Abstract
The progressive in English appears to be inherently modal, due to what Dowty (Word meaning and Montague grammar: The semantics of verbs and times in generative semantics and in Montague’s PTQ, 1979) terms the imperfective paradox. In truth-conditional accounts, the literal truth of a clause with the modal progressive hinges on the possibility of the described outcome. The clause’s truth under such accounts has also been tacitly assumed to describe its felicitous use. Two challenges for this strategy are discussed. First, a progressive clause exhibiting the imperfective paradox can occur felicitously even when the described outcome is not possible. Second, a progressive clause exhibiting the paradox can occur felicitously with an accompanying unless-clause, yet the analysis of unless-clauses directly contradicts the modal analysis of the truth-conditional behavior of the progressive clause in such cases. If the analysis of unless is not flawed, then the modal progressive will require reanalysis.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Abusch, Dorit. 1985. On verbs and time. PhD dissertation, University of Massachusetts at Amherst.
Aristotle. 1941. The basic works of Aristotle. Edited with an introduction by Richard McKeon. New York: Random House.
Bennett, Michael, and Barbara Partee. 1972. Towards the logic of tense and aspect in English. [Reprinted with a postscript by IULC, Bloomington, 1978].
Declerck Renaat, Susan Reed. (2000) The semantics and pragmatics of unless. English Language and Linguistics 4(2): 205–241
Dowty David. (1979) Word meaning and Montague grammar: The semantics of verbs and times in generative semantics and in Montague’s PTQ. Reidel, Dordrecht
Higginbotham, James. 2004. The English progressive. In The syntax of time, ed. J. Guéron and J. Lecarme, 329–358. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press.
Jespersen Otto. (1932) A modern English grammar on historical principles. Allen and Unwin, London
Landman Fred. (1992) The progressive. Natural Language Semantics 1: 1–32
Montague, Richard. 1970. Pramatics and intensional logic, Synthese 22: 68–94. [Reprinted in R. Montague, Formal philosophy, Chap. 4. Yale University Press, New Haven, 1974.]
Naumann, Ralf, and Christopher Piñón. 1997. Decomposing the progressive. In Proceedings of the 11th Amsterdam Colloquium, 241–246. Amsterdam: ITLI.
Parsons Terence. (1989) The progressive in English: Events, states and processes. Linguistics and Philosopy 12: 213–241
Parsons Terence. (1990) Events in the semantics of English: A study in subatomic semantics. MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass
Portner Paul. (1998) The progressive in modal semantics. Language 74: 760–787
Scott, Dana. 1970. Advice on modal logic. In Philosophical problems in logic, ed. K. Lambert, 143–173. Dordrecht: Reidel.
Stechow, Arnim von. 2001. Temporally opaque arguments in verbs of creation. In Semantic interfaces: Reference, anaphora, and aspect, ed. C. Cecchetto, G. Chierchia, and M. T. Guasti, 278–319. Stanford: CSLI Publications.
Sweet Henry. (1898) New English grammar, Part II. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Szabó Zoltán Gendler. (2004) On the progressive and the perfective. Noûs 38:29–59
Vlach, Frank. 1981. The semantics of the progressive. In Syntax and semantics, vol. 14: Tense and aspect, ed. Philip J. Tedesschi and Annie Zaenen, 271–292. New York: Academic Press.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Wulf, D.J. Two new challenges for the modal account of the progressive. Nat Lang Semantics 17, 205–218 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11050-009-9040-z
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11050-009-9040-z