Abstract
How to represent a syllable is by no means a settled question in generative grammar. This paper employs the diagnostic tool Replace (X) to examine the sub-syllabic constituency in Old Chinese (OC) by virtue of two types of directional reduplication data: progressive and retrogressive reduplication. This paper finds that the OC syllable is comprised of onset, nucleus, and rhyme, which have different representations in the syllable structure. This paper also argues that the OC tone should be represented in terms of another independent plane, i.e., adjoining to the whole syllable rather than the rhyme sub-syllabic constituent, on the basis of the rhyming in Shijing ‘Book of Odes’. The OC medial glides -j- and -w- show an asymmetric status in syllable structure. The former tends to be aligned with the rhyme, while the latter tends to be aligned with onset. Comparing with other OC syllable structures, it is found that theoretical analyses reveal certain aspects of sub-syllabic processes, such as the placements of medial glides, and help us to examine syllabic representations such as tone representation, all of which may not be detected by direct observation of a maximal syllable in OC. Furthermore, a comparison of syllable structures in OC and Middle Chinese suggests that syllable structure, as well as other phonological phenomena, underwent great changes from OC to Middle Chinese or Guangyun phonology.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Bao Zhiming. (1990a) Fanqie languages and reduplication. Linguistic Inquiry 21: 317–350
Bao, Zhiming. 1990b. On the nature of tone, doctoral dissertation, MIT.
Bao Zhiming. (1995) Syllable structure and partial reduplication in classical Chinese. Journal of East Asian Linguistics 4: 175–196
Bao Zhiming. (1996) The syllable in Chinese. Journal of Chinese Linguistics 24: 312–354
Bao Zhiming. (2000) Syllabic constituency and sub-syllabic processes. Journal of East Asian Linguistics 9: 287–313
Bao, Zhiming. 2001. The phonology of the medial glide in Middle Chinese. In Proceedings of the 7th international and 19th national conferences on Chinese phonology, 188–203.
Baxter William H. (1992) A handbook of Old Chinese phonology. Mouton de Gruyter, Berlin
Benedict, Peter. 1976. Archaic Chinese affixation patterns. In Proceedings for the 2nd international Sino-Tibetan conference.
Bodman N. (1954) A linguistic study of the SHIH MING. Harvard University Press, Cambridge
Chan, Marjorie K.M. 1985. Fuzhou phonology, doctoral dissertation, University of Washington.
Chan Marjorie K.M. (1990) Prelinked and floating glottal stops in Fuzhou Chinese. Canadian Journal of Linguistics 35: 331–349
Chan, Marjorie K.M. 1997. Fuzhou glottal stop: Floating segment or correlation of close contact? In Studies in Chinese phonology, ed. Wang Jianling and Norval Smith, 275–289. Berlin: Mouton de Bruyter.
Chen, Duxiu. (1937). Zhongguo gudai yuyin you fushengmu shou [A hypothesis: There are complex onsets in OC]. Dongfan Zhazhi 34: 20, 21.
Chen, Xinxiong. 1972. Guyinxue fawei [Understanding of historical phonology], doctoral dissertation, National Taiwan Normal University.
Cheng Chin-chuan. (1973) A synchronic phonology of Mandarin Chinese. De Hague, Mouton
Chiang, Wenyu. 1992. The prosodic morphology and phonology of affixation in Taiwanese and other Chinese languages, doctoral dissertation, University of Delaware.
Chou, Fa-kao. 1962. A historical grammar of ancient Chinese, part II: Morphology. In Bulletin of the Institute of History and Philology, Special Publication No. 39. Taiwan: Academic Sinica.
Chung, Ruang-Fu. 1989. Aspects of Kejia phonology, doctoral dissertation, University of Illinois, Urbana.
Chung Raung-Fu. (1997) Taiwan minnanyu de jieyin [The medial glide in Taiwanese]. Zhoungguo Yuwen 1981: 231–237
Du, Qirong. 1970. Bufeng dieyun lianmianci de xingchen yu dai l fushengmu zhi guanxi [The relationship between complex onsets with l and sound-meaning correlated words]. Lianhe Shuyun Xuebao 7.
Duanmu San. (2000) The phonology of standard Chinese. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Duanmu, San. 2001. Phonological features and onset clusters. In Proceedings of the 7th international and 19th national conferences on Chinese phonology, 112–124.
Edkins Joseph. 1874. The state of the Chinese language at the time of invention of writing. In Proceedings of Transac 2nd Congr. Or., 98–119.
Edkins Joseph. 1876. Introduction to the study of the Chinese characters. London.
Edkins Joseph. (1897) Recent researches upon the ancient Chinese sounds. CR 22: 565–570
Fu Ding-yi. (1960) Lianmian zidian [A dictionary of dissyllabic words]. Zhounghua Press, Taipei
Gu Yanwu. (1966a) Yunbuzheng [Completion of rhymes]. Taipei, Guangwen Bookstore
Gu Yanwu. (1966b) Yinxue wushu [Five books on phonology]. Taipei, Guangwen Bookstore
Hsu, Dong-Bo. 2006. Sub-syllabic processes, syllable structure, and the status of the medial glides in Old Chinese. In Proceedings of the eighteenth North America conference on Chinese linguistics (NACCL 18) (2), ed. Janet Zhangxing, 183–200. Los Angeles: GSIL Publications.
Hsu Shiyin. (1974) Hsushiyin lunwenji [Proceedings for Hsushiyin]. Taipei, Hongdao Bookstore
Ju Chi-yung. (1960) An annotated list of sound-correlated dissyllabic compounds in the Book of Odes. Bulletin of the College of Arts, National Taiwan University 9: 129–291
Karlgren, Ben. 1960. Tones in Archaic Chinese. BMFEA 32.
Kenstowicz Michael. (1994) Phonology in generative grammar. Blackwell Publications, Oxford
Li, Fankuei. 1971. Shangguyin yinjiu [Studies in OC sounds]. Qinghua Xuebao 9(1, 2).
Li, Fankuei. 1976. Jige shanggu shengmu wenti [Several problems on OC onsets]. In Proceedings of the first anniversary of Jiang Zhong-zhen’s death.
Li Fankuei. (1986) An interview with Li Fankuei. Monthly Journal for Chinese Studies 18: 6–9
Li Rong. (1973) Qieyun yinxi [Qieyun phonology]. Taipei, Dingwen Bookstore
Liang, Yuzhang. 1982. Fuzhou fangyan de ‘qiejio ci’ [L-words in the Fuzhou dialect]. Zhongguo Yuwen 37–46.
Lin Chou, Zhengsheng Geng. (2001) Shengyunxue [Chinese phonology]. Sanming Press, Taipei
Lin, Yen-hwei. 1989. Autosegmental treatsment of segmental processes in Chinese phonology, doctoral dissertation, University of Texas, Austin.
Lin Yen-hwei. (1993) Degenerate affixes and templatic constraints: Rime change in Chinese. Language 69: 649–682
Lin Yu-tan. (1967) Yuyanxue lucong [Essays on linguistics]. Taipei, Wenxin Bookstore
Lu Zhiwei. (1971) Guyin shouluei [Sketch of sounds in classical Chinese]. Taipei, Student Bookstore
Marantz Alec. (1982) Re Reduplication. Linguistic Inquiry 13: 435–483
McCarthy John, Alan Prince. (1986) Prosodic morphology. Brandeis Press, Waltham, MA
McCarthy, John, and Alan S. Prince. 2001. Prosodic morphology. The Handbook of Morphology 281–305.
Mei, Tsu-lin. 1971. Shilun jige minbei fanyan zhong de laimu s- sheng zi [Try to discuss the Laimu s-onset in Northern Min dialect]. Qinhua xuebao 9(1, 2).
Pan Wuyun. (2000) Hanyu lishi yinyunxue [Chinese historical phonology]. Shanhai Jiaoyu Press, Shanghai
Pan Wuyun. (2002) Zhuming zhongnian yuyan xuejia zixuen ji: Pan Wuyun juan [Well-known middle-aged linguists collection of self-selected publications: Pan Wuyun]. Anhuei Jiaoyu Press, Hefei
Pulleyblank Edwin G. (1962) The consonantal system of Old Chinese. Asia Major 9: 180–199
Pulleyblank Edwin G. (1963) An interpretation of Old Chinese. Asia Major 10: 200–221
Pulleyblank Edwin G. (1973) Some new hypotheses concerning word families in Chinese. Journal of Chinese Linguistics 1(1): 111–125
Pulleyblank, Edwin G. 1989. Ablaut and initial voicing in Old Chinese morphology: *A as an infix and prefix. Zhongyang Yanjiuyuan die r jie guoji hanxue huiyi lunwen ji yuyan wenzi zu (A): 1–21.
Pulleyblank, Edwin G. 2000. Morphology in Old Chinese. Journal of Chinese Linguistics 26–51.
Qian Nairong. (1992) Dandai wuyu yanjiu [Research on contemporary Wu]. Shanghai Education Press, Shanghai
Qien Xuentong. (1969) Wenzixue yinpiang [Philology: sound part]. Taipei, Student Bookstore
Shao, Rongfeng. 1991. Xiamuzi shanggu yi feng wei er shixi [An attempt to analyze rhyme of Xia in Old Chinese]. Yuyan Yenjiu 1.
Shu, Xiaogu, and Andrew Carstairs-McCarthy. 1992. Empty onsets and template ordering: Evidence from glides in Chinese, master’s thesis, University of Canterbury, Christchurch, New Zealand.
Steriade Donca. (1988) Reduplication and syllable transfer in Sanskrit and elsewhere. Phonology 5: 73–155
Sun, Jintao. 1999. Reduplication in Old Chinese, doctoral dissertation, University of British Columbia.
Sun Jintao. (2003) Retrogressive reduplication in Old Chinese. Journal of Chinese Linguistics 31: 187–217
Tang, Lan. 1937. Lu gu wu fufuyin [On the non-existence of complex onsets in OC]. Chinhua Xuebao 12(2).
Ting Pan-hsing. (1978) Lun shangu yin zhong dai l de fushengmu [On the l in OC complex onset]. Taipei, Lianjing
Ting Pang-hsing. (1979) Shanggu yin de yinjie jiegou [Syllable structure of Ancient Chinese]. Bullein of the Institute of History and Philology, Academia Sinica 50(2): 717–739
Ting, Pang-hsing. 1981. Hanyu shengdiaoyu yunwei shuo zhi jiantao [Reflections on the derivation of Chinese tones]. In Proceedings of the first international Sino-Tibetan Conference, 267–283.
Ting, Pang-hsing. 1986. Hanyu shengdiao de yianbian [The historical derivation of Chinese tones]. In Proceedings for the 2nd international Sino-Tibetan conference, 395–408.
Tong, Tonghe. 1944. Shanggu yinyun biaogao [Lists of OC phonology]. Shiyusuo Dankan Jiazhong 21.
Wan, I-ping. 1999. Mandarin phonology: Evidence from speech errors, doctoral dissertation, SUNY at Buffalo.
Wan, I-ping. 2001. On the representation and processing of prenucleur glides in Mandarin. In Proceedings of the 7th international and 19th national conferences on Chinese phonology, 232–248.
Wang, Guo-wei. 1968. Lian mian li pu [A list of reduplicated words]. In The complete works of Wang Guo-wei (Vol. 9). Taiwan: Wenhua Press.
Wang Li. (1958) Hanyu shigao [A History of Chinese]. Science Press, Beijing
Wang Li. (1975) Hanyu yinyun [Chinese phonology]. Hongdao Press, Taipei
Wei, Jiangong. 1932. Zhongguo guyin yanjiushang xiege xiangjue wenti [Several emergent problems in OC phonology]. Guoxue Jikan 3(4).
Wu, Qichan. 1932. Lainiu mingniu gu fufuyin tongzhuankao [A study on the rhyming in Lai and Mu rhyme]. Qinhua Xuebao 7(1).
Yahon Toufu. (1960) Shanggu hanyu de chunhuan yuanyin [Labial vowels in Old Chinese]. Beijing University Press, Beijing
Yen, Xuejiong. 1981. Yuanshi hanyu fushengmu laixing de henji [Traces of the types of complex onsets in Archaic Chinese]. In Proceedings of the fourteenth international Sino-Tibetan conference.
Yip Moira. (1982) Reduplication and C-V skeleton in Chinese secret languages. Linguistic Inquiry 13: 637–661
Yip Moria. (1992) Prosodic morphology in four Chinese dialects. Journal of East Asian Linguistics 1: 1–36
Zheng, Zhangshanfang. 1987. Shangu yunmu xitong he xideng, jieyin, shengdiaode fayuan wenti [Problems to rhyme systems, fourth grade, medial glides, and tone origins in Old Chinese]. Wenzhou Shifan Xuebao 43–58.
Zhou, Fagou. 1970. Lun shangguyin he qieyun yin [On sounds in OC and in qieyun]. Zhongwen Daxue Zhongguou Wenhua Yanjiusou Xuebao 1.
Zhu, Jianin. 1981. Guhanyu fushengmu yanjiou [A study on OC complex onsets], doctoral dissertation, Chinese Cultural University.
Zhu Jianin. (1993) Guyin zhi liu [A trip to sounds in Old Chinese]. Sanming Press, Taipei
Zhu Jianin. (2007) Shengyunxue [Chinese phonology]. Wunan Press, Taipei
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Hsu, DB. The syllable in Old Chinese: sub-syllabic processes, syllable structure, and the status of medial glides. J East Asian Linguist 18, 361–395 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10831-009-9050-3
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10831-009-9050-3