Abstract
Fibre-reinforced polymer (FRP) composites are gaining more attention for civil, automobile, aircraft and marine applications due to their excellent properties. The present work investigated the effect of ageing on mechanical properties of the autoclave-cured quasi-isotropic carbon/epoxy prepreg composites. The specimens were aged at artificial seawater under ambient, sub-zero (− 15 °C), and humid conditions (70% RH. and 40 °C) for 12 months. The tensile, flexural and impact properties were determined at regular intervals. The gravimetric study revealed that moisture absorption behaviour depended on the medium and duration of ageing condition. The moisture absorption for the quasi-isotropic carbon/epoxy composite specimens followed a non-fickian distribution. The moisture absorption of the carbon/epoxy composite laminate specimens showed an adverse effect on their mechanical properties. The moisture absorption results revealed that composite specimens aged under ambient condition absorbed more moisture compared with sub-zero and humid conditions. It was evident from the results that there was a 36.06% reduction in tensile properties of the composite specimens aged under ambient condition in comparison with pristine specimens. In contrast, the flexural properties were affected largely at sub-zero condition, and the impact properties were largely degraded at humid condition. The failure surface morphology revealed that matrix cracking and inner fibre debonding were the major causes of degradation in mechanical properties.
Graphical abstract
Similar content being viewed by others
Explore related subjects
Discover the latest articles, news and stories from top researchers in related subjects.Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
Introduction
Fibre-reinforced polymer (FRP) composite materials are preferred as a substitute for conventional materials because of their improved physical, chemical and mechanical properties. Owing to enhanced strength-to-weight ratio, corrosion resistance, and fatigue damage tolerance, fibre-reinforced composite materials have a wider range of applications in the aircraft, marine, and civil industries [1,2,3]. The fibre-reinforced composites are extensively employed in marine applications such as landing craft, personnel boats, shielding of wood hulls, and submarine sonar domes. Since 1980, use of FRP in the marine industries has increased extensively [4].
Glass fibre-reinforced polymer (GFRP) and carbon fibre-reinforced polymer (CFRP) composites are the major composite materials used in the marine industry. The applications of CFRP composites in the marine industry are stiffer hulls, decks, masts, corvettes, propulsion of shafts, rudders and propellers. Using CFRP composites in large marine applications reduced the hull’s weight by 30%. The composite propeller shafts, produced using CFRP laminates, offer better fatigue resistance, avoid corrosion problems and provide better vibration damping and air blast damage resistance [5, 6].
The selection of a suitable combination of matrix and fibres for marine structural applications in hostile environments is challenging among researchers. The durability of FRP under marine conditions mainly depends on environmental factors such as moisture, elevated temperature, and humidity [7]. In real-time, observing the changes in the material behaviour of FRP due to environmental conditions requires more time, owing to which researchers are now mainly focusing on accelerated ageing. Ageing is a process where the materials properties change over time. An ageing study determines the materials behaviour in any type of environments [8]. Depending on the service condition, FRP ageing tests can be chemical, physical, thermal, or a combination of them. Chemical ageing is the process of immersing FRPs in chemicals or water (seawater or distilled water, for example) for a predefined period to observe changes in mechanical and physical properties [9].
Capillary flow and diffusion are the primary mechanisms for the diffusion of water into FRP materials. Capillary flow is caused by flaws in the void, whereas diffusion is governed by molecular configurations. Plasticization and hydrolysis of resins and fibres are induced by moisture diffusion into the matrix phases [10, 11]. Plasticization lowers the fracture strength and viscosity of the polymer-water mixture, and hydrolysis causes debonding between fibres and matrix [12,13,14]. Thermal ageing is the process of detecting variations in the physical and chemical characteristics of FRP under specific temperature and humidity conditions. The temperature during ageing should be below the glass transition temperature of matrix material. The damage caused by chemical or thermal ageing increases with time, reducing the material strength and leading to failure [15,16,17].
In recent years, scientists have been focusing on understanding the effects of moisture absorption on the mechanical characteristics of FRP. Zong et al. [18] evaluated the mechanical properties of artificially aged CFRP and GFRP composites. After ageing in tap water at 80 ˚C for three months, moisture content was more in CFRP laminates than in GFRP ones. The increased moisture content was due to the reinforcement weave pattern, which might alter FRP moisture behaviour. Amounts of 11.01% and 15.98% reduction in tensile strength were observed for CFRP and GFRP composites, respectively. The diffusion coefficient for the CFRP specimens aged in normal water was more than that for seawater-aged specimens. This could be due to the higher concentration of dissolved salts in seawater, which prevented water from diffusing by osmosis.
The mechanical properties, such as tensile strength, degraded by 18% in normal water-immersed specimens, whereas it was decreased about 13% for the seawater-aged specimens [19]. The seven-month durability test of the carbon/epoxy specimens in seawater and NaCl solutions showed that moisture absorption was higher in the seawater-aged specimens than those aged in the NaCl solution. The tensile strength of the aged carbon/epoxy specimens decreased by 11.5 percent compared to the pristine specimen [20].
Forty-five days of durability test of the carbon/epoxy and glass/epoxy specimens under artificial seawater showed that glass/epoxy specimens absorbed more moisture than carbon/epoxy specimens. Moisture absorption caused plasticization and swelling resulting in the reduction of glass transition temperature (Tg) in both glass/epoxy and carbon/epoxy specimens. The seawater ageing resulted 7.7% and 3.1% reduction in flexural strength for carbon/epoxy and glass/epoxy specimens, respectively [21]. The flexural property analysis of 30 days seawater-aged carbon/epoxy specimens showed a 23% decrement compared with pristine specimens. The weak matrix-fibre interfacial bonding was the major reason for reducing mechanical properties in the conditioned carbon/epoxy specimens [22].
The moisture absorption behaviour of the carbon/epoxy composites exposed 300 days to saltwater and demineralized water was investigated by Zafar et al. [23]. Specimens aged in demineralized water had a greater equilibrium moisture content than those aged in saltwater. Accelerated ageing of the carbon/epoxy specimens resulted in a 20% degradation of tensile strength compared with the pristine specimens. The hygro-thermal ageing at 70 °C and 90% relative humidity (RH) of unidirectional carbon/epoxy specimens resulted in 41% reduction of tensile strength compared to the pristine specimens.
Askari et al. [24] examined the effect of thermal ageing (between 25 and 100 ºC) on carbon/epoxy laminates. The thermal ageing was carried out for 40 thermal cycles. The results revealed that the exposure of composite up to 40 cycles resulted in improvement in the impact properties. Scanning electron microscopic (SEM) studies showed that delamination and pullout were the primary types of failure observed during the study.
García-Moreno et al. [25] evaluated the effect of thermal ageing on the charpy impact and flexural properties of carbon/epoxy specimens. The thermal ageing below Tg caused an increase in the impact and bending strength. Above Tg, the properties were degraded with the duration of ageing. Dahil et al. [26] investigated the tensile and impact properties of hybrid glass-carbon fibre-reinforced composites. The results revealed that stacking sequence and the numbers of layers affected tensile and impact properties. SEM studies revealed the existence of surface cracks and matrix fractures after the tensile test.
Deng et al. [27] examined the effect of thermal ageing on the glass fibre-reinforced composite. The thermal ageing was performed in the range of 85 °C to 145 °C. The thermal ageing at that temperature resulted in the decrement of tensile and flexural properties. The higher temperature also caused brittle fractures and the deterioration between the fibres and matrix.
Observations based on previous studies revealed that the moisture absorption of polymer composite increased with ageing duration and temperature. Also, the studies showed that as ageing time increased, mechanical properties of the material deteriorated significantly. Several investigations on moisture absorption and its impact on mechanical properties focussed on unidirectional or angle ply, glass, or carbon epoxy composites. The literature focusing on the effects of moisture absorption and its effect on the mechanical properties of the quasi-isotropic composite laminates was limited.
The current work investigates the effects of moisture absorption on the mechanical properties of the quasi-isotropic carbon/epoxy laminates in marine environment conditions. The artificial seawater ageing investigation was carried out for 365 days in ambient, sub-zero, and humid conditions. The tensile, flexural and impact tests were performed at intervals of 3 months, and the results were compared with the pristine specimens. The thermogravimetric study was conducted to check the thermal stability of the quasi-isotropic carbon/epoxy specimens. The failure surface was analyzed using SEM technique.
Experimental
Materials
In the present work, a quasi-isotropic carbon/epoxy composite was fabricated from a unidirectional carbon fibre prepreg having a thickness of 0.2 mm and an areal weight of 200 gsm was procured from The BHOR Chemicals and Plastics Pvt Ltd, Nasik, India. The prepreg was made from carbon fibre fabric with a density of 1.8 g/cm3 and a tensile modulus of 240 GPa. Epoxy was used as the prepreg’s matrix material, having a tensile modulus of 2.91 GPa and a resin content of 38%.
Methods
The autoclave method was incorporated to fabricate carbon/epoxy laminates with a stacking sequence of [0°/ ± 45°/90°]s as reported else where [28]. The specimens were cut using a water jet cutting machine at Stonemax waterjet cutting. The average laminate thickness was 1.7 ± 0.021 mm. The 30 specimens with a dimension of 80 × 10 × 1.7 mm3 were weighed using digital balancing equipment having the least count of 0.001gms to determine experimental density. The average experimental density was 1.54 ± 0.041 g/cm3. The theoretical density was found to be 1.52 g/cm3 and calculated using the rule of mixtures. By comparing actual and theoretical densities, the void percentage in the fabricated carbon/epoxy laminate was estimated to be 1.31 percent.
Moisture absorption study
The primary aim of the current study is to examine the mechanical behaviour of quasi-isotropic carbon/epoxy laminates in the marine environment. ASTM D1141 standard was used to prepare artificial seawater to replicate the marine environment. The pH value of the prepared artificial seawater was maintained at 8.1. The selected three environments for the ageing process were (i) artificial seawater ageing at ambient temperature (≈ 30 °C), (ii) artificial seawater ageing at sub-zero temperature (− 15 ºC stored in a deep freezer), (iii) Humid conditions (70% RH and 40 ºC in an environmental chamber). The specimens were aged for 365 days.
As per ASTM D5229, the percentage of moisture gain of specimens during the ageing process was evaluated at regular intervals [29] and calculated as per Eq. (1) [30] as follows:
where Mt is the weight gain and Mo is the initial weight of the specimen (g). The moisture diffusion co-efficient (Dz) at three different ageing conditions was estimated according to Eq. (2) as follows:
where M∞ is equilibrium amount of moisture concentration, M1 and M2 (g) are the measured weights at different time periods t1 and t2 (s), correspondingly and L, h, and w are specimens length, thickness, and width (mm), respectively.
Mechanical characterization
To understand the effect of moisture absorption on mechanical properties, a series of tensile, flexural, and impact tests were conducted on aged carbon/epoxy specimens at regular intervals of 3 months. After the ageing period was completed, the specimens were stored in an airtight container. The results of aged specimens were compared with the pristine specimen.
The tensile tests were conducted under uniaxial tensile loading and displacement control mode with a 2 mm/min crosshead speed using a BiSS (India) 50 kN servo-hydraulic machine as per ASTM D3039. The tensile specimens were provided with glass fibre/epoxy end tabs for better gripping and to prevent specimen failure at gripping. The stress and strain at the fracture point were considered as the ultimate values of the carbon/epoxy specimens. The three-point flexural test assesses the carbon/epoxy specimens flexural strength and modulus.
The flexural test was conducted as per ASTM D790 using a UNITECH-9450 (India) UTM of 50 kN capacity with a crosshead speed of 1 mm/min. A rectangular specimen having a dimension of 120 × 12.7 × 1.7 mm3 with a span length of 87.5 mm was tested. The load vs displacement curve slope was utilized to calculate the flexural modulus.
A charpy impact test was performed to regulate the impact strength and energy absorption as per ISO 179. The testing energy was distributed evenly over the thickness of the specimen. The impact test was conducted using Zwick Roell JB-450I/750I (Germany) impact testing machine with a maximum energy of 25 J at a velocity of 3.809 m/s. In all test conditions, five specimens were tested to get the average tensile, flexural and impact strength of carbon/epoxy laminates.
TGA
Thermogravimetry analysis (TGA) is a technique for measuring the thermal stability of polymers and polymer-based composites. The powdered samples of pristine and aged carbon/epoxy laminates weighing 10 mg were tested to investigate the effect of ageing environment on their thermal stability. TGA was conducted by the TGA-55 (TA Instruments, New Castle, DE, USA) instrument using platinum pans with a resolution of 1 µg and could operate up to 1000 °C. The sample purge flow (nitrogen) was set to 60 mL/min, and the balance purge flow (air) at 15 mL/min. In a platinum pan, the powdered sample was heated to 800 °C at a rate of 10 °C/min.
SEM
The tensile failure surface morphology of pristine and aged carbon/epoxy specimens was analyzed using a SEM with 10 kV excitation voltage. To improve the electrical conductivity, a thin layer of gold sputtering was carried out for a period of 3–5 min on the carbon/epoxy specimens.
Results and discussion
Moisture absorption
The moisture absorption behaviour of carbon/epoxy quasi-isotropic laminates was calculated as per Eq. (1) and the moisture absorption curve for different ageing conditions is shown in Fig. 1.
The moisture content increased with an increase in the exposure period. The moisture absorption rate was found to be higher in the ambient conditions compared with other two conditions. The moisture absorption curve showed non-fickian moisture diffusion behaviour. The specimens aged under ambient and sub-zero conditions showed two-stage non-Fickian distribution. During the initial stages of absorption, a Fickian distribution was followed by non-Fickian distribution. In the first stage, the Fickian distribution response was thermally triggered, and the temperature accelerated the water absorption rate. The second stage can be attributed to structural relaxation creating voids that retain water molecules. The specimens aged under humid conditions followed sigmoidal type non-Fickian distribution attributed to phase void formation and localized ingress of water molecules [31].
The specimens aged in the artificial seawater gained 0.83%, 0.46% and 0.64% moisture in ambient, sub-zero, and humid conditions, respectively. Higher moisture absorption in ambient conditions than in humid conditions is due to the environmental humidity, which is essential in accelerating the water molecule penetration into the polymer matrix. The diffusion of moisture into carbon/epoxy specimens is controlled by the activity of water molecules, and it can be further influenced by relative humidity [32].
The water dispersion rate in the composite laminate through the area can be estimated by calculating the diffusion coefficient. The diffusion coefficient of the laminates was calculated according to Eq. (2), and the obtained results are shown in Table 1.
Carbon/epoxy specimens aged under ambient conditions had a greater moisture diffusion coefficient compared with sub-zero and humid conditions. Carbon/epoxy specimens aged in humid conditions had a lower diffusion coefficient. The decrease in moisture content and diffusion coefficient was due to the deterioration of matrix below glass transition temperature. When carbon/epoxy specimens were exposed to a humid condition, the specimens lost weight.
The chemical variations caused in the laminate due to ageing were assessed using the Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) technique. FTIR spectra of aged carbon/epoxy specimens were compared with a pristine specimen that are shown in Fig. 2.
The specimens were scanned in the frequency range of 500 cm−1 to 4000 cm−1. The vibration at 3700 cm−1 in all three ageing conditions confirms moisture absorption during the ageing process. The broad stretching of the peaks was due to the presence of the hydroxyl groups involved in hydrogen bonding. At 3700 cm−1 the intensity of these peaks was low due to a lower moisture absorption percentage compared with Fig. 1. The vibration in the range of 2230 cm−1 represented the stretching of C–O bonds. The peak intensity was higher for humid aged specimens than pristine, ambient, and sub-zero aged specimens. When carbon/epoxy specimens were immersed completely in seawater, the lack of oxygen prevented oxidation, and fewer peaks were observed for the specimens aged under ambient and sub-zero conditions. Whereas the presence of oxygen during humid conditions, the oxidation was more, hence showing sharper peaks [33]. The peaks in the range of 2020 cm−1 can be characterized by carboxyl group bending.
Effect of ageing on tensile properties
The variation of tensile strength and tensile modulus of carbon/epoxy specimens at pristine and different ageing conditions are showed in Figs. 3 a-c, respectively.
The pristine carbon/epoxy specimens show an average tensile strength of 372.16 ± 30.51 MPa at tensile strain of 0.0256 ± 0.0017 and an average tensile modulus of 15.7 ± 1.05 GPa. Following 365 days of exposure of carbon/epoxy specimens in artificial seawater, tensile properties were degraded. The specimens aged under ambient conditions showed a significant decrease in tensile properties than the other ageing condition (Fig. 3a). The tensile strength of ambient aged condition showed degradation of 10.84%, 17.08%, 32.73% and 36.06% in 3, 6, 9 and 12 months compared to the pristine specimen’s values (Fig. 3a).
The specimens aged under sub-zero conditions for the same period resulted in a degradation of tensile strength of 24.68% compared to pristine value (Fig. 3b). The specimens aged under humid conditions showed degradation of 21.3% compared to pristine value (Fig. 3c). Due to higher moisture content, tensile strength was more degraded in ambient and sub-zero aged conditions than in humid conditions, as shown in Fig. 3b, c. The moisture in the composite diffused through inherent microvoids and microcracks in the composite or might transfer through the fibre-matrix interface. The fibre-matrix interface is susceptible to moisture, thereby reducing the fibre-matrix interfacial adhesion, and as a result, the tensile strength of the composite was reduced [34, 35].
The tensile modulus of the specimens aged under ambient, sub-zero, and humid conditions compared to the pristine values showed a higher rate of degradation in the first three months, followed by a steady degradation in the subsequent three months. In the first three months of ageing, from the moisture absorption curve in Fig. 1, a higher percentage of moisture was induced into the carbon/epoxy laminates, due to which modulus showed a rapid degradation. During the further ageing stage, the rate of moisture induced into the carbon/epoxy laminates was lesser and resulted in steady degradation in tensile modulus. The specimens aged under ambient conditions, sub-zero and humid conditions showed reductions of 44.57%, 45% and 45.17% in their tensile modulus, respectively.
In the chemistry of polymer construction, polymer behaviour, hydrogen bonding, and Van Der Walls bonding significantly impact the load-bearing capacity of the polymer composites. As the moisture saturates the composite, hydrolysis and plasticization of the matrix occur, weakening the polymer chains and their bonding. Due to this, the interfacial bonding weakens, and polymer adhesion impaired, resulting in modulus degradation. The chemical reaction between chlorine ions of seawater and ions of carbon fibres also caused severe degradation of the tensile properties of the carbon fibre-reinforced composites [30, 36]. Tensile characteristics deterioration suggested that hygrothermal conditioning reduced the CFRP interfaces quality. Hygrothermal ageing utilizing seawater damaged the strain to fracture fibres within the composites.
Figure 4 a–d show the failure pattern of the specimens under pristine, ambient, sub-zero, and humid conditions. The failure in the carbon/epoxy composites was a combination of matrix and fibres failures [20]. The fibres oriented in 90° direction showed brittle failure. The fibres oriented with ± 45° directions resulted in fibres pullout and matrix cracking. The change from fibre-dominated material resistance to matrix-dominated material resistance caused the ± 45° orientations to lose strength more quickly than 0° fibres. The fibres in 0° orientation in the loading direction showed fibre breakage. With further ageing time (3 months), the delamination between the layers occurred, resulting in pullout of the fibres. The main reason behind such phenomenon was a degradation of the fibre-matrix interphase. As the ageing period increased, delamination became more intense, leading to the catastrophic failure of the CFRP specimens.
Effect of ageing on flexural properties
The flexural test of the aged carbon/epoxy specimens is favourable over tensile loading as it subjects the specimen to bending, tension, compression, and shear. The variation of flexural strength and flexural modulus of carbon/epoxy specimens under different ageing conditions are showed in Figs. 5 a–c.
The pristine carbon/epoxy specimens showed a flexural strength of 748.91 ± 14.82 MPa and a flexural modulus of 43.22 ± 3.67 GPa. However, the immersion of carbon/epoxy specimens in seawater for 12 months resulted in a decrement in flexural properties (Fig. 5a). The specimens aged under sub-zero condition showed a significant reduction in flexural properties compared with the pristine, ambient, and humid conditions (Fig. 5b). The flexural strength of specimens aged under sub-zero conditions decreased by 17.21% compared with the pristine specimen values. In contrast, flexural strength dropped by 8.21% and 13.21% in ambient and humid conditions, respectively. In the initial phases of moisture absorption, the carbon/epoxy specimens absorbed moisture rapidly, thereby reducing the internal stress, due to which the flexural strength decreased quickly.
Due to the high moisture and sub-zero temperature environment, the plasticization and swelling of the matrix occur, resulting in decreased flexural strength of carbon/epoxy specimens [37]. Under sub-zero conditions, the frozen water molecules entered these voids, making the material more brittle. The flexural modulus of the aged composite resulted in a steady degradation compared to the pristine specimen value (Fig. 5b). The flexural modulus degraded by 7.03% in sub-zero, 0.68% in humid and 1.2% in ambient conditions. It was observed that the reduction in flexural properties in seawater-aged carbon/epoxy specimens was due to the weakening of the bond between the epoxy matrix and carbon fibre leading to the failure of the carbon fibre at the outer surface. The interaction between O–H groups and fibres created hydrogen bonding is the cause of the low resistance.
Further, the moisture absorption resulted in poor interphase adhesion, thereby reducing the flexural properties of the specimens. Two modes of failure were observed during the flexural testing; the first crack initiation was heard before the total rupture of the specimen, indicating that breakage of matrix material was followed by delamination and fibre-matrix debonding, followed by tensile fracture of the specimens. The general failure during flexural tests was included tensile, compressive and shear resulting in matrix failure, delamination, fibre failure and fibre matrix debonding [38, 39].
Effect of ageing on impact properties
The variation of impact properties of carbon/epoxy specimens under different ageing conditions is shown in Figs. 6 a–c.
The pristine carbon/epoxy specimens showed an impact strength of 75.04 ± 5.87 kJ/m2. It was evident that seawater immersion of carbon/epoxy specimens for 12 months reduced the impact strength. It was apparent from the experimental results the impact strength was directly related to stacking sequence, temperature, and ageing process. Energy absorption and impact strength were reduced due to the brittleness of the carbon fibre and matrix. The specimens aged under humid conditions showed a decrease of 6.39% compared with the pristine specimen value. Due to the higher temperature under humid conditions, the carbon/epoxy specimens absorbed more moisture, reducing the energy absorbed and the impact strength.
For specimens aged under ambient and sub-zero conditions, impact strength increased in the first six months, followed by a steady degradation in the final ageing period. During ambient and sub-zero ageing, the moisture ingressed into the polymer matrix increased free volume, thereby reducing Tg and making the material ductile. The increased flexibility resulted in plasticization, thus requiring higher energy to break the specimen [40]. At the end of ageing, the specimens aged under ambient and sub-zero conditions showed a reduction of 3.96% and 8.48% in impact strength, respectively. The impact properties were reduced mainly due to the absorbed moisture causing the plasticization, which weakened the fibre matrix interphase [41, 42]. During the impact testing, along with brittle fracture and fibre breakage, matrix cracking and delamination-dominated failure were observed in the carbon/epoxy specimens.
Thermogravimetry analysis
The thermogravimetric study was conducted on quasi-isotropic carbon/epoxy composites to measure their thermal stability. The thermal analysis of the carbon/epoxy composites started with heating up to 800 ˚C at a constant heating rate. The variation of thermogravimetry curves of carbon/epoxy specimens under pristine, ambient, sub-zero, and humid conditions are showed in Figs. 7 a–d.
Bhor prepreg A45 was the epoxy used in the prepreg preparation. The thermogravimetry analysis on A45 resin showed that decomposition occurred when the temperature reached 150 °C, but from Fig. 7, it can be observed that the thermal stability of A45 epoxy resin was increased after incorporating carbon fibres in both pristine and aged composites specimens.
The thermogram can be characterized by TD, representing the temperature at which 2% weight loss occurred and where the decomposition started. T10 represents the temperature where 10% weight loss occurs, SDR is the threshold value of rapid decomposition, where rapid decomposition of resin starts, and R500 represents the remaining residue after 500 °C. For pristine specimens in Fig. 7a, 2% weight loss was noted in the range of 235 °C, where epoxy started to degrade. The T10 was observed at 380.6 C, SDR around 390 °C, and the epoxy degraded rapidly. As the temperature reached 500 °C, the epoxy in the composite had degraded completely, and only the fibres remained.
For ambient conditioned composite specimen shown in Fig. 7b, the 2% weight loss was observed at a temperature of around 249 °C. The increment was due to the water molecule entering the matrix material, which changed the chemical composition of epoxy. The 10% weight loss was observed at around 378 °C, and the rapid degradation started at around 392 °C.
For sub-zero conditioned composite specimen (Fig. 7c), TD was increased to 274 °C compared with those specimens at pristine and ambient conditions. The 10% reduction and standard value of rapid decomposition were observed around 375 °C and 395 °C, respectively. For composite specimen under humid condition (Fig. 7d), the decomposition of epoxy started around 260 °C. But for composite specimen aged in all conditions, the epoxy entirely deteriorated at the temperature around 500 °C.
Failure surface evaluation
The failure pattern of the pristine and aged composite specimens was examined using SEM technique. Figure 8 a–d show the failure patterns of tensile tested specimens under pristine and ambient, sub-zero, and humid aged conditions.
The fracture morphology of the pristine and aged specimens showed that fibres debonding was the typical mode of the failure. The SEM micrographs of tensile fractured pristine specimen shown in Fig. 8a revealed that fibres breakage was neat, indicating a better fibre-matrix interface. In addition, the presence of residual matrix flakes around the fibres surfaces indicated good fibre-matrix adhesion.
After the immersion of carbon/epoxy specimens in artificial seawater, fibres were not broken as the same as those in the case of pristine specimens, showing fibres pullout and matrix debonding, indicating the damage to the fibre-matrix interface as shown in Fig. 8 b, c, and d. After the specimens were aged under seawater, the carbon/epoxy specimens showed a brittle fracture. The fibres surfaces had become smooth for the aged carbon/epoxy specimens, and there were no residual flakes presented in the aged specimens, resulting in weak fibre-matrix adhesion. The severe degradation of the fibre-matrix adhesion resulted in decrease of mechanical properties of the aged carbon/epoxy specimens.
Conclusion
In the present work, moisture absorption and its impact on mechanical properties of the carbon/epoxy composite laminates were experimentally investigated. Carbon/epoxy laminates were aged in artificial seawater for 12 months under ambient, sub-zero, and humid conditions. Tensile, flexural and impact tests were performed once in three months. From the obtained results the following deductions can be drawn.
-
(1)
The gravimetric measurements have shown that the moisture absorption behaviour of carbon/epoxy laminates mainly depends on environmental conditions and the duration of ageing. The moisture absorption for carbon/epoxy composite laminates followed non-fickian distribution. The matrix-dominated characteristics have been reduced because of the ageing process and moisture absorption. A higher percentage of moisture content and higher diffusion coefficients were observed in the carbon/epoxy specimens immersed in ambient conditions compared with the other two conditions.
-
(2)
The tensile, flexural and impact properties mainly depended on ageing period. Tensile properties were degraded more at ambient condition. The moisture induced into the material weakened the fibre-matrix adhesion resulting in the decrement of tensile properties. In contrast, the flexural properties were degraded more in the carbon/epoxy specimens aged under sub-zero condition, and impact properties were degraded more in humid conditions. The absorbed moisture caused plasticization, which weakened the impact properties.
-
(3)
The thermogravimetric study showed that the carbon/epoxy composites were thermally stable up to 400 °C in a nitrogen atmosphere. The epoxy matrix started to degrade at around 400 °C, and epoxy was completely degraded at around 500 °C. From the results, it can be concluded that the thermal stability of the epoxy matrix material improved after incorporating carbon fibres.
-
(4)
SEM fracture analysis showed that fibres pullout and fibre-matrix interface debonding were the significant destructions observed for pristine and aged carbon/epoxy specimens. The SEM micrographs also showed that after hygrothermal ageing, the carbon/epoxy composites experienced degradation in the fibre-matrix interface, resulting in decline of mechanical properties.
Data Availability
The authors confirm that the data supporting the findings of this study are available within the article and its supplementary materials.
References
Subhani M, Al-Ameri R (2016) Strength reduction in square columns confined with CFRP under marine environment. Compos Part B Eng 97:183–192
Rao YS, Mohan NS, Shetty N, Shivamurthy B (2019) Drilling and structural property study of multi-layered fiber and fabric reinforced polymer composite-a review. Mater Manuf Process 34:1549–1579
Alam P, Robert C, Brádaigh CM (2018) Tidal turbine blade composites-A review on the effects of hygrothermal aging on the properties of CFRP. Compos Part B Eng 149:248–259
Mayya HB, Pai D, Kini VM, Padmaraj NH (2021) Effect of marine environmental conditions on physical and mechanical properties of fiber-reinforced composites—a review. J Inst Eng Ser C 102:843–849
Rubino F, Nisticò A, Tucci F, Carlone P (2020) Marine application of fiber reinforced composites: a review. J Mar Sci Eng 8:26
Gargano A, Pingkarawat K, Blacklock M, Pickerd V, Mouritz AP (2017) Comparative assessment of the explosive blast performance of carbon and glass fibre-polymer composites used in naval ship structures. Compos Struct 171:306–316
Padmaraj NH, Kini VM, Pai D (2021) Experimental investigation on fatigue behaviour of glass/epoxy quasi-isotropic laminate composites under different ageing conditions. Int J Fatigue 143:105992
Karbhari VM, Chin JW, Hunston D, Benmokrane B, Juska T, Morgan R, Lesko JJ, Sorathia U, Reynaud AD (2003) Durability gap analysis for fiber-reinforced polymer composites in civil infrastructure. Journal of composites for construction. J Compos Constr 7:238–247
Wang JU, Gangarao HO, Liang R, Liu W (2016) Durability and prediction models of fiber reinforced polymer composites under various environmental conditions: a critical review. J Reinf Plast Compos 35:179–211
Jiang X, Kolstein H, Bijlaard F, Qiang X (2014) Effects of hygrothermal aging on glass-fibre reinforced polymer laminates and adhesive of FRP composite bridge: moisture diffusion characteristics. Compos Part A Appl Sci Manuf 57:49–58
dos Santos JC, de Oliveira LA, Panzera TH, Remillat CD, Farrow I, Placet V, Scarpa F (2020) Ageing of autoclaved epoxy/flax composites: effects on water absorption, porosity and flexural behaviour. Compos Part B Eng 202:108380
Wang J, Ganga Rao H, Liang R, Zhou D, Liu W, Fang Y (2015) Durability of glass fiber-reinforced polymer composites under the combined effects of moisture and sustained loads. J Reinf Plast Compos 34:1739–1754
Glaskova-Kuzmina T, Zotti A, Borriello A, Zarrelli M, Aniskevich A (2021) Basalt fibre composite with carbon nanomodified epoxy matrix under hydrothermal ageing. Polymers 13:532
Fang M, Zhang N, Huang M, Lu B, Lamnawar K, Liu C, Shen C (2020) Effects of hydrothermal aging of carbon fiber reinforced polycarbonate composites on mechanical performance and sand erosion resistance. Polymers 12:2453
Kootsookos A, Mouritz AP (2004) Seawater durability of glass-and carbon-polymer composites. Compos Sci Technol 64:1503–1511
Cheng M, Zhong Y, Kureemun U, Cao D, Hu H, Lee HP, Li S (2020) Environmental durability of carbon/flax fiber hybrid composites. Compos Struct 234:111719
Zhu J, Deng Y, Chen P, Wang G, Min H, Fang W (2022) Prediction of long-term tensile properties of glass fiber reinforced composites under acid-base and salt environments. Polymers 14:3031
Zhong Y, Cheng M, Zhang X, Hu H, Cao D, Li S (2019) Hygrothermal durability of glass and carbon fiber reinforced composites–a comparative study. Compos Struct 211:134–143
Kafodya I, Xian G, Li H (2015) Durability study of pultruded CFRP plates immersed in water and seawater under sustained bending: water uptake and effects on the mechanical properties. Compos Part B Eng 70:138–148
Li H, Zhang K, Fan X, Cheng H, Xu G, Suo H (2019) Effect of seawater ageing with different temperatures and concentrations on static/dynamic mechanical properties of carbon fiber reinforced polymer composites. Compos Part B Eng 173:106910
Ghabezi P, Harrison N (2020) Mechanical behavior and long-term life prediction of carbon/epoxy and glass/epoxy composite laminates under artificial seawater environment. Mater Lett 261:127091
Mamalis D, Floreani C, ÓBrádaigh CM (2021) Influence of hygrothermal ageing on the mechanical properties of unidirectional carbon fibre reinforced powder epoxy composites. Compos Part B Eng 225:109281
Zafar A, Bertocco F, Schjødt-Thomsen J, Rauhe JC (2012) Investigation of the long term effects of moisture on carbon fibre and epoxy matrix composites. Compos Sci Technol 72:656–666
Askari M, Javadi M, Eslami-Farsani R, Geranmayeh A (2023) Impact properties of carbon fibersepoxy composite/aluminum laminates: effect of cryogenic and thermal aging. Iran Polym J 32:187–201
García-Moreno I, Caminero MÁ, Rodríguez GP, López-Cela JJ (2019) Effect of thermal ageing on the impact and flexural damage behaviour of carbon fibre-reinforced epoxy laminates. Polymers 11:80
Dahil L, Kaya K, Erkendirci ÖF, Arslan K (2022) Tensile strength and impact toughness of carbon/glass fiber hybrid composites with surface crack. Iran Polym J 31:275–286
Deng J, Song Y, Xu Z, Nie Y, Lan Z (2022) Thermal aging effects on the mechanical behavior of glass-fiber-reinforced polyphenylene sulfide composites. Polymers 14:1275
Padmaraj NH, Kini VM, Shreepannaga AU, Pai D (2021) Slurry erosion behaviour of carbon/epoxy quasi-isotropic laminates based on Taguchi’s optimization method. Eng Fail Anal 123:105274
Grammatikos SA, Zafari B, Evernden MC, Mottram JT, Mitchels JM (2015) Moisture uptake characteristics of a pultruded fibre reinforced polymer flat sheet subjected to hot/wet aging. Polym Degrad Stab 121:407–419
Ridzuan MJM, Abdul Majid MS, Afendi M, Azduwin K, Amin NAM, Zahri JM, Gibson AG (2016) Moisture absorption and mechanical degradation of hybrid Pennisetum purpureum/glass–epoxy composites. Compos Struct 141:110–116
Dhakal HN, MacMullen J, Zhang ZY (2015) In: Marine applications of advanced fibre-reinforced composites. In: Summerscales J (ed) Graham-Jones J. Elsevier, Amesterdam
Wang M, Xu X, Ji J, Yang Y, Shen J, Ye M (2016) The hygrothermal aging process and mechanism of the novolac epoxy resin. Compos Part B Eng 107:1–8
Haghighi-Yazdi M, Lee-Sullivan P (2015) FTIR analysis of a polycarbonate blend after hygrothermal aging. J Appl Polym Sci 132:41316
Açıkbaş G (2018) Interfacial and physico-mechanical properties of walnut shell fiber reinforced polyester matrix composites. Mater Test 60:510–518
Kumar SB, Sridhar I, Sivashanker S (2008) Influence of humid environment on the performance of high strength structural carbon fiber composites. Mater Sci Eng A 498:174–178
Fang Y, Wang K, Hui D, Xu F, Liu W, Yang S, Wang L (2017) Monitoring of seawater immersion degradation in glass fibre reinforced polymer composites using quantum dots. Compos Part B Eng 112:93–102
Niu Y-F, Yan Y, Yao J-W (2021) Hygrothermal aging mechanism of carbon fiber/epoxy resin composites based on quantitative characterization of interface structure. Polym Test 94:107019
Athijayamani A, Thiruchitrambalam M, Natarajan U, Pazhanivel B (2009) Effect of moisture absorption on the mechanical properties of randomly oriented natural fibers/polyester hybrid composite. Mater Sci Eng A 517:344–353
Jesthi DK, Nayak RK (2019) Evaluation of mechanical properties and morphology of seawater aged carbon and glass fiber reinforced polymer hybrid composites. Compos Part B Eng 174:106980
Oğuz ZA, Erkliğ A, Bozkurt ÖY (2021) Effects of hydrothermal seawater aging on the mechanical properties and water absorption of glass/aramid/epoxy hybrid composites. Int Polym Process 36:79–93
Tanoglu M, McKnight SH, Palmese GR, Gillespie JW Jr (2001) The effects of glass-fiber sizings on the strength and energy absorption of the fiber/matrix interphase under high loading rates. Compos Sci Technol 61:205–220
Fu S-Y, Feng X-Q, Lauke B, Mai Y-W (2008) Effects of particle size, particle/matrix interface adhesion and particle loading on mechanical properties of particulate–polymer composites. Compos Part B Eng 39:933–961
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to thank the Naval Research Board, Government of India (Project No: NRB-438/MAT/18-19) for providing the funding. The authors thank the Manipal Institute of Technology and Manipal Academy of Higher Education, Manipal, India for providing fabrication and testing facilities.
Funding
Open access funding provided by Manipal Academy of Higher Education, Manipal.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of interest
The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
About this article
Cite this article
Aithal, S., Hossagadde, P.N., Kini, M.V. et al. Durability study of quasi-isotropic carbon/epoxy composites under various environmental conditions. Iran Polym J 32, 873–885 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1007/s13726-023-01172-x
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s13726-023-01172-x