Abstract
The Basra reed warbler (Acrocephalus griseldis) and the cinereous bunting (Emberiza cineracea) are the only two Western Palearctic passerine bird species that overwinter in East Africa and are classified by BirdLife International as endangered and near-threatened, respectively. To refine the African wintering ranges of these two species, we made an effort to collect as much distributional data as possible. We then used the available point-locality data to predict the wintering distributions using a Geographic Information Systems (GIS) based inductive modelling technique called BIOCLIM. For this purpose, we developed four environmental GIS layers that are presumed to reflect the environmental preferences of migrant birds. Our data showed that the known winter distribution of the Basra reed warbler was concentrated in Kenya, Tanzania, Malawi and Mozambique, where it was usually found in dense vegetation growing in coastal scrub, woodland thickets, swamps, marshes, flooded pools and grasslands, and along ditches and edges of rivers, ponds, lagoons and lakes. The predicted winter distribution of this species includes most of East Africa but, given the habitat preferences of this species, is probably limited to low-lying areas near the coastline. The known winter distribution of the cinereous bunting is so far limited to Eritrea, where the species has been observed in October, November, February and March, in sparsely vegetated, sandy or rocky habitats on coastal plains and deserts. The predicted winter distribution of this species includes the plains and hills along the Red Sea coasts in southern Egypt, Sudan, Eritrea, Ethiopia and Sudan, as well as a few inland areas in Sudan, Ethiopia and Kenya.
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
Introduction
The conservation of migratory bird species poses special problems associated with their annual movements which often span continents, because species survival is dependent on the conservation of not only breeding grounds, but also stop-over sites and wintering grounds (Salathé 1991; Crick and Jones 1992; Bibby 2003). For the over 300 species breeding in the Palearctic region which migrate, in numbers estimated at 3,000–5,000 millions, to their African wintering grounds (Moreau 1972; Curry-Lindahl 1981), we know their breeding grounds and principal migration routes through Europe and the Mediterranean quite well (Cramp 1998; Glutz von Blotzheim 2001), but knowledge concerning the distribution of these migrants in Africa is still fragmentary (Walther and Rahbek 2002). For many species, knowledge of distribution may be as superficial as “occurs in Eastern Africa” or the necessarily oversimplified range maps in the otherwise impressive Birds of Africa series (Brown et al. 1982; Urban et al. 1986, 1997; Fry et al. 1988, 2000, 2004; Keith et al. 1992). Such information is insufficient in spatial resolution for proper scientific analyses and conservation management.
In an effort to pull together information on migrants in Africa, a research project at the Zoological Museum, University of Copenhagen, aims to establish a publicly accessible database on the geographical distribution of western Palearctic migratory birds in Africa. The information in this database will hopefully enhance our understanding of the whereabouts of migrants in Africa as well as guide conservation decisions (Walther and Rahbek 2002). To illustrate the potential use of such data, we here present the predicted winter distributions of two threatened western Palearctic passerine species.
The Basra reed warbler (Acrocephalus griseldis) and the cinereous bunting (Emberiza cineracea) are the only two western Palearctic passerine bird species that overwinter in East Africa (Urban et al. 1997; Fry et al. 2004) and are classified by BirdLife International (2004) as endangered and near-threatened, respectively. The Basra reed warbler breeds in thick marshy waterside vegetation in Iraq and possibly Iran and Kuwait (Cramp 1998; BirdLife International 2004). The marshes in southern Iraq have been extensively damaged in recent decades, and this massive habitat loss may have caused the population of the Basra reed warbler to deteriorate to less than 10,000 birds, putting it in the endangered category (Birdlife International 2004). The Basra reed warbler migrates through the Arabian peninsula and northeastern Africa to its overwintering range in southern Somalia, Kenya, Tanzania, Malawi, Mozambique and South Africa (Urban et al. 1997). The subspecies cineracea of the cinereous bunting breeds on Greek islands and around Develi and Kilis in Turkey, while the subspecies semenowi breeds from southeast Turkey up to the Iraqi-Iranian border (BirdLife International 2004). They both migrate through the Middle East and the Gulf Region to their overwintering range in southern Saudi-Arabia, Yemen, Sudan and Eritrea (Chappius et al. 1973; de Knijff 1991).
To refine the African wintering ranges of these two species, we made an effort to collect as much available distributional data as possible, using various published and unpublished sources (e.g. museum specimens, personal communications, etc.). However, assuming that many areas in Africa still remain undersampled, we use the available point-locality data to predict the wintering distributions using Geographic Information Systems (GIS) based modeling techniques which have, for example, been used to model the wintering grounds of the common crane (Grus grus) (Franco et al. 2000) and the migration of the Swainson’s Flycatcher (Myiarchus swainsoni) across the South American continent (Joseph and Stockwell 2000). Two types of analytic models are commonly used to predict species distributions: so-called deductive and inductive models (Corsi et al. 2000). In this study, we exclusively use inductive models that use point-locality data to derive a species’ environmental preferences. These preferences are then used to predict other suitable areas which may include areas occupied by the species and areas not occupied by the species even though they are suitable. Therefore, distributional maps based on inductive models may ‘overpredict’ the actual range because they include not just the realised, but also the potential, distribution of the species, thereby ignoring historical and biogeographical influences. Nevertheless, we hope that such distributional maps will focus future research of these two species by narrowing the areas where field workers may go looking for them.
Migrant birds in Africa are known to favour the more open habitats of the savannas (e.g. the Sahel) characterised by pronounced seasonal rainfalls which determine the emergence of green vegetation and the consequent increase of insect and bird life (Moreau 1972; Curry-Lindahl 1981; Lövei 1989; Jones 1995, 1998; Jones et al. 1996; Hockey 2000). The annual north-south movement of the Inter-tropical Convergence Zone across Africa causes rainfall patterns to shift across the continent, with the north receiving most precipitation during the months of May through November and the south during the months of November through April. As rainfall increases, plant productivity and insect abundance increase sharply, thus providing insectivorous birds with a rich food supply. It is generally assumed that this superabundant food source cannot fully be exploited by resident birds, which then can be used by migrant birds (Pearson and Lack 1992; Jones 1995; Hockey 2000; Hurlbert and Haskell 2003). To possibly reflect these habitat preferences of migrants, we chose to develop environmental GIS layers that presumably reflect the migrants’ preference for open habitats with pronounced environmental and seasonal variation.
Methods
Data acquisition
To acquire information about the winter distribution of Palearctic migratory birds in Africa, we contacted over 200 individuals or organisations plus all ringing schemes within Europe through EURING and in Africa that we knew of requesting data or references. Almost 100 people and, with the approval and support of EURING, almost all ringing schemes responded and sent data and references (see Acknowledgements). These data were entered into an Access database currently containing about 60,000 distributional records. Each record contains the species name, habitat, date, and locality (plus additional information not used in this paper). The geographical coordinates of each locality were established as follows: if the source did not provide coordinates, we consulted the Times Atlas (Bartholomew 1956), various other printed gazetteers, or the internet-based gazetteer of the National Imagery and Mapping Agency (2003). If these gazetteers provided better coordinates, we corrected the coordinates provided by the original sources.
Environmental data layers
Inductive models of species distributions require environmental data layers that contain the values (e.g. degree temperature in Celsius) of environmental variables for the study area. For our layers, we chose to divide the African continent into grid cells of 0.05° resolution. Each data layer was generated at the same resolution using Arc/Info 8.0. The following layers were developed and used.
Average temperature of the coldest month
We calculated average temperature of the coldest month from the monthly minimum temperature layers provided by the Centre for Resources and Environmental Studies (CRES) (Hutchinson et al. 1996). The CRES dataset provides average minimum monthly temperatures interpolated from 1,504 meteorological stations based on 60-year mean (1920–1980) interpolated estimates. We kept the data at their original spatial resolution of 0.05° and calculated this variable layer using an ARC/INFO script.
Elevational range
We calculated elevational range within each 0.05° grid cell from the 1-km resolution digital elevation model provided by CRES which is based on 1:1 million scale air navigation charts with a standard error for elevation ranging between 20 and 150 m. We then calculated this layer as the maximum minus minimum elevation within 0.05° grid cells.
Habitat heterogeneity
We calculated habitat heterogeneity from the 1-km resolution University of Maryland Global Land Cover Facility map which is based on Advanced Very High Resolution Radiometer (AVHRR) and categorises the landscape into 13 broad categories (evergreen needleleaf forest, evergreen broadleaf forest, deciduous needleleaf forest, deciduous broadleaf forest, mixed forest, woodland, wooded grassland, closed shrubland, open shrubland, grassland, cropland, bare ground, and urban and built up) (http://glcf.umiacs.umd.edu). The resulting grid shows the number of land cover categories within each 0.05° pixel (range 1–8).
Percent forest cover
We calculated percent tree cover from the Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer (MODIS) satellite 500-m Global Vegetation Continuous Fields dataset (Hansen et al. 2002, 2003). This dataset provides percent tree cover as estimated from satellite imagery collected from 31 October 2000 to 9 December 2001. MODIS data yield greater spatial detail in the characterisation of tree cover compared to past efforts using AVHRR data, and initial validation efforts show a reasonable relationship between the MODIS estimated tree cover and tree cover from validation sites (Hansen et al. 2002, 2003). We resampled the original 500 m resolution dataset to 0.05 degree resolution with Arc/Info Grid 8.0.
Modelling species distribution
We modelled species distributions using BIOCLIM (Busby 1991; Doran and Olsen 2001) and the environmental layers described above. BIOCLIM identifies values for each environmental layer that coincide with the species’ point-locality records to calculate environmental envelopes. These environmental envelopes are defined by percentile limits that exclude the extremes of the distribution. For example, the 95% environmental envelope excludes the lower and upper 2.5% of the records from each tail of each environmental variable’s distribution, while the 100% envelope is the most inclusive using all records (Nix 1986). BIOCLIM then uses the environmental envelopes to map the potential distribution of the species by assessing whether each cell across the study area is inside or outside the envelope. Because climatic models often overpredict species distributions, many researchers limit the amount of overprediction by clipping the predicted distributions with the boundaries of vegetation maps that coincide with species locality records. For this purpose, we used a GIS layer containing ecoregion polygons for all of Africa (Burgess et al. 2004) which we used to clip the distribution made by the BIOCLIM model thus producing a refined map of the species’ distribution.
Results
Known migration, winter distribution and habitat of the Basra reed warbler
The migration and winter distribution of the Basra reed warbler was previously described by Pearson (1982), Pearson et al. (1978, 1988), and Pearson and Lack (1992). Table 1 presents all African localities where Basra reed warbler has been recorded that we are aware of, and Table 2 summarises these records by country and month (see also Fig. 1). The Basra reed warbler usually reaches Sudan and Ethiopia in August, peaks there in September and continues migrating through until October (although it was also recorded at Dar es Salaam, Tanzania from August to October). It usually reaches Somalia, Uganda, Kenya and Tanzania in November, with the peak at Ngulia station (whose records make up more than 80% of all Kenyan records) in December. Much further south, some individuals already reach Malawi and Mozambique in November and December. During January and February, the Basra reed warbler has regularly been recorded in Kenya, Tanzania and Malawi. The few records for Mozambique, Botswana and South Africa for this time period could either be vagrant records or perhaps represent the extreme southern extent of the wintering range. During March and April, the Basra reed warbler seems to return swiftly to its breeding grounds in Iraq, passing through Mozambique, Malawi, Zambia, Tanzania, Kenya, Somalia and Djibouti.
On migration, the Basra reed warbler was observed in low reeds above water (Nikolaus 1979), mangroves and gardens (Nikolaus 1981, 1983a). All wintering areas are below 1,000 m (Urban et al. 1997). In Somalia, the Basra reed warbler was found in man-made lakes entirely overgrown with dense 3 to 4-m high Typha sp. stands (Ash and Miskell 1981). In Uganda and Kenya, it overwinters in coastal scrub consisting of 1–2 m high dense Suaeda monoica saltbushes and moist dense green thickets (e.g. Terminalia) with tall rank grass and sedges near or over wet or drying ditches, swamps, lakes and flood pools, often seasonally inundated with brackish water, with a density of 10–20 birds per hectare, and occasionally in herbaceous woodland undergrowth (Pearson 1972b, 1982; Pearson et al. 1978; Britton 1980; Urban et al. 1997). It is also found in flooded grassland, papyrus swamp (Tyler et al. 1991), river vegetation and woodland thickets (Lack 1985). In Malawi, the Basra reed warbler is typically observed in dense long grass, Combretum-Commiphora thickets, Typha sp. bulrush vegetation near ponds, and sometimes in more open vegetation, e.g. in a Morus nigra mulberry tree in a garden (Hanmer 1979). Newman et al. (1992) reported it in reed marshes, long rank grass, and, perhaps surprisingly, often in dry thickets away from water. In Tanzania, Zambia, Mozambique and Botswana, it was found in wet coastal scrub (Neil Baker, personal communication), Phragmites reedbeds (Hustler 1998), reeds and scrub thickets (Hanmer 1976b), riverine thickets (record from Luia River provided by Vincent Parker, personal communication), and Typha sp. swamps near sewage lagoons (Tyler et al. 1997), respectively.
Predicted winter distribution of the Basra reed warbler
Given the paucity of information about the migration of the Basra reed warbler, any arbitrary decision about which records to include or not would appear to be haphazard. Therefore, we chose fixed time periods as the most unambiguous way to select records. We defined three wintering periods: (1) all records from November and December (even though some of those may involve migratory individuals), (2) all records from January and February (excluding the Botswana and South African records as vagrants because currently these records appear to be rare incidences of individuals overshooting their wintering range, but see Discussion), and (3) all records from November through February (i.e. periods 1 and 2 together). If several records came from the same locality, we only used the locality once in the analyses, so that each locality had equal weight.
The predictions using the four GIS layers (average temperature of the coldest month, elevational range, habitat heterogeneity, percent forest cover) as predictors suggest that suitable locations for wintering Basra reed warblers should be found in a belt all across Africa from Senegal to Ethiopia, and then circling the Congo basin and stretching down the Indian Ocean coastline all the way to South Africa (Fig. 2a). The predictions for the three wintering periods were so similar that we consider all records from November through February from here on. The predictions shown in Fig. 2a are a clear example of overprediction in which the BIOCLIM model predicts all suitable areas in Africa, even such areas that for historical or biogeographical reasons are most likely never used by the species. To restrict our predictions, we therefore clipped our map using the African ecoregion layer. All ecoregions with no point-locality records of the Basra reed warbler were excluded from the predictions, yielding a much more restricted prediction for southeastern Africa (Fig. 2b). This much more realistic map predicts wintering areas for the Basra reed warbler along the Indian Ocean coastline from southern Somalia down to eastern South Africa and includes inland areas in southern Sudan, Uganda, Kenya, Rwanda, Burundi, Tanzania, southern Zaire (now Democratic Republic of the Congo), eastern Zambia and Zimbabwe, Malawi, Mozambique and Swaziland. The highest prediction values are naturally found in southern Kenya and Tanzania, from which most records originate. Interestingly, most southern vagrant records from Botswana and South Africa are also included in this prediction.
Known migration, winter distribution and habitat of the cinereous bunting
The migration and winter distribution of the cinereous bunting was previously described by Chappius et al. (1973) and de Knijff (1991). Since this study focuses on the African continent, we did not attempt to map the winter distribution on the Arabian peninsula. Table 3 presents all African records of the cinereous bunting that we are aware of (see also Fig. 3a). Four records are migratory records from the Sinai peninsula, from where both subspecies have been recorded. The only other Egyptian record, from Jebel Elba, is most likely fraudulent and should be disregarded (see Table 3). The African winter distribution thus contracts to areas close the Sudanese and Eritrean coast (three and five localities, respectively). Except for one record of the subspecies cineracea from 1903, all African wintering records so far pertain to the subspecies semenowi. Since all Sudanese records are either from September or April, the true wintering range may even contract further to just Eritrea where the species has been observed in October, November, February and March. The whereabouts of the species during December and January remain unknown.
The first habitat descriptions are given by Smith (1957) who observed the species on “rocky ground, short grass”. In consultation with Smith, Moreau (1972) described the coastal habitat below 300 m as consisting “mainly of sandy or gravelly plains with a cover of short grass or the taller clumps of Panicum turgidum”. He added that the open plains are interspersed with Acacia belts, rocky hills, channels with some food cultivation and fringed with Tamarix, Salvadora and Zizyphus trees. Urban and Brown (1971), without citing original references, defined the habitat as either nearly naked rock desert, open desert with annual grass or semi-desert savanna with Acacia and Chrysopogon below 1,200 m. The 1981 and 1982 records from Erkowit consist of birds netted along a dry wadi bordered by flowering Acacia trees and bushes where some waterholes with fresh water were available (G. Nikolaus, personal communication). Prendergast (1985) added that the surrounding country was bare rock and brown earth apart from some scattered drought-resistant vegetation so that the trees in the wadi “were probably the most inviting sights that many of the migrants had seen since they had set out”. The Khor Arba’at site was a small garden on a small island in a normally dry 500-m wide river bed (Nikolaus 1983a). The vegetation consisting of Niem, lime and guava trees, date palms, Henna bushes, and grass (G. Nikolaus, personal communication) provided the only concentrated green vegetation for many kilometers, thus appearing almost like an oasis.
Predicted winter distribution of the cinereous bunting
We define the wintering grounds of the cinereous bunting as the five Eritrean localities (Table 3), assuming that all Sudanese records are of individuals still on migration (see above). If several records came from the same locality, we only used the locality once in the analyses, so that each locality had equal weight.
The predictions using the four GIS layers (tree cover, average temp of coldest month, habitat heterogeneity, elevational range) as predictors suggest that suitable locations for wintering cinereous buntings should be found mostly on the plains and hills along the Red Sea coasts in southern Egypt, Sudan, Eritrea, Ethiopia and Sudan (Fig. 3b). A few inland areas in Sudan, Ethiopia and Kenya are also predicted as suitable.
Discussion
The Basra reed warbler and the cinereous bunting are classified as endangered and near-threatened, respectively (BirdLife International 2004). There is clearly a paucity of information concerning the migration and wintering areas of these two species. We hope that by using point-locality records of wintering sites and inductive modelling to predict the wintering distribution of these two species, we have shed more light on the African migration and wintering areas of these two species (noting that the cinereous bunting also winters in the southern Arabian peninsula).
The predicted distributions pinpoint areas that may have remained undersampled and thus guide fieldworkers to potentially promising areas for future exploration. For the cinereous bunting, the most promising areas are clearly the plains and hills along the Red Sea coasts in southern Egypt, Sudan, Eritrea, Ethiopia and Sudan, especially for the months of December and January for which no records exist. We know that an ongoing atlas project (Ash and Atkins: Birds of Ethiopia and Eritrea) will probably close some of these sampling gaps.
Despite a much larger number of records, sampling gaps certainly exist for the Basra reed warbler, too. Besides possible records for Ethiopia and Eritrea, records from Northern Mozambique are certainly missing because of the minimal exploration this part of the country has seen so far (Vincent Parker, personal communication). The most promising areas for future fieldwork as regards the Basra reed warbler are probably low-lying areas (below 1,000 m) near the coastline, e.g. flooded grasslands, pools, lakes, marshes, swamps, and ditches overgrown with reeds (especially Typha stands), tall rank grass and sedges, mangroves, coastal and riverine scrub, and garden and woodland thickets. Especially coastal areas in Mozambique, but perhaps also suitable inland areas in Uganda, Tanzania and eastern Zambia and Zimbabwe, could yield additional records. Two ongoing atlas projects have yielded no records for Zambia, but at least 16 sites in central and southern Malawi (Robert Dowsett, unpublished data not included in our analyses). Coastal areas in South Africa may also yield additional records, but given the low number of existing records (Table 2), most individuals probably do not migrate that far south, but go no further than Malawi and northern Mozambique. However, given the low density of field workers, the Botswana and South Africa records may not be of vagrants, but part of a genuine wintering population. Further field observations in these parts of Africa are clearly needed, and we hope that our results will stimulate further investigations.
Besides the available point-locality data, inductive models are of course also influenced by the environmental layers used in the prediction. Our environmental GIS layers hopefully reflect the overall preference of migrants for open habitats with pronounced environmental and seasonal variation (see Introduction), but of course other layers (e.g. variance of temperature or NDVI) may have yielded somewhat different predictions. However, we took great care to choose environmental variables that reflect what is generally known about the habitat preferences of migrants (Moreau 1972; Curry-Lindahl 1981; Lövei 1989; Pearson and Lack 1992; Jones 1995, 1998; Jones et al. 1996; Hockey 2000), and more details are provided in a forthcoming publication (Wisz et al., in preparation). Naturally, a GIS layer containing marshy vegetation would greatly improve our predictions for the Basra reed warbler, but such specific and fine-grained GIS layers are unfortunately not yet available.
We could have clipped the predicted distribution map for the Basra reed warbler with the Central Zambezian Miombo Woodland, Southern Miombo Woodland and Zambezian and Mopane Woodland ecoregions (see Burgess et al. 2004) which would have resulted in excluding southern Zaire, eastern Zambia, Zimbabwe and Tanzania, Malawi, western Mozambique, and Swaziland from our prediction to get an even more restricted version of Fig. 2b. However, even if the Basra reed warbler does not occur in these ecoregions, for conservation purposes it was important to keep all conceivable areas in our prediction. Different inductive algorithms such as GARP (Joseph and Stockwell 2000; Peterson 2001; Peterson et al. 2002), PCA (Robertson et al. 2001) or logistic regression (Brito et al. 1999) may also have yielded somewhat different predictions. However, some of these alternative algorithms have minimal sample size requirements, are sensitive to multi-collinearity of the predictor variables, and/or assign weights to each of the predictor variables based on their explanatory power. Considering our small sample size we decided to use the BIOCLIM algorithm because it does not suffer from any of these drawbacks.
This desk study clearly showed that more fieldwork is needed to close the painful gap in the knowledge about the wintering sites of the Basra reed warbler and the cinereous bunting. It is certainly difficult to find these species in Africa, but the results from this study hopefully narrow down the areas and the habitats in which to look for them.
References
Ash JS (1978) A Basra reed warbler Acrocephalus arundinaceus griseldis in Mozambique. Bull Br Ornithol Club 98:29–30
Ash JS (1981) Bird-ringing results and ringed bird recoveries in Ethiopia. Scopus 5:85–101
Ash JS, Miskell JE (1981) Basra reed warblers Acrocephalus griseldis overwintering in Somalia. Scopus 5:81–82
Ash JS, Miskell JE (1998) Birds of Somalia. Pica, Yale
Backhurst GC, Pearson DJ (1977) Southward migration at Ngulia, Tsavo, Kenya. Scopus 1:12–17
Backhurst GC, Pearson DJ (1979) Southward migration at Ngulia, Tsavo, Kenya 1978/79. Scopus 3:19–25
Backhurst G, Pearson DJ (1980) Southward migration at Ngulia, Tsavo, Kenya 1979/80. Scopus 4:14–20
Backhurst GC, Pearson DJ (1981) Ringing and migration at Ngulia, Tsavo, November 1980 – January 1981. Scopus 5:28–30
Backhurst GC, Pearson DJ (1983a) Ringing and migration at Ngulia, Tsavo, November–December, 1981. Scopus 5:166–167
Backhurst GC, Pearson DJ (1983b) Ringing and migration at Ngulia, Tsavo, October to December 1982. Scopus 6:144–145
Backhurst GC, Pearson DJ (1984) Ringing and migration at Ngulia, Tsavo, autumn 1983. Scopus 7:136–138
Backhurst GC, Pearson DJ (1987) Ringing and migration Ngulia, Tsavo, autumn 1985. Scopus 9:160–162
Backhurst GC, Pearson DJ (1988) Ringing and migration at Ngulia, Tsavo, autumn 1986. Scopus 10:133–135
Backhurst GC, Pearson DJ (1989) Ringing and migration at Ngulia, Tsavo, autumn 1987. Scopus 11:120–122
Backhurst GC, Pearson DJ (1990) Ringing and migration at Ngulia, Tsavo, autumn 1988. Scopus 12:127–129
Backhurst GC, Pearson DJ (1991) Ringing and migration at Ngulia, Tsavo, 1989–90 autumn. Scopus 13:181–183
Backhurst GC, Pearson DJ (1992) Ringing and migration at Ngulia, Tsavo, autumn 1990. Scopus 14:159–164
Backhurst GC, Pearson DJ (1993) Ringing and migration at Ngulia, Tsavo, autumn 1991. Scopus 15:172–177
Backhurst G, Pearson D (1994) Ngulia Ringing Group (Kenya) - autumn 1993. Bull Afr Bird Club 1:8
Backhurst G, Pearson D (2000) Ngulia 1999—another record season. Kenya Birds 8:24–26
Backhurst GC, Britton PL, Mann CF (1973) The less common Palaearctic migrant birds of Kenya and Tanzania. J East Afr Nat Hist Soc Nat Mus 140:1–38
Backhurst GC, Kelsey MG, Pearson DJ (1986) Ringing and migration at Ngulia, Tsavo, autumn 1984. Scopus 8:128–130
Baha El Din SM (1992) Ornithological news from Egypt. Courser 3:59–67
Bartholomew J (ed) (1956) The Times atlas of the world, vol IV. Times Publishing, London
Benson CW (1944) Notes from Nyasaland. Ibis 86:445–480 (amended 1945:602, and 1947:359)
Benson CW, Benson FM (1977) The birds of Malawi. Montfort, Limbe, Malawi
Bibby CJ (2003) Conservation of migratory birds. In: Berthold P, Gwinner E, Sonnenschein E (eds) Avian migration. Springer, Berlin New York Heidelberg, pp 407–420
BirdLife International (2004) Threatened birds of the world 2004. CD-ROM. BirdLife International, Cambridge, UK
Boothroyd B (1987) The attraction of Palaearctic migrants to lights at Kiambere, Kenya. Scopus 11:38–41
Brito JC, Crespo EG, Paulo OS (1999) Modelling wildlife distributions: logistic multiple regression vs overlap analysis. Ecography 22:251–260
Britton PL (1978) The Andersen collection from Tanzania. Scopus 2:77–85
Britton PL (1980) Birds of East Africa: their habitat, status and distribution. East African Natural History Society, Nairobi, Kenya
Britton PL (1981) Notes on the Andersen collection and other specimens from Tanzania housed in some West German museums. Scopus 5:14–21
Britton PL, Britton HA (1977) An April fall of Palaearctic migrants at Ngulia. Scopus 1:109–111
Brown LH, Urban EK, Fry CH, Newman K (1982) The birds of Africa, vol I. Academic Press, London
Bruun B (1984) Cinereous bunting Emberiza cineracea in Egypt. Courser 1:44–46
Burgess ND, D’Amico Hales J, Underwood E, Dinerstein E, Olson D, Itoua I, Schipper J, Ricketts T, Newman K (2004) Terrestrial ecoregions of Africa and Madagascar: a conservation assessment. Island Press, Washington DC, USA (In press)
Busby JR (1991) BIOCLIM—a bioclimatic analysis and prediction system. In: Margules CR, Austin MP (eds) Nature conservation: cost effective biological surveys and data analysis. CSIRO, Canberra, Australia, pp 64–68
Chappius C, Heim de Balsac H, Vielliard J (1973) Distribution, reproduction, manifestations vocales et affinités du Bruant cendré, Emberiza cineracea. Bonn Zool Beitr 24:302–316
Clancey PA (1975) Miscellaneous taxonomic notes on African birds XLII. The great reed warbler Acrocephalus arundinaceus (Linnaeus) in the South African sub-region. Durban Mus Novit 10:231–238
Corsi F, de Leeuw J, Skidmore A (2000) Modeling species distribution with GIS. In: Boitani L, Fuller TK (eds) Research techniques in animal ecology: controversies and consequences. Columbia University Press, New York, pp 389–434
Cramp S (1998) The complete birds of the Western Palearctic on CD-ROM. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Crick HQP, Jones PJ (1992) The ecology and conservation of Palaearctic-African migrants. Ibis 134 [suppl] :1–132
Curry-Lindahl K (1981) Bird migration in Africa. Academic Press, London, UK
Cyrus DP (1986) First record of Basra reed warbler in southern Africa. Ostrich 57:112–114
Dal-Fiume C (1907) Catalogo di una collezione di uccelli della Colonia Eritrea. Atti Soc Ital Sci Nat Milano 46:73–103
Doran B, Olsen P (2001) Customizing BIOCLIM to investigate spatial and temporal variations in highly mobile species. In: Proc 6th Int Conf GeoComputation. Pullar, University of Queensland, Brisbane, Australia
Douthwaite RJ, Miskell JE (1991) Additions to Birds of Somalia, their habitat, status and distribution (Ash & Miskell 1983). Scopus 14:37–60
Dowsett RJ, Backhurst GC, Oatley TB (1988) Afrotropical ringing recoveries of Palaearctic migrants 1. Passerines (Turdidae to Oriolidae). Tauraco 1:29–63
Franco AMA, Brito JC, Almeida J (2000) Modelling habitat selection of common cranes Grus grus wintering in Portugal using multiple logistic regression. Ibis 142:351–358
Friedmann H, Loveridge A (1937) Notes on the ornithology of tropical East Africa. Bull Mus Comp Zool Harv Univ 81:1–413
Fry CH, Keith S, Urban EK (1988) The birds of Africa, vol III. Academic Press, London
Fry CH, Keith S, Urban EK (2000) The birds of Africa, vol VI. Academic Press, London
Fry CH, Keith S, Urban EK (2004) The birds of Africa, vol VII. Academic Press, London
Goodman SM, Meininger PL (1989) The birds of Egypt. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Grote H (1930) Wanderungen und Winterquartiere der paläarktischen Zugvögel in Afrika. Mitt Zool Mus Berlin 16:1–116
Glutz von Blotzheim UN (2001) Handbuch der Vögel Mitteleuropas (CD-ROM). Aula, Wiesbaden
Hanmer DB (1976a) Migrant warblers in the lower Shire Valley of Malawi. Safring News 5:21
Hanmer DB (1976b) Birds of the lower Zambezi. Southern Birds 2:1–66
Hanmer DB (1979) A trapping study of Palaearctic passerines at Nchalo, southern Malawi. Scopus 3:81–92
Hanmer D (1994) The distribution of Basra reed warblers. WBC News 167 (December):14
Hansen M, DeFries R, Townshend JRG, Sohlberg R, Dimiceli C, Carroll M (2002) Towards an operational MODIS continuous field of percent tree cover algorithm: examples using AVHRR and MODIS data. Remote Sensing Environ 83:303–319
Hansen MC, DeFries RS, Townshend JRG, Carroll M, Dimiceli C, Sohlberg RA (2003) MOD44B: Vegetation Continuous Fields Collection 3, Version 3.0.0 User guide.http://modis.umiacs.umd.edu/documents/MOD44B_User_Guide_v3.0.0.pdf. Cited 20 April 2004
Hartert E (1903–1923) Die Vögel der paläarktischen Fauna, vols 1–3 und Nachträge. Friedländer, Berlin
Hartlaub G (1891) Ornithologie der östlichäquatorialen Länder und der östlichen Küstengebiete Afrikas. Abhl. naturw. Verh Bremen 12:1–46
Heuglin MT von (1869) Ornithologie Nordost-Afrika’s, der Nilquellen- und Küsten-Gebiete des Rothen Meeres und des nördlichen Somal-Landes, vol 1. Fischer, Cassel, Germany
Hockey PAR (1990) Rare birds in Southern Africa, 1988: sixth report of the SAOS Rarities Committee. Bird S Afr 42:34–38
Hockey PAR (1995) Rare birds in South Africa, 1991–1992. Bird S Afr 47:14–19
Hockey PAR (2000) Patterns and correlates of bird migrations in sub-saharan Africa. Emu 100:401–417
Hogg P, Dare PJ, Rintoul JV (1984) Palaearctic migrants in the central Sudan. Ibis 126:307–331
Hurlbert AH, Haskell JP (2003) The effect of energy and seasonality on avian species richness and community composition. Am Nat 161:83–97
Hustler K (1998) Basra reed warbler at Kazungula. Honeyguide 44:149
Hutchinson MF, Nix HA, MacMahon JP, Ord KD (1996) A topographic and climatic database for Africa—version 1.1. Australian National University. http://cres.anu.edu.au/outputs/africa.html. Cited 20 April 2004
Jackson C (1996) Ngulia records tumble. Kenya Birds 4:58–59
Jackson FJ, Sclater WL (1938) The birds of Kenya Colony and the Uganda Protectorate, vols I-III. Gurney and Jackson, London
Jones PJ (1995) Migration strategies of Palearctic passerines in Africa. Israel J. Zool. 41:393–406
Jones P (1998) Community dynamics of arboreal insectivorous birds in African savannas in relation to seasonal rainfall patterns and habitat change. In: Newbery DM, Prins HHT, Brown ND (eds) Dynamics of tropical communities. 37th Symp Br Ecol Soc Lond 1998, Blackwell Science, Oxford, pp 421–447
Jones P, Vickery J, Holt S, Cresswell W (1996) A preliminary assessment of some factors influencing the density and distribution of palearctic passerine migrants wintering in the Sahel zone of West Africa. Bird Study 43:73–84
Joseph L, Stockwell D (2000) Temperature-based models of the migration of Swainson’s Flycatcher (Myiarchus swainsoni) across South America: a new use for museum specimens of migratory birds. Proc Acad Natl Sci Philadelphia 150:293–300
Keith S, Urban EK, Fry CH (1992) The birds of Africa, vol IV. Academic Press, London
Knijff P de (1991) Little-known West Palearctic birds: cinereous bunting. Birding World 4:384–391
Knox AG (1993) Meinertzhagen, Richard—a case of fraud examined. Ibis 135:320–325
Lack P (1975) Records of “less common Palaearctic migrants” in Tsavo National Park East 1974–75. East Afr Nat Hist Soc Bull. August/September:87–88
Lack PC (1985) The ecology of the land-birds in Tsavo East National Park, Kenya. Scopus 9:2–23, 57–96
Lack PC, Leuthold W, Smeenk C (1980) Check-list of the birds of Tsavo East National Park, Kenya. J East Afr Nat Hist Soc 170:1–25
Logan K (1996) Alethes & akalats: a birding trip to Mozambique. WBC News 172:11–13
Lövei GL (1989) Passerine migration between the Palaearctic and Africa. Curr Ornithol 6:143–174
Madarász J (1915) A contribution to the ornithology of the Danakil-land. Ann Mus Nat Hungary 13:277–300
Meinertzhagen R (1930) Nicholl’s birds of Egypt. London
Moreau RE (1972) The Palaearctic-African bird migration systems. Academic Press, London
Moreau RE, Moreau WM (1937) Biological and other notes on some East African birds. Ibis (14)1:152–174
National Imagery and Mapping Agency (2003) Search: Geographic Names Database (GNDB). http://gnpswww.nima.mil/geonames/GNS/index.jsp. Cited 20 April 2004
Newman K, Johnston-Stewart N, Medland B (1992) Birds of Malawi: a supplement to Newman’s birds of Southern Africa. Southern Book Publishers, Halfway House, South Africa
Nikolaus G (1979) The first record of the Basra reed warbler in the Sudan. Scopus 3:103–104
Nikolaus G (1981) Palaearctic migrants new to north Sudan. Scopus 5:121–124
Nikolaus G (1982) Autumn passage of marsh warbles Acrocephalus palustris and sprossers Luscinia luscinia on the Sudan Red Sea coast. Scopus 6:17–19
Nikolaus G (1983a) An important passerine ringing site near the Sudan Red Sea coast. Scopus 7:15–18
Nikolaus G (1983b) A bird cemetery in the Nubian desert, Sudan. Scopus 7:48
Nix HA (1986) A biogeographic analysis of Australian Elapid snakes. In: Longmore R (ed) Atlas of Australian Elapid snakes. Australian Government Publishing Service, Canberra, pp 4–15
Pearson DJ (1972a) The wintering and migration of Palaearctic passerines at Kampala, southern Uganda. Ibis 114:43–60
Pearson DJ (1972b) Some migrant bird records from the Kampala area, Uganda. East Afr Nat Hist Soc Bull February:27–29
Pearson DJ (1978) East African bird report 1977. Scopus 1:113–154
Pearson DJ (1979) East African bird report 1978. Scopus 2:105–144
Pearson DJ (1980) East African bird report 1979. Scopus 3:105–131
Pearson DJ (1981) East African bird report 1980. Scopus 4:101–122
Pearson DJ (1982) The migration and wintering of Palaearctic Acrocephalus warblers in Kenya and Uganda. Scopus 6:49–59
Pearson DJ (1983a) East African bird report 1981. Scopus 5:129–153
Pearson DJ (1983b) East African bird report 1982. Scopus 6:109–128
Pearson DJ (1984) East African bird report 1983. Scopus 7:105–135
Pearson DJ (1986) East African bird report 1984. Scopus 8:101–123
Pearson DJ (1987) East African bird report 1985. Scopus 9:145–159
Pearson DJ (1989a) Palaearctic migrants in the Middle and Lower Jubba valley, southern Somalia. Scopus 12:53–60
Pearson DJ (1989b) East African bird report 1987. Scopus 11:101–119
Pearson DJ, Backhurst GC (1976) The southward migration of Palaearctic birds over Ngulia, Kenya. Ibis 118:78–105
Pearson DJ, Backhurst GC (1978) Southward migration at Ngulia, Tsavo, Kenya 1977/78. Scopus 2:42–47
Pearson DJ, Lack PC (1992) Migration patterns and habitat use by passerine and near-passerine migrant birds in eastern Africa. Ibis 134 [suppl] :89–98
Pearson DJ, Britton HA, Britton PL (1978) Substantial wintering populations of the Basra reed warbler Acrocephalus griseldis in eastern Kenya. Scopus 2:33–35
Pearson DJ, Nikolaus G, Ash JS (1988) The southward migration of Palaearctic passerines through northeast and east tropical Africa: a review. Proc Pan-Afr Ornithol Congr 6:243–262
Peterson AT (2001) Predicting species’ geographic distributions based on ecological niche modeling. Condor 103:599–605
Peterson AT, Ortega-Huerta MA, Bartley J, Sanchez-Cordero V, Soberón J, Buddemeier RH, Stockwell DRB (2002) Future projections for Mexican faunas under global climate change scenarios. Nature 416:626–629
Prendergast EDV (1985) Bird migration through the Sudan. Adjutant 15:17–18
Reichenow A (1904–1905) Die Vögel Afrikas. Dritter Band. Neumann, Neudamm, Germany
Robertson MP, Caithness N, Villet MH (2001) A PCA-based modelling technique for predicting environmental suitability for organisms from presence records. Div Distrib 7:15–27
Ryall C (1992) Avifauna of Nguuni, near Mombasa, Kenya, between September 1984 and October 1987: part II—Palaearctic species. Scopus 15:84–92
Salathé T (ed) (1991) Conserving migratory birds. International Council for Bird Preservation, Cambridge, UK
Sclater WL, Mackworth-Praed C (1918) A list of the birds of the Anglo-Egyptian Sudan based on the collections of Mr A.L. Butler, Mr A. Chapman, Capt. H. Lynes, R.N. and Major Cuthbert Cristy, R.A.M.C. (T.F.). Part I. Corvidae-Fringillidae. Ibis 60:416–476
Sharpe RB (1888) Catalogue of the Passeriformes or perching birds, in the collection of the British Museum. Fringilliformes: Part III containing the family Fringillidae. Trustees of the British Museum, London
Shelley GE, Sclater PL (1898) On the final collections of birds made by Mr. Alexander Whyte, F.Z.S., in Nyasaland. Ibis (7)4:376–381
Sinclair JC and the Rarities Committee (1986) SAOS Rarities Committee’s annual report. Bokmakierie 38:20–25
Smith KD (1955) Recent records from Eritrea. Ibis 97:65–80
Smith KD (1957) An annotated check list of the birds of Eritrea. Ibis 99:1–26, 307–337
Smith KD (1960) The passage of Palaearctic migrants through Eritrea. Ibis 102:536–544
Someren V van (1929) Notes on the birds of Jubaland and the Northern Frontier. J. E. Afr. Uganda Nat. Hist. Soc. 35:25–70
Someren VGL van (1932) Birds of Kenya and Uganda, being addenda and corrigenda to my previous paper in “Novitates Zoologicae,” XXIX, 1922. Novit. Zool. 37:252–380
Sub-committee of the EANHS Bird Committee (2001) records. Kenya Birds 9:32–38
Turner DA (1977) Some recent records of Palaearctic birds in Kenya and Tanzania. Scopus 1:39–43, 78–81
Turner DA (1991) East African bird report 1989. Scopus 13:137–180
Turner DA (1992) East African bird report 1990. Scopus 14:129–158
Turner DA, Pearson DJ (1988) East African bird report 1986. Scopus 10:118–132
Tyler SJ, Tyler L, Lewis JMS (1991) Birds of Lake Naivasha 1. General studies. Scopus 14:107–116
Tyler SJ, Lewis JMS, Tyler L (1997) First record of Basra reed warbler Acrocephalus griseldis in Botswana. Ostrich 68:44–45
Urban EK, Brown LH (1971) A checklist of the birds of Ethiopia. Addis Ababa University Press, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia
Urban EK, Fry CH, Keith S (1986) The birds of Africa, vol II. Academic Press, London
Urban EK, Fry CH, Keith S (1997) The birds of Africa, vol V. Academic Press, London
Vaurie C (1959) The birds of the Palearctic fauna. A systematic reference: Order Passeriformes. Witherby, London
Walther BA, Rahbek C (2002) Where do Palearctic migratory birds overwinter in Africa? Dansk Ornithol Foren Tidsskr 96:4–8
Zedlitz OG (1910–1911) Meine ornithologische Ausbeute in Nordost-Afrika. J Ornithol 58::290–394, 731–808; 59:1–92, 591–613
Acknowledgements
We thank the many people and institutions who have helped our project called “A database of Western Palearctic birds migrating within Africa to guide conservation decisions” and who are acknowledged on the website http://www.zmuc.dk/VerWeb/STAFF/Bawalther/migratoryBirds-africa.htm. For providing references for this particular study, we specifically thank Linda Birch, Robert Dowsett, Louis Hansen, Sue Robinson, and the librarians at BirdLife International, Cambridge, and the Royal Society for the Protection of Birds, Sandy, especially Ian Dawson and Lynn Giddings. Our thanks also go to Elizabeth and Neil Baker, Robert Dowsett, John Miskell, Gerhard Nikolaus, David Pearson, and Robert Prŷs-Jones, who have shown a special interest in our study and provided very useful data, to Robert Hijmans who greatly helped with GIS applications, and to Andrzej Dyrcz and one anonymous referee for insightful comments. B.A.W. was financed through a two-year Marie Curie Individual Fellowship funded by the European Commission’s “Improving Human Research Potential” programme, administered by the European Commission Research Directorate General in Brussels. C.R. acknowledges the Danish National Science Foundation grant no. I. hr. 21–03–0221 for support.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Communicated by F. Bairlein
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Walther, B.A., Wisz, M.S. & Rahbek, C. Known and predicted African winter distributions and habitat use of the endangered Basra reed warbler (Acrocephalus griseldis) and the near-threatened cinereous bunting (Emberiza cineracea). J Ornithol 145, 287–299 (2004). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10336-004-0036-7
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10336-004-0036-7