Abstract
Pollen-limited plants are confronted with a difficult tradeoff because they must present showy floral displays to attract pollinators and yet must also minimize their apparency to herbivores. In these systems, traits that increase pollinator visitation may also increase herbivore oviposition and overall plant resistance may therefore be constrained to evolve largely as a correlated response to selection on plant apparency or vigor. We used a family-structured quantitative genetic experiment to evaluate the importance of ungulate browsing, flowering date and plant height (traits that are related to overall vigor), and variation in a putative phytochemical defense (cucurbitacin production) on patterns of seed fly attack in a scarlet gilia population. We found significant genetic variation in the amount of insect damage plants experience in the field, providing evidence that resistance may evolve. In addition, we found that browsing reduced seed fly attack and that oviposition is strongly related to plant size and flowering date; large, early flowering plants experience high attack. In addition, we found that high cucurbitacin production was correlated with low seed fly damage, although this effect was relatively weak.
We found directional selection on final plant height and flowering date; tall, early flowering plants had the highest reproductive success. In addition, we found negative directional selection on cucurbitacin production, which may indicate a high cost of cucurbitacin or other functions of this phytochemical. Although seed fly herbivory arguably decreases plant fitness, we found an unexpected positive relationship between damage and fitness. A negative relationship between fitness and damage may be masked in this system through strong positive indirect correlations between patterns of damage and levels of pollinator visitation. Finally, we found significant genetic variation in flowering date, plant height, and cucurbitacin production. Resistance to seed flies may evolve in this population, but largely as a non-adaptive correlated response to selection on overall plant vigor. Phytochemicals may play a more important role in defense in years with high seed fly attack, or when pollen-limitation is less severe.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
W.G. Abrahamson A.E. Weiss (1997) Evolutionary Ecology Across Three Trophic Levels: Goldenrods, Gallmakers, and Natural Enemies. Monographs in Population Biology 29 Princeton University Press Princeton, NJ
C. Alonso C.M. Herrera (1996) ArticleTitleVariation in herbivory within and among plants of Daphne laureola (Thymelaeaceae): correlation with plant size and architecture J. Ecol 84 495–502
M. Arisawa J.M. Pezzuto A.D. Kinghorn G.A. Cordell N.R. Farnsworth (1984) ArticleTitlePlant Pharma Sci 73 411–413
C.K. Augspurger (1981) ArticleTitleReproductive synchrony of a tropical shrub: experimental studies on effects of pollinators and seed predators on Hybanthus prunifolius (Violaceae) Ecology 62 775–788
J. Bergelson T. Juenger M.J. Crawley (1996) ArticleTitleRegrowth following herbivory in Ipomopsis aggregata: compensation but not overcompensation Am. Nat 148 744–755 Occurrence Handle10.1086/285952
M. Blackford L. Dinan (1997) ArticleTitleThe effect of ingested ecdysteroid agonists (20-hydroxyecdysone, RH5849, RH5992) and an ecdysteroid antagonist (cucurbitacin B) on larval development of two polyphagus lepidopterans (Acherontia atropos and Laconobia oleraceae). Entomol Experimentalis et Applica 83 263–276 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1002914313556
A.K. Brody (1992a) ArticleTitleOviposition choices by a pre-dispersal seed predator (Hylemya sp.) I. correspondance with hummingbird pollinators, and the role of plant size, density and floral morphology Oecologia 91 56–62
A.K. Brody (1992b) ArticleTitleOviposition choices by a pre-dispersal seed predator (Hylemya sp.) II. a positive association between female choice and fruit set Oecologia 91 63–67
A.K. Brody (1997) ArticleTitleEffects of pollinators, herbivores, and seed predation on flowering phenology Ecology 78 1624–1631
A.K. Brody R.J. Mitchell (1997) ArticleTitleEffects of experimental manipulation of inflorescence size on pollination and pre-dispersal seed predation in the hummingbird-pollinated plant Ipomopsis aggregata Oecologia 110 86–93 Occurrence Handle10.1007/s004420050136
A.K. Brody S.I. Morita (2000) ArticleTitleA positive association between oviposition and fruit set: female choice or manipulation Oecologia 124 418–425
A.K. Brody N.M. Waser (1995) ArticleTitleOviposition pattern and larval success of a pre-dispersal seed predator attacking two confamilial host plants Oikos 74 477–452
D.R. Campbell (1991) ArticleTitleEffects of floral traits on sequential components of fitness in Ipomopsis aggregata Am. Nat 137 713–737 Occurrence Handle10.1086/285190
D.R. Campbell K.J. Halama (1993) ArticleTitleResource and pollen limitations to lifetime seed production in a natural plant population Ecology 74 1043–1051
C.C. Cockerham B.S. Weir (1977) ArticleTitleQuadratic analysis of reciprocal crosses Biometrics 33 187–203 Occurrence Handle843573
M.J. Crawley (1983) Herbivory: The Dynamics of Animal-Plant Interactions Blackwell Scientific Oxford, UK
M.J. Crawley (1993) GLIM for Ecologists. Methods in Ecology Blackwell Scientific Publications Oxford, UK
D. De Steven (1983) ArticleTitleReproductive consequences of insect seed predation in Hamamelis virginiana Ecology 64 89–98
L. Dinan P. Whiting J.P. Girault R. Lafont T.S. Dhadialla D.E. Gess B. Mugat C. Antoniewski J.A. Lepesant (1997) ArticleTitleCucurbitacins are insect steroid hormone antagonists acting at the ecdysteroid receptor Biochem. J 327 643–650 Occurrence Handle9581538
L. Dinan T. Savchenko P. Whiting S.D. Sarker (1999) ArticleTitlePlant natural products as insect steroid receptor agonists and antagonists Pest. Sci 55 331–335 Occurrence Handle10.1002/(SICI)1096-9063(199903)55:3<331::AID-PS889>3.0.CO;2-1
D.R. Elam Y.B. Linhart (1988) ArticleTitlePollination and seed production in Ipomopsis aggregata: differences among and within flower color morph Am. J. Botany 75 1262–1274
E. Elle N. Dam Particlevan J. Daniel Hare (1999) ArticleTitleCost of glandular trichomes, a “resistance” character in Datura wrightii Regel (Solanaceae) Evolution 53 IssueID1 22–35
D.S. Falconer T.F.C. Mackay (1996) Introduction to Quantitative Genetics EditionNumber4 th edn Longman Group Essex England
R.S. Fritz (1992) Community structure and species interactions of phytophagous insects on resistant and susceptible host plants R.S. Fritz E.L Simms (Eds) Plant Resistance to Herbivores and Pathogens: Ecology, Evolution, and Genetics. University of Chicago Press Chicago 240–277
F.R. Hainsworth L.L. Wolf T. Mercier (1984) ArticleTitlePolination and pre-dispersal seed predation: net effects on reproduction and inflorescence characteristics in Ipomopsis aggregata Oecologia 63 405–409 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00390673
F.R. Hainsworth L.L. Wolf T. Mercier (1985) ArticleTitlePollen limitation in a monocarpic species, Ipomopsis aggregata J. Ecol 73 263–270
S. Harrison R. Karban (1986) ArticleTitleEffects of an early-season folivorous moth on the success of a late-season species, mediated by a change in the quality of a shared host, Lupinus arboreus Sims Oecologia 69 352–359 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00377056
T. Juenger J. Bergelson (1997) ArticleTitlePollen and resource limitation of compensation to herbivory in scarlet gilia, Ipomopsis aggregata Ecology 78 1684–1695
T. Juenger J. Bergelson (1998) ArticleTitlePairwise versus diffuse natural selection and the multiple herbivores of scarlet gilia, Ipomopsis aggregata Evolution 52 1583–1592
T. Juenger J. Bergelson (2000) ArticleTitleThe evolution of compensation to browsing in scarlet gilia, Ipomopsis aggregata: herbivore-imposed natural selection and quantitative genetics of tolerance characters Evolution 54 764–777 Occurrence Handle10937251
R. Karban (1989) ArticleTitleCommunity organization of Erigeron glaucus folivores: effects of predation, competition, and host plant Ecology 70 1028–1039
R. Lande S.J. Arnold (1983) ArticleTitleThe measurement of selection on correlated characters Evolution 37 1210–1226
J.H. Lawton M.P. Hassell (1984) Interspecific competition in insects C.B. Huffaker R.C. Rabbs (Eds) Ecological Entomology Wiley New York
J.H. Lawton D.R. Strong (1981) ArticleTitleCommunity patterns and competition in folivorous insects Am. Nat 118 317–338 Occurrence Handle10.1086/283826
R.C. Littell G.A. Milliken W.W. Stroup R.D. Wolfinger (1996) SAS System for Mixed Models SAS Institute Inc. Cary, NC 663
M. Lynch B. Walsh (1998) Genetics and the Analysis of Quantitative Traits Sinauer Associates Inc. Sunderland, MA
R.J. Marquis (1992) The selective impact of herbivores Fritz Simms (Eds) Plant Resistance to Herbivores and Pathogens; Ecology, Evolution, and Genetics. The University of Chicago Press Chicago 301–325
R. Mauricio M.D. Rausher (1997) ArticleTitleExperimental manipulation of putative selective agents provides evidence for the role of natural enemies in the evolution of plant defense Evolution 51 1435–1444
R.A. McLean S. William W.W. Stroup (1991) ArticleTitleA unified approach to mixed linear models Am. Stat 45 54–63
M. Miro (1995) ArticleTitleCucurbitacins and their pharmological effects Phytotherapy Research 9 159–168
R. Mitchell (1994) ArticleTitleEffects of floral traits, pollinator visitation, and plant size on Ipomopsis aggregata fruit production Am. Nat 143 871–889 Occurrence Handle10.1086/285637
T. Mitchell-Olds R.G. Shaw (1987) ArticleTitleRegression analysis of natural selection: statistical inference and biological interpretation Evolution 41 1149–1161
K.N. Paige T.G. Whitham (1987) ArticleTitleFlexible life-history traits: shifts by scarlet gilia in response to pollinator abundance Ecology 68 1691–1695
D. Pilson (1992) ArticleTitleAphid distribution and the evolution of goldenrod resistance Evolution 46 1358–1371
P.W. Price (1991) ArticleTitleThe plant vigor hypothesis and herbivore attack Oikos 62 244–251
InstitutionalAuthorNameSAS Institute. (1997) SAS/STAT Software: Changes and Enhancements Through Release 612 SAS Institute, Inc. Cary, NC
D. Schluter M.L. Nychka (1994) ArticleTitleExploring fitness surfaces Am. Nat 143 597–616 Occurrence Handle10.1086/285622
J.C. Schultz I.T. Baldwin (1982) ArticleTitleOak leaf quality declines in response to defoliation by gypsy moth larvae Science 217 149–151
S.R. Searle G. Casella C.E. McCulloch (1992) Variance Components. Wiley Series in Probability and Mathematical Statistics John Wiley and Sons New York
R. Shaw (1987) ArticleTitleMaximum-likelihood approaches applied to quantitative genetics of natural populations Evolution 41 812–826
E. Simms (1992) Costs of plant resistance to herbivory R.S. Fritz E.L. Simms (Eds) Plant Resistance to Herbivores and Pathogens: Ecology, Evolution, and Genetics. The University of Chicago Press Chicago, IL
R.R. Sokal F.J. Rohlf (1981) Biometry: The Principles and Practice of Statistics in Biological Research EditionNumber2 W.H. Freemon and Company New York
StatSoft (1995) Statistica StatSoft, Inc. Tulsa, OK
D. Tallamy J. Stull N.P. Ehresman P.M. Gorski C.E. Manson (1997) ArticleTitleCucurbitacins as feeding and oviposition deterrents to insects Environ. Entomol 26 678–683
J.S. Thaler (1999) ArticleTitleJasmonate-inducible plants defences cause increased parasitism of herbivores Nature 399 686–687 Occurrence Handle10.1038/21420
D.H. Wilken S.T. Allard (1986) ArticleTitleIntergradation among populations of the Ipomopsis aggregata complex in the Colorado Front Range Syst. Botany 11 1–13
K.S. Williams J.H. Meyers (1984) ArticleTitlePrevious herbivore attack of red alder may improve food quality for fall webworm larvae Oecologia 63 166–170 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00379873
T.P. Young (1987) ArticleTitleIncreased thorn length in Acacia drepanolobium – an induced response to browsing Oecologia 71 436–438 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00378718
M. Zimmerman (1980a) ArticleTitleReproduction in Polemonium: pre-dispersal seed predation Ecology 61 IssueID3 502–506
M. Zimmerman (1980b) ArticleTitleSelective deposition of an oviposition-deterring pheromone by Hylemya Environ. Entomol 9 321–324
M. Zimmerman R.S. Gross (1984) ArticleTitleThe relationship between flowering phenology and seed set in an herbaceous perennial plant, Polemonium foliosissimum Gray Am. Midl. Nat 111 185–191
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Co-ordinating editor: J. Tuomi
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Juenger, T., Morton, T.C., Miller, R.E. et al. Scarlet gilia resistance to insect herbivory: the effects of early season browsing, plant apparency, and phytochemistry on patterns of seed fly attack. Evol Ecol 19, 79–101 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10682-004-8090-4
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10682-004-8090-4