Abstract
In this work, the effectiveness of silicoorganic treatments for the consolidation, with or without waterproofing, of silicified stones (one conglomerate and four sandstones) from Zamora is analyzed, provided that these treatments are applied in the same way. Changes in the following properties have been monitored: total and free porosity, real and apparent density, absorption coefficient, imbibition coefficient, and capillary absorption coefficient. These intrinsic stone properties and the treatments employed have a significant effect on changes in these variables and lead to differences in the transport of fluid in the stone. This is the first time that the Canonical Biplot has been applied to this type of data to determine the control of the effectiveness of silicoorganic treatments applied to rocks. It was observed that the double action treatment RC80, which includes both waterproofing and consolidating, is more effective than the consolidating treatment RC70.
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
Introduction
The effectiveness of consolidation treatments with or without waterproofing can be measured by analyzing, prior to and after their application, different hydric properties of stone materials such as total and free porosity, real and apparent density, absorption coefficient, imbibition coefficient, and capillary absorption coefficient. These hydric properties indicate the extent to which fluids can circulate throughout the pore network and are intrinsic to each material. As a result, they influence the introduction of conservation products into stone.
The porosity of stone material, either macro or micro, determines which of the hydric properties are important. Previous studies regarding this (Iñigo et al. 2001), using ANOVA (Analysis of Variance, a classical statistical method for analyzing possible comparisons in one variable), show that free porosity and the capillary absorption coefficient are the properties that vary the most for silicified granites from Avila (granites that have undergone paleoalterations and which have given rise to silicified materials). Later on, Iñigo et al. (2006) show, using these silicified granites from Avila, that the imbibition coefficient could also be used for determining the effectiveness of conservation products. In order to evaluate the effectiveness of consolidation with or without waterproofing treatments, and to verify their suitability, the hydric properties and color changes on the surface of different types of materials (bricks, stone, etc.) before and after applying several treatments were analyzed. These types of analyses have also been carried out by several other authors (Hammecker et al. 1992; Valdeon et al. 1992; Vicente 1996; Villegas-Sánchez and Espinosa-Gaitán 2001; García-Garmilla et al. 2002; Berardi et al. 2002; Espinosa-Gaitan et al. 2002; Quaresima et al. 2002; Alcalde-Moreno et al. 2003; Buj and Gisbert 2006; Luque et al. 2008; Torrisi 2008; Alejandre and Villegas 2009; García et al. 2010; Ribas et al. 2011; Galvana et al. 2014; García-Talegón et al. 2015, 2016a; Arezki et al. 2016; Costa et al. 2017). In addition, Martín et al. (2002) designed an instrument that allows a wide range of temperatures to be maintained and controlled automatically using a computer. This instrument is used to automatically acquire data without interrupting the process (water absorption by capillarity and by total immersion, sorption, and desorption of water and water vapor permeability) and is essential because some of the previously mentioned properties are temperature dependent. This instrument allows these properties to be measured at actual temperatures, that is, temperatures to which the stones of monuments are exposed.
Porosity, besides being considered a hydric property, can be calculated using other methods such as the adsorption of nitrogen (it determines the microporosity of the material) and mercury intrusion. These methods can be used to determine the effectiveness of conservation treatments by calculating the porosity before and after their application. Our research group has carried out work in this field (Iñigo et al. 2007) and determined that RC70 was the most efficient product over RC80 for decreasing porosity. This is because the surface of the samples treated with RC80 does not allow real porosity to be determined. For this reason, it is necessary to determine values for more than one property using several techniques, allowing the most effective treatment to be identified.
Total porosity of a material is the sum of “trapped” porosity (pores that are not connected to the external surface and fluids are unable to circulate freely) and “free” porosity (pores are connected to the external surface and easily accessed by fluids). Total porosity thus controls fluid transport through the stone at ambient temperature and pressure (Meng 1992; Brandes and Stadlbauer 1992).
The penetration of liquids or other fluids inside the pore network of a solid material can be evaluated using the capillary absorption coefficient (CAC) (Meng 1992; Cordova and Gomez 1997).
In the present work, we report on the effect of consolidation treatments, with or without waterproofing, on hydric properties (total and free porosity, real and apparent density, absorption coefficient, imbibition coefficient, and capillary absorption coefficient) when non-weathered stones are submitted to different silicoorganic conservation treatments. The use of the Canonical Biplot allowed us to establish possible variations among different types of stone materials depending on the treatment applied.
Materials and methods
One white siliceous conglomerate (Z1) and four siliceous sandstones facies (TG, white sandstone with large-sized grains; TB, white sandstone; TO, ochreous sandstone and TR, red sandstone) with different porosity values and containing strongly reactive components (swelling clays, and opal that dissolves in basic solutions, iron oxyhydroxides, which can come to the surface of the stone through dissolution and dragging due to freeze/thawing processes, changing the characteristics of the materials such as the surface color, etc.) were used in this study. Their mineralogical origin, chemical and petrophysical properties have been described elsewhere (Añorbe-Urmeneta 1997). All materials are widely used in construction and are currently being used in the conservation intervention of the Cathedral and other buildings in Zamora (Spain).
The untreated stones and their corresponding treated counterparts are known to be affected by the specific climate of the area, which is Mediterranean, tending toward being continental, and the different microclimates inside buildings (Iñigo et al. 2000; Iñigo and Vicente-Tavera 2002). In this climate, there are daily abrupt changes in temperature which can lead to fissures. In addition, processes of freezing/thawing giving rise to fissures, scales, etc. and processes of haloclasty due to the effects of atmospheric and underground and/or subsurface water pollution, give rise to efflorescence and crusts.
The following commercial conservation products were tested: RC70 (ethyl silicate) as the consolidant and RC80 (a mixture of ethyl silicate, a methyl resin, and polysiloxane) as the consolidant plus water repellent. All products contain a catalyst, which favors polymerization, and were provided by Rhodia Siliconas Spain, Ltd.
The treatments were carried out as follows: both consolidation treatments (RC70 and RC80) followed the recommendations by Iñigo et al. (2001, 2006), which promotes the penetration of products inside stone samples (5 cubic samples measuring 5 × 5 × 5 cm in each group). The treatment was carried out in four consecutive steps, one immediately after the other: (1) immersion of the stone samples in white spirit (also used as a solvent for the conservation products) for 30 min; (2) immersion in a white spirit solution + conservation product (5% w/w) for 8 h; (3) immersion in a white spirit solution + conservation product (40% w/w) for 24 h and (4) immersion in a white spirit solution + conservation product (75% w/w) for 48 h. Curing extended for 1 month at room temperature and ambient laboratory conditions.
The following hydric properties were analyzed: total porosity (NF 1973a) and free porosity (NF 1973a, b), absorption coefficient (NF 1973a, b), real and apparent density (NF 1973a), imbibition coefficient (NORMAL 1981), and capillary absorption coefficient (NORMAL 1986).
The Canonical Biplot was performed to analyze variation between the five different untreated stone varieties and their corresponding treated samples.
The Canonical Biplot is complementary to the MANOVA analysis (Multivariate Analysis of Variance), but includes all of the characteristics of the Biplot method (Gabriel 1971, 1972, 1995), and can be used to discriminate the set of groups of previously established populations. This technique was later developed and completed (Galindo 1986; Amaro et al. 2004; Vicente-Villardón 2018), and applied to the field of Cultural Heritage conservation (Iñigo et al. 2014, 2017, 2019; García-Talegón et al. 2016b).
The results are summarized on several factorial planes, where the variables are represented as vectors that start out from a hypothetical origin and the means of the different groups as stars surrounded by confidence circles in the same reference system. If two variables are represented with a very small angle, then the variables are highly correlated, and if they are opposite, their correlation is inverse. Additionally, if the angle is close to perpendicularity, their correlation is minimum. When projecting all of the star markers perpendicularly onto the directions of any of the variables, the order of the projections in the direction of those variables is equivalent to the value of the population means for that variable. If two confidence circles are projected perpendicularly on one of the variables and the intervals of both projections do not overlap, this is tantamount to saying that there are differences between both means (Student’s t-test); the amplitudes of the circles will depend on the significance, α, determined (MSD, Bonferroni corrections, etc.). These interpretations are subject to a series of measurements of the quality of representation for the different planes (inertia absorption of the planes, the goodness of the projections of the measurements on the variables for the dimensions selected, etc.).
The Canonical Biplot is a comprehensive technique that analyzes all variables together, minimizing Type I risk, while the classic individual ANOVAs are used for each variable. Likewise, the Biplot representation allows us to easily visualize all the possible differences between the different groupings for all of the variables analyzed.
In our case, there are 8 variables (the previously mentioned hydric properties), and the nomenclature used was YZ, where Y indicates the type of rock (Z1, TG, TB, TO, and TR) and Z the type of treatment (untreated, RC70 and RC80). Thus, Z1RC80 corresponds to rock Z1 treated with RC80.
Results and discussion
The variation in weight of the treated samples with respect to the untreated samples provides an approximation of the amount of product introduced through the pore network of the stones. The weight gain observed in the varieties treated with RC70 varied between 0.48–1.10% and between 0.90–1.11% in the samples treated with RC80, when using the original weight of the corresponding untreated rocks as a reference.
Table 1 shows the means and standard error of the hydric properties for each treatment and stone variety.
After applying the multivariate Canonical Biplot technique, we obtained a Wilk’s lambda of 34.0991 (p < 0.001), which can be interpreted as though there were differences among the means of the joint measurements of the populations (groups) for all variables. Regarding the absorption of inertia, the first three axes absorbed 92.913% of the total inertia.
Although porosity was not low (≈ 11%), no changes were detected in any of the hydric properties studied using the different silicoorganic treatments (Table 1 and Figs. 1 and 2) on the white silicified conglomerates Z1, because when analyzing the graphs, the projections of the confidence circles of the groupings (Z1-Z1RC70 and Z1-Z1RC80) overlap. This indicated that these types of properties were not suitable for determining the effectiveness of the various treatments applied. However, in the silicified sandstones of Zamora, which have greater porosity, the following variations were observed:
Total porosity (TP)
In Fig. 1, differences were detected only between the treated and untreated samples of varieties TR and TO.
Free porosity (FP), absorption coefficient (AC), and real density (RD)
In Fig. 1, differences were observed between the treated and untreated stones and between the samples treated with RC70 and RC80. The values obtained for the samples treated with RC80 were lower than the values obtained for those treated with RC70. This indicated that the consolidant RC80 decreases free porosity (FP), the absorption coefficient (AC), and real density (RD) more than RC70, as it substantially reduces the circulation of fluids through the pore network. This may have occurred due to the fact that RC80 contains polysiloxane derivatives that are hydrophobic in nature.
Apparent density (AD)
In Fig. 1, differences were observed between the treated and untreated samples of TR, and between the RC70 and RC80 treatments. In Fig. 2, differences were only detected in varieties TB and TO among the samples treated with RC80 and the untreated samples.
Imbibition coefficient (IC)
In Fig. 1, differences were observed between the treated and the untreated samples of all stone varieties studied. However, no differences were detected among the samples treated with RC70 and RC80, except for TR.
Capillary absorption coefficient (CAC)
This variable behaved the same as the variables of free porosity (FP), the absorption coefficient (AC), and real density (RD); although no differences were detected for TB treated with RC70 and RC80 as shown in Fig. 1. Again, this could be due to the hydrophobic nature of the polysiloxane derivatives.
In view of the Canonical Biplot results, the most determinant hydric properties capable of distinguishing between high and low efficiency of the different treatments were the capillary absorption coefficient, the absorption coefficient, real density and free porosity. These properties presented greater variations with respect to the different stone substrates and the different conservation treatments applied. In addition, the imbibition coefficient was also able to distinguish between the effectiveness of the treatments, although to a lesser extent because there were fewer variations. As was observed, these hydric properties are directly related to the circulation of fluids inside the pore network and are intrinsic properties of the stones both before and after treatment.
In summary, we can affirm that the most effective treatment for these types of stone varieties, under the conditions applied, is the consolidant plus water repellent, RC80, due to its double action (consolidant + water repellant), as shown in Fig. 1. This treatment decreases the hydric properties related to the transport of fluids, such as porosity, absorption coefficient and coefficient of capillary absorption, more than treatment RC70, and at the same time increases real density. However, RC70 can be used as a preconsolidant due to its density and the fact that its viscosity is lower than that of RC80.
In this work, additional hydric properties have been identified, capable of confirming the effectiveness of the treatments used in this study on the various types of stone, that had not been previously identified in other studies using different types of stones (silicified granites) (Iñigo et al. 2001, 2006). It can be said that the response of a stone material to a particular treatment depends on its intrinsic characteristics. Therefore, it is advisable to study different types of treatments on each stone substrate.
Conclusions
The results of direct observation and the statistical analysis have allowed the following conclusions to be drawn:
- 1)
The Canonical Biplot has been successfully applied in this research field as a novel and alternative technique to classical individual ANOVA techniques.
- 2)
In the case of white silicified conglomerates from Zamora, Z1, the hydric properties analyzed in this work cannot be used to evaluate the effectiveness of the two silicoorganic treatments tested, due to the lack of variability after their application.
- 3)
The effectiveness of the treatments applied to the stone substrates can be determined by measuring the following properties: open porosity, absorption coefficient, real density, and the capillary absorption coefficient. In addition, the imbibition coefficient can also be used to evaluate treatment efficacy, but with less reliability.
- 4)
The variations observed for these parameters, with respect to the quality of the materials before and after treatment, show an improvement in the properties of porous siliceous sandstones from the point of view of their use as building materials.
- 5)
The combined action of the consolidant plus water repellent, RC80, is more effective than the consolidant on its own, RC70.
- 6)
Since the way in which stone materials respond to a given treatment depends on their intrinsic characteristics, the results were difficult to predict prior to carrying out the experiments. Therefore, it is advisable that each material is tested with each treatment under experimental conditions that are similar to those of each specific monument.
References
Alcalde-Moreno M, Villegas-Sanchez R, Vale-Parapar JF (2003) Study on weathering and conservation treatments for the stone of Andalusian monuments. Macroscopical morphology of accelerated weathering of some petreous materials. In: Pérez-Rodríguez JL (ed) Applied study of Cultural Heritage and clays. CSIC, Madrid, pp 259–288
Alejandre FJ, Villegas R (2009) Brick durability and conservation treatment (Santa María de Jesús chapel portal, Seville, Spain). Mater Construcc 59(293):85–103
Amaro IR, Vicente-Villardón JL, Galindo-Villardón MP (2004) ANOVA Biplot para arreglos de tratamientos con dos factores basado en modelos lineales generales multivariantes. Interciencia 29:26–32
Añorbe-Urmeneta M (1997) Valoración del deterioro y conservación en la piedra monumental. CEDEX (Centro de Estudios y Experimentación de Obras Publicas), Madrid
Arezki S, Chelouah N, Tahakourt A (2016) The effect of the addition of ground olive stones on the physical and mechanical properties of clay bricks. Mater Construcc 66(322):e082
Berardi E, Mecchi AM, Calia A, Lettieri M (2002) Water-repellent treatments on some calcareous Apulian stones of differing porosity. In: Galan E, Zezza F (eds) The protection and conservation of the Cultural Heritage of the Mediterranean cities. Swets & Zeitlinger B. V, Lisse, pp 401–406
Brandes C, Stadlbauer E (1992) Capillary water absorption of painted stone. In: Delgado-Rodrigues J, Henriques F, Telmo-Jeremias F (eds) Deterioration and conservation of stone, vol 2. Laboratório Nacional de Engenharia Civil, Lisbon, pp 591–600
Buj O, Gisbert J (2006) Evaluation of three consolidants on Miocene sandstone from the Ebro basin. In: Fort R, Alvarez-de Buergo M, Gomez-Heras M, Vazquez-Calvo C (eds) HWC 2006 - heritage, weathering and conservation, vol 2. Taylor & Francis/Balkema, Leiden, pp 741–747
Cordova A, Gomez A (1997) Modellization of the invasion of a porous material by a fluid and effect of chemical dissolution. European Cultural Heritage Newsletter on Research 10:150–151
Costa D, Leal AS, Mimoso JM, Pereira SRM (2017) Consolidation treatments applied to ceramic tiles: are they homogeneous? Mater Construcc 67(325):e113
Espinosa-Gaitan J, Ontiveros-Ortega E, Villegas-Sanchez R, Alcalde-Moreno M (2002) Evaluation of treatments for the stone of the Cordoba door of Carmona (Seville, España). In: Galan E, Zezza F (eds) The protection and conservation of the Cultural Heritage of the Mediterranean cities. Swets & Zeitlinger B. V, Lisse, pp 431–436
Gabriel KR (1971) The biplot-graphic display of matrices with applications to principal component analysis. Biometrika 58:453–467
Gabriel KR (1972) Analysis of meteorological data by means of canonical decomposition and biplots. J Appl Meteorol 11:1071–1077
Gabriel KR (1995) MANOVA biplots for two-way contingency tables. In: Krzanowsky W (ed) Recent advances in descriptive multivariate analysis. Clarendon Press, Oxford, pp 227–268
Galindo MP (1986) Una alternativa de representación simultanea: HJ-Biplot. Qüestiió 1:13–23
Galvana S, Plaa C, Cuetoa N, Martínez-Martíneza J, García-del Cura MA, Benavente D (2014) A comparison of experimental methods for measuring water permeability of porous building rocks. Mater Construcc 64(315):e028
García O, Rz-Maribona I, Gardei A, Riedl M, Vanhellemont Y, Santarelli ML, Strupi-Suput J (2010) Comparative study of the variation of the hydric properties and aspect of natural stone and brick after the application of 4 types of anti-graffiti. Mater Construcc 60(297):69–82
García-Garmilla F, Rodríguez-Maribona I, Cano M, Zalbide M, Ibáñez-Gómez JA, Osa-Chans E, Garín S (2002) An analytical comparison of two commercial consolidating products applied to Eocene sandstones from 16th and 19th century monuments in San Sebastián, northern Spain. Mater Construcc 52(266):5–18
García-Talegón J, Iñigo AC, Vicente-Tavera S (2015) Villamayor stone (Golden stone) as a global heritage stone resource from Salamanca (NW of Spain). J Geol Soc London Spec Publ 407:109–120
García-Talegón J, Iñigo AC, Vicente-Tavera S, Molina E (2016a) Silicified granites (bleeding stone and ochre granite) as global heritage stones resources from Avila (central of Spain). Geosci Can 43(1):53–62
García-Talegón J, Iñigo AC, Vicente-Palacios V (2016b) A laboratory simulation of desalting on calcareous building stone with wet sepiolite. Environ Earth Sci 75:925–932
Hammecker C, Esbert RM, Jeannette D (1992) Geometry modifications of porous network in carbonate rocks by ethyl silicate treatment. In: Delgado-Rodrigues J, Henriques F, Telmo-Jeremias F (eds) Deterioration and conservation of stone, vol 3. Laboratório Nacional de Engenharia civil, Lisbon, pp 1053–1062
Iñigo AC, Rives V, Vicente MA (2000) Reproducción en cámara climática de las formas de alteración más frecuentes detectadas en materiales graníticos, en clima de tendencia continental. Mater Construcc 50(257):57–60
Iñigo AC, Vicente-Tavera S, Vicente MA, Rives V (2001) Effect of treatments on the pore network of granites. J Mater Civil Eng 13:166–168
Iñigo AC, Vicente-Tavera S (2002) Surface-inside (10 cm) thermal gradients in granitic rocks. Effect of environmental conditions. Buil Environ 37:101–108
Iñigo AC, Vicente-Tavera S, Rives V (2006) Statistical design applied to hydric property behaviour for monitoring granite consolidation and/or water-repellent treatments. Mater Construcc 56(281):17–28
Iñigo AC, Supit JFD, Prieto O, Rives V (2007) Change in microporosity of granitic building stones upon consolidation treatments. J Mater Civil Eng 19:437–440
Iñigo AC, García-Talegón J, Vicente-Tavera S (2014) Canonical Biplot statistical analysis to detect the magnitude of the effects of phosphates crystallization aging on the color in siliceous conglomerates. Color Res Appl 39(1):82–87
Iñigo AC, García-Talegón J, Vicente-Tavera S, Casado-Marín S, Martín-González S (2017) Multivariate analyses of soluble salts responsable for pathologies in granites of the Roman Aqueduct of Segovia, Spain. Inter J Conser Sci 8(1):59–66
Iñigo AC, García-Talegón J, Vicente-Palacios V, Vicente-Tavera S (2019) Canonical Biplot as a tool to detect microclimates in the inner and outer parts of El Salvador Church in Seville, Spain. Measurement 136:745–760
Luque A, Cultrone G, Sebastián E, Cazalla O (2008) Evaluación de la eficacia de tratamientos en el incremento de la durabilidad de una calcarenita bioclástica (Granada, España). Mater Construcc 58(292):115–128
Martín J, Navas FJ, Alcántara R (2002) An instrumental system for continuous measuring of the sorption properties in porous materials. In: Galán E, Zezza F (eds) The conservation of monuments in the Mediterranean Basin - protection and conservation of the Cultural Heritage of the Mediterranean cities. Swets & Zeitlinger B. V, Lisse, pp 327–330
Meng B (1992) Moisture-transport-relevant characterization of pore structure. In: Delgado-Rodrigues J, Henriques F, Telmo-Jeremias F (eds) Deterioration and conservation of stone, vol 1. Laboratório Nacional de Engenharia Civil, Lisbon, pp 387–396
NF (1973a) Mesures de la Porosité, de la Masse Volumique Réelle et de la Masse Volumique Apparente [Measurements of Porosity, Real Density and Apparent Density]. B10–503 (in French)
NF (1973b) Mesure du Coeficient de Absortion d’Eau [Measurement of the Water Absorption Coefficient]. B10–504 (in French)
NORMAL (1981) Assorbimento d’acqua per immersione totale, capacitá di imbibizione [Absorption of water by total immersion, imbibition capacity]. 7 (in Italian).
NORMAL (1986) Assorbimento d’acqua per capillaritá, coefficiente di assorbimento capillare [Water absorption by capillarity, capillary absorption coefficient]. 11/85 (in Italian)
Quaresima R, Scoccia G, Volpe R, Toscani G (2002) Behaviour of different treated and untreated stones exposed to salt crystallization test. In: Galan E, Zezza F (eds) The protection and conservation of the Cultural Heritage of the Mediterranean cities. Swets & Zeitlinger B. V, Lisse, pp 455–460
Ribas T, Iglesias J, Taboada J, Avilán J (2011) Oxidación de sulfuros en pizarra ornamental: tratamientos protectores con siloxanos. Mater Construcc 61(301):115–130
Torrisi A (2008) Evaluation of five fluorinated compounds as calcarenite protectives. J Cult Herit 9:135–145
Valdeon L, Grossi CM, Marcos RM, Esbert RM (1992) Effect of conservation treatments on hydric properties of stones. In: Delgado-Rodrigues J, Henriques F, Telmo-Jeremias F (eds) Deterioration and conservation of stone, vol 3. Laboratório Nacional de Engenharia civil, Lisbon, pp 1073–1081
Vicente MA (1996) Summary of project STEP-CT9001, granitic materials and historical monuments: study of factors and mechanism of weathering and application to historical heritage conservation. In: Vicente MA, Delgado-Rodrigues J, Acevedo J (eds) Degradation and conservation of granitic rocks in monuments. EUROPEAN COMMISSION, Directorate-General XII, Brussels, pp 4–45
Vicente-Villardón JL (2018) MULTBIPLOT: Multivariate Analysis using Biplots. http://biplot.usal.es. Accessed 6 February 2018
Villegas-Sánchez R, Espinosa-Gaitán J (2001) Evaluation of treatment products for the front door of the church of Santiago, Guadix. Mater Construcc 51(261):21–32
Funding
The authors are grateful for financial support for this work from the Ministry of Education and Science (CGL2007-62168BET and FEDER funds), Ministry of Science and Innovation (MAT2010-20660) and Ministry of Science, Innovation and Universities (PGC2018-098151-B-100).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher’s note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Iñigo, A.C., García-Talegón, J., Vicente-Tavera, S. et al. Evaluation of effectiveness of silicoorganic treatments using hydric properties. Archaeol Anthropol Sci 12, 86 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12520-020-01038-w
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12520-020-01038-w