada. Landscape Ecol 35, 1229–1247 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10980-020-00996-9
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10980-020-00996-9