Abstract
Although the foundation of financial accounting and auditing has traditionally been based upon a rule-based framework, the concept of a principle-based approach has been periodically advocated since being incorporated into the AICPA Code of Conduct in 1989. Recent high profile events indicate that the accountants and auditors involved have followed rule-based ethical perspectives and have failed to protect investors and stakeholders – resulting in a wave of scandals and charges of unethical conduct. In this paper we describe how the rule-based traditions of auditing became a convenient vehicle that perpetuated the unethical conduct of firms such as Enron and Arthur Andersen. We present a model of ten ethical perspectives and briefly describe how these ten ethical perspectives impact rule-based and principle-based ethical conduct for accountants and auditors. We conclude by identifying six specific suggestions that the accounting and auditing profession should consider to restore public trust and to improve the ethical conduct of accountants and auditors.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
W. S. Albrecht R. J. Sack (2000) Accounting Education: Charting the Course through a Perilous Future American Accounting Association Sarasota, FL
M. L. Ambrose M. Schminke (2003) ArticleTitle‘Organizational Structure as a Moderator between Procedural Justice, Interactional Justice, Perceived Organizational Support, and Supervisor Trust’ Journal of Applied Psychology 88 IssueID2 295–305
InstitutionalAuthorNameAmerican Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA) (1986) ‘Restructuring Professional Standards to Achieve Professional Excellence in a Changing Environment’ AICPA New York, NY
InstitutionalAuthorNameAmerican Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA) (2003) Professional Standards, 1 AICPA New York, NY
InstitutionalAuthorNameArbinger Institute (2000) Leadership and Self-Deception Berrett-Koehler Publishers San Francisco CA
L. Bean (2004) ArticleTitle‘Rebates: Do the Big Four Need an Ethics Audit?’ Journal of Corporate Accounting and Finance 15 IssueID4 37–40
M. S. Beasley D. R. Hermanson (2004) ArticleTitle‘Going Beyond Sarbanes-Oxley Compliance: Five keys to Creating Value’ CPA Journal 74 11–13
F. N. Brady (1990) ‘Ethical Managing: Rules and Results’ McMillan New York
R. B. Brandt (1992) Morality, Utilitarianism, and Rights University Press Cambridge, MA
Business Week: 02/07/2000, ‘If You Can’t Trust the Auditors’ 3667, 38.
C. Caldwell S. J. Bischoff R. Karri (2002) ArticleTitle‘The Four Umpires: A Paradigm for Ethical Leadership’ Journal of Business Ethics 36 153–163 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1014230002724
C. Caldwell S. E. Clapham (2003) ArticleTitle‘Organizational Trustworthiness: An International Perspective’ Journal of Business Ethics 47 IssueID4 349–365 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1027370104302
Caldwell, C., S. Clapham, and Proctor, G.: 2003, ‘Trustworthiness, Justice, and the Mediating Lens: A Demographic Analysis’, Paper presented at the European Academy of Management Conference in Milan, Italy, April 3–5, 2003.
Caldwell, C., G. Proctor, D. E. Hallock, and Loffredo, D.: 2004, ‘Moral Relativism and Ethical Choices’, Paper submitted in October 2004 to the Journal of Business Ethics.
D. Callahan (2004) The Cheating Culture: Why More Americans are Doing Wrong to Get Ahead Harcourt, Inc. Orlando, FL
K. Cameron (2003a) ‘Organizational Virtuousness and Performance’ S. Kim Cameron E. Jane Dutton E. Robert Quinn (Eds) Positive Organizational Scholarship: Foundations of a New Discipline Berrett-Koehler Publishers San Francisco, CA 48–65
K. S. Cameron (2003b) ‘Ethics, Virtuousness, and Constant Change’ N. M. Tichy A. R. McGill (Eds) The Ethical Challenge: How to Lead with Unyielding Integrity Jossey-Bass San Francisco, CA 185–194
A. B. Carroll A. K. Buchholtz (2003) Business and Society: Ethics and Stakeholder Management EditionNumber4 South-Western College Publishing Cincinnati OH
S. L. Carter (1997) Integrity Harper Perennial New York, NY
Cheney, G.: 2004, ‘Accounting Today’, 14–15.
G. Cheney (2002) ArticleTitle‘Ripples from Enron’ Australian CPA 72 IssueID2 62–64
J. C. Collins J. I. Porras (1994) Built to Last: Successful Habits of Visionary Companies Harper- Collins New York, NY
A. J. Constantini (2004) ArticleTitle‘What’s Ahead in Enforcement?’ Journal of Accountancy 198 IssueID3 72–77
C. Cullinan (2004) ArticleTitle‘Enron as a Symptom of Audit Process Breakdown: Can the Sarbanes-Oxley Act Cure the Disease?’ Critical Perspectives on Accounting 15 IssueID6/7 853–864
L. A. Cunningham (2004) ArticleTitle‘The Appeals and Limits of Internal Controls to Fight Fraud, Terrorism, Other Ills’ Journal of Corporation Law 29 IssueID2 267–346
T. R. Gregori ParticleDe (1979) ArticleTitle‘Market Morality: Robert Nozick and the Question of Economic Justice’ American Journal of Economics and Society 38 IssueID1 17–30
R. A. DiBattista (1989) ArticleTitle‘Providing a Rationale for Ethical Conduct from Alternatives Taken in Ethical Dilemmas’ Journal of General Psychology 116 IssueID2 207–214
J. K. Dillard K. Yuthas (2002) ArticleTitle‘Ethical Audit Decisions: A Structuration Perspective’ Journal of Business Ethics 36 IssueID1/2 49–64 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1014244109742
T. Donaldson T. Dunfee (1999) Ties that Bind: A Social Contracts Approach to Business Ethics Harvard Business Press Cambridge, MA
T. R. Dyckman R. E. Dukes C. J. Davis (2001) Intermediate Accounting EditionNumber5 McGraw-Hill New York, NY
G. Eynon N. T. Hill K. T. Stevens (1997) ArticleTitle‘Factors that Affect the Moral Reasoning Ability of Accountants: Implications for Universities and the Profession’ Journal of Business Ethics 16 IssueID12/13 1297–1309 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1005754201952
J. M. Fedders (1998) ArticleTitle‘Qualitative Materiality: The Birth, Struggles, and Demise of an Unworkable Standard’ Catholic University Law Review 48 41–84
InstitutionalAuthorNameFinancial Accounting Standards Board (1985) ArticleTitle‘OFFICIAL RELEASES: Statement of Financial Accounting Concepts No. 5 – Recognition and Measurement in Financial Statements of Business Enterprises’ Journal of Accountancy 159 IssueID3 151–165
T. Fort (2003) ‘The Best Ethical Choices Come When Long-Term Impact Rules’ M. Noel Tichy R. Andrew McGill (Eds) The Ethical Challenge: How to Lead with Unyielding Integrity Jossey-Bass San Francisco, CA 195–208
J. Gaa (1990) ArticleTitle‘Discussion of “A Theory of Evidence Based On Audit Assertions” Contemporary Accounting Research 6 IssueID2 427–431
A. D. Gomez-Guillamon (2003) ArticleTitle‘The Usefulness of the Auditing Report in Investment and Financing Decisions’ Managerial Auditing Journal 18 IssueID6/7 549–559
M. I. Gordon (2001) ArticleTitle‘Commentary on: Some Thoughts on Social and Environmental Accounting Education’ Accounting Education 10 IssueID4 361–364 Occurrence Handle10.1080/09639280210121178
B. Hanney (2003) ArticleTitle‘Called to Account’ Accountancy 132 IssueID1324 144–148
T. L. Herron D. L. Gilbertson (2004) ArticleTitle‘Ethical Principles vs. Ethical Rules: The Moderating Effect of Moral Development on Audit Independence Judgments’ Business Ethics Quarterly 14 IssueID3 499–523
J. C. Hilliard (2004) ArticleTitle‘Inspired by the Golden Rule’ Publishers Weekly 251 IssueID51 212–15
L. T. Hosmer (1995) ArticleTitle‘Trust: The Connecting Link between Organizational Theory and Behavior’ Academy of Management Review 20 379–404
L. T. Hosmer (1994) ArticleTitle‘Strategic Planning as if Ethics Mattered’ Strategic Management Journal 15 17–34
L. T. Hosmer (1996) The Ethics of Management Irwin Chicago, IL
E. A. Imhoff SuffixJr. (2003) ArticleTitle‘Accounting Quality, Auditing, and Corporate Governance’ Accounting Horizons 17 117–128
E. J. Kane (2004) ArticleTitle‘Continuing Dangers of Disinformation in Corporate Accounting Reports’ Review of Financial Economics 13 IssueID1/2 149–164
M. T. Keim C. T. Grant (2003) ArticleTitle‘To Tell or Not to Tell: An Auditing Case in Ethical Decision Making and Conflict Resolution’ Issues in Accounting Education 18 IssueID4 397–407
J. M. Kouzes B. Z. Posner (1993) Credibility: How Leaders Gain and Lose It, and Why People Demand It Jossey-Bass San Francisco, CA
D. Lea (2004) ArticleTitle‘The Imperfect Nature of Corporate Responsibilities to Stakeholders’ Business Ethics Quarterly 14 IssueID2 201–217
E. A. Lind T. R. Tyler (1988) The Social Psychology of Procedural Justice Plenum New York, NY
B. Manville J. Ober (2003) A Company of Citizens: What the World’s First Democracy Teaches Leaders about Creating Great Organizations Harvard Business School Press Cambridge, MA
J. B. McGuire A. Sundgren T. Schneeweis (1988) ArticleTitle‘Corporate Social Responsibility and Firm Financial Performance’ Academy of Management Journal 31 IssueID4 854–872
J. F. McKernan K. K. MacLullich (2004) ArticleTitle‘Accounting, Love, and Justice’ Accounting, Auditing, and Accountability Journal 17 IssueID3 327–360
B. McLean P. Elkind (2003) The Smartest Guys in the Room: The Amazing Rise and Scandalous Fall of Enron Penguin Books London
G. F. Miller (2000) ArticleTitle‘Staff Accounting Bulletin No, 99 – Another Ill-advised Foray into the Murky World of Qualitative Materiality’ Northwestern University Law Review 95 361–406
Miller, P. and Bahnson, P.: 2004, ‘Audit Revolution: From Compliance to Adding Value’, Accounting Today, 14–15.
InstitutionalAuthorNameMiller GAAS Update Service (2004) ‘The Sarbanes- Oxley Act of 2002’ 4 IssueID11 2
Nozick, R.: 1974, Anarchy, State and Utopia (Blackwell Publishing).
L. S. Paine (2003) Value Shift: Why Companies Must Shift Social and Financial Imperatives to Achieve Superior Performance McGraw-Hill New York, NY
Pearson, M.: 1988, ‘A New Code of Professional Conduct for CPAs’, Ohio CPA Journal. Winter, 7–9.
J. Pfeffer (1998) The Human Equation: Building Profits by Putting People First Harvard Business School Press Boston, MA
Pincus, K. V.: 2000, ‘The Role of Rules in Accounting: Do Rules Guide us to the Right Path or to the Path of Least Resistance?’.
L. Ponemon (1992) ArticleTitle‘Ethical Reasoning and Selection-Socialization in Accounting’ Accounting Organizations and Society 17 IssueID3/4 239–258
Rittenberg, L. and Schwieger, B.: 2003, Auditing Concepts for a Changing Environment. Fourth Edition (Thompson Publishing).
D. M. Rousseau (1995) Psychological Contracts in Organizations – Understanding Written and Unwritten Agreements Sage Publications Thousand Oaks, CA
Sayther, C.: 2004, ‘Shifting Sands: The Changing Relationship between Financial Executives and Auditors’, Financial Executive, July/August, 6.
E. H. Schein (1992) Organizational Culture and Leadership Jossey-Bass San Francisco, CA
H. M. Schilit (2002) Financial Shenanigans: How to Detect Accounting Gimmicks and Fraud in a Financial Report EditionNumber2 McGraw-Hill New York, NY
K. Schipper (2003) ArticleTitle‘Principle-Based Accounting Standards’ Accounting Horizons 17 IssueID1 61–72
M. Schminke M. L. Ambrose T. W. Noel (1997) ArticleTitle‘The Effect of Ethical Frameworks on the Perception of Organizational Justice’ Academy of Management Journal 40 IssueID5 1190–1207
P. Selznick (1992) The Moral Commonwealth: Social Theory and the Promise of Community University of California Press Berkely, CA
R. C. Solomon (1992) Ethics and Excellence: Cooperation and Integrity in Business Oxford University Press New York, NY
M. Shaub (1994) ArticleTitle‘An Analysis of Factors Affecting the Cognitive Moral Development of Auditors and Auditing Students’ Journal of Accounting Education 12 IssueID1 89–97 Occurrence Handle10.1016/0748-5751(94)90016-7
Shefrin Hersh Statman Meir (1993) ArticleTitle‘Ethics, Fairness and Efficiency in Financial Markets’ Financial Analysts Journal 49 IssueID6 21–30
J. Sweeney (1995) ArticleTitle‘The Moral Expertise of Auditors: An Explanatory Analysis’ Research on Accounting Ethics 1 213–234
J. T. Sweeney R. W. Roberts (1997) ArticleTitle‘Cognitive Moral Development and Auditor Independence’ Accounting, Organizations & Society 22 IssueID3/4 337–353
C. Swinson (2003) ArticleTitle‘Abuse of Trust’ Accountancy 132 IssueID1321 26
J. Thibault L. Walker (1975) Procedural Justice: A Psychological Analysis Erlbaum Associates Hillsdale, NJ
Tie, R.: 1999, ‘Special Report: Concerns over Auditing Quality Complicate the Future of Accounting’, Journal of Accountancy (December), 14–15.
H. Uzun S. H. Szewczyk R. Varma (2004) ArticleTitle‘Board Composition and Corporate Fraud’ Financial Analysts Journal 60 IssueID3 33–43
C. C. Verschoor (2004) ArticleTitle‘Is Ethics Awareness Enough?’ Strategic Finance 85 IssueID12 17–18
Votaw, D.: 1974, ‘Individualism Lives! Nozick is Its Prophet’, Business and Society Revi‘ew. Fall, 1975, 15, 101–104.
O. E. Williamson (1975) Markets and Hierarchies, Analysis and Antitrust Implications: A Study in the Economics of Internal Organization Free Press New York, NY
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Satava, D., Caldwell, C. & Richards, L. Ethics and the Auditing Culture: Rethinking the Foundation of Accounting and Auditing. J Bus Ethics 64, 271–284 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-005-0556-y
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-005-0556-y