Abstract
Existing ratoon sugarcane management machinery cannot satisfy the new agronomic requirements for the integration of ratoon sugarcane ridge-breaking, fertilizing, and re-ridging. Thus, a machine integrating these functions for ratoon sugarcane was designed. The machine structure and key components were designed in accordance with the analysis results of the agronomic requirements. The field orthogonal experiments indicated that the factors affecting the broken rate of soil are speed of rotary shaft, forward speed, and working depth. The influence on the hilling height includes the following aspects: working depth, speed of rotary shaft, and forward speed. Analysis of variance showed that the speed of rotary shaft and forward speed had exceedingly significant effect on the broken rate of soil, the working depth had exceedingly significant effect on the hilling height, and the speed of the rotary shaft reached a significant level. When the tractor was at low gear III and its forward speed was 1.2 m/s, the speed of the rotary shaft was 300 r/min, and the working depth was 20 cm, the verification experiments indicated that the hilling height and the broken rate of soil were 87.4% and 17.0 cm, respectively. The combination of these operating parameters could obtain a better balance between effect and efficiency. Results of production experiments showed that the field performance of the machine satisfied the agronomic requirements, and the ratoon sugarcane sprouted and grew well in the experimental area. The research provided a supporting machine to promote the application of new agronomic practice for ratoon sugarcane management.
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
Introduction
Sugarcane is one of the most important sugar crops in China, where sucrose production is approximately 90% of the sugar production (Bai 2021). Sugarcane is planted in an area of approximately 1.08 million hectares in China, of which the ratoon sugarcane accounts for 50% to 70% of the cultivated area (Chen and Hu 2021; Zhou et al. 2013). Quality and yield of ratoon sugarcane are important to sugar industry (Singh et al 2011).
Agricultural scientists have presented a new agronomic practice that integrates ratoon sugarcane ridge-breaking, fertilizing, and re-ridging to enhance productivity and develop simplified cultivation techniques for ratoon sugarcane. This agronomic practice is as follows. First, ridges are broken immediately after sugarcane harvesting, trash shredding, and stubble shaving. Second, the soil is crushed and mixed with shredded trash. Finally, the slow-release fertilizer is earthed up, and the crushed soil is used to cover the stubbles. This new agronomic practice can reduce rot diseases caused by stubble exposure, maintain warmth, prevent frostbite, loosen the soil, and promote the sprouting of underground buds. Furthermore, given that the intertillage season in the seedling stage is extremely short, and inaccurate time can cause yield reduction (Li 2010; Liu et al 2021), this agronomic practice dispenses with intertillage of seedling stage. Therefore, this agronomic practice can increase productivity and reduce cultivation cost.
At present, to reduce ratoon sugarcane management cost, scholars have carried out research on ratoon sugarcane management machine. A small ratoon sugarcane ridge-breaking fertilizer applicator mounted with a walking tractor was developed to solve the operation problem in small hills (Xu et al. 2014). The 2CLF-1 ratoon sugarcane field managing machine was designed for conventional operations, such as stubble shaving, ridge-breaking, fertilization, and film mulching (Qin et al. 2015). Tang et al. (2019) developed a machine for ratoon sugarcane shoveling. Singh et al. (2017a) designed and developed a disk-type sugarcane ratoon management device for ratoon field with trash and evaluated in sandy loam soil. Choudhary et al. (2017) modified and upgraded a machine into multipurpose SORF machine, and its performance was evaluated with field experiments and contrasted with conventional practice. This research was aimed at conventional agronomic operations, given that studies on the supporting machine for the new agronomic practice are limited. The existing machinery was inapplicable to new agronomic requirements. Thus, a machine integrating ridge-breaking, fertilizing, and ridging for ratoon sugarcane was designed. The machine was evaluated in a series of field experiments.
Materials and Methods
An integrated machine was designed and developed in accordance with new agronomic requirements. It consisted of base frame, plow of ridge-breaking, transmission, rotary tillage unit, fertilizer unit, hilling unit, and ridge compacting unit (Fig. 1). The working units could be adjusted in accordance with different row spacing. The working processes of the machine are shown in Fig. 2, and the technical parameters are shown in Table 1.
Transmission Unit
The working power of the entire machine was provided by a tractor and delivered through a transmission unit. It consists of a transmission shaft, worm drive box, bevel gearbox, hexagonal shaft, and a series of driving chains (Fig. 3). Initially, the power take-off (PTO) driveshaft transmitted power to the bevel gearbox by transmission shaft. Then, the gearbox transmitted power to the chain drive unit and fertilization gear on both sides. Finally, the rotary blade unit was driven by the chain drive unit to rotate, the fertilization gear transmitted power to the worm gear by chain drive, and the fertilizer turntable was driven by the worm drive to rotate.
Base Frame
Base frame was designed to rigidly support different components, and it was provided with three-point linkage for connecting with the tractor. It was made of mild steel square pipe (80 mm × 80 mm) with a wall thickness of 8 mm. The power of the machine was provided by the tractor, which was connected through the three-point linkage of the frame to pull the machine forward and control the cutting depth.
Plow of Ridge-Breaking
The front of the frame was designed with four plows of ridge-breaking to split and pre-loose the solid soil in the area to be rotated to reduce the working resistance of the rotary tillage unit and improve soil crushing rate and reliability of the rotary tillage unit. In addition, the plow was used for cracking the soil near the root to increase the permeability and cutting of side old roots. Each plow consisted of a mounting base and plow body with holes at 60-mm intervals for depth adjustment, as required (Akhalaya and Shogenov 2017; Salar et al. 2013). Replaceable high manganese steel colter was mounted on the plow body by pin to protect plowshare from being worn. The selected penetrating angle was 27°, and the gap angle was 10°(Fig. 4).
Rotary Tillage Unit
Rotary tillage unit was designed to spin through the power take-off driveshaft of the tractor at a rotational speed of 200–300 r/min to break the ridge and crush the soil according to the calculation theory and the reference (Zhong et al. 2021). It consisted of a chain drive unit, rotary blade unit, balk plow, and arc-shaped baffle (Fig. 5). The rotary blade unit was connected to the chain drive unit by spline joint. According to tilling width, 12 rotary blades were mounted on two disks of the rotary blade unit, and the cutting area is divided into four parts. The disks were made of 15-mm-thick and 220-mm-diameter circular steel plate, and the drive shaft was made of 80-mm-diameter, 16-mm-thick, and 210-mm-long steel hollow shaft. The working diameter of the rotary tillage was 530 mm, and the designed maximum working depth was 210 mm. The axial thrust effect of the rotary tillage was highlighted, evenly stressed, and worked stably to increase the soil lateral supply; the rotary blades of each rotary blade unit were arranged in a staggered six-head short spiral line (Zhang et al. 2019; Jia et al. 2011). An arc-shaped baffle mounted on top of the rotary blade unit was designed to divert the soil particles thrown by the rotary tillage cutting to the side. The baffle could facilitate subsequent soil accumulation and ridge formation and prevent soil particles from hitting the operators and entering the transmission unit.
Hilling Unit
The hilling plow was mounted on the rear of the frame by mounting base and using fasteners. Each plow consisted of the plow body, two active moldboards, and adjusting mechanism. Replaceable wearing plates were mounted on the plowshare by pin to protect the plowshare from being worn (Fig. 6). The selected materials included 30-mm-thick mild steel plate for plow standard and 5-mm-thick high manganese steel plate for active moldboard. In accordance with the row spacing, the width range of the plow was 400–700 mm with an adjusting mechanism, and the height was 370 mm (Singh et al. 2017b). The plow bottom surface was designed with horizontal straight-line elements, the opening of the guiding curve was 232 mm, and the element angle was in the range of 36.5°–40°. The plow squeezed the crushed soil to both sides and covered the stubbles in advance. Then, the soil forms a natural ridge shape for easy compaction according to the repose angle.
Ridge Compacting Unit
Lack of soil in the stubbles can cause accumbent sugarcane, yield reduction of high cutting by sugarcane harvesters, and aboveground buds sprouting. Thus, a ridge compacting unit was designed. When the hilling process was completed, the sugarcane ridge should be reshaped and compacted to form a drum-type ridge shape with single-peak. This shape is beneficial to rainwater flow and avoids lack of soil in stubbles with rain erosion. The unit was designed as an elastic floating with profiling adjustment to adapt to the change in the sugarcane field. It consisted of regulation spring, connector, and ridge roller (Fig. 7). The traction to the ridge compacting unit was provided through connecting the connector and mounting base of the hilling plow. The ridge roller reshaped and compacted the ridge due to its own weight. When it encountered a large volume of mud that cannot be crushed, the traction resistance of the roller increased, and the spring contraction drove the roller body to bounce up to avoid clogging of the large clod and trash. The large clod and trash in front of the roller increased the traction resistance and affected the forming effect. The minimum diameter of the roller body was 85 mm, and the maximum diameter was 125 mm; the diameter of the mounting shaft was 50 mm, the width of the middle roller body was 700 mm, and the width of the side roller body was 450 mm. Nylon material was selected for the roller body, and steel hollow pipe was selected for the mounting shaft to reduce the weight of the unit and soil adhesion.
Fertilizer Unit
The slow-release fertilizer of the new agronomic practice was granulated fertilizer. A guide plate fertilizer feed unit was designed to prevent the fertilizer from clogging due to moisture (Fig. 8). Granulated fertilizers spilled from the fertilizer box to the turntable due to their own weight. The turntable served as the feeding conveyor, and the fertilizers flowed from the gap between the fertilizer box and outer turntable through rotation. Then, the fertilizers rose along the slope of the guide plate by thrust to the turntable edge and dropped into the fertilizer pipe to be discharged. Adjusting the guide plate height and gap of the fertilizer box and turntable could control fertilization.
Performance Evaluation
The performance of the integrated machine was evaluated by the operating parameters of the field experiment. The experiment was carried out at the base of research and breeding for sugarcane in the subtropical agricultural science new city of Guangxi, China. The area is located at 22°30′N, 107°46′E with subtropical monsoon climate, having humid hot summer and dry cold winter. The soil in the experimental area was laterite soil in texture (44% clay, 37% silt, and 19% sand). The detailed conditions of the experimental area are shown in Table 2. The experiment was conducted in December 2020 (Fig. 9).
Experimental Factors and Indicators
The effects of the operating parameters on the agronomic indicators were investigated in the experiments. The parameters included forward speed of the machine, speed of the rotary shaft, and working depth in accordance with the actual operating conditions of the tractor driver. The indicators included the broken rate of soil and hilling height in accordance with the agronomic requirements.
Flat and stable working areas were selected as the measurement areas, and the measurement point was obtained every two meters along the row, with a total of 10 points. The height of the soil ridge formed by burying the stubbles was measured, and the schematic of the measurement is shown in Fig. 10 (Zhang et al. 2018). In addition, the mean value of the hilling height was considered for this measurement. DHF-LX1204 tractor was used for power.
In the same measurement area, one measurement point was obtained every three meters, with a total of three points. An area of 0.5 m in length along the row and width of soil disturbance range was selected in each measurement point. Soil blocks of the area were divided into two parts in accordance with the maximum diameter, as follows: the unbroken soil blocks with a maximum diameter greater than 25 mm and the broken soil blocks with maximum diameter below 25 mm (Lv et al. 2019). The two parts of the soil blocks were weighed separately. The broken rate of soil was calculated according to Eq. (1), and its mean value was considered for this measurement.
where St is the broken rate of soil, %, Ws is the weight of broken soil blocks, kg, and Ww is the weight of unbroken soil blocks, kg.
Field Experiment Design
A three-factor three-level orthogonal experiment was designed to study the effect of forward speed of the machine, speed of the rotary shaft, and working depth on the indicators, as well as the optimal combination of these operating parameters. The levels were preliminarily confirmed by theoretical calculation and design requirements prior to the experiment. I low, II low, and III low operating gears were selected as the levels to characterize the forward speed of the machine according to the technical parameters of the tractor and machine technical specification because the forward speed of the machine was determined by the tractor gear. The speed range is 0.65–1.2 m/s (Xiao 1999). The coding table of the experiment factors and levels is shown in Table 3. Orthogonal table was selected as the experimental arrangement, and nine sets of experiments were performed. The experimental arrangement and mean values of the results are shown in Table 4.
Results and Discussion
The variance of the three-factor three-level experimental data was analyzed by Minitab software to investigate the significance of the effect of the factors on the indicators. The significance test was performed with p value, and the result is shown in Table 5.
According to the analysis of variance, for the broken rate of soil, the parameters in the order of significance were speed of rotary shaft, forward speed of the machine, and working depth. The speed of the rotary shaft and forward speed of the machine had an extremely significant effect on the broken rate of soil with p value; the effect of the working depth was insignificant. This result was consistent with the theory of the effect of bite length on the quality of broken soil, where the forward speed was higher, the bite length was longer, and the broken rate of soil was lower. The higher speed of the rotary shaft indicates smaller bite length and higher broken rate of soil. Under the condition of uniform soil quality in the field, the working depth unaffected the bite length; thus, the effect on the broken soil rate was insignificant.
For the hilling height, because the mean square of factor A was smaller than the mean square of the error, the forward speed of the machine slightly affected the hilling height and could be classified as an error (Ren 2009). According to the analysis result, the working depth had an extremely significant effect on the hilling height, and the speed of the rotary shaft had a significant effect. The working depth was extremely significant and indicated that the larger working depth results in greater excavation amount and higher hilling height. The speed of the rotary shaft was significant and indicated that the higher speed leads to more soil thrown out, thereby effectively increasing the hilling height.
The main effect plots are shown in Fig. 11; the mean level of two indicators had three factors, and the range analysis was performed (Table 6). Figure 11 and Table 6 show that the primary and secondary factors influence the broken rate of soil; they include speed of the rotary shaft, forward speed of the machine, and working depth. The optimal combination of the operating parameters, namely B3A1C3 positively affected the broken rate of soil. The working depth had the greatest effect on the hilling height, followed by the speed of rotary shaft; the forward speed of machine had the least effect. The optimal combination was C3B3A3. The result was consistent with the analysis of variance.
Verification Experiment
According to the range analysis, the optimal combination for two indicators was different. The optimal level of factors that significantly affected each indicator was selected, and the optimal combination A1B3C3 of the two indicators was obtained from the results of the orthogonal experiment. However, the combination C3B3A3 with the greatest hilling height was not obtained from the orthogonal experiments. Furthermore, the actual working process not only considered the effect but also the efficiency. According to the basic requirements of agricultural mechanization for the construction of high-quality and high-yield sugar cane base in Guangxi, the broken rate of soil reached 85%, and the hilling height reached 15 cm with the agronomic requirements.
According to Table 4, the combinations that satisfied the agronomic requirements were A1B3C3 and A2B2C3. However, the optimal combination A3B3C3 for the hilling height was not obtained from the orthogonal experiments. Therefore, a ratoon field with slope and soil conditions similar to the experimental area was selected to carry out verification experiments. The result is shown in Table 7.
Three parameter combinations satisfied the agronomic requirements based on the verification result of the experiment. The field efficiency was determined by the forward speed of the machine. Thus, to avoid missing the farming season and to reduce the cost of operation, the A3B3C3 combination with higher efficiency could be selected when the best effect was not required.
After the test prototype was adjusted and improved, the production experiment was carried out at the base in the crushing season for 2020–2021. The production experiment status is shown in Fig. 12.
Economic Analysis
For example, in the Guangxi sugarcane area of China, the conventional ratoon management included ridge-breaking and intertillage of seedling stage. The total cost of machine operation included the abovementioned components; the average was between ¥1200 and ¥1500 per ha. However, the cost of integration included ratoon ridge-breaking, fertilizing, and re-ridging without intertillage of the seedling stage. The cost was between ¥900 and ¥1050 per ha and reduced by ¥300–450 per ha compared with the conventional practice (1Chinese Yuan = 0.16 US$).
Conclusions
A machine integrating ridge-breaking, fertilizing, and ridging for ratoon sugarcane was designed in accordance with the new agronomic requirements. A series of field and production experiments were conducted for the test prototype. The field performance and seedling status showed that the integrated machine can satisfy the agronomic requirement. This study introduced an agricultural machine for popularization and application of the new agronomic practice.
The influence law of each operating parameter on the effect was obtained through the orthogonal experiment. The speed of the rotary shaft and the forward speed of the machine had an extremely significant effect on the broken rate of soil. The working depth had an extremely significant effect on the hilling height, and the speed of the rotary shaft had a significant effect.
Three parameter combinations that satisfy the agronomic requirements were obtained through verification experiment in the field and provided basis for selecting operating parameters for operators in field practice. The combination of operating parameters that could consider the effect and efficiency was III low for forward speed, speed of the rotary shaft at 300 rpm, and working depth of 20 cm. The broken rate of the soil for this combination was 87.4%, and the hilling height was 17.0 cm.
References
Akhalaya, B.K., and Y.K. Shogenov. 2017. Mechanization and automation of working processes of tillage and seeding. Russian Agricultural Sciences 43 (3): 277–280.
Bai, C. 2021. Strengthen scientific and technological support and promote the high-quality green development of sugar industry. Sugar Crops of China 43 (1): 62–66.
Chen, C.B., and Z.H. Hu. 2021. Considerations on high quality development of sugar in China. Sugarcane and Canesugar 50 (1): 1–7.
Choudhary, R.L., G.C. Wakchaure, P.S. Minhas, and A.K. Singh. 2017. Response of ratoon sugarcane to stubble shaving, off-barring, root pruning and band placement of basal fertilisers with a multi-purpose drill machine. Sugar Tech 19 (1): 33–40.
Jia, H.L., D.Y. Huang, X.L. Liu, Z.H. Wang, Z.C. Liu, and C.L. Ma. 2011. Symmetrical multi-spiral arrangement of tillage blades on rotor. Transactions of the Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering 27 (4): 111–116.
Li, Y.R. 2010. Modern sugarcane science. Beijing: China Agriculture Press.
Liu, Q.T., M.J. Zhu, T. Wu, J.C. Zhou, X.M. Luo, T.F. He, and X.P. Zou. 2021. Design and testing of a diamond-shaped four-wheeled gantry-like sugarcane cultivator. Sugar Tech. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12355-021-00971-x.
Lv, J.Q., Z.F. Liu, P.R. Wang, Z.H. Li, J.C. Li, Z.Y. Liu, and D.Q. Yang. 2019. Design and experiment of driving-type crushing-weeding multi-functional potato cultivator. Transactions of the Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering 35 (10): 1–8.
Qin, S.M., L.J. Wei, C. Huang, M. Li, Y.G. Deng, J.M. Zhang, R.H. Li, and Q.X. Zhou. 2015. Design and test of 2CLF-1 ratoon sugarcane field managing machine. Guangdong Academy of Agricultural 42 (4): 157–161.
Ren, L.Q. 2009. Experimental design and optimization. Beijing: Higher Education Press.
Salar, M.R., A. Esehaghbeygi, and A. Hemmat. 2013. Soil loosening characteristics of a dual bent blade subsurface tillage implement. Soil and Tillage Research 134: 17–24.
Singh, J., A.K. Singh, M.P. Sharma, P.R. Singh, and A.C. Srivastava. 2011. Mechanization of sugarcane cultivation in India. Sugar Tech 13 (4): 310–314.
Singh, A.K., P.R. Singh, and S. Solomon. 2017a. Design and development of a tractor-operated disc -type sugarcane ratoon management device. Sugar Tech 19 (5): 501–509.
Singh, S., A. Tripathi, and A.K. Singh. 2017b. Effect of Furrow opener design, furrow depth, operating speed on soil characteristics, draft and germination of sugarcane. Sugar Tech 19 (5): 476–484.
Tang, R.X., H.Z. Wang, Y.F. Yang, X.W. Niu, K. Chen, W.S. Fang, Y. Zhu, X.J. Zhang, and G.Z. Wang. 2019. Performance experiments of model 3CP-460 ratoon sugarcane shovel breaking machine. Agricultural Engineering 9 (11): 17–20.
Xiao, Y. 1999. Overall design for DFH1204 wheeled tractor. Tractor & Farm Transporter 1999 (4): 29–36.
Xu, S.N., W.Z. Wang, Z.X. Liang, S.L. Zheng, W.Z. He, P.Y. Xu, B.Q. Ou, and F.X. Fang. 2014. Development and application of small sugarcane ridge breaking fertilizing machine with walking tractor. Tropical Agricultural Engineering 38 (6): 1–5.
Zhang, X.L., Z.W. Tong, L.H. Li, Y.J. Li, C.P. Hou, and Y.F. Xia. 2018. Design and experiment of tobacco hilling machine for compound cutting. Transactions of the Chinese Society for Agricultural Machinery 49 (9): 73–81.
Zhang, C.L., J.F. Xia, J.M. Zhang, H. Zhou, Y.H. Zhu, and J.W. Wang. 2019. Design and experiment of knife roller for six-head spiral straw returning cultivator. Transactions of the Chinese Society for Agricultural Machinery 50 (3): 25–34.
Zhong, J.Q., L.M. Tao, S.P. Li, F.L. Ma, and Y.L. Chen. 2021. Design and Evaluation of a Novel Transversal Double-bud Sugarcane Planter with Seed Pre-cutting. Sugar Tech. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12355-020-00927-7.
Zhou, Q.X., L.J. Wei, C. Huang, Y.G. Deng, M. Li, J.M. Zhang, and R.H. Li. 2013. Benefit analysis on combined performance technology of stumping, ridge-breaking and film-covering operations for ratoon sugarcane. Guangdong Academy of Agricultural 40 (21): 178–181.
Acknowledgements
The authors thank Bao-Shan Chen, Hong-Tao Jiang, Min Huang, and Zhong-Xiao Huang for their valuable help in the design and experiments.
Funding
This study was supported by Project of State Key Laboratory for Conservation and Utilization of Subtropical Agro-bioresources (Grant no. SKLCUSA-a202007), National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant No. 52165009) and Innovation Project of Guangxi Graduate Education (Grant no. YCBZ2020035).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
Shang-Ping Li, Jia-Feng Pan, Jia-Qin Zhong, Wei Li, De-Quan Yang, and Qing-Gui Mo performed analysis on all samples, interpreted data and wrote the manuscript. All the authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of Interest
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
Human and Animal Rights
This article does not contain any studies with human participants or animals performed by any of the authors.
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Li, SP., Pan, JF., Zhong, JQ. et al. Design and Evaluation of a Machine Integrating Ridge-Breaking, Fertilizing, and Ridging for Ratoon Sugarcane Without Intertillage. Sugar Tech 24, 1913–1923 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12355-021-01073-4
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12355-021-01073-4