Abstract
The ability of Section 404 of the Clean Water Act to act as an effective, efficient, and equitable land-use planning tool was assessed through a survey of Section 404 permits in Wisconsin. In a six-month period of permitting, the 404 program reduced wetland losses in the state by 15%. Several factors were examined that may affect permit decisions; these factors are water dependency, alternatives, project type, wetland type, and public or agency comments. Only the water dependency of the project had a statistically significant effect on permit decisions, although development projects that were perceived to provide public good were more likely to be permitted. Environmental impacts of a proposed fill project were not adequately assessed in any of the permit decisions. Because of the way Section 404 is interpreted and administered by the US Army Corps of Engineers, increasing net benefits and achieving an equitable distribution of those benefits is difficult. The corps does not perform any functional evaluations of wetlands nor do they attempt to measure economic value and environmental impacts. In addition, the 404 review process is, in effect, inaccessible to the public. The de facto interpretations of the Section 404 regulations and a lack of program funding and trained personnel all contribute to the program's ineffectiveness.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
Literature Cited
Adamus P. R., ARA Inc., E. J. Clairain, Jr., R. D. Smith, and R. E. Young. 1987. Wetland evaluation technique. Department of the Army, Waterways Experiment Station, Corps of Engineers, Vicksburg, Mississippi.
Barnard, W. 1984. GAO publishes study on use and regulation of wetlands.National Wetlands Newsletter 6(2):6–7.
Burke D. G., E. J. Meyers, R. W. Tiner, Jr., and H. Groman. 1988. Protecting nontidal wetlands. Planning Advisory Service Report No. 412/413. American Planning Association, Chicago, Illinois.
Carter, V. 1986. An overview of the hydrologic concerns relating to wetlands in the U.S.Canadian Journal of Botany 64:364–374.
Ervin, D. E., J. B. Fitch, R. K. Godwin, W. B. Shepard, and H. H. Stoevener. 1977. Land use control: Evaluating economic and political effects. Ballinger, Cambridge, Massachusetts.
Farber, S., and R. Costanza. 1987. The economic value of wetlands systems.Journal of Environmental Management 24:41–47.
Florida Department of Environmental Regulation. 1991. Report on the effectiveness of environmental regulation. Tallahassee, Florida.
GAO (General Accounting Office). 1988. Wetlands: The Corps of Engineers' administration of the Section 404 program. GAO/RCED-88-110. Washington, DC.
Hunter, D. B. 1988. An ecological perspective on property: A call for judicial protection of the public's interest in environmentally critical resources.Harvard Environmental Law Review 12:311–383.
Jacobs, H. M. 1989. Social equity in agricultural land protection. Landscape and Urban Planning 17:21–33.
Kunz, K., M. Rylko, and E. Somers. 1988. An assessment of wetland mitigation practices in Washington state.National Wetlands Newsletter 10(3):2–4.
Kusler, J., and M. Kentula (eds.). 1990. Wetland creation and restoration: The status of the science. US Environmental Protection Agency 600/3-89/038. Corvallis, Oregon.
McChesney, F. L. 1983. Corps recasts 404 permit program, braces for political, legal skirmishes.Environmental Law Reporter 13:10128–10134.
O'Brien, A. L. 1988. Evaluating the cumulative effects of alteration on New England wetlands.Environmental Management 12:627–636.
Ogawa, H., and J. W. Male. 1990. Evaluation framework for wetland regulation.Journal of Environmental Management 30:95–109.
OTA (Office of Technology Assessment). 1984. Wetlands: Their use and regulation. OTA-0-206, Washington, DC.
Owen, C. R. 1990. Effectiveness of compensatory wetland mitigation in Wisconsin. Report to the Lake Michigan Federation, Chicago, Illinois.
Race, M. S., and D. R. Christie. 1982. Coastal zone development: Mitigation, marsh creation and decision-making.Environmental Management 6:317–328.
Roherty, M. 1988. Personal communication between M. Roherty, USACE permit review staff, and Catherine Owen on 18 November 1988. St. Paul, Minnesota.
USACE (US Army Corps of Engineers, St. Paul District). 1988. Department of the Army permit evaluation and decision document. Army Corps of Engineers Regulatory Division, St. Paul, Minnesota.
USACE (US Army Corps of Engineers, St. Paul District). 1991. St. Paul District analysis regarding Section 404 review of commercial cranberry operations. Draft Report. St. Paul, Minnesota.
US Soil Conservation Service. 1990. Memo to William Ford, Senior Staff Attorney for Wisconsin Legislative Council, from Thomas P. Thrall, State Biologist, US Department of Agriculture, Soil Conservation Service.
Wakefield, P. 1982. Reducing the federal role in wetlands protection.Environment 24(10):3–33.
WDNR (Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources). 1989. Section 404 tracking for corps individual permit decisions in Wisconsin, 1982–1989. B. Simon and L. Stoerzer, Bureau of Water Regulation and Zoning, Madison, Wisconsin.
WDNR (Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources). 1990a. Can the state assume 404 responsibilities? Study in progress, Madison, Wisconsin.
WDNR (Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources). 1990b. Wetland losses in Wisconsin. Memo to the Wisconsin State Legislative Council Subcommittee on Wetlands, Madison, Wisconsin.
Yocom, T. G., R. A. Leidy, and C. A. Morris. 1989. Wetlands protection through impact avoidance: A discussion of the 404(b)(1) alternatives analysis.Wetlands 9:283–297.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Owen, C.R., Jacobs, H.M. Wetland protection as land-use planning: The impact of section 404 in Wisconsin, USA. Environmental Management 16, 345–353 (1992). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02400073
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02400073