Abstract
Our knowledge on distribution, habitats and behavior of Southern Ocean fishes living at water depths beyond scuba-diving limits is still sparse, as it is difficult to obtain quantitative data on these aspects of their biology. Here, we report the results of an analysis of seabed images to investigate species composition, behavior, spatial distribution and preferred habitats of demersal fish assemblages in the southern Weddell Sea. Our study was based on a total of 2736 high-resolution images, covering a total seabed area of 11,317 m2, which were taken at 13 stations at water depths between 200 and 750 m. Fish were found in 380 images. A total of 379 notothenioid specimens were recorded, representing four families (Nototheniidae, Artedidraconidae, Bathydraconidae, Channichthyidae), 17 genera and 25 species. Nototheniidae was the most speciose family, including benthic species (Trematomus spp.) and the pelagic species Pleuragramma antarctica, which was occasionally recorded in dense shoals. Bathydraconids ranked second with six species, followed by artedidraconids and channichthyids, both with five species. Most abundant species were Trematomus scotti and T. lepidorhinus among nototheniids, and Dolloidraco longedorsalis and Pagetopsis maculatus among artedidraconids and channichthyids, respectively. Both T. lepidorhinus and P. maculatus preferred seabed habitats characterized by biogenous debris and rich epibenthic fauna, whereas T. scotti and D. longedorsalis were frequently seen resting on fine sediments and scattered gravel. Several fish species were recorded to make use of the three-dimensional structure formed by epibenthic foundation species, like sponges, for perching or hiding inside. Nesting behavior was observed, frequently in association with dropstones, in species from various families, including Channichthyidae (Chaenodraco wilsoni and Pagetopsis macropterus) and Bathydraconidae (Cygnodraco mawsoni).
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
Introduction
From a zoogeographic perspective, the Southern Ocean is divided into three subregions (Kock 1992): (1) Ice-free zone, between the Antarctic Convergence and the northern limit of the Antarctic pack-ice in winter/spring, which is almost exclusively inhabited by meso- and bathypelagic fishes; (2) Seasonal Pack-ice Zone (and the islands north of it) between the boundaries of the pack-ice extension in winter/spring and autumn/summer, respectively, where mesopelagic species and a coastal fish fauna dominated by nototheniids of the genera Lepidonotothen and Notothenia, harpagiferids and some channichthyids occurs; and (3) High-antarctic Zone, around the Antarctic continent that is covered by sea ice for most of the year, characterized by a few mesopelagic species and a coastal fish fauna composed of nototheniids, mostly Trematomus spp., and many species of artedidraconids, bathydraconids and channichthyids.
As part of the East Antarctic Province in the High-Antarctic zone, the Weddell Sea is a deep embayment situated between 70–78°S and 20–60°W (Fig. 1). It has a wide, relatively deep (200–500 m) continental shelf, deepening in the southeastern part in the Filchner Trough ( > 1500 m depth), with the shelf break located at 600 m. The circulation in the Weddell Sea is dominated by a cyclonic, oceanic wind-driven gyre, with a southern branch flowing as Modified Warm Deep Water (mWDW) along the shelf ice edge to the southwest splitting into two branches, one following the shelf break and the other heading south towards the Filchner and Ronne Ice Shelves (Ryan et al. 2016). Two other water masses characterize the continental shelf of the Weddell Sea, i.e. the cold and less saline Eastern Shelf Water (ESW) with temperatures ranging between ‒ 2 and ‒ 1.6 °C, and the ice shelf water (ISW) located along both sides of the Filchner Trough at 700–1000 m depth, with temperatures between ‒ 2.4 and ‒ 2 °C (e.g. Nicholls et al. 2009).
At a large spatial scale, the demersal fish fauna of the southern and eastern Weddell Sea has been thoroughly investigated during bottom trawling surveys (Kock et al. 1984; Schwarzbach 1988; Ekau 1990). The fish assemblage inhabiting the continental shelf is dominated by nototheniids (Trematomus scotti, T. lepidorhinus and T. eulepidotus), followed in decreasing importance by channichthyids (Chionodraco myersi and Pagetopsis maculatus) and artedidraconids (Artedidraco spp.), whereas bathydraconids are negligible. The fish fauna inhabiting the deep waters of the Filchner Trough is different and composed primarily of bathydraconids (Akarotaxis nudiceps and Gerlachea australis) and artedidraconids (Dolloidraco longedorsalis), and to a lesser extent by the nototheniid Trematomus loennbergii (Schwarzbach 1988; Ekau 1990).
There is a long history of employing seabed photography to investigate composition, spatial distribution and habitat preferences of benthic communities (e.g. Bohnsack 1979), but it was rarely used in the Southern Ocean. It is a non-destructive and effective survey method, allowing a fine-scale description of benthic assemblages while minimizing the impacts of direct sampling. Using both still and video cameras mounted on remotely operated vehicles, species composition, relative abundance and behavior of benthic fish communities have been reported from the Weddell Sea and Lazarev Sea (Ekau and Gutt 1991; Gutt et al. 1994; Gutt and Ekau 1996). More recently, photographic surveys targeting the benthic communities of the continental shelf and upper slope of Marguerite Bay, the Amundsen Sea and the Antarctic Peninsula provided insights into the local fish fauna (Eastman et al. 2013; Amsler et al. 2016).
Within the framework of the research project Dynamics of Antarctic Marine Shelf Ecosystems (DynAMo), aimed at assessing the change and quality of benthos and endotherms in stable high-Antarctic environments not yet affected by climate change, a seabed imaging survey was carried out in the southeastern Weddell Sea using the ocean floor observation system (OFOS) developed at the Alfred Wegener Institute, Helmholtz Centre for Polar and Marine Research in Bremerhaven (AWI). In the present study, we analyzed the seabed images for the fish fauna they show to: (1) investigate species composition, relative abundance and spatial distribution of the demersal fish (2) obtain insights on their habitat preferences and the parental care behavior observed in some species, and (3) explore the relationships between fish and some putative abiotic and biotic drivers by multivariate analyzes.
Materials and methods
Field sampling
A seabed imaging survey to investigate the epibenthic communities and their habitats was carried out during the ANT-XXXI/2 (PS96) cruise of RV Polarstern in the Weddell Sea from December 2015 to February 2016 (for more details, see Schröder 2016). Seafloor images were obtained using the Ocean Floor Observation System (OFOS), which consisted of two downward-looking cameras mounted side-by-side: a high-resolution, wide-angle still camera (Canon®EOS 5D Mark III) and a high-definition color video camera (Sony®FCBH11).
The system was vertically lowered over the stern of the vessel with a broadband fiber-optic cable down to about 1.5 m above the seabed, then towed along transects at a speed of 0.5 km (0.25 m s−1). The proper position of the system above the seafloor was monitored by the live video feed and by occasionally operating the winch to compensate for small-scale bathymetric variations. The height above the seafloor and water depth were continuously recorded by means of OFOS sensors. Three lasers placed beside the still camera, emitting parallel beams producing three equidistant (50 cm from each other) red light points on the seafloor, allowed for precise determination of the entire seabed area pictured in each image. A seabed photo, showing on average an area of about 3.45 m2, was automatically taken every 30 s to obtain a series of stills along the transect. Overall, OFOS was deployed along 13 stations located in the southeastern and southern Weddell Sea. From east to west, a single station was located off Austasen, two stations were situated on the edge of the Riiser-Larsen Ice Shelf, five stations were located on the shelf east of the Filchner Trough, one station was within the Filchner Trough at about 750 m depth, and the remaining four stations were situated on the broad shelf west of the Filchner Trough (Fig. 1). For more details on the construction and operation of OFOS during the PS96 cruise see Piepenburg et al. (2017).
Image analysis
All images recorded during the survey were examined, and those showing fishes were subject to scrutiny. With the exception of zoarcids, all fishes were identified to the species level, using morphological diagnostic characters useful for identification (Gon and Heemstra 1990 and references therein). For each image, abundance of epibenthic invertebrate fauna at taxonomic unit and feeding guild level, as well as sediment characteristics were recorded and used to describe the epibenthic fauna accompanying all fish specimens. When appropriate, we classified benthic communities based on the previously described macrozoobenthic communities of the Weddell Sea (Voß 1988). For each fish species, the number of specimens and the standardized abundance (individuals 100 m−2) was determined for each transect.
Multivariate analyzes
Spatial distribution and species composition patterns of the fish fauna were explored by means of multivariate analyzes. Complete-linkage cluster analysis, based on Euclidean distances quantifying the faunistic similarities between stations, was used to create a dendrogram visualizing the spatial resemblance pattern of the fish fauna. In addition, we used non-metric multidimensional scaling (MDS) of the similarity matrix as an ordination approach, representing the faunistic resemblance pattern through the distances between stations in a two-dimensional MDS plot. Moreover, we investigated the relationship between the fish fauna and a number of parameters also recorded for each transect, which are thought to potentially drive the distribution and composition of fish assemblages: water depth, bottom type, and type of macrobenthic epifauna co-occurring with the fish. These factors were categorized as follows:
-
(1)
Water depth (using mean depth of photo transect): 100–200, 200–300, 300–400, 400–500 and 750 m.
-
(2)
Bottom type: (a) fine sediment (b) spicule mats (c) fine sediment with drop stones (d) fine sediment with gravels.
-
(3)
Type of accompanying macrobenthic epifauna [using the seabed-community classification proposed for the Weddell Sea by Voß (1988)]: (a) Eastern Shelf Community (ESC) (b) Southern Shelf Community (SSC), and (c) Southern Trench Community (STC).
The affiliation of each station with one category each of these three factors was visualized with separately superimposing them in the MDS plot showing the fish-based resemblance pattern. Moreover, using a more formalized approach, BIO-ENV analysis (Clark and Warwick 1994) was employed to explore the degree of multivariate correlation between the fish-based faunistic similarities among stations and the resemblance pattern according to the three environmental factors.
Finally, to assess differences in fish biodiversity among the environmental factor gradients, Shannon diversity (H’), species richness (Margalef, d) and evenness (Pielou, J’) indices were computed for each category. All statistical analyzes were performed using the PRIMER v5 software packages (Clarke and Gorley 2001).
Results
Photographic survey overview
Photographic surveys were conducted at 13 stations at water depths of 200 to 750 m, yielding 110 to 292 seabed images collected along drift transects of 0.9 to 2.6 km length (Table 1). Out of a total of 2736 still images analyzed, covering an overall area of 11,317 m2, a total of 380 (13.9%) showed fishes. Most images showed a single specimen (93.6%), and rarely two (6.1%) or three (0.3%) specimens of different species. A total of 379 notothenioid fish specimens from four families, 17 genera and 25 species were recorded in the seabed images (Table 2). Most fish specimens were identified to species (98.7%) or genus (1.3%) level. Only three were unidentifiable zoarcids. Average fish species densities recorded along the transects ranged between 0.09 (for Trematomus hansoni) and 3.04 (for T. scotti) individuals 100 m−2 (Table 3). Raw count data of fish recorded in seabed images are presented in Online Resource 1.
Species composition and habitat preferences
Nototheniidae
Nototheniidae (notothens) was the most speciose fish family recorded in the Weddell Sea (Table 2), encompassing benthic and epibenthic species of the genus Trematomus and the pelagic species Pleuragramma antarctica.
Pleuragramma antarctica Boulenger, 1902 (Fig. 2a). This species was encountered primarily off the Riiser-Larsen Ice shelf (station 090-4; Table 2), forming dense shoals swimming in the water column near the seafloor. In addition, single specimens were occasionally observed in waters as deep as 750 m (station 072-4) in close proximity of the bottom, characterized by a seafloor covered by fine sediments and a benthic fauna dominated by motile deposit feeders, such as echinoids and crustaceans, and tube-forming polychaetes.
Trematomus eulepidotus Regan, 1914 (Fig. 2b). This epibenthic species was relatively common, being recorded at nine out of 13 stations and at depths of 249–484 m (Table 2). The majority of specimens were encountered in close association with the eastern shelf benthos community sensu Voß (1988), also accompanied by various motile organisms like ophiuroids, and sessile polychaetes and sponges living either on fine sediment (stations 008-2 and 010-3), or dispersed on spicule mats (station 007-1). Interestingly, some specimens were resting on the sponges, or hiding in the cavities. This species was also abundant off the Ronne Ice Shelf (station 027-2), dwelling on fine sediment populated by deposit (ophiuroids) and patchy sessile suspension feeders (ascidians).
Trematomus hansoni Boulenger, 1902 (Fig. 2c). This species was very rare, as only a single specimen was found off the Riiser-Larsen Ice Shelf (station 090-4) at a depth of 281 m (Table 2). The benthos at this station was characterized by a mixture of eastern and southern shelf communities sensu Voß (1988), composed of abundant sessile organisms (bryozoans and sponges) living on fine sediment with sparse gravel.
Trematomus lepidorhinus (Pappenheim, 1911) (Fig. 2d). This species was the most abundant epibenthic nototheniid, recorded at depths of 240 to 468 m at almost one-half of stations surveyed (Table 2). Most specimens were encountered at station 010-3, where the benthos was characterized by a patchily distributed eastern shelf benthic community sensu Voß (1988). It was less frequently found in association with epibenthic communities on dense spicule mats and dominated by sponges of the genus Rossella (station 007-1), or in association with mixed eastern and southern shelf benthic communities sensu Voß (1988), composed of bryozoans and sponges living on fine sediments with scattered gravels (station 57-3). This species was generally observed swimming just above the bottom, often hiding in close proximity to sponges or other macrobenthic invertebrates.
Trematomus loennbergii Regan, 1913 (Fig. 2e). This epibenthic species was less common, and the few specimens encountered were found at a single station (007-1) at 412 to 417 m depth Table 2). The benthic community here consisted almost exclusively of sponges of the genus Rossella inhabiting dense spicule mats.
Trematomus pennellii Regan, 1914 (Fig. 2f). This benthic species was occasionally encountered, but almost exclusively in the easternmost sampling site (station 001-4) at depths ranging from 268 to 313 m (Table 2). The benthic community was dominated by a mixture of motile (crinoids, holothuroids and ophiuroids) and sessile invertebrates (bryozoans, polychaetes) inhabiting fine sediments, gravel patches or dropstones. Most fish specimens were probably adult females in spawning condition, with a rounded swollen abdomen.
Trematomus scotti (Boulenger, 1907) (Fig. 2g). It was the most abundant and widespread notothenioid species, which occurred at 10 of 13 stations at water depths of 197 to 487 m (Table 2). T. scotti is a small demersal fish, which was found in different habitats dominated by several motile benthic organisms (crinoids, holothuroids, ophiuroids) living on fine sediments, as well as sessile invertebrates (bryozoans, sponges, polychaetes and ascidians) on fine sediments with gravel. Trematomus scotti specimens were always observed resting directly on the sediment.
Trematomus tokarevi Andriashev, 1978 (Fig. 2h). Only two specimens of this rare species were observed at the deepest sampling site located in the Filchner Trough (station 072-4; Table 2), characterized by fine sediments mostly inhabited by motile deposit feeders, such as echinoids and crustaceans.
Artedidraconidae
Artedidraconidae (plunderfishes) were represented with five benthic species belonging to all four genera in the family (Artedidraco, Dolloidraco, Histiodraco and Pogonophryne) (Table 2).
Artedidraco loennbergi Roule, 1913 (Fig. 3a). Only two specimens were recorded on the shelf west of the Filchner Trough (stations 037-3 and 048-2) at 386 to 487 m depth (Table 2). They were resting on the fine sediment populated by deposit-feeding benthos (polychaetes, ophiuroids) and by patchily distributed sessile suspension feeders (ascidians).
Artedidraco orianae Reagan, 1914 (Fig. 3b). A single specimen was found at 418 m (station 007-1, Table 2), within a dense population of sponges (Rossella) on spicule mats.
Histiodraco velifer (Regan, 1914) (Fig. 3c). A single specimen of this species was recorded off the Riiser-Larsen Ice Shelf (station 106-2) in relatively shallow waters (197 m) (Table 2), in a curled-up position on a substratum dominated by ophiuroids, and patchily distributed small sponges and bryozoans.
Dolloidraco longedorsalis Roule, 1913 (Fig. 3d). This was the most abundant species among artedidraconids, being encountered in almost one-half of the stations across a depth range of 388 to 751 m (Table 2). Most specimens were observed at station 008-2, hosting an extremely patchily distributed eastern shelf benthos community sensu Voß (1988), which also consisted of motile organisms (mainly ophiuroids) living on fine sediments. Dolloidraco longedorsalis was also abundant at two other stations (048-2 and 061-1), which were dominated by deposit feeders (ophiuroids, echinoids and polychaetes) and sessile suspension feeders (sponges) sparsely distributed on fine sediments with occasional dropstones.
Pogonophryne scotti Regan, 1914 (Fig. 3e, f). This was the only species from the speciose genus Pogonophryne encountered in the Weddell Sea. The specimens occurred over a wide depth range (274 to 754 m; Table 2), generally resting on fine sediments inhabited by a benthic community mainly composed of motile (ophiuroids) species and occasional sessile invertebrates (sponges, bryozoans and polychaetes). One specimen of P. scotti was found resting on top of a glass sponge.
Bathydraconidae
Bathydraconidae (dragonfishes) were represented by seven species (Table 2) from seven genera (Akarotaxis, Bathydraco, Cygnodraco, Gerlachea, Gymnodraco, Prionodraco and Racovitzia) of the total of eleven genera belonging to this family.
Akarotaxis nudiceps (Waite, 1916) (Fig. 4a). This was one of the most abundant and deep living bathydraconids, although most specimens were documented in the Filchner Trench (station 072-4) at 750 m depth (Table 2). At this site, the benthic fauna was composed primarily of motile deposit feeders, such as echinoids (Sterechinus) and crustaceans. A few other specimens were found in shallower stations (037-3 and 061-1), dominated by deposit feeders (polychaetes and ophiuroids) and sessile suspension feeders (ascidians) sparsely distributed on fine sediments.
Bathydraco macrolepis Boulenger, 1907 (Fig. 4b). As the only representative of the genus Bathydraco, this species was occasionally encountered at four different stations at 386 to 751 m depth (Table 2). The seafloor at the sampling sites was inhabited by deposit feeders (ophiuroids, echinoids and polychaetes) and sessile suspension feeders (ascidians and sponges) scattered on fine sediments with dropstones.
Cygnodraco mawsoni Waite, 1916 (Fig. 4c, d). This was a common species, occurring at four stations (001-4, 007-1, 010-3, 090-4) at depths of 270–417 m off the Riiser-Larsen Ice Shelf (Table 2). The seabed at these stations hosted a typical eastern shelf benthos community sensu Voß (1988), mainly consisting of motile (ophiuroids) or sessile invertebrates (sponges, ascidians and polychaetes) patchily distributed on fine sediments or sponge spicule mats. The C. mawsoni specimens frequently settled on the substrate, assuming a characteristic S-shaped body conformation. Remarkably, a single specimen was photographed guarding eggs laid on a flat stone (Fig. 4d).
Gerlachea australis Dollo, 1900 (Fig. 4e). This species was particularly abundant in the Filchner Trench at 754 m depth (Table 2). It was seldom recorded in shallower waters (station 106-2, 197 m). The benthic community consisted mainly of motile deposit feeders, and was dominated by echinoids and crustaceans living on fine sediment with scattered dropstones.
Gymnodraco acuticeps Boulenger, 1902 (Fig. 4f). Compared to other bathydraconids, this species was relatively rare, occurring only at two stations situated east of the Filchner Trench between 237 and 476 m (Table 2). Two specimens were encountered on fine sediments populated mainly by motile deposit feeders (ophiuroids and echinoids), although another specimen was associated with sessile organisms (sponges, bryozoans) living on spicule mats and biological debris.
Prionodraco evansii Regan, 1914 (Fig. 4g). This small species was primarily recorded off the Riiser-Larsen Ice Shelf (stations 001-4, 010-3), as well as off the Ronne Ice Shelf (station 027-2) at depths of 273 to 324 m (Table 2). Most specimens were found in association with sparse motile benthic fauna (crinoids, holothuroids, ophiuroids) or occasionally with sessile invertebrates (ascidians, bryozoans and polychaetes) on fine sediments.
Racovitzia glacialis Dollo, 1900 (Fig. 4h). This species had a wide distribution, occurring on the eastern and western side of the Filchner Trench, as well as off the Riiser-Larsen Ice Shelf at 197 to 484 m depth (Table 2). The benthic community consisted of motile (crinoids, ophiuroids) and sessile organisms (sponges, bryozoans and polychaetes) sparsely distributed on fine sediment with dropstones.
Channichthyidae
From the family Channichthyidae (icefishes) five primarily benthic species, representing four of the eleven genera of this family (Chaenodraco, Chionodraco, Cryodraco and Pagetopsis), were identified in the images (Table 2).
Chaenodraco wilsoni Regan, 1914 (Fig. 5a). Single specimens of this species were encountered in three stations located in the Filchner Trench, at the eastern side, and off the Ronne Ice Shelf at depths of 293 to 752 m (Table 2). The benthic community at these stations was characterized by deposit feeders (polychaetes, crustaceans and ophiuroids) and patchily distributed sessile suspension feeders (sponges and ascidians) living on fine sediments. A single male C. wilsoni was photographed while swimming just above the bottom in close proximity of a nest with thousands of eggs.
Chionodraco hamatus (Lönnberg, 1906) (Fig. 5b, c). It was a rather common channichthyid, occurring both in the shelves east (stations 007-1, 008-2, 010-3) and west (stations 026-3, 037-3) of the Filchner Trench at 286 to 415 m (Table 2). The seabed fauna at the eastern side of the Trench was characterized by a typical eastern shelf benthic community sensu Voß (1988), formed by motile taxa (e.g. ophiuroids) on fine sediments and sessile invertebrates (sponges, bryozoans and polychaetes) on spicule mats. At the western side of the Trench, the benthos community consisted of deposit feeders (polychaetes and ophiuroids) and patchily distributed sessile suspension feeders (ascidians) living on fine sediments.
Cryodraco antarcticus Dollo, 1900 (Fig. 5d). This species was recorded at slightly more than one-half of sampling stations over a wide depth range (289–752 m), although usually as single or a few individuals (Table 2). It was found across various benthic communities, including deposit (ophiuroids, echinoids, crustaceans and polychaetes) and sessile suspension feeders (sponges, ascidians) on fine sediments with dropstones or rarely on spicule mats. The specimens were often observed resting on the substrate on the long pelvic fins.
Pagetopsis macropterus (Boulenger, 1907) (Fig. 5e). A single specimen guarding a nest with eggs was encountered east of the Filchner Trench at 238 m (Table 2), in association with sponges and bryozoans living on spicule mats and biological debris.
Pagetopsis maculatus Barsukov & Permitin, 1958 (Fig. 5f). This was by far the most abundant and widespread channichthyid species, encountered at nine out of 13 stations at depths of 244 to 483 m (Table 2). While most specimens were recorded on the shelf east of the Filchner Trench, a few specimens were found also on the shelves west and north of the Ronne Ice Shelf. The benthic community consisted of several taxa, encompassing mainly motile organisms (ophiuroids) living on fine sediments, and sessile suspension feeders (mainly sponges and ascidians) on spicule mats.
Zoarcidae
From this family, only three unidentified specimens were encountered at two stations located east of the Filchner Trench at 404 to 417 m depth (Table 2), in association with sessile invertebrates (sponges) inhabiting spicule mats.
Fish community structure in relation to environmental factors
With regard to their resemblance in fish fauna, stations were clustered in four main groups, mainly characterized by water depth and location (Fig. 6a). There were two small clusters, with only two stations each. The first featured stations on the narrow north-eastern shelf (stations 090-4 and 106-2), while the second encompassed the station in the deep Filchner Trough and a station located on the western shelf (072-4 and 037-3, respectively). A third cluster included the deep stations located on the wide shelves east and west of the Filchner Trough (008-2, 026-3, 048-2, and 061-1). The largest cluster was formed by the shallower stations distributed along the eastern shelf (001-4, 007-1, 010-3 and 057-3) and off the Ronne Ice Shelf (station 027-2). The ordination of stations in the MDS plot showed largely the same spatial resemblance pattern (Fig. 6b).
Superimposing the three environmental categorical factors on the station configuration in the MDS plot (Fig. 7a–c) revealed that all of them did not match well with the stations clusters based on faunistic resemblances, suggesting that these three factors had only little influence on the spatial distribution of the fish fauna. The results of the BIO-ENV analysis corroborated this impression, yielding correlations (ρ values) between the biotic fish-based station-similarity pattern and three- to one-factor combinations of environmental resemblance patterns that were 0.24 at maximum (for water depth and type of accompanying epifauna, see Table 4). This is a further clear indication that the three factors considered in our study had only minor influence on the distribution of the fish fauna.
With regard to diversity (Shannon, Margalef, and Pielou indices), computed for all classes of each environmental category (Fig. 8a–c), evenness (J) was rather similar across all classes for each factor. In contrast, both Shannon diversity (H') and Margalef species richness (d) increased with water depth (except for the last depth class ( > 750 m) that encompassed, however, only one station in the Filchner Trough) and decreased from fine sediment to gravel. With regard to the type accompanying epibenthic fauna, fish diversity and species richness were similar between the Eastern Shelf Community (ESC) and Southern Shelf Community (SSC), but clearly lower for the Southern Trench Community (STC) (please note again that the latter was represented only by the single station in the Filchner Trough).
Discussion
Taxonomic composition, spatial distribution and behavior
The high resolution and definition of the OFOS cameras allowed, with the exception of zoarcids, species-level identification of even the smallest fish specimens recorded along the transects. Only five Trematomus specimens were identified to genus level only, owing to the poor quality of some images (blurred or dark photographs).
Previous trawl and photographic surveys conducted in the Weddell Sea (e.g. Ekau 1990; Ekau and Gutt 1991; Hubold 1992) documented the genus Chionodraco as represented by two species, C. hamatus and C. myersi, which are distributed over a largely overlapping depth range. We have tentatively identified all our specimens as C. hamatus, based on their narrower eye diameter and wider interorbital width respect to the head length, as well as to their relatively large body size (Miller 1993). All Cryodraco specimens have been provisionally identified as C. antarcticus, although the sister species C. atkinsoni has been recently recognized as valid through morphological and molecular genetic characters (La Mesa et al. 2002; Dornburg et al. 2016), and both are likely to be present in the Weddell Sea.
The rare nototheniid species Trematomus tokarevi was recorded for the first time in the deep shelf waters of the Weddell Sea. It can be easily confused with Trematomus nicolai (Kuhn et al. 2009), a similar species rarely encountered in shallow waters of the Weddell Sea (Hubold 1992). Based on the recent revision of the bathymetric distribution of notothenioid fishes (Eastman 2017), the minimum depths of occurrence of Bathydraco macrolepis and Racovitzia glacialis have now been documented as somewhat shallower at 386 m and 197 m, respectively.
Seabed photography also provided insights into the behavior of some species. As expected, the majority of species were primarily benthic, resting on the substrate. The most common epibenthic species, such as Trematomus eulepidotus and T. lepidorhinus, were generally found to swim slowly a few centimeters above the substrate, or sometimes to perch on or inside large cup-shaped sponges, displaying a “sit, -observe and hide” strategy (Gutt and Ekau 1996). In contrast to previous direct observations made with a video camera in the Ross Sea, documenting loose aggregations of Pleuragramma antarctica in the upper layers of the water column (Fuiman et al. 2012), we observed strikingly dense shoals of this species in the deepest reaches of the water column < 20 m above the seafloor.
Nesting behavior was observed in three species of different families. Males of Chaenodraco wilsoni, characterized by an obvious black blotch in the center of the first dorsal fin, guarded eggs deposited on a flat stone, as previously reported from both the southern and northern Weddell Sea (Kock et al. 2008; Riginella et al. 2014). Among bathydraconids, parental care was observed for the first time in Cygnodraco mawsoni, which was photographed directly on a nest assuming a typical defense posture (Ekau and Gutt 1991), as well as in Gymnodraco acuticeps, whose spawning behavior has been described in considerable detail (Evans et al. 2005). With our new observations, there are now about a dozen species of high-Antarctic notothenioids known to exhibit nesting or egg-guarding behavior. Therefore, with the exception of the few pelagic species that are likely broadcast spawners, this behavior may be a characteristic feature of many demersal notothenioids.
Comparison with previous studies and other areas
As reported in previous studies (Ekau and Gutt 1991; Gutt et al. 1994; Gutt and Ekau 1996), seabed photographic surveys are useful for documenting and describing demersal fish assemblages of the Weddell Sea, revealing differences in species composition and relative abundance among neighboring areas. In agreement with previous results, the fish assemblage of the shelf north of Halley Bay (including stations 007-1, 008-2 and 010-3) was by far the richest, in terms of both total fish abundance and number of species (Table 2). The fish assemblage was dominated by nototheniids (particularly Trematomus scotti and T. lepidorhinus), followed by channichthyids (Chionodraco hamatus) and bathydraconids (Dolloidraco longedorsalis). The Filchner Trough (station 072-4) was the second most populated area, consisting mainly of deep-water species such as bathydraconids and Trematomus tokarevi. Nevertheless, both diversity (Shannon) and species richness (Margalef) were lower in the Filchner Trough than in other areas, as individuals were unequally distributed among the species (Table 2). Finally, the wide and moderately deep continental shelf west of the Filchner Trough (including stations 026-3, 027-2 and 037-3) hosted a relatively poor fish community, in agreement with previous photographic surveys conducted in the southwestern Weddell Sea off Gould Bay and Vahsel Bay (Ekau and Gutt 1991).
Within the four groups of stations derived by the cluster analysis, the mean depth and the macrobenthic epifauna influenced the fish composition primarily at small spatial scales, providing food resources, protection from predators or suitable breeding sites. Considering the most abundant species, Trematomus lepidorhinus and Pagetopsis maculatus preferred areas with biogenous debris and a rich epibenthic invertebrate fauna forming a three-dimensional habitat, which provided a suitable environment for settling or hiding. On the other hand, Trematomus scotti and Dolloidraco longedorsalis were recorded primarily in areas characterized by fine sediments with sparse gravels, where they were resting on and camouflaged by the substrate.
The relatively low values of correlation between the biotic fish-based station-similarity patterns and the selected environmental factors clearly indicate that several other parameters may play a role in determining species composition and distribution, all contributing to a more complex network of abiotic and biological interactions. Other factors like bottom temperature and food availability (Schwarzbach 1988; Ekau and Gutt 1991), or the impact of iceberg scouring (e.g. Brenner et al. 2001) may considerably affect fish distribution at small spatial scale in the Weddell Sea. In addition, the highly patchy distribution of benthic assemblages and substratum found along the transects did not allow to unambiguously determine their relationships with the local fish fauna.
Our photographic survey also provides further evidence that ice-rafted dropstones are important as sites of benthic diversity. In a photographic survey off the western Antarctic Peninsula at water depths of 437 to 724 m, Ziegler et al. (2017) found that although dropstones occupied < 1% of the total seafloor area surveyed, they contributed 20% of the megabenthic invertebrate species diversity. Ziegler et al. (2017) also captured images of the channichthyid Chaenodraco wilsoni guarding nests of eggs laid on dropstones. Notothenioids were also found in the vicinity of or directly on dropstones in many of our images. On the relatively barren seafloor characterizing outer shelf and upper slope environments, dropstones increase benthic habitat diversity by enhancing topographic heterogeneity and, when occupied by invertebrates, trophic complexity. Benthic notothenioids are frequently associated with dropstones, as these represent favorable habitats for feeding and hard substrates for nesting.
In terms of species composition and relative abundance, the demersal fish community of the southern Weddell Sea described in the present study closely resembled those reported from other areas, such as the Lazarev Sea (e.g. Gutt and Ekau 1996; Zimmermann 1997) and Ross Sea (Eastman and Hubold 1999; Donnelly et al. 2004). Therefore, as noted already by other authors (e.g. Andriashev 1965; DeWitt 1971), the benthic fish fauna of the Weddell Sea is a component of the East Antarctic or Greater Antarctic zoogeographical province.
References
Amsler MO, Eastman JT, Smith KE, McClintock JB, Singh H, Thatje S, Aronson RB (2016) Zonation of demersal fishes off Anvers Island, western Antarctic Peninsula. Antarct Sci 28:44–50
Andriashev AP (1965) A general review of the Antarctic fish fauna. In: Oye P, Mieghem J (eds) Biogeography and ecology in Antarctica, Monographiae Biologicae, vol 15. Junk, The Hague, pp 491–550
Bohnsack JA (1979) Photographic quantitative sampling of hard-bottom benthic communities. Bull Mar Sci 29:242–252
Brenner M, Buck BH, Cordes S, Dietrich L, Jacob U, Mintenbeck K, Schröder A, Brey T, Knust R, Arntz W (2001) The role of iceberg scours in niche separation within the Antarctic fish genus Trematomus. Polar Biol 24:502–507
Clarke KR, Gorley RN (2001) PRIMER v5: user manual/tutorial. PRIMER-E, Plymouth Marine Laboratory, Plymouth
Clarke KR, Warwick RM (1994) Change in marine communities: an approach to statistical analysis and interpretation. Natural Environment Research Council, Swindon
DeWitt HH (1971) Coastal and deep-water benthic fishes of the Antarctic. In: Bushnell VC (ed) Antarctic map folio series, Folio 15. American Geographical Society, New York, pp 1–10
Donnelly J, Torres JJ, Sutton TT, Simoniello C (2004) Fishes of the eastern Ross Sea, Antarctica. Polar Biol 27:637–650
Dornburg A, Eytan RI, Federman S, Pennington JN, Stewart AL, Jones CD, Near TJ (2016) Molecular data support the existence of two species of the Antarctic fish genus Cryodraco (Channichthyidae). Polar Biol 39:1369–1379
Eastman JT (2017) Bathymetric distributions of notothenioid fishes. Polar Biol 40:2077–2095
Eastman JT, Hubold G (1999) The fish fauna of the Ross Sea. Antarct Sci 11:293–304
Eastman JT, Amsler MO, Aronson RB, Thatje S, McClintock JB, Vos SC, Kaeli JW, Singh H (2013) Photographic survey of benthos provides insights into the Antarctic fish fauna from the Marguerite Bay slope and the Amundsen Sea. Antarct Sci 25:31–43
Ekau W (1990) Demersal fish fauna of the Weddell Sea, Antarctica. Antarct Sci 2:129–137
Ekau W, Gutt J (1991) Notothenioid fishes from the Weddell Sea and their habitat, observed by underwater photography and television. Proc NIPR Symp Polar Biol 4:36–49
Evans CW, Cziko P, Cheng CHC, DeVries AL (2005) Spawning behaviour and early development in the naked dragonfish Gymnodraco acuticeps. Antarct Sci 17:319–327
Fuiman LA, Davis RW, Williams TM (2002) Behavior of midwater fishes under Antarctic ice: observations by a predator. Mar Biol 140:815–822
Gon O, Heemstra PC (1990) Fishes of the Southern Ocean. JLB Smith Institute of Ichthyology, Grahamstown
Gutt J, Ekau W (1996) Habitat partitioning of dominant high Antarctic demersal fish in the Weddell Sea and Lazarev Sea. J Exp Mar Biol Ecol 206:25–37
Gutt J, Ekau W, Gorny M (1994) New results on the fish and shrimp fauna of the Weddell Sea and Lazarev Sea (Antarctic). Proc NIPR Symp Polar Biol 7:91–102
Hubold G (1992) Ecology of Weddell Sea fishes. Ber Polarforsch 103:1–157
Kock K-H (1992) Antarctic fish and fisheries. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Kock K-H, Schneppenheim R, Siegel V (1984) A contribution to the fish fauna of the Weddell Sea. Arch Fisch Wiss 34:103–120
Kock K-H, Pshenichnov L, Jones CD, Gröger J, Riehl R (2008) The biology of the spiny icefish Chaenodraco wilsoni Regan, 1914. Polar Biol 31:381–393
Kuhn KL, Near TJ, Jones CD, Eastman JT (2009) Aspects of the biology and population genetics of the Antarctic nototheniid fish Trematomus nicolai. Copeia 2:320–327
La Mesa M, Vacchi M, Iwami T, Eastman JT (2002) Taxonomic studies of the Antarctic icefish genus Cryodraco Dollo, 1900 (Notothenioidei: Channichthyidae). Polar Biol 25:384–390
Miller RG (1993) History and Atlas of the Fishes of the Antarctic Ocean. Foresta Institute for Ocean and Mountain Studies, Carson City
Nicholls KW, Østerhus S, Makinsin K, Gammelsrød T, Fahrbach E (2009) Ice-ocean processes over the continental shelf of the Southern Weddell Sea, Antarctica: a review. Rev Geophys 47: RG3003
Piepenburg D, Buschmann A, Driemel A, Grobe H, Gutt J, Schumacher S, Segelken-Voigt A, Sieger R (2017) Seabed images from Southern Ocean shelf regions off the northern Antarctic Peninsula and in the southeastern Weddell Sea. Earth Syst Sci Data 9:461–469
Riginella E, Mazzoldi C, Rasotto MB, La Mesa M (2014) Reproductive traits in Antarctic fish: a comparative analysis of notothenioidei. Ber Polarforsch 680:106–109
Ryan S, Schröder M, Huhn O, Timmermann R (2016) On the warm inflow at the eastern boundary of the Weddell Gyre. Deep-Sea Res I 107:70–81
Schröder M (2016) The expedition PS96 of the research vessel Polarstern to the southern Weddell Sea in 2015/2016. Ber Polarforsch 700:1–142
Schwarzbach W (1988) The demersal fish fauna of the eastern and southern Weddell Sea: geographical distribution, feeding of fishes and their trophic position in the food web. Ber Polarforsch 54:1–93
Voß J (1988) Zoogeography and community analysis of macrozoobenthos of the Weddell Sea (Antarctica). Ber Polarforsch 45:1–145
Ziegler AF, Smith CR, Edwards KF, Vernet M (2017) Glacial dropstones: islands enhancing seafloor species richness of benthic megafauna in West Antarctic Peninsula fjords. Mar Ecol Prog Ser 583:1–14
Zimmermann C (1997) On the demersal fish fauna of the Lazarev Sea (Antarctica): composition and community structure. In: Battaglia B, Valencia J, Walton DWH (eds) Antarctic communities: species, structure and survival. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 26–32
Acknowledgements
We are greatly indebted to all the crew and scientific personnel aboard R/V Polarstern during cruise ANT-XXXI/2 (PS96) in the Weddell Sea for their valuable support during field activities. We are very grateful to Odd Aksel Bergstad, Mauricio F. Landaeta and an anonymous reviewer for their constructive comments on the original manuscript. This study was financially supported by the PNRA (Italian National Antarctic Research Program) within the research project 2013/C1.07. JT Eastman was supported by National Science Foundation grant NSF ANT 04-36190.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Electronic supplementary material
Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
La Mesa, M., Piepenburg, D., Pineda-Metz, S.E.A. et al. Spatial distribution and habitat preferences of demersal fish assemblages in the southeastern Weddell Sea (Southern Ocean). Polar Biol 42, 1025–1040 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00300-019-02495-3
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00300-019-02495-3