Abstract.
The notions of ‘idealisation’ and ‘approximation’ are strongly linked to the question of ‘how our theories represent the phenomena in their scope’. Although there is no consensus amongst Philosophers on the nature of the process of idealisation and how it affects theoretical representation, at the level of science education much can be gained from the insights of existing philosophical analyses. Traditionally, teaching methodologies treat the observed divergence between theoretical predictions and experimental data by appealing to the more common-sensical notion of ‘approximation’. The use of the latter notion, however, to explicate discrepancies between theory and experiment obscures the theory/experiment relation. It does so, I argue, because from the viewpoint of scientific modelling ‘approximation’ either depends upon or piggybacks on ‘idealisation’.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Abd-El-Khalick F., Lederman N.G. (2000). Improving Science Teachers’ Conceptions of Nature of Science: A Critical Review of the Literature. International Journal of Science Education 22(7): 665–701
Cartwright N.D.(1983). How the Laws of Physics Lie. Clarendon Press, Oxford
Cartwright N.D.(1989). Nature’s Capacities and their Measurement. Clarendon Press, Oxford
Cartwright N.D.(1999). The Dappled World: A Study of the Boundaries of Science. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Constantinou C.P.(1999). The Cocoa Microworld as an Environment for Developing Modelling Skills in Physical Science. International Journal of Continuing Education and Life-long Learning 9: 201–213
da Costa N.C.A., French S.(1990). The Model-Theoretic Approach in the Philosophy of Science. Philosophy of Science 57: 248–265
da Costa N.C.A., French S.(2003). Science and Partial Truth. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Giere R.N.(1988). Explaining Science: A Cognitive Approach. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Halloun I., Hestenes D.(1987). Modelling Instruction in Mechanics. American Journal of Physics 55(5): 455–462
Hestenes D. (1987). Toward a Modelling Theory of Physics Instruction. American Journal of Physics 55(5): 440–454
Hogan K.(2000). Exploring a Process View of Students’ Knowledge About the Nature of Science. Science Education 84: 51–70
Laymon, R.: 1980, Idealisation, Explanation, and Confirmation, in P.D. Asquith and R.N. Giere (eds), PSA 1982, Vol. 1, Philosophy of Science Association, East Lansing, pp. 336–350.
Laymon R.(1985). Idealisation and the Testing of Theories by Experimentation. In: Achinstein P., Hannaway O. (eds), Observation, Experiment, and Hypothesis in Modern Physical Science. MIT Press, Massachusetts, pp. 147–173
Laymon R.(1987). Using Scott Domains to Explicate the Notions of Approximate and Idealised Data. Philosophy of Science 54: 192–221
Leach J., Millar R., Ryder J., Sére M.G.(2000). Epistemological Understanding in Science Learning: The Consistency of Representations Across Contexts. Learning and Instruction 10(6): 497–527
Lederman N.G.(1992). Students’ and Teachers’ Conceptions of the Nature of Science: A Review of the Research. Journal of Research in Science Teaching 29: 331–359
Lederman N.G., Abd-El-Khalick F., Bell R.L., Schwartz R.S.(2002). Views of Nature of Science Questionnaire (VNOS): Toward Valid and Meaningful Assessment of Learners’ Conceptions of Nature of Science. Journal of Research in Science Teaching 39: 497–521
Matthews R.M. (2004). Idealisation and Galileo’s Pendulum Discoveries: Historical, Philosophical and Pedagogical Considerations. Science & Education 13: 689–715
Matthews R.M., Gauld C., Stinner A.(2004). The Pendulum: Its Place in Science, Culture and Pedagogy. Science & Education 13: 261–277
McMullin E. (1985). Galilean idealisation. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 16: 247–273
Morgan M.S., Morrison M.C. (eds) (1999). Models as Mediators: Perspectives on Natural and Social Science. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Morrison M.C.(1998). Modelling Nature: Between Physics and the Physical World. Philosophia Naturalis 35: 65–85
Morrison, M.C.: 1999, Models as Autonomous Agents, in M.S. Morgan and M. Morrison (eds), Models as Mediators, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 38–65.
Nagel E.(1979). The Structure of Science. Hackett Publishing, Indianapolis
Nelson R.A., Olsson M.G.(1986). The Pendulum—Rich Physics from a Simple System. American Journal of Physics 54(2): 112–121
Newburgh R. (2004). The Pendulum: A Paradigm for the Linear Oscillator. Science & Education 13: 297–307
Niiniluoto I.(1987). Truthlikeness. D.Reidel, Dordrecht
Niiniluoto I. (1999). Critical Scientific Realism. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Nola R. (2004). Pendula, Models, Constructivism and Reality. Science & Education 13: 346–377
Popper K.R. (1979). Objective Knowledge: An Evolutionary Approach. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Popper K.R.(1989). Conjectures and Refutations. Routledge, London
Portides D. (2005). A Theory of Scientific Model Construction: The Conceptual Process of Abstraction and Concretization. Foundations of Science 10: 67–88
Portides, D.: forthcoming, ‘Scientific Models and the Semantic View of Scientific Theories’, Philosophy of Science, Proceedings PSA 2004, Part I Contributed Papers.
Psillos S. (1999). Scientific Realism: How Science Tracks Truth. Routledge, London
Redhead M. (1980). Models in Physics. British Journal of the Philosophy of Science 31: 145–163
Shapere D. (1984). Reason and the Search for Knowledge. Reidel, Dordrecht
Suppe F.(1974). The Search for Philosophic Understanding of Scientific Theories. In: Suppe F. (eds) 1977 The Structure of Scientific Theories. University of Illinois Press, Urbana, pp. 3–241
Suppe F.(1989). The Semantic Conception of Theories and Scientific Realism. University of Illinois Press, Urbana
Van Fraassen B.C. (1980). The Scientific Image. Clarendon Press, Oxford
Van Fraassen B.C.(1989). Laws and Symmetry. Clarendon Press, Oxford
Wells M., Hestenes D., Swackhamer G.(1995). A Modelling Method for High School Physics Instruction. American Journal of Physics 63(7): 606–619
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Portides, D.P. The Relation between Idealisation and Approximation in Scientific Model Construction. Sci & Educ 16, 699–724 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11191-006-9001-6
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11191-006-9001-6