Abstract
This study considered what insights into outdoor education (OE) research and scholarship could be gleaned from citation indices and patterns. Citation indices have long been used as ranking tools in the physical sciences, and more recently have been used in humanities and social sciences. High citation measures indicate high research impact, although the converse is not necessarily true because research can have impact unrelated to citations, especially in a small practical field such as OE, and citation indices cannot be used for cross-discipline comparisons without considering variations in citation patterns between fields or disciplines. Citation data can also be used for purposes other than ranking. One aim of this article is to consider what OE citation patterns indicate about the distinctiveness of OE as a field. We wanted to use citation data to inform our understanding, as researchers, of the nature and structure of OE discourse. In particular, we made use of citation tools to look at not only which OE work had been cited but also where citation impact occurred. The study examined the most-cited OE research and scholarship published from 2000 to 2013. We attempted to answer the following questions: (1) What do citation patterns indicate about OE research impact outside the field? (2) Does where OE research is published predict where its citation impact, if any, will be? (3) Do citation patterns point to the existence of a single OE literature, or several? (4) Do citation impacts provide insight into how, if at all, the OE field progresses? Using Google Scholar data, Publish or Perish software, and searches for “outdoor education,” we obtained 1,446 articles or other sources. Using Zotero software, we reviewed and analysed these articles and works. We found strong support for an argument that OE discourse constituted a distinct research community clustered around the Australian Journal of Outdoor Education (now the Journal of Outdoor and Environmental Education), the Journal of Adventure Education and Outdoor Learning, and the Journal of Experiential Education. Most published OE work is never cited, and a small number of well-cited works form patterns of citation. We were surprised by the number of theses in the citing works, and found that with the exception of a few articles any impact of OE research and scholarship outside of the OE journals, theses, or OE conferences, is highly diffuse.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Adkins, C., & Simmons, B. (2002). Outdoor, experiential, and environmental education: Converging or diverging approaches? ERIC Digest. (EDO-RC-02-1). From ERIC Clearinghouse on Rural Education and Small Schools.
Allison, P., & Pomeroy, E. (2000). How shall we “know?” Epistemological concerns in research in experiential education. Journal of Experiential Education, 23 (2), 91–98.
Baldwin, C., Persing, J., & Magnuson, D. (2004). The role of theory, research, and evaluation in adventure education. Journal of Experiential Education, 26 (3), 167–183.
Bengtsson, L., Elg, U., & Lind, J.-I. (1997). Bridging the transatlantic publishing gap: How North American reviewers evaluate European idiographic research. Scandinavian Journal of Management, 13 (4), 473–492.
Bogner, F. X. (2002). The influence of a residential outdoor education programme to pupil’s environmental perception. European Journal of Psychology of Education, 17 (1), 19–34.
Breunig, M. (2005). Turning experiential education and critical pedagogy theory into praxis. Journal of Experiential Education, 28 (2), 106–122.
Brookes, A. (2002). Lost in the Australian bush: Outdoor education as curriculum. Journal of Curriculum Studies, 34 (4), 405 425.
Brookes, A. (2003a). A critique of neo-Hahnian outdoor education theory. Part one: Challenges to the concept of ‘character building’. Journal of Adventure Education and Outdoor Learning, 3 (1), 49–62.
Brookes, A. (2003b). A critique of neo-Hahnian outdoor education theory. Part two: ‘The fundamental attribution error’ in contemporary outdoor education discourse. Journal of Adventure Education and Outdoor Learning, 3 (2), 119–132.
Brookes, A. (2004). Astride a long-dead horse. Mainstream outdoor education theory and the central curriculum problem. Australian Journal of Outdoor Education, 8 (2), 22–33.
Brown, M. (2002). The facilitator as gatekeeper: A critical analysis of social order in facilitation sessions. Journal of Adventure Education and Outdoor Leadership, 2 (2), 101–112.
Brown, M. (2008). Comfort zone: Model or metaphor. Australian Journal of Outdoor Education, 12 (1), 3–12.
Brymer, E., & Gray, T. (2006). Effective leadership: Transformational or transactional? Australian Journal of Outdoor Education, 10 (2), 13–19.
Bunting, C. J., & Donley, J. P. (2002, January). Ten years of challenge course research: A review of affective outcome studies. Paper presented at the 6th Coalition for the Education in the Outdoors Research Symposium, Bradford Woods, Indiana.
Davidson, L. (2001). Qualitative research and making meaning from adventure: A case study of boys’ experiences of outdoor education at school. Journal of Adventure Education & Outdoor Learning, 1 (2), 11–20.
Davis, B., Rea, T., & Waite, S. (2006). The special nature of the outdoors: Its contribution to the education of children aged 3-11. Australian Journal of Outdoor Education, 10 (2), 3–12.
Dillon, J., Rickinson, M., Teamey, K., Morris, M., Choi, M. Y., Sanders, D., & Benefield, P. (2006). The value of outdoor learning: Evidence from research in the UK and elsewhere. School science review, 87 (320), 107–111.
Dunlap, R. E., & Van Liere, K. D. (2008). The “New Environmental Paradigm.” The Journal of Environmental Education, 40 (1), 19–28. doi: 10.3200/JOEE.40.1.19-28
Estes, C. A. (2004). Promoting student-centered learning in experiential education. Journal of Experiential Education, 27 (2), 141–160.
ai]Garst, B., Scheider, I., & Baker, D. (2001). Outdoor adventure program participation impacts on adolescent self-perception. Journal of Experiential Education, 24 (1), 41–49.
Gilbertson, K. (2006). Outdoor education: Methods and strategies: Human Kinetics, Champaign Il.
Goldenberg, M., McAvoy, L., & Klenosky, D. B. (2005). Outcomes from the components of an outward bound experience. Journal of Experiential Education, 28 (2), 123–146.
Gough, N., & Sellers, W. (2004). Re/de/signing the world: Postructuralism, deconstruction and “reality” in outdoor/environmental education research. Paper presented at the International Outdoor Education Research Conference: Connections and disconnections: Examining the reality and rhetoric, Bendigo, Victoria, Australia.
Hales, R., & Watkins, M. (2004). The potential contribution of phenomenography to study individuals’ meanings of environmental responsibility. Paper presented at the International Outdoor Education Research Conference: Connections and disconnections: Examining the reality and rhetoric, Bendigo, Victoria, Australia.
Harrison, S. (2010). “Why are we here?” Taking “place” into account in UK outdoor environmental education. Journal of Adventure Education & Outdoor Learning, 10 (1), 3–18.
Harzing, A.-W. (2010). The Publish or Perish book: Tarma Software Research, Melbourne, Australia.
Harzing, A.-W. (2013). A preliminary test of Google Scholar as a source for citation data: A longitudinal study of Nobel prize winners. Scientometrics, 94(3), 1057–1075.
Hirsch, J. E. (2005). An index to quantify an individual’s scientific research output. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, US, 16569–16572.
Hovelynck, J. (2001). Beyond didactics: A reconnaissance of experiential learning. Australian Journal of Outdoor Education-Vol, 6 (1), 4–12.
Hubbs, D. L., & Brand, C. F. (2005). The paper mirror: Understanding reflective journaling. Journal of Experiential Education, 28 (1), 60–71.
Irwin, D. (2008). Weaving the threads: Challenges encountered while educating for sustainability in outdoor education. New Zealand Journal of Outdoor Education: Ko Tane Mahuta Pupuke, 2 (3), 36–53.
Jones, M. (2004). Disconnections between outdoor programs and education principles. Paper presented at the International Outdoor Education Research Conference: Connections and disconnections: Examining the reality and rhetoric, Bendigo, Victoria, Australia.
Loynes, C. (2002). The generative paradigm. Journal of Adventure Education & Outdoor Learning, 2 (2), 113–125.
LSE Public Policy Group. (2011). Maximising the impacts of your research: A handbook for social scientists. London, England: LSE Public Policy Group.
Lugg, A. (2004). Outdoor adventure in Australian outdoor education: Is it a case of roast for Christmas dinner? Australian Journal of Outdoor Education, 8 (1), 4–11.
Lugg, A. (2007). Developing sustainability-literate citizens through outdoor learning: Possibilities for outdoor education in higher education. Journal of Adventure Education & Outdoor Learning, 7 (2), 97–112.
Martin, P. (2004a). Outdoor adventure in promoting relationships with nature. Australian Journal of Outdoor Education, 8 (1), 20–28.
Martin, P. (2004b). Outdoor education for human/nature relationships. Paper presented at the International Outdoor Education Research Conference: Connections and disconnections: Examining the reality and rhetoric, Bendigo, Victoria, Australia.
McKenzie, M. (2003). Beyond “the outward bound process”: Rethinking student learning. Journal of Experiential Education, 26 (1), 8–23.
McKenzie, M. D. (2000). How are adventure education program outcomes achieved? A review of the literature. Australian Journal of Outdoor Education-Vol, 5 (1).
Moseley, C., Reinke, K., & Bookout, V. (2002). The effect of teaching outdoor environmental education on preservice teachers’ attitudes toward self-efficacy and outcome expectancy. The Journal of Environmental Education, 34 (1), 9–15.
Mygind, E. (2007). A comparison between children’s physical activity levels at school and learning in an outdoor environment. Journal of Adventure Education & Outdoor Learning, 7 (2), 161–176.
Mygind, E. (2009). A comparison of children’s statements about social relations and teaching in the classroom and in the outdoor environment. Journal of Adventure Education & Outdoor Learning, 9 (2), 151–169.
ai]Neill, J. T. (2002). Meta-analytic research on the outcomes of outdoor education. Paper presented at the 6th Biennial Coalition for Education in the Outdoors Research Symposium, Bradford Woods, IN.
Neill, J. T., & Dias, K. L. (2001). Adventure education and resilience: The double-edged sword. Journal of Adventure Education & Outdoor Learning, 1 (2), 35–42.
Nicol, R. (2002). Outdoor education: Research topic or universal value? Part one. Journal of Adventure Education & Outdoor Learning, 2 (1), 29–41.
Nicol, R. (2003). Outdoor education: Research topic or universal value? Part three. Journal of Adventure Education & Outdoor Learning, 3 (1), 11–27.
Payne, P., & Wattchow, B. (2008). Slow pedagogy and placing education in post-traditional outdoor education. Australian Journal of Outdoor Education, 12 (1), 25–38.
Payne, P. G. (2002). On the construction, deconstruction and reconstruction of experience in “critical” outdoor education. Australian Journal of Outdoor Education, 6 (2), 4–21.
Pryor, A., Carpenter, C., & Townsend, M. (2012). Outdoor education and bush adventure therapy: A social-ecological approach to health and wellbeing. Australian Journal of Outdoor Education, 9 (1), 3–13.
Quay, J. (2003). Experience and participation: Relating theories of learning. Journal of Experiential Education, 26 (2), 105–112.
Rickinson, M., Dillon, J., Teamey, K., Morris, M., Choi, M. Y., Sanders, D., & Benefied, P. (2004). A review of research on outdoor learning. London, England: National Foundation for Educational Research and King’s College.
Russell, K. C. (2001). What is wilderness therapy? Journal of Experiential Education, 24 (2), 70–79.
Russell, K. C. (2006). Brat camp, boot camp, or........? Exploring wilderness therapy program theory. Journal of Adventure Education & Outdoor Learning, 6 (1), 51–67.
Sandell, K., & Ohman, J. (2013). An educational tool for outdoor education and environmental concern. Journal of Adventure Education & Outdoor Learning, 13 (1), 36–55.
Sandseter, E. B. H. (2009). Characteristics of risky play. Journal of Adventure Education & Outdoor Learning, 9 (1), 3–21.
Sibthorp, J., Paisley, K., Furman, N., & Gookin, J. (2008a). Long-term impacts attributed to participation in wilderness education: Preliminary findings from NOLS. Paper presented at the Ninth Biennial Coalition for the Education in the Outdoors Research Symposium, Bradford Woods, Indiana.
Sibthorp, J., Paisley, K., Gookin, J., & Furman, N. (2008b). The pedagogic value of student autonomy in adventure education. The Journal of Experiential Education, 31 (2), 136–151.
Stewart, A. (2004). Decolonising encounters with the Murray River: Building place responsive outdoor education. Australian Journal of Outdoor Education, 8 (2), 46–55.
Thomas, G., Potter, T, & Allison, P. (2009). A tale of three journals: A study of papers published in AJOE, JAEOL and JEE between 1998 and 2007. Australian Journal of Outdoor Education, 13 (1), 16–29.
Wattchow, B. (2004). Lived-experience in outdoor education: Explorations for the educational practitioner/ researcher. Paper presented at the International Outdoor Education Research Conference: Connections and disconnections: Examining the reality and rhetoric, Bendigo, Victoria, Australia.
Wattchow, B., & Brown, M. (2011). A pedagogy of place: Outdoor education for a changing world: Melbourne, Australia: Monash University Publishing.
Woodhouse, J. L., & Knapp, C. E. (2000). Place-based curriculum and instruction: Outdoor and environmental education approaches. ERIC Digest. Charleston, WV: ERIC Clearinghouse for Rural Education and Small Schools.(ERIC Document Reproduction Services No. ED 448 012).
ZinK., R. (2003). Abseiling at 5, rafting at 10, what do we do with them when they are 15? Why pursuits might seem like an obvious choice for outdoor education. New Zealand Journal of Outdoor Education, 1 (2), 56–62.
ZinK., R., & Boyes, M. (2006). The nature and scope of outdoor education in New Zealand schools. Australian Journal of Outdoor Education, 10 (1), 11–21.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Dr. Andrew Brookes was Associate Professor, Outdoor Education, at La Trobe University until 2014. He teaches casually at La Trobe University, consults as an expert witness, and is in the process of completing a monograph for Springer (“Preventing Fatal Incidents in School and Youth Group Camps and Excursions -3 Understanding the Unthinkable”) in the series: International Explorations in Outdoor and Environmental Education. His most recent publications are Foundation Myths and the Roots of Adventure Education in the Anglosphere and Outdoor Education, Safety and Risk in the Light of Serious Accidents, in the International Handbook of Outdoor Studies, edited by Barbara Humberstone, Heather Prince, and Karla Henderson: Routledge, 2015.
Dr. Alistair Stewart is a Senior Lecturer and current program head of the Department of Outdoor and Environmental Education, La Trobe University, Bendigo. His teaching and research interests include poststructuralist curriculum inquiry and place-responsive pedagogy, with particular reference to natural and cultural history.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Brookes, A., Stewart, A. What do citation patterns reveal about the outdoor education field? A snapshot 2000–2013. Journal of Outdoor and Environmental Education 19, 12–24 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03400991
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03400991