Abstract
In Skinner’s (1957) conceptual analysis, the process of self-editing is integral to the dynamic complexities of multiply determined verbal behavior, but the analysis has generated little in the way of an experimental analysis. The majority of scientific work on self-editing has taken place within linguistics and cognitive psycholinguistics. Here we compare and contrast behavioral and cognitive psycholinguistic approaches to self-editing, highlighting points of contact that can be identified despite fundamental differences in theoretical styles. We conclude that the two approaches are not mutually exclusive on all dimensions, and suggest that a consideration of cognitive psycholinguistic research may help to spur an experimental analysis of self-editing from a behavioral perspective.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Anderson, J. R. (1995). Cognitive psychology and its implications. (4th ed.). New York: Freeman.
Andresen, J. T. (1992). The behaviorist turn in recent theories of language. Behavior and Philosophy, 20, 1–19.
Baars, B. J. (1992a). A dozen competing-plans techniques for inducing predictable slips in speech and action. In B. J. Baars (Ed.), Experimental slips and human error: Exploring the architecture of volition (pp. 129–150). New York: Plenum.
Baars, B. J. (1992b). Preface. In B. J. Baars (Ed.), Experimental slips and human error: Exploring the architecture of volition (pp. vii–xii). New York: Plenum.
Barker, L. (2002). Psychology. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.
Biassou, N., Obler, L. K., Nespoulous, J. L., Dordain, M., & Harris, K. S. (1997). Dual processing of open- and closed-class words. Brain and Language, 57, 360–373.
Bierwisch, M. (1981). Linguistics and language error. Linguistics, 19, 583–626.
Bloomfield, L. (1933). Language. New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston.
Bloomfield, L. (1939). Linguistic aspects of science. In O. Neurath, R. Carnap, & C. W. Morris (Eds.), International encyclopedia of unified science: Vol. 1, Number 4. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Browman, C. P. (1980). Perceptual processing: Evidence from slips of the ear. In V. A. Fromkin (Ed.), Errors in linguistic performance: Slips of the tongue, ear, pen, and hand (pp. 213–230). New York: Academic Press.
Butterworth, B. (1981). Speech errors: Old data in search of new theories. Linguistics, 19, 627–662.
Carroll, D. W. (2004). Psychology of language (4th ed.). Belmont, CA: Wadsworth/Thomson Learning.
Catania, A. C. (1980). Autoclitic processes and the structure of behavior. Behaviorism, 8, 175–186.
Chaika, E. (1982). Language: The social mirror. Rowley, MA: Newbury House.
Chomsky, N. (1959). Review of Verbal Behavior by B. F. Skinner. Language, 35, 26–58.
Chomsky, N. (1965). Aspects of the theory of syntax. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Cohen, B. D. (1978). Self-editing deficits in schizophrenia. Journal of Psychiatric Research, 14(1-sup-4), 267–273.
Critchfield, T. S. (2000). Staffing the empirical analysis of verbal behavior. The Analysis of Verbal Behavior, 17, 175–177.
Cutler, A. (1981). The reliability of speech error data. Linguistics, 19, 561–582.
Cutting, J. C., & Bock, K. (1997). That’s the way the cookie bounces: Syntactic and semantic components of experimentally elicited idiom blends. Memory and Cognition, 25, 57–71.
Davis, K. M., & Blaney, P. H. (1976). Overinclusion and self-editing in schizophrenia. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 85, 51–60.
De Laguna, G. A. (1973). Speech: Its functions and development. Bloomington: Indiana University Press. (original work published 1927)
de Villiers, P. A., & de Villiers, J. G. (1992). Language development. In M. H. Bornstein & M. E. Lamb (Eds.), Developmental psychology: An advanced textbook (3rd ed., pp. 337–418. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
Deacon, T. W. (1997). The symbolic species: The coevolution of language and the brain. New York: W. W. Norton.
Dell, G. S. (1985). Positive feedback in hierarchical connectionist models: Applications to language production. Cognitive Science, 9, 3–23.
Dell, G. S. (1986). A spreading-activation theory of retrieval in sentence production. Psychological Review, 93, 283–321.
Dell, G. S., & Reich, P. A. (1980). Toward a unified theory of slips of the tongue. In V. A. Fromkin (Ed.), Errors in linguistic performance: Slips of the tongue, ear, pen, and hand (pp. 273–286). New York: Academic Press.
Dell, G. S., & Reich, P. A. (1981). Stages in sentence production: An analysis of speech error data. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 20, 611–629.
Dell, G. S., & Repka, R. J. (1992). Errors in inner speech. In B. J. Baars (Ed.), Experimental slips and human error: Exploring the architecture of volition (pp. 237–262). New York: Plenum.
DiCamilla, F. J., & Anton, M. (2004). Private speech: A study of language for thought in the collaborative interaction of language learners. International Journal of Applied Linguistics, 14, 36–69.
Donahoe, J. W. (1998). Interpreting verbal behavior. The Analysis of Verbal Behavior, 15, 107–112.
Dulany, D. E. (1968). Awareness, rules, and propositional control: A confrontation with S-R behavior theory. In T. R. Dixon & D. L. Horton (Eds.), Verbal behavior and general behavior theory (pp. 340–387). Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
Eshleman, J. W. (1991). Quantified trends in the history of verbal behavior research. The Analysis of Verbal Behavior, 9, 61–80.
Fay, D. (1980). Transformational errors. In V. A. Fromkin (Ed.), Errors in linguistic performance: Slips of the tongue, ear, pen, and hand (pp. 111–122). New York: Academic Press.
Fay, D. (1981). Substitutions and splices: A study of sentence blends. Linguistics, 19, 717–749.
Finnegan, E. (1999). Language: Its use and structure (3rd ed.). Fort Worth, TX: Harcourt Brace.
Fowler, C. A. (1981). Review article: V. Fromkin’s Errors in Linguistic Performance: Slips of the Tongue, Ear, Pen, and Hand. Linguistics, 19, 819–840.
Fromkin, V. A. (1980). Introduction. In V. A. Fromkin (Ed.), Errors in linguistic performance: Slips of the tongue, ear, pen, and hand (pp. 1–12). New York: Academic Press.
Garrett, M. (1982). Production of speech: Observations from normal and pathological language use. In A. W. Ellis (Ed.), Normality and pathology in cognitive functions (pp. 19–76). London: Academic Press.
Garrett, M., & Fodor, J. A. (1968). Psychological theories and linguistic constructs. In T. R. Dixon & D. L. Horton (Eds.), Verbal behavior and general behavior theory (pp. 451–477). Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
Goldstein, L. (1980). Bias and asymmetry in speech perception. In V. A. Fromkin (Ed.), Errors in linguistic performance: Slips of the tongue, ear, pen, and hand (pp. 241–262). New York: Academic Press.
Graber, D. A. (1976). Verbal behavior and politics. Chicago: University of Illinois Press.
Greer, R. D., & Ross, D. E. (2004). Verbal behavior analysis: A program of research in the induction and expansion of complex verbal behavior. Journal of Early Intensive Behavioral Intervention, 1, 141–165.
Harley, T. A. (2001). The psychology of language: From data to theory. (2nd ed.). New York: Psychology Press.
Harley, T. A., & MacAndrew, S. B. G. (2001). Constraints upon word substitution speech errors. Journal of Psycholinguistic Research, 30, 395–418.
Harzem, P. (1986). The language trap and the study of pattern in human action. In T. Thompson & M. D. Zeiler (Eds.), Analysis and integration of behavioral units (pp. 45–53). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
Harzem, & P, (Miles). T. R. Conceptual issues in operant psychology: 1978.
Hayes, S. C., & Brownstein, A. J. (1986). Mentalism, behavior-behavior relations, and a behavior-analytic view of the purposes of science. The Behavior Analyst, 9, 175–190.
Herrnstein, R. J. (1970). On the law of effect. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 13, 243–266.
Hineline, P. N. (1980). The language of behavior analysis: Its community, its functions, and its limitations. Behaviorism, 8, 67–86.
Hinson, J. M., & Staddon, J. E. R. (1983). Hill-climbing by pigeons. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 39, 25–48.
Holz, W. C., & Azrin, N. H. (1966). Conditioning human verbal behavior. In W. K. Honig (Ed.), Operant behavior (pp. 790–826). New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts.
Horne, P. J., & Lowe, C. F. (1996). On the origins of naming and other symbolic behavior. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 65, 185–241.
Horne, P. J., & Lowe, C. F. (2000). Putting the naming account to the test. In J. C. Leslie & D. Blackman (Eds.), Experimental and applied analysis of human behavior (pp. 127–148). Reno, NV: Context Press.
Horne, P. J., Lowe, C. F., & Randle, V. R. L. (2004). Naming and categorization in young children: II. Listener behavior training. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 81, 267–288.
Horton, D. L., & Dixon, T. R. (1968). Traditions, trends, and innovations. In T. R. Dixon & D. L. Horton (Eds.), Verbal behavior and general behavior theory (pp. 572–581). Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
Hutchinson, W. R. (1998). Computer simulations of verbal behavior for research and persuasion. The Analysis of Verbal Behavior, 15, 117–120.
Huxley, A. (1940). Words and their meanings. Los Angeles: Ward Ritchie Press.
Hyten, C., & Chase, P. N. (1991). An analysis of self-editing: Method and preliminary findings. In L. J. Hayes & P. N. Chase (Eds.), Dialogues on verbal behavior (pp. 67–81). Reno, NV: Context Press.
Julià, P. (1983). Explanatory models in linguistics: A behavioral perspective. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Kanfer, F. H. (1968). Verbal conditioning: A review of its current status. In T. R. Dixon & D. L. Horton (Eds.), Verbal behavior and general behavior theory (pp. 254–290). Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
Kollins, S. H., Newland, M. C., & Critchfield, T. S. (1997). Human sensitivity to reinforcement in operant choice: How much do consequences matter? Psychonomic Bulletin and Review, 4, 208–220. (Erratum: Psychonomic Bulletin and Review, 4, 431)
Lamarre, J., & Holland, J. G. (1985). The functional independence of mands and tacts. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 43, 5–19.
Laver, J. (1973). The detection and correction of slips of the tongue. In V. A. Fromkin (Ed.), Speech errors as linguistic evidence(pp. 132–143). The Hague: Mouton.
Laver, J. (1980). Monitoring systems in the neurolinguistic control of speech production. In V. A. Fromkin (Ed.), Errors in linguistic performance: Slips of the tongue, ear, pen, and hand (pp. 287–306). New York: Academic Press.
Leigland, S. (1989). On the relation between radical behaviorism and the science of verbal behavior. The Analysis of Verbal Behavior, 7, 25–42.
Levelt, W. J. M. (1983). Monitoring and self-repair in speech. Cognition, 14, 41–104.
Levelt, W. J. M. (1989). Speaking: From intention to articulation. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Lodhi, S., & Greer, R. D. (1989). The speaker as listener. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 51, 353–359.
Lowe, C. F., Horne, P. J., Harris, F. D., & Randle, V. R. L. (2002). Naming and categorization in young children: Vocal tact training. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 78, 527–549.
Lowe, C. F., Horne, P. J., & Hughes, J. C. (2005). Naming and categorization in young children: III. Vocal tact training and transfer of function. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 83, 47–65.
Mabry, J. H. (1993). Comments on Skinner’s grammar. The Analysis of Verbal Behavior, 11, 77–88.
MacCorquodale, K. (1970). On Chomsky’s review of Skinner’s Verbal Behavior. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 13, 83–99.
MacKay, D. G. (1980). Speech errors: Retrospect and prospect. In V. A. Fromkin (Ed.), Errors in linguistic performance: Slips of the tongue, ear, pen, and hand (pp. 319–332). New York: Academic Press.
Maltzman, I. (1968). Theoretical conceptions of semantic conditioning and generalization. In T. R. Dixon & D. L. Horton (Eds.), Verbal behavior and general behavior theory(pp. 291–339). Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
Marr, M. J. (1984). Conceptual approaches and issues. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 42, 353–362.
Marx, M. H. (Ed.). (1963). Theories in contemporary psychology. New York: Macmillan.
Mattson, M. E., & Baars, B. J. (1992). Error-minimizing mechanisms: Boosting or editing? In B. J. Baars (Ed.), Experimental slips and human error: Exploring the architecture of volition (pp. 263–287). New York: Plenum.
McLeish, J., & Martin, J. (1975). Verbal behavior: A review and experimental analysis. The Journal of General Psychology, 93, 3–66.
McNamara, P., Obler, L. K., Au, R., Durso, R., & Albert, M. L. (1992). Speech monitoring skills in Alzheimer’s disease, Parkinson’s disease, and normal aging. Brain and Language, 42, 38–51.
Meara, P., & Ellis, A. W. (1981). The psychological reality of deep and surface phonological representations: Evidence from speech errors in Welsh. Linguistics, 19, 797–804.
Morgan, D. L., & Buskist, W. (1990). Conversations with the keepers of the internal order: A review of B. J. Baars’ The Cognitive Revolution in Psychology. The Behavior Analyst, 13, 199–200.
Motley, M. T. (1980). Verification of “Freudian slips” and semantic prearticulatory editing via laboratory-induced spoonerisms. In V. A. Fromkin (Ed.), Errors in linguistic performance: Slips of the tongue, ear, pen, and hand (pp. 133–148). New York: Academic Press.
Navon, D., & Gopher, D. (1979). On the economy of the human information processing system. Psychological Review, 86, 214–255.
Newkirk, D., Klima, E. S., Pedersen, C. C., & Bellugi, U. (1980). Linguistic evidence from slips of the hand. In V. A. Fromkin (Ed.), Errors in linguistic performance: Slips of the tongue, ear, pen, and hand (pp. 165–198). New York: Academic Press.
Newland, M. C. (1992). Goal-directed behaviorism? A review of The Goal of B. F. Skinner and Behavior Analysis by R. W. Proctor and D. J. Weeks. The Behavior Analyst, 15, 165–169.
Nooteboom, S. G. (1969). The tongue slips into patterns. In A. G. Sciarone, A. J. van Essen, & A. A. Van Raad (Eds.), Leyden studies in linguistics and phonetics (pp. 114–132). The Hague: Mouton.
Nooteboom, S. G. (1980). Speaking and unspeaking: Detection and correction of phonological and lexical errors in spontaneous speech. In V. A. Fromkin (Ed.), Errors in linguistic performance: Slips of the tongue, ear, pen, and hand (pp. 87–96). New York: Academic Press.
Norman, D. A. (1981). Categorization of action slips. Psychological Review, 88, 1–15.
Normand, M. P., Fossa, J. F., & Poling, A. (2000). Publication trends in The Analysis of Verbal Behavior: 1982–1998. The Analysis of Verbal Behavior, 17, 167–173.
Olynyk, M., D’Anglejan, A., & Sankoff, D. (1987). A quantitative and qualitative analysis of speech markers in the native and second language speech of bilinguals. Applied Psycholinguistics, 8, 121–135.
Palmer, D. C. (1996). Achieving parity: The role of automatic reinforcement. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 65, 289–290.
Palmer, D. C. (1998). The speaker as listener: The interpretation of structural regularities in verbal behavior. The Analysis of Verbal Behavior, 15, 3–16.
Palmer, D. C. (1999). A call for tutorials on alternative approaches to the study of verbal behavior. The Analysis of Verbal Behavior, 16, 49–55.
Payne, & D. G, (Wenger). M. J. Cognitive psychology: 1998.
Pepper, S. C. (1942). World hypotheses: A study in evidence. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Pinker, S. (1999). Words and rules: The ingredients of language. New York: Basic Books.
Place, U. T. (1983). Skinner’s Verbal Behavior IV—How to improve Part IV, Skinner’s account of syntax. Behaviorism, 11, 163–186.
Place, U. T. (1991). Conversation analysis and the analysis of verbal behavior. In L. J. Hayes & P. N. Chase (Eds.), Dialogues on verbal behavior (pp. 85–109). Reno, NV: Context Press.
Postma, A. (2000). Detection of errors during speech production: A review of speech monitoring models. Cognition, 77, 97–131.
Postma, A., & Kolk, H. (1990). Speech errors, disfluencies, and self-repairs of stutterers in two accuracy conditions. Journal of Fluency Disorders, 15, 291–303.
Postma, A., & Kolk, H. (1992). The effects of noise masking and required accuracy on speech errors, disfluencies, and self-repairs. Journal of Speech and Hearing Research, 35, 537–544.
Postma, A., & Kolk, H. (1993). The covert repair hypothesis: Prearticulatory repair processes in normal and stuttered disfluencies. Journal of Speech and Hearing Research, 36, 472–487.
Postma, A., Kolk, H., & Povel, D. (1990). On the relation among speech errors, disfluencies, and self-repairs. Language and Speech, 33, 19–29.
Reese, H. W. (1991). Mentalistic approaches to verbal behavior. In L. J. Hayes & P. N. Chase (Eds.), Dialogues on verbal behavior (pp. 151–177). Reno, NV: Context Press.
Richelle, M. (1976). Formal analysis and functional analysis of verbal behavior: Notes on the debate between Chomsky and Skinner. Behaviorism, 4, 209–221.
Salzinger, K. (1991). Cognitive problems, behavioral solutions. In L. J. Hayes & P. N. Chase (Eds.), Dialogues on verbal behavior (pp. 183–196). Reno, NV: Context Press.
Schnaitter, R. (1986). Behavior as a function of inner states and outer circumstances. In T. Thompson & M. D. Zeiler (Eds.), Analysis and integration of behavioral units(pp. 247–274). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
Sellen, A. J., & Norman, D. A. (1992). The psychology of slips. In B. J. Baars (Ed.), Experimental slips and human error: Exploring the architecture of volition (pp. 317–339). New York: Plenum.
Shattuck-Hufnagel, S., & Klatt, D. H. (1980). How single phoneme error data rule out two models of error generation. In V. A. Fromkin (Ed.), Errors in linguistic performance: Slips of the tongue, ear, pen, and hand (pp. 35–46). New York: Academic Press.
Shimp, C. P. (1969). Optimal behavior in free-operant experiments. Psychological Review, 76, 97–112.
Skinner, B. F. (1957). Verbal behavior. New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts.
Skinner, B. F. (1966). What is the experimental analysis of behavior? Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 9, 213–218.
Skinner, B. F. (1977). Why I am not a cognitive psychologist. Behaviorism, 5, 1–10.
Skinner, B. F. (1986). The evolution of verbal behavior. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 45, 115–122.
Smith, R., Michael, J., & Sundberg, M. L. (1996). Automatic reinforcement and automatic punishment in infant vocal behavior. The Analysis of Verbal Behavior, 13, 39–48.
Steinberg, D. D. (1993). An introduction to psycholinguistics. London: Longman Group.
Stemberger, J. P. (1982). Syntactic errors in speech. Journal of Psycholinguistic Research, 11, 313–345.
Stemberger, J. P. (1984). Structural errors in normal and agrammatic speech. Cognitive Neuropsychology, 1, 281–313.
Stemberger, J. P. (1989). Speech errors in early child language production. Journal of Memory and Language, 28, 164–188.
Stemberger, J. P. (1992). The reliability and replicability of naturalistic speech error data: A comparison with experimentally induced errors. In B. J. Baars (Ed.), Experimental slips and human error: Exploring the architecture of volition (pp. 195–215). New York: Plenum.
Stemmer, N. (1992). Skinner and a solution to the problem of inner events. The Behavior Analyst, 15, 115–128.
Sundberg, M. L. (1991). 301 research topics from Skinner’s book Verbal Behavior. The Analysis of Verbal Behavior, 9, 81–96.
Sundberg, M. L., Michael, J., Partington, J. W., & Sundberg, C. A. (1996). The role of automatic reinforcement in early language acquisition. The Analysis of Verbal Behavior, 13, 21–37.
Tincoff, R., & Jusczyk, P. W. (1999). Some beginnings of word comprehension in 6-month-olds. Psychological Science, 10, 172–175.
van Borsel, J. (1988). An analysis of the speech of five Down’s syndrome adolescents. Journal of Communication Disorders, 21, 409–421.
van Wijk, C., & Kempen, G. (1987). A dual system for producing self-repairs in spontaneous speech: Evidence from experimentally elicited corrections. Cognitive Psychology, 19, 403–440.
Vargas, J. S. (1991). Cognitive analysis of language and verbal behavior: Two separate fields. In L. J. Hayes & P. N. Chase (Eds.), Dialogues on verbal behavior (pp. 197–201). Reno, NV: Context Press.
Vaughn, M. E., & Michael, J. (1982). Automatic reinforcement: An important but ignored concept. Behaviorism, 10, 217–227.
Whitney, W. D. (1971). Whitney on language: Selected writings of William Dwight Whitney(M. Silverstein, Ed.). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Whorf, B. L. (1956). Language, thought, and reality: Selected writings of Benjamin Lee Whorf (J. B. Carroll, Ed.). New York: Technology Press of MIT and Wiley.
Wijnen, F. (1992). Incidental word and sound errors in young speakers. Journal of Memory and Language, 31, 734–755.
Winokur, S. (1976). A primer of verbal behavior: An operant view. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
Yaruss, J. S., & Conture, E. G. (1996). Stuttering and phonological disorders in children: Examination of the covert repair hypothesis. Journal of Speech & Hearing Research, 39, 349–364.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
We thank Michael Dougher, Per Holth, Pauline Horne, and David Palmer for helpful comments on an earlier draft of this manuscript.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Epting, L.K., Critchfield, T.S. Self-editing: On the relation between behavioral and psycholinguistic approaches. BEHAV ANALYST 29, 211–234 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03392131
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03392131