Abstract
We will show that there is a strong form of emergence in cell biology. Beginning with C.D. Broad’s classic discussion of emergence, we distinguish two conditions sufficient for emergence. Emergence in biology must be compatible with the thought that all explanations of systemic properties are mechanistic explanations and with their sufficiency. Explanations of systemic properties are always in terms of the properties of the parts within the system. Nonetheless, systemic properties can still be emergent. If the properties of the components within the system cannot be predicted, even in principle, from the behavior of the system’s parts within simpler wholes then there also will be systemic properties which cannot be predicted, even in principle, on basis of the behavior of these parts. We show in an explicit case study drawn from molecular cell physiology that biochemical networks display this kind of emergence, even though they deploy only mechanistic explanations. This illustrates emergence and its place in nature.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
W. Bechtel (1988) Philosophy of Science: An Overview for Cognitive Science Lawrence Erlbaum Hillsdale.
Bechtel W., Richardson R.C. (1992). Emergent Phenomena in Complex Systems’ in Beckermann, Flohr, and Kim. 257–288
W. Bechtel R.C. Richardson (1993) Discovering Complexity:Decomposition and Localization as Research Strategies Princeton University Press. Princeton.
A. Beckermann (2000) The Perennial Problem of the Reductive Explainability of Phenomenal Consciousness – C.D. Broad on the Explanatory Gap T. Metzinger (Eds) Neural Correlates of Consciousness – Empirical and Conceptual Questions MIT Press Cambridge 41–55
Beckermann A., Flohr H., Kim J. (Emergence or Reduction? Essays on the Prospects of Nonreductive Physicalism: de Gruyter, Berlin, New York
F. Boogerd F. Bruggeman C. Jonker H. Loorende Jong Tamminga Treur J. H. Westerhoff W. Wijngaards (2002) ArticleTitleInter-Level Relations in Computer Science, Biology and Psychology Philosophical Psychology. 15 463–472 Occurrence Handle10.1080/0951508021000042012
C.D. Broad (1919) ArticleTitleMechanical Explanation and Its Alternatives’) Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society. 19 86–124
C.D. Broad (1925) The Mind and Its Place in Nature: Kegan Paul, Trench Trubner & Co. London.
F.J. Bruggeman H.V. Westerhoff F.C. Boogerd (2002a) ArticleTitleBiocomplexity A Pluralist Research Strategy is Necessary for a Mechanistic Explanation of the “Live” State Philosophical Psychology. 15 411–440 Occurrence Handle10.1080/0951508021000041996
F.J. Bruggeman H.V. Westerhoff J.B. Hoek B.N. Kholodenko (2002b) ArticleTitle‘Modular Response Analysis of Cellular Regulatory Networks’) Journal of Theoretical Biology. 218 507–520 Occurrence Handle1:CAS:528:DC%2BD38Xns12gsb0%3D
F.C. Craver (2001) ArticleTitleRole Functions, Mechanisms and Hierarchy Philosophy of Science. 68 53–74 Occurrence Handle10.1086/392866
C. F. Craver L. Darden (2001) Discovering Mechanisms in Neurobiology: The Case of Spatial Memory’ P. Machamer R. Grush P McLaughlin (Eds) Theory and Method in Neuroscience University of Pittsburgh Press Pittsburgh, PA. 112–137
L. Darden F. Carl Craver (2002) ArticleTitleStrategies in the Interfield Discovery of the Mechanism of Protein Synthesis’) Studies in the History and Philosophy of the Biological and Biomedical Sciences. 33 1–28 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S1369-8486(01)00021-8
C. Francke P.W. Postma H.V. Westerhoff J.G. Blom M.A. Peletier (2003) ArticleTitleWhy the Phosphotransferase System of Escherichia coli Escapes Diffusion Limitation Biophysical Journal. 85 612–622 Occurrence Handle1:CAS:528:DC%2BD3sXltlekurk%3D Occurrence Handle12829515
S. Glennan (2002) ArticleTitleRethinking Mechanistic Explanation Philosophy of Science. 69 S342–S353 Occurrence Handle10.1086/341857
H. Heinrich T.A. Rapoport (1974) ArticleTitleA Linear Steady-State Treatment of Enzymatic Change General Properties, Control and Effector Strength European. Journal of Biochemistry. 42 89–95 Occurrence Handle10.1111/j.1432-1033.1974.tb03318.x Occurrence Handle1:CAS:528:DyaE2cXktFSltL0%3D Occurrence Handle4830198
H. Kacser J.A. Burns (1973) ArticleTitleThe control of flux’, Symp Soc. Exp. Bid. 27 65–104 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:CSuD28npt1w%3D
H.V. KahnD. Westerhoff D. Westerhoff (1991) ArticleTitleControl Theory of Regulatory Cascades Journal of Theoretical Biology. 153 255–285 Occurrence Handle1686290
J. Kim (1998) Mind in a Physical World: An Essay on the Mind-Body Problem and Mental Causation MIT Press Cambridge.
J. Kim (1999) ArticleTitleMaking Sense of Emergence Philosophical Studies. 95 3–36 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1004563122154
T. Langer et al. (1992) ArticleTitleSuccessive Action of KnaK, Dnaj, and GroEL Along the Pathway of Chaperone-Mediated Protein Folding’ Nature. 356 683–689 Occurrence Handle10.1038/356683a0 Occurrence Handle1:CAS:528:DyaK38XisFSlsL8%3D Occurrence Handle1349157
J. Levine (1983) ArticleTitleMaterialism and Qualia The Explanatory Gap Pacific Philosophical Quarterly. 64 354–361
J. Levine (1993) ‘On Leaving Out What It’s Like’ M. Davies G. W Humphreys (Eds) Consciousness Blackwell Oxford 121–136
P.K. Machamer L. Darden C.F. Craver (2000) ArticleTitleThinking About Mechanisms Philosophy of Science. 67 1–25 Occurrence Handle10.1086/392759
E. Mayr (1982) The Growth of Biological Thought Harvard University Press Cambridge.
McLaughlin B. (1992). The Rise and Fall of British Emergentism’ in Beckermann, Flohr, and Kim. 49–93
J.D. Murray (1989) Mathematical Biology Springer-Verlag Berlin.
E. Nagel (1961) The Structure of Science Routledge Kegan Paul. New York.
I.H. Segel (1993) Enzyme Kinetics: Behavior and Analysis of Rapid Equilibrium and Steady-State Enzyme Systems. Wiley Interscience. New York
A. Stephan (1998) ArticleTitleVarieties of Emergence in Artificial and Natural Systems Zeitschrift für Naturforschung. 53c 639–656
A. Stephan (1999) Emergenz Von der Unvorhersagbarkeit zur Selbstorganisation. Dresden University Press Dresden
Stephan, A. (2002). Emergence, Irreducibility, and Downward Causation’, Grazer Philosophische Studien. 65 (Special issue on Mental Causation, Multiple Realization, and Emergence): pp 77–93
H.V. Westerhoff D.B. Kell (1996) ArticleTitleWhat Biotechnologists Knew All Along? Journal of Theoretical Biology 182 411–420 Occurrence Handle10.1006/jtbi.1996.0181 Occurrence Handle1:CAS:528:DyaK28XntVarsro%3D Occurrence Handle8944175
H.V. Westerhoff K. Dam Particlevan (1987) Thermodynamics and Control of Biological Free Energy Transduction Elsevier Amsterdam
H.V. Westerhoff (2000) ArticleTitlePerspectives: Live Perspectives of Biochemistry The Biochemist 22 43–47
W. C. Wimsatt (1976) Reductionism, Levels of Organization, and the Mind-Body Problem G. Globus G. Maxwell I. Savodnik (Eds) Consciousness and the Brain Plenum Press New York 196–267
W. C. Wimsatt (1986) Forms of Aggregativity A. Donagan N. Perovich M. A. Weding (Eds) Human Nature and Natural Knowledge: Essays Presented to Marjorie Grene on the Occasion of Her 75th Birthday Reidel Dordrecht 259–291
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Boogerd, F.C., Bruggeman, F.J., Richardson, R.C. et al. Emergence and Its Place in Nature: A Case Study of Biochemical Networks. Synthese 145, 131–164 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-004-4421-9
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-004-4421-9