Abstract
Animal and human anatomy is among the most complex systems known, and suitable teaching methods have been of great importance in the progress of knowledge. Examining the human body is part of the process by which medical students come to understand living forms. However, the need to preserve cadavers has led to the development of various techniques to manufacture models for teaching purposes. A variety of materials, such as wax, wood, papier-maché, or glass, have long been used to construct animal and plant models. In the case of the human body, the most innovative, yet controversial, method of preservation has been plastination, invented by the German physician Gunther von Hagens, by which actual human bodies are preserved as odourless and aesthetic models for teaching and exhibitions. We point out in our study that the ‘hands-on’ approach that some anatomical models allow, namely, the (clastic) disassembly and reassembly of the parts of complex systems and their models, is not only a crucial tool for learning, but is far superior to the simple passive observation that rigid, single-piece models allow. And what is valid for the learning of anatomy can be generalized to the acquisition of knowledge of other complex physical systems.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Explore related subjects
Discover the latest articles, news and stories from top researchers in related subjects.Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Asma S T 2001 Stuffed animals and pickled heads: the culture and evolution of natural history museums (Oxford: Oxford University Press)
Bates A W 2008 “Indecent and demoralizing representations”: public anatomy museums in mid-Victoria England; Med. Hist. 52 1–22
Bissel T L 1960 History of entomology at the University of Maryland; Bull. Entomol. Soc. Am. 6 80–85
Campbell M 2004 Dr Auzoux’s uteri models; Aust. N Z J. Obst. Gynaecol. 44 488
Chadarevian S de and Hopwood N 2004 Models: the third dimension of science (Stanford: Stanford University Press)
Daston L and Galison P 1992 The image of objectivity. Representations 40 81–128
Daston L and Galison P 2007 Objectivity (New York: Zone Books)
Davis A B and Merzbach U C 1975 Early auditory studies: activities in the psychology laboratories of American universities; Smithsonian Studies in History and Technology No. 31, pp 1–39
Donovan E 1794 Instructions for collecting and preserving various subjects of natural history (London: Rivington)
Duran E, Duran L B and Worch E A 2009 Papier-mache animals: an integrating theme for elementary classrooms; Sci. Edu. Rev. 8 11
Findlen P 1994 Possessing nature: museum, collecting, and scientific culture in early modern Italy (Berkeley: University of California Press)
Galdo Manuel María José de 1878 Manual de historia natural, 7th edition with 342 figures (Madrid: J Moraleda)
Gelfand T 1972 The’ Paris manner’ of dissection: student anatomical dissection in early eighteenth-century Paris; Bull. Hist. Med. 46 99–130
Grob B 2004 The anatomical models of Dr Louis Auzoux; Mus. Boerhaave Commun. 305 109–149
Guerrero C R 2006 El Instituto de Segunda Enseñanza del Noviciado de Madrid, laboratorio de ensayo para la renovación de la enseñanza oficial (1868–1872); Bol. Inst. Libre Enseñanza 61 41–60
Hehmeyer I and Khan A 2007 Islam’s forgotten contributions to medical science; CMAJ 176 1467–1468
Howie D 2002 Interpreting probability. Controversies and developments in the early twentieth century (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press)
Larsen A 1996 Equipment for the field; in Cultures of Natural History (eds) N Jardine J A Secord and E C Spary (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press) pp 358–377
Levins R 1966 The strategy of model building in population biology; Am. Sci. 54 421–431
Malomo A O, Idowu O E and Osuagwu F C 2006 Lessons from history: human anatomy, from origin to the Renaissance; Int. J. Morphol. 24 99–104
Poggesi M 1999 The wax figure collection in ‘La Specola’ in Florence; in Encyclopedia Anatomica: Museo La Specola Florence (Köln: Taschen)
Porter R 1997 The greatest benefit to mankind. A medical history of humanity (New York: W W Norton and Company, Inc.)
Richardson R 2000 Death, dissection and the destitute (London: The University of Chicago Press)
Rizzolo L J and Stewart W B 2006 Should we continue teaching anatomy by dissection when…?; Anat. Rec. (Part B: New Anat.) 289B 215–218
Roda-Murillo O, López-Soler M, Roda-Murillo A and Ramírez-Ortiz I 2006 Plastination in the teaching of neuroanatomy; Eur. J. Anat. 10 85–89
Romer J J 1797 Anleitung Alle Arten Naturlicher Corper. Reprint published by Kessinger Pub Co (2009) 258. Also available at the internet archive: http://www.archive.org/details/anleitungallear00compgoog (accessed 12 September 2009)
Saeed M, Rufai AA and Elsayed SE 2001 Mummification to plastination; Saudi Med. J. 22 956–959
Shoja M M and Tubbs R S 2007 The history of anatomy in Persia; J. Anat. 210 359–378
Sigwart J D 2008 Crystal creatures: context for the Dublin Blaschka Congress; Hist. Biol. 20 1–10
Stullich S and Bryant K D 2005 College park (MD) (Images of America) (Charleston: Arcadia Publishing)
Suarez M M 2003 La atención médica del recién nacido en el Hospital de Maternidad e Infancia de México. Siglo XIX; Bol. Mex. His. Fil. Med. 6 17–23
Tsukisawa M 2007 Anatomy education at the beginning of Japan’s Meiji era and an anatomical model with topographical expressions of anatomy under the fasciae (in Japanese); Kaibogaku Zasshi. 82 3–8
Valenzuela J L C 2007 La estatua anatómica del Dr Auzoux en Chile; Int. J. Morphol. 25 202
Valero M and García A 1999 Ciencia y Coleccionismo en Cuba durante el siglo XIX; Asclepio 51 205–226
von Hagens G 2002 Anatomy and plastination; in: Body worlds:
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Dedicated to the generation of students who have grown up with virtual computer worlds. May they find delight in the manipulation of earthly objects.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Valdecasas, A.G., Correas, A.M., Guerrero, C.R. et al. Understanding complex systems: lessons from Auzoux’s and von Hagens’s anatomical models. J Biosci 34, 835–843 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12038-009-0097-0
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12038-009-0097-0