Abstract
In this paper, we analysed six indicators of the SCI Journal Citation Reports (JCR) over a 19-year period: number of total citations, number of citations to the two previous years, number of source items, impact factor, immediacy index and cited half-life. The JCR seems to have become more or less an authority for evaluating scientific and technical journals, essentially through its impact factor. However it is difficult to find one's way about in the impressive mass of quantitative data that JCR provides each year. We proposed the box plot method to aggregate the values of each indicator so as to obtain, at a glance, portrayals of the JCR population from 1974 to 1993. These images reflected the distribution of the journals into 4 groups designated low, central, high and extreme. The limits of the groups became a reference system with which, for example, it was rapidly possible to situate visually a given journal within the overall JCR population. Moreover, the box plot method, which gives a zoom effect, made it possible to visualize a large sub-population of the JCR usually overshadowed by the journals at the top of the rankings. These top level journals implicitly play the role of reference in evaluation processes. This often incites categorical judgements when the journals to be evaluated are not part of the top level. Our «rereading» of the JCR, which presented the JCR product differently, made it possible to qualify these judgements and bring a new light on journals.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
J. Reed-Scott,Guide de l'inventaire des collections des bibliothèques de recherches en Amérique du Nord, Association of research libraries, office of management services, 1988, p. 68.
E. Garfield, Citation analysis as a tool in journal evaluation,Science (Washington, D.C.) 178, No. 4060 (1972) 471–479.
E. Garfield,Citation Indexing — Its Theory and Application in Science, Technology, and Humanities, John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1979, p. 274.
R. Todorov, W. Glänzel, Journal citation measures: a concise review,Journal of Information Science, 14 (1988) 47–56.
E. Garfield, The impact factor,Current Contents. Life Sciences, 37, No. 25 (1994) 3–7.
E. Garfield, Using the impact factor,Current Contents. Life Sciences, 37, No. 29 (1994) 3–5.
E. Garfield, The application of citation indexing to journals management,Current Contents. Life Sciences, 37, No. 33 (1994) 3–5.
E. Garfield, 1993 SCI Journal Citation Reports; a bibliometric analysis of science journals in the ISI database, Institute for Scientific Information, Philadelphia, 1994.
T.E. Smith, The Journal Citation Reports as a deselection tool,Bulletin of the Medical Library Association, 73, No. 4 (1985) 387–389.
R.N. Broadus, A proposed method for eliminating titles from periodical subscription lists,College & Research Libraries, (January, 1985) 30–35.
A.E. Cawkell, Evaluating scientific journals with Journal Citation Reports — A case study in acoustics,Journal of the American Society for Information Science, 29, No. 1, (1978) 41–46.
B.A. Rice, Selection and evaluation of chemistry periodicals,Science and Technology Libraries (New York, N.Y.), 4, No. 1 (1983) 43–59.
J.M. Chambers, W.S. Cleveland, B. Kleiner, P.A. Tukey,Graphical Methods for Data Analysis, Wadsworth & Brooks, California, 1983, p. 386.
P. Sprent,Applied Nonparametric Statistical Methods, Chapman and Hall, London, 1989, p. 255.
E. Garfield, SCI Journal Citation Reports; a bibliometric analysis of science journals in the ISI database.Science Citation Index 1977 annual, Vol. 13, Institute for Scientific Information, Philadelphia, 1978, p.8.
E. Garfield, 1989 SCI Journal Citation Reports; a bibliometric analysis of science journals in the ISI database, Institute for Scientific Information, Philadelphia, 1991.
M.H. Magri, A. Solari, K. Rerat, Le SCI Journal Citation Reports ou comment positionner une revue dans l'environnement ISI. Journées d'étude sur les systèmes d'information élaborée, 30 Mai–2 Juin, Ile Rousse, 1995, session poster.
A. Solari, M.H. Magri, The SCI Journal Citation Reports as a potential tool for studying journals? II Description by subject category of the JCR journal population based on the impact factor. (In preparation, 1995).
E. Garfield, SCI Journal Citation Reports; a bibliometric analysis of science journals in the ISI database,Science Citation Index 1987 annual, vol. 19, Institute for Scientific Information, Philadelphia, 1987.
R.W. Allee, The relationship between primary and secondary publishers: ISI's journal selection guidelines and use of the Journal Citation Reports (JCR),Serials Librarian, 13, No. 2/3 (1987) 47–55.
E. Garfield, How ISI selects journals for coverage: quantitative and qualitative considerations,Current Contents. Life Sciences, 33, No. 22 (1990) 5–13.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Magri, MH., Solari, A. The SCI Journal Citation Reports: A potential tool for studying journals?. Scientometrics 35, 93–117 (1996). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02018235
Received:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02018235