Abstract
Saltwater intrusion (SWI) is a type of pollution that adversely affects the quality of groundwater in coastal aquifers. The Nile Delta aquifer (NDA) in Egypt contains a large amount of freshwater. Increasing abstraction from the aquifer and sea level rise have led to an increase in SWI, which has reached up to 100 km inland. Therefore, practical measures are required to prevent further SWI. This study aims to identify an optimal well system to manage the intrusion of saline water in NDA using a number of management systems, including pumping of brackish water, aquifer recharge, and abstraction of the freshwater. SEAWAT code is used to simulate SWI in the aquifer considering different scenarios of pumping and sea level rise. Four scenarios are used to control SWI, including: decreasing pumping from the aquifer, increasing recharge using treated waste water, increasing abstraction of brackish water for desalination, and a combination of these systems. The results showed that increasing recharge could lead to greater retardation of SWI (19.5%) than decreasing pumping (6.2%) and abstraction of brackish water (5.9%). However, a combined well system of pumping, recharge and abstraction is shown to be a more effective tool to control SWI in coastal aquifers, with retardation percentage of 21.3%.
Résumé
L’intrusion d’eau salée (IES) est un type de pollution qui agit défavorablement sur la qualité de l’eau des aquifères côtiers. L’aquifère du Delta du Nil (ADN) en Egypte abrite une part importante d’eau douce. L’augmentation des prélèvements dans l’aquifère et l’élévation du niveau de la mer ont conduit à un accroissement de l’IES, qui s’est étendue jusqu’à 100 km à l’intérieur des terres. Par conséquent, des mesures opérationnelles sont nécessaires pour prévenir une progression de l’IES. La présente étude vise à identifier un dispositif de puits optimisé, destiné à contrôler l’intrusion d’eau salée dans l’ADN, en mettant en œuvre un certain nombre de dispositifs de gestion, incluant un pompage d’eau saumâtre, une recharge de l’aquifère et une extraction d’eau douce. Le programme SEAWAT est utilisé pour simuler l’IES dans l’aquifère, en prenant en compte divers scénarios de pompage et d’élévation du niveau de la mer. Quatre scénarios sont utilisés pour contrôler l’IES, comprenant: décroissance du pompage en aquifère, augmentation de la recharge par de l’eau usée traitée, accroissement de l’extraction d’eau saumâtre pour la désalinisation et combinaison de ces dispositifs. Les résultats montrent que l’accroissement de la recharge pourrait conduire à retarder l’IES davantage (19.5%) que la décroissance du pompage (6.2%) et l’extraction d’eau saumâtre (5.9%). Cependant, un dispositif de puits combinant le pompage, la recharge et l’extraction s’est révélé être un outil plus efficace pour contrôler l’IES dans les aquifères côtiers, avec un taux de retard de 21.3%.
Resumen
La intrusión de agua salada (SWI) es un tipo de contaminación que afecta negativamente a la calidad de las aguas subterráneas de los acuíferos costeros. El acuífero del Delta del Nilo (NDA) en Egipto contiene una elevada cantidad de agua dulce. La cada vez mayor extracción del acuífero y el ascenso del nivel del mar han provocado un aumento de la SWI, que ha llegado hasta 100 km tierra adentro. Por lo tanto, es necesario adoptar medidas prácticas para evitar una mayor SWI. Este estudio pretende identificar un sistema de pozos óptimo para gestionar la intrusión de agua salina en el NDA utilizando varios sistemas de gestión, incluyendo el bombeo de agua salobre, la recarga del acuífero y la extracción del agua dulce. Se utiliza el código SEAWAT para simular la SWI en el acuífero considerando diferentes escenarios de bombeo y ascenso del nivel del mar. Se utilizan cuatro escenarios para controlar el SWI, que incluyen: la disminución del bombeo del acuífero, el aumento de la recarga utilizando aguas residuales tratadas, el aumento de la extracción de agua salobre para la desalinización, y una combinación de estos sistemas. Los resultados mostraron que el aumento de la recarga podía conducir a un mayor retraso de la SWI (19.5%) que la disminución del bombeo (6.2%) y la extracción de agua salobre (5.9%). Sin embargo, un sistema de pozos combinado de bombeo, recarga y extracción se muestra como una herramienta más eficaz para controlar la SWI en los acuíferos costeros, con un porcentaje de retardo del 21.3%.
摘要
咸水入侵 (SWI)是污染类型之一, 会对沿海含水层的地下水质量产生不利影响。埃及尼罗河三角洲含水层(NDA)含有大量的淡水。含水层中开采量的增加和海平面的上升导致了咸水入侵的增加, 已达到内陆100 km。因此, 需要采取措施来防止海水进一步的入侵。本研究旨在通过包括咸水抽取、含水层补给和淡水开采的系列管理措施来确定最佳的井系统来管理尼罗河三角洲含水层的咸水入侵。考虑到开采和海平面上升的不同情景, 采用SEAWAT代码来模拟含水层的咸水入侵。提出控制咸水入侵的四种方案, 包括:减少从含水层的开采量, 利用处理过的废水增加补给量, 增加海水淡化的咸水开采量以及这些方案的组合。结果表明, 增加补给量(19.5%)可能比减小开采量(6.2%)和咸水开采量(5.9%)有更大的咸水入侵阻滞效果。但是, 这几种措施的组合方案在控制沿海含水层咸水入侵更有效, 阻滞百分比为21.3%。
Resumo
A intrusão de água salgada (IAS) é um tipo de poluição que impacta negativamente a qualidade das águas subterrâneas em aquíferos costeiros. O aquífero do Delta do Nilo (ADN), no Egito, contém uma grande quantidade de água doce. O aumento da captação do aquífero e a elevação do nível do mar levaram a um aumento da IAS, que chegou a 100 km no interior. Portanto, são necessárias medidas práticas para evitar mais IAS. Este estudo visa identificar um sistema de poço ideal para gerenciar a intrusão de água salgada no ADN utilizando diversos sistemas de gerenciamento, incluindo bombeamento de água salobra, recarga de aquíferos e captação de água doce. O código SEAWAT é usado para simular IAS no aquífero considerando diferentes cenários de bombeamento e elevação do nível do mar. Quatro cenários são usados para controlar a IAS, incluindo: diminuição do bombeamento do aquífero, aumento da recarga usando água residual tratada, aumento da captação de água salobra para dessalinização, e uma combinação destes sistemas. Os resultados mostraram que o aumento da recarga poderia levar a um maior retardo da IAS (19.5%) do que a diminuição do bombeamento (6.2%) e da captação de água salobra (5.9%). Entretanto, um sistema combinado de bombeamento, recarga e captação de poços demonstrou ser uma ferramenta mais eficaz para controlar a IAS em aquíferos costeiros, com um percentual de retardo de 21.3%.
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
Introduction
The high rate of population growth over the past 100 years has increased the water demand in different areas of the world. The increasing water demand has increased pumping from groundwater aquifers, which has in turn caused saltwater intrusion (SWI) in coastal aquifers. In normal circumstances, freshwater flows in the coastal direction but overpumping may lead to reversal of the flow inland, causing SWI (Bear et al. 1999). Also, there has been significant climate change in the last few decades, which has led to rise in sea levels. The rise in mean sea level may occur due to thermal expansion of seas or melting of glaciers and ice caps. According to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC 1996), over the twentieth century, sea levels have risen about 1–2 cm/year. The expected rise in sea level by the end of the twenty-first century is between 2 and 8.8 cm/year (IPCC Climate Change 2001).
The main causes of saltwater intrusion include overabstraction, changes in groundwater flow, tidal effects, seismic waves, dispersion and sea level rise. One of the main impacts of the sea level rise on coastal regions is increasing SWI. It also has a direct impact on groundwater resources, soil salinity, and agricultural productivity in coastal zones. Saltwater intrusion into coastal aquifers should be controlled in order to protect groundwater resources from deterioration. The control of saltwater intrusion requires keeping an appropriate balance between water abstracted from and recharged to the aquifer (Bear et al. 1999). Different measures to control SWI were presented by Todd (1974) including: decreasing pumping rate, relocation of wells, use of subsurface barriers, natural and artificial recharge, and abstraction of saline water and disposal to the sea.
A number of numerical models have been used to improve understanding of the relevant processes that cause SWI and find appropriate control methods. A large number of studies have investigated saltwater intrusion. However, less research has been carried out to study the control of saltwater intrusion (Abd-Elhamid and Javadi 2008). In this study, a number of effective methods to control SWI are examined and compared including: reducing pumping rates, artificial recharge, abstraction of saline water and a combination of these methods. A comprehensive review of the developed models to study and control SWI is presented in the following.
Reducing abstraction rates aims to obtain a sustainable yield, while using other sources of water to meet the demand for water. The control of SWI has been studied using a number of models by managing the abstraction—e.g. Scholze et al. (2002); Zhou et al. (2003) and Bhattacharjya and Datta (2005). Qahman and Larabi (2004) used the SEAWAT code to study the problem of extensive SWI in the Gaza aquifer, in Palestine. Saltwater intrusion was investigated under different scenarios of abstraction over the study period. The study showed that the aquifer is very sensitive to pumping, which should be managed to protect the aquifer from SWI. Narayan et al. (2006) used various pumping and recharge schemes to determine the current and possible future extent of saltwater intrusion in the Burdekin aquifer in Australia using the SUTRA code.
Artificial recharge helps to raise groundwater levels in aquifers. Surface spread of water from rivers or canals, treated wastewater, and desalinated water are possible sources of water for recharging unconfined aquifers, while recharge wells can be used for confined aquifers. The management of SWI in coastal aquifers using artificial recharge was studied by a number of researchers such as Narayan et al. (2006), Papadopoulou et al. (2005) and Kashef (1976). Mahesha (1996a) simulated the effect of recharge wells on SWI in confined aquifers. Several conditions were studied by changing well spacing and recharge duration. The study showed that spacing of the wells and rate and duration of recharge can decrease SWI by repulsion of the saline wedge.
The abstraction saline water and its disposal to the sea helps to decrease the mass of saline water in coastal aquifers. This method was applied to control saltwater intrusion in coastal aquifers by a number of researchers such as Maimone and Fitzgerald (2001) and Kacimov et al. (2009). Sherif and Hamza (2001) studied the balance between saltwater and freshwater using abstraction of brackish water from the transition zone using a two-dimensional (2D) finite element model. Sherif and Kacimov (2008) examined different pumping scenarios and suggested that pumping brackish water can reduce the intrusion of saline water. The main problem in abstraction of brackish water is that the disposal of the saline water to the sea could affect the marine life, fishing and tourism in these areas (Abd-Elhamid and Javadi, 2008). Johnson and Spery (2001) studied a number of methods to control SWI in different states of the United States of America. In California, the saline water was abstracted and desalinated using reverse osmosis. The treated water was mixed with groundwater to produce an appropriate water quality for domestic use. In Los Angeles, treated waste water was used to recharge the aquifer using a system of wells to protect coastal aquifers from SWI.
A combination of two or more of the aforementioned methods could give a better control of SWI. Different combined methodologies to control SWI in coastal zones were used by a number of researchers—e.g. Zhou et al. (2003); Hong et al. (2004); Narayan et al. (2006); Paniconi et al. (2001); and Barrocu et al. (2004). Mahesha (1996c) used a series of wells for abstracting saline water in combination with freshwater recharge wells. The study indicated that the combination of abstraction and recharge gives better results compared with the abstraction or recharge method, leading to larger spaces between wells and smaller recharge rates. Abd-Elhamid and Javadi (2011) introduced the ADR (abstraction, desalination and recharge) method to control SWI. The ADR method includes abstraction of saline water, desalination and recharge to the aquifer. A finite element model was developed and used to simulate SWI. The results indicated that the ADR method is more effective than the abstraction or recharge method. A simulation-optimization model was developed by Javadi et al. (2012) to control SWI using the combination of the abstraction and recharge techniques. The developed model was applied to a confined coastal aquifer. The results showed that using the combined recharge and abstraction system is significantly more effective in controlling SWI than using abstraction or recharge wells separately. The combination of abstraction and recharge wells gave lower cost and lower salt concentration in the aquifer.
Javadi et al. (2013) used the SUTRA code integrated with a genetic algorithm optimization tool to identify the efficacy of different scenarios of controlling SWI in an unconfined coastal aquifer. The method was based on a combination of abstraction of saline water and recharge of aquifer using surface ponds. The results confirmed that the combined system is more effective in controlling SWI than using separate methods. Javadi et al. (2015) presented a methodology based on the combination of abstraction of saline water and desalination for domestic use, and recharge of the aquifer using treated wastewater. The results showed that this method is effective to controlling SWI and it results in lower salinity and cost.
The Nile Delta aquifer (NDA) in Egypt is subject to severe SWI from the Mediterranean Sea. The NDA is one of the largest aquifers in the world (Sherif and Singh 1999). Water resources in NDA are threatened by the increasing population, overpumping, subsidence, coastal erosion, contamination and salinization. These have led to high risks for water resources in the Nile Delta region and management of water resources has become crucial. Various studies on the NDA have indicated that SWI has been extended to 100 km inland. This aquifer is covered by the delta and has a huge volume of freshwater; however, the quality of the abstracted water is adversely affected by SWI, upconing and contamination. A number of studies have been directed to identify SWI in the NDA using different numerical models—e.g., Farid (1980), 1985); Amer and Farid (1981); Sherif et al. (1990); Darwish (1994); Amer and Sherif (1996)., Sherif and Singh (1999); Saifelnaser and Sherif (2012). Abd-Elaty et al. (2014) studied the effect of sea level rise and climatic change on SWI in the NDA using SEAWAT. The study indicated that SLR reduction in surface-water recharge and increasing abstraction rate have strong impact on groundwater level, but a combination of these scenarios would have larger impact on the aquifer.
Recently, Abd-Elhamid et al. (2019) used SEAWAT code to investigate the possible adverse impact of reducing the flow in the Nile River due to the construction of the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam on the Nile Delta aquifer, Egypt. The results showed that the abstraction rates should be reduced by 60 and 40% by filling the reservoir in 3 and 6 years respectively, to maintain the freshwater body in the Nile Delta aquifer. Abd-Elaty et al. (2019) developed a numerical simulation to investigate the efficiency of physical barriers systems (PBS) for controlling SWI in coastal aquifers. The results showed that the PSB can effectively control SWI whereby the cut-off wall gave higher retardation than subsurface dams. Abd-Elhamid et al. (2020a, b) simulated the effect of aquifer bed slope and seaside slope on SWI due to the possible impacts of SLR, decreasing aquifer recharge by overpumping and reduction in recharge. The results showed that SWI increased by increasing seaside slope and the bed slope toward the seaside while it was decreased by increasing the bed slope toward the land. Abd-Elaty et al. (2020) used SEAWAT code to simulate SWI in GAZA aquifer. Management of SWI in Gaza aquifer was studied using different techniques including recharging the aquifer using treated wastewater and abstraction of saline water. The results showed that the SWI is retarded due to recharge of treated waste water more than abstraction of saline water. Abd-Elhamid et al. (2020a, b) developed a numerical model to investigate and manage SWI in coastal aquifers using coastal earth fill. The results indicated that SWI is decreased by increasing the fill width.
The current study presents a numerical study to control SWI in the NDA using different well systems which has not been studied before. Different scenarios are considered in this study including, decreasing pumping rates, recharging the aquifer using treated wastewater, abstraction of brackish water and combination of these three methods.
Numerical model
In this study, SEAWAT-V4 code was used to simulate SWI and assess different scenarios for controlling SWI in the Nile Delta aquifer. SEAWAT simulates variable-density, transient groundwater flow using MODFLOW and MT3DMS programs. The latest version (SEAWAT-V4) was designed to calculate fluid density, viscosity and heat (Langevin et al. 2007).
Study area
The Nile Delta aquifer is one of the main aquifers in Egypt (Sherif et al. 2012). This study focuses on the middle part of the Nile Delta aquifer (MND) which is considered to be the highest part affected by SWI from the Mediterranean Sea (Fig. 1a). The abstraction rate from this area is very high which has resulted in more SWI in the middle part. The MND is located between latitudes 30°20′ and 31°50’N, and longitudes 30°10’and 31°35′E. It is bounded by the Mediterranean Sea in the north, River Nile to the south and the east and the two branches of the Nile in the west and has an area of 9,000 km2. The stratigraphy of the study area is divided into Pliocene sediments, an upper fluviatile sequence (late Pliocene), and Quaternary (Pleistocene and Holocene) sediments lying over the Pliocene sediments. The sediments constitute variable proportions of sand, clay and gravel with lateral variation and variable thicknesses (Sallouma 1983). The thickness of the Quaternary aquifer varies from 200 m in the south to 1,000 m in the north (RIGW 1992). The main aquifer in the study area is the Quaternary aquifer. The aquifer is composed of loose sand with gravel related to the old litho-facies (Hefny (1980), Sallouma (1983) and Serag El Din (1989)) as shown Fig. 1b (Sakr 2005).
Aquifer geometry
SEAWAT code is used to simulate heads and solute transport in the aquifer. The domain (9,000 km2) is divided into 157 rows and 141 columns with square cells of dimensions 1 km2 (Fig. 2a). The depth was divided into 11 layers with varying depth from 200 m in Cairo to 1,000 m at the sea. The top layer represents clay cap with depth varying from 20 m in the south to 50 m in the north. The other layers representing the Quaternary aquifer are divided into equal thickness. The aquifer is semiconfined due to the top clay layer. Two vertical sections are taken in X and Y directions as shown in Fig. 2b,c.
Boundary conditions
The flow and concentration boundary conditions were allocated to the model with zero constant hydraulic head along the shoreline in the north and a specified head of 16.96 m in the south. The east and west boundaries were assigned according to the water levels in the Damietta and Rosita branches of the River Nile. Burrules Lake was assigned as a water body with zero specified head. A concentration of total dissolved solids (TDS), 40,000 mg/L, was applied along the coastal line, and 35,000 mg/L in Burrules Lake, which receives water from some drainages in the Nile Delta. The initial groundwater concentration was set to zero. The initial values of hydraulic parameters of the aquifer, obtained from previous studies, were used as input to the model.
Hydraulic parameters
The hydraulic parameters of the study area for each layer, including specific storage (Ss), specific yield (Sy), hydraulic conductivity (K) and porosity, were taken from previous studies (e.g., RIGW 1980). The conductivity in the vertical and horizontal directions (Kcv and Kch) for the top layer was taken as 2.50 and 25–55 mm/day respectively (RIGW 1980). The average horizontal hydraulic conductivity (Kh) of the Quaternary aquifer sediments was taken as 75 m/day (RIGW/IWACO 1999). The specific storage and the storativity (S) were 0.20 and 2.5 × 10−3 respectively (RIGW 1980). The longitudinal and lateral dispersivities were taken as 100 and 10 m, respectively, and the diffusion coefficient (D*) as 10−4 m2/day (Sherif et al. 1988). The aquifer recharge ranges from 0.25 to 0.80 mm/day (Morsy 2009).
Figure 3 presents the annual abstraction rates for the Nile Delta aquifer from 1990 to 2016. The abstraction reached 1.60 and 2.60 billion cubic meters (BCM) in 1980 and 1991 (RIGW 1992) and 3.02 and 4.90 BCM in 1999 and 2003 (Morsy 2009). Also, the annual abstraction reached 3.50 BCM in 2003 (RIGW 2003) and 7.00 BCM in 2016 (Molle et al. 2016). Mabrouk (2013) indicated that the abstraction rate of the aquifer increases by 0.10 BCM/year, while the rate increased to 0.20 BCM/year from 2003 to 2010. The total number of pumping wells in the study area (MDA) is 946 (Fig. 4), and the total pumping from the MND aquifer was taken as 2.22 × 106 m3/day (810 × 106 m3/year; Morsy 2009).
Model calibration
The model was calibrated using field data collected by RIGW (2002). The solute transport model was calibrated in two steps. The first step was done for the hydraulic head using the constant density option (visual MODFLOW) through several trials by changing the hydraulic parameters including hydraulic conductivity, which ranges from 0.05 to 0.20 m/day for the clay cap and from 25 to 150 m/day for the Quaternary aquifer. The recharge rate ranged from 36 to 400 mm/year. Readings from 22 observation wells in the study area were used for calibration (see Fig. 5). The field data on hydraulic heads were collected by RIGW in 2002. From the model results the mean and absolute residual mean reached −0.07 and 0.144 m respectively, while the root mean square was 0.153 m and normalized RMS was 1.341%. The calibration target of the model was 10% of the difference between maximum and minimum groundwater heads which is about 1.40 m as shown in Fig. 6.
The second stage was carried out using the variable density option (SEAWAT-V4) for concentration parameters of TDS based on the data collected from a field survey of groundwater quality monitoring wells and the measured salinity values based on RIGW (2002). The initial time was applied as 0.001 day using time step of 200 days while the model reached the steady-state condition after 1,825,000 days. As the head convergence criterion, the tolerance of 1 × 10−7 m was assigned using the preconditioned conjugate gradient (PCG) solver, while the generalized conjugate gradient solver (GCG) was used for the transport equation with a Courant number of 0.75 to limit the time step size with maximum step size of 365 days using the simulation period of 1,825,000 days.
Figure 7a shows the distribution of TDS in the MND with average depth ranging from 675 m in the north to 150 m in the south. The Middle Nile Delta aquifer is subject to severe SWI from the Mediterranean Sea (100-km inland intrusion) as shown in Fig. 7b. From the current model results (base case), the 17,500 mg/L equi-concentration line reached up to 82.75 km from the shoreline, and transition zone was 38 km as shown in Fig. 7c. These results are consistent with field data of SWI in the Nile Delta aquifer presented by Sherif et al. (2012) and Nofal et al. (2015). Moreover the salt mass balance of the aquifer that reached 4.4572 × 1013 kg.
Results and discussion
Different scenarios were studied to investigate SWI in the MND aquifer and to control SWI, as will be discussed in the following sections.
Investigation of SWI in the MND
The SEAWAT code was applied to investigate the intrusion of saline water in the MND aquifer. Different scenarios and their impacts on SWI in the MND are studied including: 0.5-m SLR, 50% increase in the abstraction rate in pumping wells (946 wells), and a combination of these cases.
Scenario 1: sea level rise
In this scenario, the effect of sea level rise is studied, where 0.5-m rise in the sea level is considered at 2050. The results show that SLR of 0.5 m would increase saltwater intrusion as shown in Fig. 8a and the intrusion of the equi-concentration line 17,500 mg/L would reach to 84.25 km from the shoreline.
Scenario 2: increasing pumping rates
Population growth leads to increase in the abstraction from groundwater aquifers. In this scenario, the model was used to assess the impact of increasing pumping rates by 50%. Figure 8b shows that increasing pumping rate by 50% would lead to increase in SWI with the equi-concentration line 17,500 mg/L reaching to 88 km from the shoreline.
Scenario 3: combination of SLR and increasing abstraction rates
In this scenario, the combination of scenarios 1 and 2 (0.5 m SLR and 50% increase in pumping rates) is simulated. The results show that in this case saltwater intrusion increases as shown in Fig. 8a. The intrusion of the equi-concentration line 17,500 mg/L reached 89.50 km from the shoreline. Figure 8b shows that this scenario could result in higher SWI in the MND aquifer than the previous two scenarios.
Control of saltwater intrusion
The numerical model was used to study the control of SWI in the MND using different scenarios including: decreasing pumping rate from the aquifer, increasing recharge to the aquifer, increasing brackish water abstraction from the aquifer, and a combination of these scenarios. A number of wells were assigned to the model to represent recharge and abstraction from the aquifer. The distribution of 111 recharge wells, 159 abstraction wells and the combination are shown in Fig. 9a–c. The distribution of 946 pumping wells is shown in Fig. 4. The results of the four scenarios are presented below and compared with the new position of SWI in the aquifer presented in scenario 3.
Scenario 4: decreasing pumping
It was shown that increasing the pumping rates would increase the intrusion length (scenario 2). To prevent such increase in SWI, the pumping rate from 946 wells in the MND is reduced by 25 and 50% of the total pumping rate (2.22 × 106 m3/day). The results show that the equi-concentration line 17,500 mg/L would reach to 86.50 and 84 km from the shoreline due to reduction of 25 and 50% respectively (Fig. 10a,b). The relation between intrusion length (XT) and reduction of pumping rates from wells can be seen in Fig. 10c. The results reveal that decreasing pumping rate would lead to decrease in seawater intrusion. The relation can be used to determine the intrusion length (XT) knowing the pumping rate.
Scenario 5: increasing recharge
Another scenario is considered to control SWI by recharging treated wastewater to the aquifer using wells. Altogether, 111 wells (150 m deep) in three rows are considered with spacing of 2 and 5 km distance between rows. This water has TDS of 200 mg/L. It is assumed to be taken from treated wastewater treatment. The recharge rate is taken as 125 and 150% of the pumping rate. The results show that intrusion would reach 79 and 72 km from shoreline for the equi-concentration 17,500 mg/L for 125 and 150% increase in recharge respectively (Figs. 10b and 11a). Figure 11c shows the relation between (XT) and increasing recharge rate. The results indicate that increasing recharge rate leads to decrease in seawater intrusion. The relation can be used to calculate intrusion length (XT) knowing the recharge rate.
Scenario 6: abstraction of brackish water and disposal to the sea
This scenario is used to study controlling SWI using 159 abstraction wells (350 m deep) installed in three rows in the north of the region with 2-km spacing and 10-km distance between the rows. The abstraction rate is taken as 125 and 150% of the pumping rate. Figure 12a,b shows that SWI would reach 87 and 84.25 km from the shoreline for equi-concentration line 17,500 for 125 and 150% of abstraction rates, respectively. A relation between the intrusion length (XT) and abstraction rate is shown in Fig. 12c. The relation can be used to calculate the intrusion length (XT) as a function of the abstraction rate. The results indicate that increasing abstraction of brackish water leads to decrease in seawater intrusion.
Scenario 7: combination of scenarios 4, 5 and 6
In this scenario, a combination of the preceding three scenarios including reducing abstraction rate (scenario 4), increasing recharge using treated wastewater (scenario 5) and abstracting brackish water (scenario 6) is applied to control SWI. The reduction in pumping rates can be achieved by a number of measures including—increase the public awareness of the necessity to save water, increase the efficiency of irrigation networks by lining the canals, changing the crop pattern and use new methods for irrigation such as drip irrigation, recycling of agriculture drainage water, reuse of treated wastewater and desalination of seawater. The source of freshwater for recharge can be provided using treated wastewater or collecting the storm water in a drainage system and injecting it to the aquifer to protect the coastal area from flash flooding such as was the case of the city of Alexandria, Egypt, in 2015. The abstracted brackish water or saline water could be desalinated and used for different purposes. The results show that the intrusion could reach 78 and 70.50 km from the shoreline for equi-concentration line 17,500 mg/L for the cases of 125 and 150% change as shown in Figs. 12b and 13a. A relation between intrusion length (XT) and combined scenario is shown in Fig. 13c. The results show that decreasing abstraction of freshwater, increasing recharge and increasing the abstraction of brackish water lead to higher retardation of seawater intrusion. The relation can be used to determine the intrusion length (XT) as a function of the recharge and abstraction rates.
The intrusion length in the MND aquifer due to different scenarios is summarized in Table 1, which shows a comparison between the different scenarios, and salt mass balances in the MND aquifer for different scenarios are summarized in Table 2. The intrusion length reached 82.75 km under the current conditions (base case) which increased to 89.50 km (scenario 3) when 150% increase in pumping rate and sea level rise of 50 cm were considered. Different scenarios were considered to manage saltwater intrusion in scenario 3. The first three single-well systems used in scenarios 4, 5 and 6 to control SWI are capable of reducing the intrusion and moving the transition zone towards the sea. Decreasing pumping rate by 50% (scenario 4) could move the equi-concentration line 175,000 mg/L back 5.50 km (6.2%) towards the sea, whereas increasing recharge by 150% (scenario 5) could move the equi-concentration line 175,000 mg/L back 17.75 km (19.5%) towards the sea. Increasing abstraction of brackish water from the aquifer by 150% (scenario 6) would move the equi-concentration line 175,000 mg/l back 5.25 km (5.9%) toward the sea. However, combination of these three systems (decreasing pumping, increasing recharge and increasing abstraction of brackish water by 150%), which was presented in scenario 7, could move the equi-concentration line 175,000 mg/l back 19 km (21.30%) towards. Scenario 7 is considered the best scenario, as it gives the highest retardation to SWI. In addition to providing higher retardation for SWI, scenario 7 also has some other advantages including: (1) recharging the aquifer using treated wastewater which can help in sustainable management of water resources; and (2) abstracting brackish water that can be desalinated using e.g., solar-powered desalination plants, which can provide an additional source of freshwater to meet part of the water demand that in turn can help to reduce abstraction of groundwater. This method can control SWI and protect the MND aquifer from deterioration.
Conclusion
Saltwater intrusion (SWI) threatens many coastal aquifers in the world. Increasing rates of abstraction of groundwater, climate change and sea level rise have increased the intrusion of saline water into coastal aquifers. Saltwater intrusion control is essential for protection of groundwater storage in coastal areas. The Nile Delta aquifer contains a large quantity of freshwater (400 BCM) but it is subject to severe SWI from the Mediterranean Sea. This paper presented a numerical study to simulate SWI in the Middle Nile Delta (MND) aquifer. The impact of increasing pumping from the aquifer, sea level rise and combination of the two on SWI was studied, which resulted in increasing the intrusion of saline water by 1.50, 5.25 and 6.75 km respectively. Different scenarios were considered to control saltwater intrusion including: decreasing rate of abstraction from the aquifer, increasing recharge using treated waste water, abstraction of brackish water for desalination and combinations of these scenarios. The results indicated that decreasing pumping, increasing recharge and increasing brackish water abstraction (scenarios 4, 5 and 6) can retard saltwater intrusion by 6.2, 19.5 and 5.9%, respectively. However, combination of scenarios 4, 5 and 6 (scenario 7) can lead to further retardation of saltwater intrusion (21.3%). Management of saltwater intrusion in coastal aquifers could protect groundwater reserves that could help countries like Egypt avoid water scarcity.
References
Abdelaty IM, Abd-Elhamid HF, Fahmy MR, Abdelaal GM (2014) Study of impact climate change and other on groundwater system in Nile Delta Aquifer. Egyptian J Eng Sci Technol 17(4):2061–2079
Abd-Elaty I, Abd-Elhamid HF, Nezhad MM (2019) Numerical analysis of physical barriers systems efficiency in controlling saltwater intrusion in coastal aquifers. Environ Sci Poll Res 26(35):35882–35899. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11356-019-06725-3
Abd-Elaty I, Abd-Elhamid HF, Qahman K (2020) Coastal aquifer protection from saltwater intrusion using abstraction of brackish water and recharge of treated wastewater: case study of the Gaza aquifer. J Hydrol Eng 25(7):1–15. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)HE.1943-5584.0001927
Abd-Elhamid HF, Javadi AA (2008) Mathematical models to control saltwater intrusion in coastal aquifer. Proceeding of GeoCongress, New Orleans, LA
Abd-Elhamid HF, Javadi AA (2011) A cost-effective method to control seawater intrusion in coastal aquifers. J Water Resour Manag 25:2755–2780
Abd-Elhamid HF, Abdelaty I, Sherif M (2019) Evaluation of potential impact of Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam on seawater intrusion in the Nile Delta Aquifer. Int J Environ Sci Technol 16(5):2321–2332. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13762-018-1851-3
Abd-Elhamid HF, Abd-Elaty I, Hussain MS (2020a) Mitigation of seawater intrusion in coastal aquifers using coastal earth fill considering future sea level rise. Environ Sci Pollut Res 27:23234–23,245. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11356-020-08891-1
Abd-Elhamid HF, Abd-Elaty I, Sherif MM (2020b) Effects of aquifer bed slope and sea level on saltwater intrusion in coastal aquifers. Hydrology 7(1):5
Amer A, Farid MS (1981) About sea water intrusion phenomenon in the Nile Delta aquifer. Proceedings of the International Workshop on Management of the Nile Delta Groundwater Aquifer. CU/MIT, Cairo
Amer A, Sherif MM (1996) An integrated study for seawater intrusion in the Nile Delta aquifer. Working paper for SRP. NWRC-MPWWR, Cairo
Bear J, Cheng AH, Sorek S, Quazar D, Herrera I (1999) Seawater intrusion in coastal aquifers: concepts, methods and practices. Kluwer, Dordrecht, The Netherlands
Barrocu G, Cau P, Muscas L, Soddu S, Uras G (2004) Predicting groundwater salinity changes in the coastal aquifer of Arborea (central-western Sardinia). Proceedings of the 18th Salt Water Intrusion Meeting, Cartagena, Spain, 31 May–3 June 2004
Bhattacharjya R, Datta B (2005) Optimal management of coastal aquifers using linked simulation optimization approach. Water Resour Manag 19:295–320
Darwish MM (1994) Effect of probable hydrological changes on the Nile Delta aquifer system. PhD Thesis, Faculty of Engineering, Cairo University, Cairo, Egypt
Farid MS (1980) Nile Delta groundwater study. MSc Thesis, Faculty of Engineering, Cairo University, Egypt
Farid MS (1985) Management of groundwater system in the Nile Delta. PhD Thesis, Faculty of Engineering, Cairo University, Egypt
Hefny KH (1980) Groundwater in the Nile Valley (in Arabic). Ministry of Irrigation. Water Research Center, Groundwater Research Inst, Cairo, pp 1–120
Hong S, Park N, Bhopanam N, Han S (2004) Verification of optimal model of coastal pumping with sand-tank experiment. Proceeding of the 18th Salt Water Intrusion Meeting, Cartagena, Spain, 31 May–3 June 2004
IPCC (1996) In: Houghton JT, Meira Fihlo LG, Callander BA, Harris N, Kattenberg A, Maskell K (eds) Climate change: the science of climate change—contribution of Working Group I to the second assessment report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
IPCC Climate Change (2001) In: McCarthy JJ, Canziani OF, Leary NA, Dokken DJ, White KS (eds) Impacts, adaptations, and vulnerability: contribution of Working Group II to the third assessment report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Javadi AA, Abd-Elhamid HF, Farmani R (2012) A simulation-optimization model to control seawater intrusion in coastal aquifers using abstraction/recharge wells. Int J Numeric Analytic Methods Geomech 36(16):1757–1779
Javadi AA, Hussaina M, Sherif M (2013) Optimal control of seawater intrusion in coastal aquifers. International Conference on Computational Mechanics (CM13), Durham, UK, 25–27 March 2013
Javadia AA, Hussaina M, Sherif M, Farmani R (2015) Multi-objective optimization of different management scenarios to control seawater intrusion in coastal aquifers. Water Resour Manage 29:1843–1857
Johnson T, Spery M (2001) Direct potable use of intruded seawater from west coast basin aquifers, Los Angeles country, California. Proceedings of the 1st international conference and workshop on Saltwater Intrusion and Coastal Aquifers: Monitoring, Modelling, and Management, Morocco, April 2001
Kacimov AR, Sherif MM, Perret JS, Al-Mushikhi A (2009) Control of sea-water intrusion by salt-water pumping Coast of Oman. Hydrogeol J 17:541–558
Kashef A (1976) Control of saltwater intrusion by recharge wells. J Irrig Drainage Division 102:445–456
Langevin CD, Thorne DT, Jr., Dausman AM, Sukop MC, Guo W (2007) SEAWAT Version 4: a computer program for simulation of multi-species solute and heat transport. USGS Techniques and Methods, book 6, chap A22, US Geological Survey, Reston, VA, 39 pp
Mabrouk MB, Jonoski A, Solomatine D, Uhlenbrook S (2013) A review of seawater intrusion in the Nile Delta groundwater system the basis for assessing impacts due to climate changes and water resources development. J Hydrol Earth Syst Sci 10:10873–10,911
Mahesha A (1996a) Transient effect of battery of injection wells on seawater intrusion. J Hydraulic Eng ASCE 122:266–271
Mahesha A (1996b) Control of seawater intrusion through injection-extraction well system. J Irrig Drainage Eng ASCE 122:314–317
Maimone M, Fitzgerald R (2001) Effective modelling of coastal aquifers systems. Proceedings of the 1st international conference and workshop on Saltwater Intrusion and Coastal Aquifers: Monitoring, Modelling, and Management, Morocco, April 2001
Narayan KA, Schleeberger C, Charlesworth PB, Bristow KI (2006) Effects of groundwater pumping on saltwater intrusion in the lower Burdekin Delta, north Queensland. CSIRO Land and Water, Davies Laboratory, Townsville, Australia
Morsy WS (2009) Environmental management to groundwater resources for Nile Delta region. PhD Thesis, Faculty of Engineering, Cairo University, Egypt
Molle F, Gaafar I, El-Agha DE, Rap E (2016) Irrigation Efficiency and the Nile Delta Water Balance, Water and salt management in the Nile Delta: Report no. 9, International Water Management Institute and Australian Center for International Agriculture Research, Canberra
Nofal ER, Amer MA, El-Didy SM, Fekry AM (2015) Delineation and modeling of seawater intrusion into the Nile Delta Aquifer: a new perspective. Water Sci 29(2):156–166
Paniconi C, Khlaifi I, Lecca G, Giacomelli A, Tarhouni J (2001) A modelling study of seawater intrusion in the Korba plain, Tunisia. Physics Chem Earth (B) 26(4):345–351
Papadopoulou MP, Karatzas GP, Koukadaki MA, Trichakis Y (2005) Modelling the saltwater intrusion phenomenon in coastal aquifers: a case study in the industrial zone of Herakleio in Crete. Global NEST J 7(2):197–203
Qahman K, Larabi A (2004) Three dimensional numerical models of seawater intrusion in Gaza aquifer, Palestine. Proceedings of the 18th Salt Water Intrusion Meeting, Cartagena, Spain, 31 May–3 June 2004
RIGW (1992) Hydrogeological map of Egypt: map sheet of Nile Delta. Research Institute for Groundwater, National Water Research Center, Kanater El Khairia, Egypt
RIGW (2002) Nile Delta groundwater modeling report. Research Inst. for Groundwater, Kanater El-Khairia, Egypt
RIGW (2003) Monitoring of groundwater microbiological activities in the Nile Delta Aquifer. In: A study completed for the National Water Quality and Availability Management project (NAWQAM). Kanater El-Khairia, Egypt
RIGW (Research Institute for Groundwater) (1980) Projected of the Safe Yield Study for Groundwater Aquifer in the Nile Delta and Upper Egypt, part 1 (in Arabic). Ministry of Irrigation, Academy of Scientific Research and Technology, and Organization of Atomic Energy, Cairo, Egypt
RIGW/IWACO (1999) Environmental management of groundwater resources (EMGR). Final technical report TN/70.0067/WQM/97/20, Research Inst. for Groundwater, Kanater El-Khairia, Egypt
Sakr SA (2005) Impact of the possible sea level rise on the Nile Delta aquifer: a study for Lake Nasser Flood and Drought Control Project (LNFDC/ICC). Planning Sector, Ministry of Water Resources and Irrigation, Cairo
Sallouma MKM (1983) Hydrogeological and hydrochemical studies east of Nile Delta, Egypt, PhD Thesis, Ain Shams Univ., Cairo, 166 pp
Scholze O, Hillmer G, Schneider W (2002) Protection of the groundwater resources of Metropolis CEBU (Philippines) in consideration of saltwater intrusion into the coastal aquifer. Proceedings of the 17th Salt Water Intrusion Meeting, Delft, The Netherlands
Serag El Din HM (1989) Geological, hydrochemical and hydrological studies on the Nile Delta Quaternary Aquifer. PhD Thesis, Mansoura Univ., Mansoura, Egypt
Sherif MM, Hamza KI (2001) Mitigation of seawater intrusion by pumping brackish water. J Transport Porous Media 43(1):29–44
Sherif M, Kacimov A (2008) Pumping of brackish and saline water in coastal aquifers: an effective tool for alleviation of seawater intrusion. Proceedings of 20th SWIM. Naples, FL, June 2008
Sherif MM, Singh VP (1999) Effects of climate change on sea water intrusion in coastal aquifers. Hydrol Processes J 13:1277–1287
Sherif MM, Singh VP, Amer AM (1988) A two-dimensional finite element model for dispersion (2D-FED) in coastal aquifers. Hydrol J 103:11–36
Sherif MM, Singh VP, Amer AM (1990) A note on saltwater intrusion in coastal aquifers. Water Resour Manag 4:123–134
Sherif MM, Sefelnasr A, Javadi A (2012) Incorporating the concept of equivalent freshwater head in successive horizontal simulations of seawater intrusion in the Nile Delta Aquifer, Egypt. J Hydrol 464–465:186–198
Todd DK (1974) Saltwater intrusion and its control. J Am Water Works Assoc 66(3):180–187
Zhou X, Chen M, Liang C (2003) Optimal schemes of groundwater exploitation for prevention of seawater intrusion in the Leizhou Peninsula in southern China. Environ Geol 43:978–985
Funding
The authors would like to thank the Water and Water Structures Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, Zagazig University, for supporting this research.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher’s note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Abd-Elaty, I., Javadi, A.A. & Abd-Elhamid, H. Management of saltwater intrusion in coastal aquifers using different wells systems: a case study of the Nile Delta aquifer in Egypt. Hydrogeol J 29, 1767–1783 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10040-021-02344-w
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10040-021-02344-w