Abstract
Critical research is becoming increasingly accepted as a valid approach to research in information systems. It is deemed to be particularly suitable for situations where researchers want to address conspicuous injustice, such as in areas of development or the digital divide. Critical research in information systems (CRIS), I will argue, is a possible approach to some of the ethical problems arising in the context of information and communication technology (ICT). It can be sensitive to the question of culture and therefore suitable for researching cross-cultural ethical questions in ICT. It is often unclear, however, what exactly critical research stands for and to what extent critical approaches are applicable across cultural boundaries. This paper will address these problems by proposing a definition of critical research as focused on changing the status quo and aiming for emancipation. It will then look at the question whether different cultures are compatible and comparable and what the role of culture in research on information systems is. The paper will then return to the question whether the critical intention to emancipate and empower humans is an expression of cultural imperialism or whether there are valid ways of promoting emancipation across cultural divides.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
S. Abdat and G.P. Pervan. Reducing the Negative Effects of Power Distance During Asynchronous Pre-Meeting with Using Anonymity in Indonesian Culture. In F. Sudweeks and C. Ess, editors, Proceedings of the Second International Conference on Cultural Attitudes towards Technology and Communication, pp. 209–215. Murdoch, Western Australia, June 2000. Murdoch University Press, Murdoch, WA
Alvesson M., Deetz S. (2000)Doing Critical Management Research. SAGE, London
Alvesson M., Willmott H. (1992) On the Idea of Emancipation in Management and Organization Studies. Academy of Management Review 17(3): 432–464
Barbar B. (1995) Jihad versus McWorld. Times Books, New York
Beck U. (1998)Was ist Globalisierung? Irrtümer des Globalismus - Antworten auf Globalisierung.5, Suhrkamp Verlag, Frankfurt a. M
F. Bell and A. Adam. Whatever Happened to Information Systems Ethics? Caught between the Devil and the Deep Blue Sea. In B. Kaplan, D.P. Truex, D. Wastell, A.T.␣Wood-Harper and J. DeGross, editors, Information Systems Research: Relevant Theory and Informed Practice (IFIP 8.2 Proceedings), pp. 159–174. Kluwer, Dordrecht, 2004
R.W. Berne. Recognizing Religious Mythology in Visions of New Technology. IEEE Technology and Society Magazine, 22(1): 34–39, 2003
Brooke C. (2002a) Critical Perspectives on Information Systems: An Impression of the Research Landscape. Journal of Information Technology 17: 271–283
Brooke C. (2002b) What Does it Mean to be ‘Critical’ in IS Research? Journal of Information Technology 17: 49–57
Burrell G., Dale K. (2003) Building Better Worlds?: Architecture and Critical Management Studies. In: Alvesson M., Willmott H. (eds.) Studying Management Critically. SAGE, London, pp. 177–196
Castells M. (2000) The Information Age: Economy, Society, and Culture. Volume I: The Rise of the Network Society. 2nd edition, Blackwell, Oxford
Castells M. (2000b) The Information Age: Economy, Society, and Culture. Volume III: End of Millennium. 2nd edition Blackwell, Oxford
Cecez-Kecmanovic D. (2001) Doing Critical IS Research: The Question of Methodology. In: Trauth E. (ed.) Qualitative Research in IS: Issues and Trends. Idea Group Publishing, Hershey, pp. 141–162
Cecez-Kecmanovic D., Janson M., Brown A. (2002) The Rationality Framework for a Critical Study of Information Systems. Journal of Information Technology 17: 215–227
Chua W.F. (1986) Radical Developments in Accounting Thought. The Accounting Review 61(4): 601–632
C. Ciborra. A Critical Review of the Literature on the Management of Corporate Information Infrastructure. In C. Ciborra and Associates, editors, From Control to Drift: The Dynamics of Corporate Information Infrastructures, pp. 15–40. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Dawson R.J., Newman I.A. (2002) Empowerment in IT Education. Journal of Information Technology Education 1(2): 125–141
Ess C. (2001) Introduction: What’s Culture Got to Do with It? Cultural Collisions in the Electronic Global Village, Creative Inferences, and the Rise of Culturally-Mediated Computing. In: Ess C., Sudweeks F. (eds.) Culture, Technology, Communication: Towards and Intercultural Global Village. SUNY Press, Albany, pp. 1–52
Fairclough N. (2003) Analysing Discourse – Textual Analysis for Social Research. Routledge, London & New York
Floridi L. (1999) Philosophy and Computing: An Introduction. Routledge, London
Forester J. (1992) Critical Ethnography: On Fieldwork in a Habermasian Way. In: Alvesson M., Willmott H. (eds.) Critical Management Studies. SAGE, London, pp. 46–65
Gehlen A. (1997) Der Mensch: seine Natur und seine Stellung in der Welt. 13th edition, UTB, Wiesbaden
Heng M.S.H., de Moor A. (2003) From Habermas’s Communicative Theory to Practice on the Internet. Information Systems Journal 13: 331–352
Himanen P. (2001) The Hacker Ethic and the Spirit of the Information Age. Secker & Warburg, London
Hirschheim R., Klein H.K. (1994) Realizing Emancipatory Principles in Information Systems Development: The Case for ETHICS. MIS Quarterly 18(1): 83–109
Hirschheim R., Klein H. (1989) Four Paradigms of Information Systems Development. Communications of the ACM 32(10): 1199–1216
Höffe O. (1995) Moral als Preis der Moderne: ein Versuch über Wissenschaft, Technik und Umwelt. 3rd edition, Suhrkamp, Frankfurt a. M
D. Howcroft and E.M. Trauth. The Choice of Critical Information Systems Research. In B. Kaplan, D.P. Truex, D. Wastell, A.T. Wood-Harper and J. DeGross, editors, Information Systems Research: Relevant Theory and Informed Practice (IFIP 8.2 Proceedings), pp. 196–211. Kluwer, Dordrecht, 2004
Huntington S. (1993) The Clash of Civilisations? Foreign Affairs Summer 72(3): 22–49
Jermier J.M., Forbes L.C. (2003) Greening Organizations: Critical Issues. In: Alvesson M., Willmott H. (eds.) Studying Management Critically. SAGE, London, pp. 157–176
Klein H.K., Huynh M.Q. (2004) The Critical Social Theory of Jürgen Habermas and its Implications for IS Research. In: Mingers J., Willcocks L. (eds.) Social Theory and Philosophy for Information Systems. Wiley, Chichester, pp. 157–237
Kvwasny L., Greenhill A., Trauth E. (2005) Giving Voice to Feminist Projects in MIS Research. International Journal of Technology and Human Interaction 1(1): 1–18
Kvasny L., Trauth E. (2003) The Digital Divide at Work and Home: The Discourse about Power and Underrepresented Groups in the Information Society. In: Wynn E., Whitley E., Myers M.D., DeGross J. (eds.) Global and Organizational Discourse About Information Technology. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, pp. 273–291
R. Lenoir. Entretien avec René Lenoir. In F. Lenoir, editor, Le temps de la responsabilité — Entretiens sur l’éthique, pp.␣97–118. Fayard, Paris, 1991
Levy D.L., Alvesson M., Willmitt H. (2003) Critical Approaches to Strategic Management. In: Alvesson M., Willmott H. (eds.) Studying Management Critically. SAGE, London, pp. 92–110
Maitland C.F., Bauer J.M. (2001) National Level Culture and Global Diffusion: The Case of the Internet. In: Ess C., Sudweeks F. (eds.) Culture, Technology, Communication: Towards and Intercultural Global Village. SUNY Press, Albany, pp. 87–129
Marx K. (1969) Manifest der Kommunistischen Partei. Reclam, Stuttgart
K. Marx. In I. Fetscher, editor, Karl Marx/Friedrich Engels Studienausgabe, vol. 1. Fischer Philosophie, Frankfurt a.␣M, 1964
McAulay L., Doherty N., Keval N. (2002) The Stakeholder Dimension in Information Systems Evaluation. Journal of Information Technology 17: 241–255
K. McGrath, Doing Critical Research in Information Systems: A Case of Theory and Practice Not Informing Each Other. Information Systems Journal, 15: 85–101, 2005
Mingers J. (1992) Technical, Practical and Critical OR – Past, Present and Future? In: Alvesson M., Willmott H. (eds.) Critical Management Studies. SAGE, London, pp. 90–113
Ngwenyama O.K., Lee A.S. (1997) Communication Richness in Electronic Mail: Critical Social Theory and the Contextuality of Meaning. MIS Quarterly 21(2): 145–167
Nord W.R., Jermier J.M. (1992) Critical Social Science for Managers? Promising and Perverse Possibilities. In: Alvesson M., Willmott H. (eds.) Critical Management Studies. SAGE, London, pp. 202–222
B.J. Oates. Action Research: Time to Take a Turn? In B. Kaplan, D.P. Truex, D. Wastell, A.T. Wood-Harper and J. DeGross, editors, Information Systems Research: Relevant Theory and Informed Practice (IFIP 8.2 Proceedings), pp. 315–333. Kluwer, Dordrecht, 2004
Orlikowski W.J., Baroudi J.J. (1991) Studying Information Technology in Organizations: Research Approaches and Assumptions. Information Systems Research 2(1): 1–28
Orlikowski W.J., Iacono C.S. (2001) Research Commentary: Desperately Seeking the “IT” in IT Research – A Call to Theorizing the IT Artifact. Information Systems Research 12(2): 121–134
Postman N. (1992) Technopoly – The Surrender of Culture to Technology. Vintage Books, New York
Probert S.K. (2002) Ethics, Authenticity and Emancipation in Information Systems Development. In: Salehnia, Ali (ed.) Ethical Issues of Information Systems. IRM Press, Hershey, PA, pp. 249–254
Rey L. (2001) Cultural Attitudes toward Technology and Communication: A Study in the “Multi-cultural” Environment of Switzerland. In: Ess C., Sudweeks F. (ed.) Culture, Technology, Communication: Towards and Intercultural Global Village. SUNY Press, Albany, pp. 151–160
Ricoeur P. (1983) Tems et récit – 1. L’intrigue et le récit historique. Editions de Seuil, Paris
Riis A.M. (1997) The Information Welfare Society: An Assessment of Danish Governmental Initiatives Preparing for the Information Age. In: Kahin B., Wilson E.J. (eds) National Information Infrastructure Initiatives Vision and Policy Design. MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts, pp. 424–456
Robey D., Azevedo A. (1994) Cultural Analysis of the Organizational Consequences of Information Technology. Accounting, Management and Information Technologies 1(4): 23–37
Saravanamuthu K. (2002) Information Technology and Ideology. Journal of Information Technology 17: 79–87
Schultze U., Leidner D. (2002) Studying Knowledge Management in Information Systems Research: Discourses and Theoretical Assumptions. MIS Quarterly 26(3): 213–242
Stahl B.C., El-Beltagi I. (2004) Cultural Universality versus Particularity in CMC. Journal of Global Information Technology Management 7(4): 47–65
Trauth E. (2001) Choosing Qualitative Methods in IS Research: Lessons Learned. In: Trauth E. (eds.) Qualitative Research in IS: Issues and Trends. Idea Group Publishing, Hershey 271–287
Trauth E., O’Connor B. (1991) A Study of the Interaction Between Information Technology and Society: An Illustration of Combined Qualitative Research Methods. In: Nissen H.-E., Klein H.K., Hirschheim R. (eds.) Information Systems Research: Contemporary Approaches & Emergent Traditions. North Holland, Amsterdam, pp. 131–144
Ulrich W. (2001) A Philosophical Staircase for Information Systems Definition, Design, and Development. Journal of Information Technology Theory and Application 3(3): 55–84
Varey R.J. Wood-Harper T., Wood B. (2002) A Theoretical Review of Management and Information Systems Using a Critical Communications Theory. Journal of Information Technology 17: 229–239
Walsham G. (2002) Cross-Cultural Software Production and Use: A Structurational Analysis. MIS Quarterly 26(4): 359–380
Walsham G. (2001) Making a World of Difference – IT in a Global Context. Wiley, Chichester
Walsham G. (1993) Interpreting Information Systems in Organizations. Wiley, Chichester
J. Ward and J. Peppard. Reconciling the IT/business relationship: A troubled marriage in need of guidance. Journal of Strategic Information Systems, 5: 37–65, 1996
Weber M. (1994) Objectivity and understanding in economics. In: Hausman D.M. (ed.) The Philosophy of Economics: An Anthology. 2nd edition, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 69–82
J.Y. Weisinger and E. Trauth. Situating Culture in the Global Information Sector. Information Technology & People, 15(4): 306–320, 2002
Weizenbaum J. (1976) Computer Power and Human Reason. W. H. Freeman and Company, San Francisco
Wilson F.A. (1997) The Truth is Out There: the Search for Emancipatory Principles in Information Systems Design. Information Technology & People 10(3): 187–204
Wilson M. (2003) Rhetoric of Enrollment and Acts of Resistance: Information Technology as Text. In: Wynn E., Whitley E., Myers M.D., DeGross J. (eds.) Global and Organizational Discourse About Information Technology. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, pp. 225–248
Wyatt S., Thomas G., Terranova T. (2002) They Came, They Surfed, They Went Back to the Beach: Conceptualizing Use and Non-Use of the Internet. In: Woolgar S. (ed.) Virtual Society? Technology, Cyberbole, Reality. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp. 23–40
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Stahl, B.C. Emancipation in cross-cultural IS research: The fine line between relativism and dictatorship of the intellectual. Ethics Inf Technol 8, 97–108 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10676-006-9118-y
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10676-006-9118-y