Abstract
A contingent valuation study was carried out under similar conditions on two sites simultaneously: Strasbourg (France) and Kehl (Germany) in order to test the reliability of the benefit transfer method. On average, the air quality is approximately the same in the two cities. Using a transfer of the benefit function, we compared the direct estimated benefits from improved air quality with the transferred benefits in the same city. The originality of this test is that the valued good is the same in both cities, which means that the transfer is an “intra-site” transfer. However our findings show that the method of benefit transfer was not generally valid. Indeed inhabitants of Kehl declared a higher price for their state of health and air quality than inhabitants in Strasbourg. This result could be explained by a stronger sensitivity to environmental problems in Germany.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Alberini A.,M. Cropper, F. Tsu-Tan, A. Krupnick, L. Jin-Tan, D. Shaw and W. Harrington (1997),'Valuing Health Effects of Air Pollution in Developing Countries:The Case of Taiwan',Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 34,107–126.
Bergland O.,K. Magnussen and S. Navrud (1995),Benefit Transfer:Testing for Accuracy and Reliability,Discussion Paper #D-03/1995,The Agricultural University of Norway.
Brouwer R.and F.A. Spaninks (1999),'The Validity of Environmental Benefits Transfer: Further Empirical Testing',Environmental and Resource Economics 14,91–117.
Chow G.(1960),'Tests of Equality Between Sets of Coeffcients in Two Linear Regressions', Econometrica 28,591–605.
Delquie ´P.(1993),'Inconsistent Trade-offs Between Attributes:New Evidence in Preference Assessment Biases',Management Science 39(11),1382–1395.
Downing M.and T. Ozuna (1996),'Testing the Reliability of the Benefit Function Transfer Approach',Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 30,316–322.
Greene W.H.(1997),Econometric Analysis,3rd ed.Upper Saddle River,New Jersey: Prentice Hall,1075 pp.
Grenier P.and S. Jacobzone (1996),'Comportement de pre ´vention,consommation d' alcool et tabagie:peut-on parler d' une gestion globale du capital sante ´?',Une mode ´lisation microe ´conome ´trique empirique,Document de travail INSEE,48 pp.
Kirchhoff S.,B. Colby and J. LaFrance (1997),'Evaluating the Performance of Benefit Transfer:an Empirical Enquiry',Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 33, 75–93.
Krupnick A.,K. Harrison, E. Nickell and M. Toman (1996),'The Value of Health Bene ts from Ambient Air Quality Improvements in Central and Eastern Europe:An Exercise in Bene ts Transfer',Environmental and Resource Economics 7,307–332.
Loehman E.T.,S. Berg, A. Arroyo, R. Hedinger, J. Schwartz, M. Shaw, V. De, D. Rio, W. Rossley and A. Green (1979),'Distributional Analysis of Regional Benefits and Cost of Air Quality Control',Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 6,222–243.
Navrud S.(1998),Valuing Health Impacts from Air Pollution in Europe:New Empirical Evidence on Morbidity,Discussion Paper #D-04/1998,The Agrigultural University of Norway.
Poe G.L.,E.K. Severance-Lossin and M.P. Welsch (1994),'Measuring the difference (X )Y )of Simulated Distributions:A Convolutions Approach',American Journal Agriculture and Economics 76,904–915.
Rozan A.(1999),Contingent Valuation of Health Benefits Induced by Air Pollution:The Example of the Region of Strasbourg,PhD Thesis,University Louis Pasteur,Strasbourg I.
Rozan A.(2000a),'Une E ´valuation E ´conomique des Be ´ne ´ces de Morbidite ´Induits par une Ame ´lioration de la Qualite ´de l' air’,Economie et Pre ´vision 143–144,247–259.
Rozan A.(2000b),'Diffe ´rences Culturelles Face a`un Mëme Actif Environnemental:Une Comparaison Franco-allemande des Consentements a`Payer Pour une Ame ´lioration de la Qualite ´de l' air',Re ´gion et De ´veloppement 12,79–104.
Rozan A.,A. Stenger and M. Willinger (1999),'Valeur de Pre ´servation et Transfe ´rabilite ´ Intra-site et Inter-site:Application a`la Nappe Phre ´atique d' Alsace',in P. Point,ed.,La Valeur e ´conomique des hydrosyste`mes.Me ´thodes et mode`les d' e ´valuations des services de ´livre ´s,Economica,January.
Schkade D.A.and J.W. Payne (1993),'Where Do the Numbers Come From?How People Respond to CV',in J.A. Hausman,ed.,Contingent Valuation:A Critical Assessment (pp.271–304).Amsterdam: North-Holland.
Smith V.K.and J.C. Huang (1993),'Hedonic Models and Air Pollution.Twenty-Five Years and Counting',Environmental and Resource Economics 3,381–394.
Tolley G., L. Babcock, M. Berger, A. Bilotti, G. Blomquist, M. Brien, R. Fabian, G. Fishelson, C. Kahn, A. Kelly, D. Kenkel, R. Krumm, T. Miller, R. Oshfeldt, S. Rosen, W. Webb, W. Wilson and M. Zelder (1986),Valuation of Reductions in Human Health Symptoms and Risks.Report for USEPA grant #CR-811053-01-0,US.EPA,Washington DC.
Tolley G.,D. Kenkel and R. Fabian (1994),Valuing Health for Policy;an Economic Approach. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Rozan, A. Benefit Transfer: A Comparison of WTP for Air Quality between France and Germany. Environmental and Resource Economics 29, 295–306 (2004). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10640-004-5266-x
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10640-004-5266-x