Abstract
This paper aims at contributing to the ongoing epistemological debate on the nature of models by proposing an excursus from emerging to scientific modeling that will highlight the similarities between the two forms: this analysis will also allow to focus on the development of those traits that are instead typical of scientific models. The analysis of basic forms of modeling will to show how even mindless processing of external reality does not provide passive descriptions but is rather a poietic aggression which constitutes external reality as the organism perceives it. In my argument I will make apparent how this poietic character is indeed common to both emerging and scientific modeling. My final contention will be that scientific endeavor, captured within Magnani’s notion of epistemic warfare, is not characterized by a dramatic qualitative difference in the nature of models at play, but by a new conception and attitude displayed by scientists in their used of models, also coupled with the other fundamental scientific tool: the experiment.
Access provided by Autonomous University of Puebla. Download to read the full chapter text
Chapter PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Keywords
These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.
References
Albertazzi, L., van Tonder, G.J., Vishwanath, D. (eds.): Perception Beyond Inference: The Information Content of Visual Processes. The MIT Press, Cambridge (2011)
Bertolotti, T., Magnani, L.: The Role of Agency Detection in the Invention of Supernatural Beings An Abductive Approach. In: Magnani, L., Carnielli, W., Pizzi, C. (eds.) Model-Based Reasoning in Science and Technology. SCI, vol. 314, pp. 239–262. Springer, Heidelberg (2010)
Bird, C.D., Emery, N.J.: Rooks use stones to raise the water level to reach a floating worm. Current Biology 19, 1410–1414 (2009)
Calvo, P., Keijzer, F.: Cognition in plants. In: Baluška, F. (ed.) Plant-Environment Interactions: From Sensory Plant Biology to Active Plant Behavior, pp. 247–266. Springer, Heidelberg (2009)
Cartwright, N.: How the Laws of Physics Lie. Oxford University Press, Oxford (1983)
Cartwright, N.: If no capacities then no credible worlds. But can models reveal capacities? Erkenntnis 70, 45–58 (2009)
Cartwright, N.: Models: Parables v fables. In: Frigg, R., Hunter, M. (eds.) Beyond Mimesis and Convention. Boston Studies in the Philosophy of Science, vol. 262, pp. 19–31. Springer, Netherlands (2010)
Chakravartty, A.: Informational versus functional theories of scientific representation. Synthese 172, 197–213 (2010)
Chandrasekharan, S.: Building to discover: a common coding model. Cognitive Science 33, 1059–1086 (2009)
Clark, K.L.: Negation as failure. In: Gallaire, H., Minker, J. (eds.) Logic and Data Bases, pp. 94–114. Plenum, New York (1978)
Contessa, G.: Scientific representation, interpretation, and surrogative reasoning. Philosophy of Science 74, 48–68 (2007)
Contessa, G.: Scientific models and fictional objects. Synthese 172, 215–229 (2010)
Davis, G., Holmes, A.: What is enumerated by subitization mechanisms? Perception & Psychophysics 67(7), 1229–1241 (2005)
De Cruz, H.: Towards a darwinian approach to mathematics. Foundations of Science 11, 157–196 (2006)
Dehaene, S., Spelke, E., Pinel, P., Stanescu, R., Tsivkin, S.: Sources of mathematical thinking: behavioral and brain imaging evidence. Science 284(5416), 970–974 (1999)
Dehaene, S.: The Number Sense. Oxford University Press, Oxford (1997)
Faust, J.: Can religious arguments persuade? International Journal for Philosophy of Religion 63, 71–86 (2008)
Feyerabend, P.: Against Method (1975), 3rd edn. Verso, London-New York (1993)
Frigg, R.: Fiction and scientific representation. In: Frigg, R., Hunter, M.C. (eds.) Beyond Mimesis and Nominalism: Representation in Art and Science, pp. 97–138. Springer, Heidelberg (2010)
Frigg, R.: Fiction in science. In: Woods, J. (ed.) Fictions and Models: New Essays, pp. 247–287. Philosophia Verlag, Munich (2010)
Frigg, R.: Models and fiction. Synthese 172, 251–268 (2010)
Galilei, G.: The Assayer (1623). In: Drake, S. (ed.& trans.) Discoveries and Opinions of Galileo, pp. 231–280. Doubleday, New York (1957)
Gendler, T.S.: Galileo and the indispensability of scientific thought experiment. The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 49(9), 397–424 (1998)
Gibson, J.J.: The Ecological Approach to Visual Perception. Houghton Mifflin, Boston (1979)
Giere, R.N.: Explaining Science: a Cognitive Approach. University of Chicago Press, Chicago (1988)
Giere, R.: An agent-based conception of models and scientific representation. Synthese 172, 269–281 (2007)
Giere, R.: Why scientific models should not be regarded as works of fiction. In: Suárez, M. (ed.) Fictions in Science. Philosophical Essays on Modeling and Idealization, pp. 248–258. Routledge, London (2009)
Glendinning, P.: The mathematics of motion camouflage. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series B: Biological Sciences 271(1538), 477–481 (2004)
Godfrey-Smith, P.: Models and fictions in science. Philosophical Studies 143, 101–116 (2009)
Gorman, M.E.: Transforming Nature. Ethics, Invention and Discovery. Kluwer, Dordrecht (1998)
Heyes, C.M.: Imitation, culture and cognition. Animal Behavior 46, 999–1010 (1993)
Hodgson, D.: Evolution of the visual cortex and the emergence of symmetry in the acheulean techno-complex. Evolution 8, 93–97 (2009)
Holland, J.H.: Hidden Order. Addison-Wesley, Reading (1995)
Holland, J.H.: Emergence: From Chaos to Order. Oxford University Press, Oxford (1997)
Jacob, P., Jeannerod, M.: Ways of Seeing: The Scope and Limits of Visual Cognition. Oxford University Press, Oxford (2003)
Kirsh, D.: Complementary strategies: Why we use our hands when we think. In: Moore, J.D., Lehman, J.F. (eds.) Proceedings of the Seventheenth Annual Conference of the Cognitive Science Society, pp. 212–217. Lawrence Erlbaum, Mahwah (1995)
Kuorikoski, J., Lehtinen, A.: Incredible worlds, credible results. Erkenntnis 70, 119–131 (2009)
Laurent, É.: Mental representations as simulated affordances: not intrinsic, not so much functional, but intentionally-driven. Intellectica 1-2(36-37), 385–387 (2003)
Lockhart, P.: Lockhart’s lament (March 2008), http://www.maa.org/devlin/devlin_03_08.html
Magnani, L.: Abduction, Reason, and Science. Processes of Discovery and Explanation. Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers, New York (2001)
Magnani, L.: Conjectures and manipulations. Computational modeling and the extra-theoretical dimension of scientific discovery. Minds and Machines 14, 507–537 (2004)
Magnani, L.: Model-based and manipulative abduction in science. Foundations of Science 9, 219–247 (2004)
Magnani, L.: Mimetic minds. Meaning formation through epistemic mediators and external representations. In: Loula, A., Gudwin, R., Queiroz, J. (eds.) Artificial Cognition Systems, pp. 327–357. Idea Group Publishers, Hershey (2006)
Magnani, L.: Animal abduction. From mindless organisms to artifactual mediators. In: Magnani, L., Li, P. (eds.) Model-Based Reasoning in Science, Technology, and Medicine, pp. 3–37. Springer, Berlin (2007)
Magnani, L.: Morality in a Technological World. Knowledge as Duty. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (2007)
Magnani, L.: Abductive Cognition: The Epistemological and Eco-Cognitive Dimensions of Hypothetical Reasoning. Springer, Heidelberg (2009)
Magnani, L.: Scientific Models are Not Fictions: Model-Based Science as Epistemic Warfare. In: Magnani, L., Li, L. (eds.) Philosophy and Cognitive Science. SAPERE, vol. 2, pp. 1–38. Springer, Heidelberg (2012)
Mäki, U.: MISSing the world. Models as isolations and credible surrogate systems. Erkenntnis 70, 29–43 (2009)
Millikan, R.G.: On reading signs: Some differences between us and the others. In: Kimbrough Oller, D., Griebel, U. (eds.) Evolution of Communication Systems: A Comparative Approach, pp. 15–29. The MIT Press, Cambridge (2004)
Mizrahi, M.: Idealizations and scientific understanding. Philosophical Studies (2009), http://www.springerlink.com/content/e33h421502t20118/ , doi: 10.1007/s11098-011-9716-3
Morrison, M.: Fictions, representations, and reality. In: Suárez, M. (ed.) Fictions in Science: Philosophical Essays on Modeling and Idealization, pp. 110–135. Routledge, London (2009)
Nersessian, N.J.: Creating Scientific Concepts. MIT Press, Boston (2010)
Pesic, P.: Wrestling with proteus: Francis bacon and the “torture” of nature. Isis 90(1), 81–94 (1990)
Portides, D.P.: The relation between idealization and approximation in scientific model construction. Science & Education 16, 699–724 (2007)
Raftopoulos, A.: Is perception informationally encapsulated? The issue of theory-ladenness of perception. Cognitive Science 25, 423–451 (2001)
Raftopoulos, A.: Reentrant pathways and the theory-ladenness of perception. Philosophy of Science 68, S187–S189 (2001); Proceedings of PSA 2000 Biennal Meeting
Rivas, J., Burghardt, G.M.: Crotalomorphysm: a metaphor for understanding anthropomorphism by omission. In: Bekoff, M., Allen, C., Burghardt, M. (eds.) The Cognitive Animal. Empirical and Theoretical Perspectives on Animal Cognition, pp. 9–18. The MIT Press, Cambridge (2002)
Sage, J.: Truth-reliability and the evolution of human cognitive faculties. Philosophical Studies 117, 95–106 (2004)
Skelhorn, J., Rowland, H.M., Ruxton, G.D.: The evolution and ecology of masquerade. Biological Journal of the Linnean Society 99(1), 1–8 (2010)
Srinivasan, M.V., Davey, M.: Strategies for active camouflage of motion. Proceedings: Biological Sciences 259(1354), 19–25 (1995)
Stevens, M., Merilaita, S.: Animal camouflage: current issues and new perspectives. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 364, 423–427 (2009)
Suárez, M.: Scientific fictions as rules of inference. In: Suárez, M. (ed.) Fictions in Science: Philosophical Essays on Modeling and Idealization, pp. 158–178. Routledge, London (2009)
Suárez, M.: Fictions, inference, and realism. In: Woods, J. (ed.) Fictions and Models: New Essays, pp. 225–245. Philosophia Verlag, Munich (2010)
Sugden, R.: Credible worlds, capacities and mechanisms. Erkenntnis 70, 3–27 (2009)
Thomson-Jones, M.: Missing systems and the face value practice. Synthese 172, 283–299 (2010)
Toon, A.: The ontology of theoretical modelling: models as make believe. Synthese 172, 301–315 (2010)
Tweney, R.D.: Discovering discovery: How faraday found the first metallic colloid. Perspectives on Science 14(1), 97–121 (2006)
Weir, A.A.S., Kacelnik, A.: A new caledonian crow (corvus moneduloides) creatively re-designs tools by bending or unbending aluminium strips. Animal Cognition 9, 317–334 (2006)
Weisberg, M.: Three kinds of idealization. Journal of Philosophy 104(12), 639–659 (2007)
Woods, J., Rosales, A.: Unifying the fictional. In: Woods, J. (ed.) Fictions and Models: New Essays, pp. 345–388. Philosophia Verlag, Munich (2010)
Woods, J., Rosales, A.: Virtuous Distortion: Abstraction and Idealization in Model-Based Science. In: Magnani, L., Carnielli, W., Pizzi, C. (eds.) Model-Based Reasoning in Science and Technology. SCI, vol. 314, pp. 3–30. Springer, Heidelberg (2010)
Woods, J.: The Death of Argument. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht (2004)
Woods, J. (ed.): Fictions and Models: New Essays. Philosophia Verlag, Munich (2010)
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2012 Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg
About this paper
Cite this paper
Bertolotti, T. (2012). From Mindless Modeling to Scientific Models. In: Magnani, L., Li, P. (eds) Philosophy and Cognitive Science. Studies in Applied Philosophy, Epistemology and Rational Ethics, vol 2. Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-29928-5_4
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-29928-5_4
Publisher Name: Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg
Print ISBN: 978-3-642-29927-8
Online ISBN: 978-3-642-29928-5
eBook Packages: Humanities, Social Sciences and LawPhilosophy and Religion (R0)