Abstract
N-response curves of numerous N-fertilizer trials with sugar beet and potato are described by a quadratic and a modified exponential equation. For both sugar beet and potato the modified exponential equation was much better than the quadratic equation when the residual sum of squares (RSS) was taken as a measure of the degree of fit. In order to take into account the few occasions when the quadratic model was superior, it is suggested that both models should be used for the data of each individual trial. The economically optimum application rate of fertilizer N is calculated on the basis of the best-fitting model. This procedure yielded optima which covered entire ranges of fertilizer-N levels tested: 0–250 kg ha−1 for sugar beet and 0–400 kg ha−1 for potato. The magnitude of the confidence intervals (p > 95%) of the optimum N-fertilizer application rate frequently was very high. In 46% of the sugar beet trials and even in 60% of the potato trials it was higher than 300 kg ha−1 N. It is suggested that N-fertilizer recommendations be drawn up only with reliable optima.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Abshahi A, Hills FJ and Broadbent FE (1984) Nitrogen utilization by wheat from residual sugarbeet fertilizer and soil incorporated sugarbeet tops. Agron J 76:954–958
Adams RM, Farris PJ and Halvorson AD (1983) Sugar beet N fertilization and economic optima: Recoverable sucrose vs. root yield. Agron J 75:173–176
Armstrong MJ, Milford GFJ, Pocock TO, Last PJ and Day W (1986) The dynamics of nitrogen uptake and its remobilization during the growth of sugar beet. J Agric Sci Cambridge 107:145–154
Bakker Y, Withagen L and Wijnen G (1981) De nieuwe richtlijn voor de stikstofbemesting van suikerbieten. Bedrijfsontwikkeling 12:383–385
Barber SA (1973) The changing philosophy of soil test interpretations. In: Soil testing and plant analysis. Rev. edn., pp 201–211. Madison, Wisc: Soil Science Society of America
Boon R (1981) Stikstofadvies op basis van profielanalyse voor wintergraan en suikerbieten op diepe leem- en zandleemgronden. Pedologie 21: 347–363
Boyd DA, Yuen LTK and Needham P (1976) Nitrogen requirement of cereals. 1. Response curves. J Agric Sci Cambridge 87:149–162.
Dilz K, Darwinkel A, Boon R and Verstraeten LMJ (1982) Intensive wheat production as related to nitrogen fertilisation, crop protection and soil nitrogen: Experience in the Benelux. Proc Fertiliser Society London, No. 211:93–124
Draycott AP (1972) Sugar-Beet Nutrition. London: Applied Science Publishers LTD
George BJ (1983) Design and interpretation of nitrogen response experiments. In: The nitrogen requirement of cereals. RB 385, pp 133–149. London: Min Agric Food Fish
Greenwood DJ, Draycott A, Last PJ and Draycott AP (1984) A concise simulation model for interpreting N-fertilizer trials. Fert Res 5:355–369
Greenwood DJ, Neeteson JJ and Draycott A (1985) Response of potatotes to N fertilizer: Quantitative relations for components of growth. Plant Soil 85:163–183
Haby VA, Simons C, Stauber MS, Lund R and Kresge PO (1983) Relative efficiency of applied N and soil nitrate for winter wheat production. Agron J 75:49–52
Hargrove WL, Touchton JT and Johnson JW (1983) Previous crop influence on fertilizer nitrogen requirements for double-cropped wheat. Agron J 75:855–859
Harris PM (1978) Mineral nutrition. In: Harris PM (ed.) The potato crop. The scientific basis for improvement, pp 195–243. London: Chapman and Hall
Hesterman OB, Shaeffer CC, Barnes DK, Lueschen WE and Ford JH (1986) Alfalfa dry matter and nitrogen production, and fertilizer nitrogen response in legume-corn rotations. Agron J 78:19–23
Hoffmann F and Ulbrich B (1986) Stickstoffaufnahme und -verwertung durch Zuckerrüben. Arch Acker-Pflanzenbau Bodenk 30:283–291
Holbrook JR, Osborne JD and Ridgman WJ (1982) An attempt to improve yield and quality of direct-drilled winter wheat grown continuously. J Agric Sci Cambridge 99:163–172
LEI (1985) Landbouwcijfers. 's Gravenhage: Landbouw-Economisch Instituut/Centraal Bureau voor de Statistiek
Neeteson JJ (1985) Effectiveness of the assessment of nitrogen fertilizer requirement for potatoes on the basis of soil mineral nitrogen. In: Neeteson JJ and Dilz K (eds) Assessment of nitrogen fertilizer requirement, pp 15–24. Haren (Gn): Inst Soil Fertility
Neeteson JJ and Smilde KW (1983) Correlative methods of estimating the optimum nitrogen fertilizer rate for sugar beet as based on soil mineral nitrogen at the end of the winter period. Proc symp ‘Nitrogen and Sugar Beet’, pp 409–421. Brussels: IIRB
Neeteson JJ, Wijnen G and Zandt PA (1984) Nieuwe stikstofbemestingsadviezen voor aardappelen. Bedrijfsontwikkeling 15:331–333
Ogunlela VB, Lombin GL and Abed SM (1982) Growth response, yield and yield components of upland cotton (Gossypium hirsutum L.) as affected by rates and time of nitrogen application in the Nigerian savannah. Fert Res 3:399–409
PAGV (1984) Kwantitatieve Informatie. Publ No 16. Lelystad: PAGV
Pal UR, Murari K and Malik HS (1984) Yield response of sorghum cultivars to inorganic nitrogen fertilizer. J Agric Sci Cambridge 102:7–10
Ris J, Smilde KW and Wijnen G (1981) Nitrogen fertilizer recommendations for arable crops as based on soil analysis. Fert Res 2:21–32
Sahota TS and Singh M (1984) Relative efficiency of N fertilizers as influenced by N-serve in the potato crop. Plant Soil 79:143–152
Sanford JO and Hairston JE (1984) Effects of N fertilization on yield, growth and extraction of water by wheat following soybeans and grain sorghum. Agron J 76:623–626
Sharma RC (1985) Nitrogen management of potatoes in the presence of farmyard manure and PK fertilizer on acid hill soil of Shimla. J Agric Sci Cambridge 107:15–19
Sparrow PE (1979) Nitrogen response curves of spring barley. J Agric Sci Cambridge 92:307–317
Sylvester-Bradley R, Dampney PMR and Murray AWA (1983) The response of wheat to nitrogen. In: The nitrogen requirement of cereals. RB 385, pp 151–174. London: Min Agric Food Fish
Van Noordwijk M, Floris J and De Jager A (1985) Sampling schemes for estimating root density distribution in cropped fields. Neth J Agric Sci 33:241–261
Van der Paauw F (1954) Evaluation of methods of soil testing by means of field experiments. Intern Soc Soil Sci. Joint Meeting, Dublin 1952. Transactions I. pp 207–221.
Visser WC (1942) Over de bruikbaarheid van de grafisch-statistische bewerkingstechniek. Landbkd Tijdschr 54:403–416
Visser WC (1943) Over eenige grondslagen van het grafisch-statistisch onderzoek. Landbkd Tijdschr 55:163–170
Wehrmann J and Scharpf HC (1979) Der Mineral-stickstoffgehalt des Bodens als Massstab für den Stickstoffdüngerbedarf (Nmin-Methode). Plant Soil 52:109–126
Wehrmann J and Scharpf HC (1980) Der Mineralstickstoffgehalt des Bodens als Grundlage der Stickstoffdüngung bei Zuckerrüben. Proc 43th Winter-congress, pp 327–341. Brussels: IIRB
Wood J (1980) The mathematical expression of crop response to inputs. In: Physiological aspects of crop productivity, pp 263–271. Berne: Int Potash Inst
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Neeteson, J.J., Wadman, W.P. Assessment of economically optimum application rates of fertilizer N on the basis of response curves. Fertilizer Research 12, 37–52 (1987). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01049419
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01049419