1 Introduction

Every material interacts with light per a ratio of photonic reflection, absorption, and transmission (PRAT) that is characteristic of that material. Most materials have invariant PRAT responses [1]. Some materials display changing PRAT ratios in response to varying photonic or other energy sources [2–4]. A few rare materials change the energy levels of incident photons (conversion-capable) [5, 6]. Typically, conversion-capable materials change material-specific photons to lower energies (Stokes shift, downconversion) [2, 7, 8]. A few engineered conversion-capable materials cause photonic shifts to higher energy levels (upconversion, anti-Stokes shift) through photon–phonon interactions [9–11].

Until the present research, upconversion-capable materials were engineered. Additionally, the anti-Stokes upconversion shifts in these materials were fueled by high temperatures, radioactive elements, heavy metals, high-energy photons, and/or electricity [11–13]. Furthermore, unreflected photonic energy incident on an upconversion-capable material lost at least 50 % of its energy via thermal conversion [14–16].

It will be shown that the constraints of toxicity and thermal loss do not apply to the present research material. In particular, research of the thermal and photonic efficiency of the naturally occurring photonic opal material at upconversion is presented. It will be shown that the examination of upconversion-capable materials under photonic, electronic and thermal (PET) isolation, with controlled access to exogenous energy, can reveal unexpected photon–material interactions that would not necessarily appear otherwise. Furthermore, the results of many types of analyses, including controlled applications of various energy sources, are presented regarding the identification and exploration of the first naturally occurring non-toxic silicate material displaying an anti-Stokes upconversion at ambient conditions.

2 Methods

2.1 Experimental methods

PET isolation provides valuable control over energies that materials could convert into photons. [15–18] Hence, during all phases of this research, scrupulous care was taken to control PET energy sources. None of the tools, furniture, clothing, walls, and materials used during the analyses exhibited PET behaviors that might affect or alter the photonic responses of the specimen. All items used during the analyses were non-responsive to ultraviolet (UV) light in addition to being white or neutral colors in visible light so as to avoid introducing non-native color reflections.

All laser-specimen interactions were conducted aphotonically (a.k.a. total darkness). Aphotonicity was achieved through extensive laboratory preparations and painstaking experimental technique. All light sources in the laboratory were extinguished or blocked, including: LED, starlight, ambient, incandescent, and leakage from other rooms. All laser experiments were conducted after astronomical twilight. Windows and doors were covered with layers of light-blocking materials. Power strips, computers, and all other electrical devices were disconnected from electrical outlets and/or covered with light-blocking materials. Control over the LEDs in the desk-type lamp used during experimentation setup of each laser ensured a virtually instantaneous and complete photonic emission on–off response (e.g., no bulb after-glow when shut off). Preparations continued until the laboratory had no discernible light after a half hour of darkness immersion visibility adjustment. A timer, located in another room, ensured that each experimental observation occurred only after at least 20 min of aphotonicity [19].

In addition to aphotonicity, electrical and thermal energy sources were eliminated and/or controlled. Control was achieved through extensive laboratory preparations and painstaking experimental technique. Three days prior to installing the laser assembly, thermal fluctuations via air flows were eliminated. Obvious sources of air flows (vents, doors, windows) were blocked and/or switched off. Less obvious sources of air flows were identified, then blocked, and/or switched off, by watching a thin smoke plume from a long match. Two days prior to installing the laser assembly, all items in the laboratory were cleaned. All items in the laser assembly were electrically and thermally non-conductive. The specimen and each laser were held in non-conductive holders. The base of the laser assembly was a condensed foam board that was designed to be electrically and thermally non-conductive for electronic components. Enhancing electrical control, the lasers were internally battery powered. The small LED desk-type lamp used during experimentation setup of each laser was the only item in the laboratory that was connected to an electrical outlet. The lamp was located about two meters away from the laser assembly. The lamp was shielded from leaking electrical or magnetic energy with a power cord magnetic wrap. The researcher was electrically grounded and did not touch the specimen, or any part of the laser assembly, during and for at least 20 min prior to each experimental observation. Thermal activity of the specimen and the experimental setup were monitored by an infrared (IR) thermal imager. All instruments, furniture, specimens, and equipment were used in an air environment at ambient temperature, pressure, and humidity. Plus, the physical movement of the researcher was severely limited during laser experimentation to avoid static electricity discharges that may not have otherwise been controlled by grounding.

The laser experiments utilized, independently, three low-power lasers (<5 mW) of differing wavelengths (Table 1). The laser assembly (Fig. 1) was designed to align each laser to be incident on the specimen at the horizontal and vertical midpoints as well as to prevent electrical and thermal conduction to the specimen. The prongs of the specimen holder were positioned so as to not interfere with the laser trajectory.

Table 1 Materials and equipment
Full size table
Fig. 1
figure 1

a Side and top views of the incident laser through the material in the specimen holder. b Laser assembly depiction: support board, laser holder, laser, grasping specimen holder, and walls. Not to scale

Full size image

The spectrophotometer scanned from 400 to 1100 nm wavelengths on the intact specimen (Table 1). Natural materials are rarely uniform molecularly. Non-uniformity can affect spectrophotometric scans. To avoid potential region-limited properties of the research specimen, scans were done multiple times on the specimen in different co-axial positions (Fig. 1).

Additional tests were run on the experimental material. Analytical tests included: refractometer, specific gravity, short-wave ultraviolet (SWUV), mid-wave ultraviolet (MWUV), long-wave ultraviolet (LWUV), thermal conductivity, dichroscope, spectroscope, and polariscope (Table 1). To protect the specimen from damages that might affect its properties, all tests were nondestructive.

2.2 Experimental calculations

Shown in Table 2 the interaction of incident laser photons with the specimen corresponded to a 3.0 upconversion shift multiplicity. Commonly, shift multiplicity is at most 2.0. Also, this material has a 2:3 red-to-violet dispersed anti-Stokes upconversion ( upconvert). This material was analyzed for shift multiplicity and upconversion under PET isolation. All observations occurred at ambient temperature. Measurements revealed no thermal shifts during observations, even after prolonged laser exposures.

Table 2 Speed of light in vacuum is used here
Full size table

3 Results and discussion

In broad-spectrum white light, the research specimen appeared to be a fairly unremarkable form of precious opal (Fig. 2a). It was transparent, nearly colorless, with mild play-of-color and no contra luz. It was an internally flawless, gem-quality cabochon, natural opal specimen.

Fig. 2
figure 2

Natural silicate opal specimen. a in broad-spectrum daylight, and b converting low-power red laser photons into higher-energy violet photons with micro-lasing. Upconversion and micro-lasing are much more pronounced when seen with the eye. (Copyright by Dr. Michelle R. Stem and Dr. Jimmie L. Joseph, used with permission)

Full size image

Calculation of specific gravity (SG) allowed the density and volume of the specimen to be determined (Table 3). The typically accepted range of SG for a natural precious opal is about 1.73–2.3. [20–22] The SG for the present specimen was within the upper limit of that range. Even so, obtaining a stable SG value for opal is often problematic, particularly because the variable water content of opal causes SG fluctuations. Each precious opal incorporates into its structure an amount of H2O that tends to range from 6 to 10 %. Values can vary naturally from this range. Also, individual opals can have fluctuating H2O levels in response to changes in the environment [21]. Obviating hydration stability issues during examination, the specimen was soaked in purified water for about 12 h prior to experimental analyses. After soaking, the specimen was removed from the water and then quickly surface-dried with a clean Kimwipe immediately prior to measurements and observations. Between each analysis, the specimen was returned to the water. No hydrophilic items came into contact with the specimen during analysis. The SG value shows that the specimen was a precious opal with a naturally lower H2O content than most precious opals and/or the opal had a minor amount of denser impurities.

Table 3 Measured, calculated, and observed data of the research specimen
Full size table

As shown in Table 3, thermal conductivity testing identified that the specimen was an amorphous, non-crystalline silicon. The results agreed with expectations. Natural opal is not known to be a good thermal conductor at ambient temperatures [20, 21, 23].

Heretofore, the means to upconvert photons to higher energy required light to be passed through adjacent materials with lower indices of refraction and/or the addition of significant energy (e.g., heat, high-intensity light, radioactivity). However, the present research found that incident red laser photons had an unexpected upconversion response after traversing from air into the research specimen, by interacting with the structure of the specimen while under PET isolation. This photon–material interaction resulted in a highly efficient, dispersed anti-Stokes upconversion [11–13].

Application of the 650 nm laser caused an extremely efficient photonic upconversion with dense, ultra-fine micro-lasing [18] (Fig. 2b). A strong red-to-violet secondary photonic effect (SPE) dispersed evanescent glow of upconverted photons was exhibited over approximately 78 % of the specimen volume. The incident laser light propagated through approximately 17 % of the specimen volume. Approximately 5 % of the specimen volume displayed a blurry red-to-violet transition area between the upconverted and laser propagation areas. The dispersed upconversion was stable over several minutes of constant wave laser exposure with no thermal or other changes in the specimen. Evenly distributed throughout the SPE volume was a dense, ultra-fine lattice of micro-lasing in wavelengths matching those of the corresponding volume areas (e.g., red micro-lasing in red areas, violet micro-lasing in violet areas). The micro-lasing twitched and shifted positions quickly, such that it appeared to dance throughout the specimen in a fairly even distribution.

Typically, a material upconverts an incident laser beam into a different wavelength while maintaining laser propagation and without converting non-laser photons [24]. However, the research specimen displayed an atypical photon–material upconversion response to the 650 nm laser. The incident photonic and propagation energies were dispersed into the specimen via nearly total internal reflection and absorption of the laser light, allowing only a mild, vertical red glow of about 15 × 100 mm on the opposite wall (Fig. 1). Laser propagation intensity decreased mildly as the beam traversed the specimen and ended abruptly at the edge of the specimen (Fig. 2b). Thus, a portion of the incident laser photons were upconverted as a result of the material converting another portion of the incident laser photons into an amplified photon–phonon evanescent energy that was redistributed by internal micro-lasing. Furthermore, phonons appeared to strongly enhance photon anti-propagation, thus contributing to the dispersed character of the upconversion [9, 25].

Application of the 532 nm laser caused all of the specimen to glow green. Evenly distributed throughout the volume was a dense, ultra-fine, dancing lattice of green micro-lasing [18]. The density of the green micro-lasing was lower than the density observed with the 650 nm laser. No coherent laser beam propagated through the specimen. The incident photonic and propagation energies were dispersed into the specimen via nearly total internal reflection and absorption of the laser light, allowing only a mildly glowing area of about 70 mm diameter of green light on the opposite wall. Dispersion was stable over several minutes of constant wave laser exposure with no thermal or other changes in the specimen.

Application of the 405 nm laser caused the specimen to display a thick, even-toned violet-blue glow. The specimen had no micro-lasing or laser beam propagation. Even so, the specimen had a mild photonic texture of numerous tiny sparkling speckles. The evenly distributed speckles seemed to shift position slightly. It is possible that these sparkles were micro-laser bursts that were too short for clear identification. The incident photonic and propagation energies were dispersed into the specimen via nearly total internal reflection and absorption of the laser light. Dispersion was stable over several minutes of constant wave laser exposure with no thermal or other changes in the specimen. It is uncertain if micro-lasing differences correlate to the dispersed upconversion property. While not an exact match to the upconverted red photons, application of a violet laser did not cause a downconversion to red or further upconversion to UV. Thus, the material may have a tight wavelength tolerance to trigger photonic upconversion and a resistance to further conversions.

The research material responded to each of three UV light sources (Table 1). SWUV caused a deep blackish orange glow. MWUV caused a deep orange glow. LWUV caused a transparent yellow glow. Prior to the current research, SWUV and LWUV were the only types of UV light documented as having been applied or shown to elicit photonic responses from opals. UV response in opal is not a common property. This specimen displayed a wider range of visible light photonic responses to the UV lights than was documented before [20, 21] (Table 3).

Figure 3 shows scans of the specimen analyzed length-wise, then rotated 180º, and scanned again covering wavelengths from 400 to 1100 nm. The scan at 0º (scan 1) had greater absorbance levels at all wavelengths than did the scan at 180º (scan 2). The scans had overall absorption slopes that showed an inverse, but not proportionate, correlation with wavelength. As such, the specimen absorbed fewer photons as the wavelengths increased toward red. There were changes in absorption at: 449.9–585.1, 585.1–615.0, 849.5, and 1000–1100 nm. The scans revealed a low maximum absorbance of 0.346 and stepwise absorption increases of 0.019 from 449.9 to 585.1 nm and 0.006 at 849.5 nm. There were only two non-stepwise absorption changes. The first was a small, slightly convex non-sloping absorption change, of about 0.003, from 585.1 to 615.0 nm. The second was a small absorption increase, of about 0.003, from 1000 to the maximum scan range due to water in natural opal. The spectrophotometric analysis agrees with the visible appearance of the specimen as being slightly orange red (Fig. 2a) and able to transmit over violet and UV wavelengths (Fig. 2b).

Fig. 3
figure 3

Spectrophotometric absorption scans of the specimen, with the specimen oriented lengthwise at 0º and 180º to the scanning photon beam. The scan at 0º (scan 1) had greater absorbance values at all wavelengths compared to the scan at 180º (scan 2)

Full size image

The spectrophotometric scans of the specimen revealed a sinusoidal pattern in the absorption levels that was previously unobserved. Sets of three larger peaks, followed by three smaller peaks were repeated across the scanned spectral range, with each set having the same peak height and width. Each set of the larger peaks had wavelengths that totaled 32 nm (±0.25 nm) and peak heights that averaged 0.003. Each set of smaller peaks had wavelengths that totaled 28 nm (±0.25 nm) and peak heights that averaged 0.001. The first apex of the first set of larger peaks appeared at about 420 nm and repeated every 60 nm, until the final appearance at about 960 nm. Calibration and zeroing of the spectrophotometer was redone prior to confirming this sinusoidal pattern via several additional scans. This is the first time that this spectrophotometric pattern was observed or documented [10, 25] (Fig. 3).

For comparative purposes, spectrophotometric scans were run of two visually similar natural opal specimens that did not have upconversion properties. These opal comparatives displayed the same sinusoidal pattern. Thus, the repetitive spectrophotometric pattern was found to be a property of at least some natural opals, not necessarily related to upconversion [9, 10, 25] (Table 2).

Spectrophotometric scans of a silicate glass (SiO2) cuvette, with and without water, were run as comparisons to those of opal (SiO2·nH2O) (Fig. 4). The cuvette was colorless, transparent silicate glass that was designed to hold samples for spectrophotometric analyses. The cuvette lid was not used so as to avoid it possibly affecting the photonic behavior of the cuvette. One scan (scan 1) was run with the empty cuvette and one scan (scan 2) was run with the cuvette filled with H2O.

Fig. 4
figure 4

Spectrophotometric absorption scans of a typical SiO2 cuvette. The mostly flat graph line (scan 1) shows a scan of the cuvette filled with air and the graph line with the large peak (scan 2) shows a scan of the cuvette filled with H2O

Full size image

As expected, the spectrophotometric scan of the empty cuvette had a low, essentially flat absorbance of 0.062. The scan of the water-filled cuvette showed the presence of H2O via a fairly wide, relatively large peak of 0.236 at 973.7 nm and two smaller shoulder peaks at about 738 and 835 nm with a maximum absorbance of 0.045. The shoulder peaks did not appear in the scans of the opal specimen. Hence, the structure of the opal seemed to overcome the effects that H2O had on photons at the shoulder wavelengths. Other than the H2O peaks, the cuvette scan showed virtually no absorbance. Both cuvette scans show extremely small absorbance increases of about 0.001 at 585.1 nm, which matches the wavelength of one of the larger absorption changes of the specimen. Neither of the cuvette scans have the patterned sets of peaks of the opal specimen. Interestingly, water attenuated the absorbance of the empty cuvette by approximately 50 % over all wavelengths (Fig. 4).

The typically accepted refractive index (RI) range for natural precious opal is about 1.41–1.46 [20, 21]. The RI of the specimen was 1.43. RI and other properties, such as play-of-color, confirm that the research specimen is a natural precious opal (Table 3).

The specimen was spectroscopically examined using broad-spectrum white light. The transmission levels increased steadily from red through green photonic frequencies. There were no spectral gaps or lines. There were no spectroscopic transmissions of blue through violet wavelengths. Thus, all blue through violet wavelength photons were absorbed, including the portion of the spectrum into which the specimen upconverted red photons (Table 3).

The dichroscope confirmed that the opal specimen was not dichroic. Ultra-light orange was the only color seen through the dichroscope. The results were in accordance with reported properties of opal. Opal has not been found to be dichroic [20, 21] (Table 3).

As expected, the polariscope showed that the opal was isotropic. Not expected, the polariscope revealed a color changing pattern within the isotropic character. As expected for an isotropic material, the opal remained lit during the complete revolution of the polar grating. The specimen was light blue at maximum grating eclipse and transitioned to being yellow every 45° at no grating eclipse (Fig. 5). Typically, when an isotropic material is rotated in a polariscope and causes the display to show a lighter version of the same color every 45°, the material is designated as being single refractive with anomalous double refraction. However, the present specimen did not just lighten, it changed colors. These polariscope results had not been documented before for opal, or any isotropic specimen.

Fig. 5
figure 5

Depiction of the changing colors of the specimen when rotated in the polariscope

Full size image

4 Conclusions

Arguably, the pinnacle of photonic control materials is opal; so much so that it is used as a template for the most advanced photonic control materials [17, 18, 26, 27]. Even so, the present research revealed a natural, non-toxic SiO2·nH2O material with properties that are exceptions to expected photon–material interactions. Under PET isolation, the material had a dispersed, anti-Stokes, nonlinear 2:3 photonic upconversion response. The specimen upconverted low-power (<5 mW), constant wave, 650 nm red laser photons into dispersed 433 nm violet photons at ambient temperatures (Fig. 2b). Upconversion efficiency was about 78 % by volume with no detectable thermal variance. Incident photons travelled from a lower refractive index (e.g., air), under PET isolation [11–13]. PET isolation ensured that photonic behaviors could only be the result of the interaction of the specimen with the laser and denied the material access to energy responses that might otherwise have been preferred. Hence, evanescent amplification became the preferred photon–phonon energy response [10, 11, 15].

A significant portion of the traversing 650 nm photons were broadly dispersed within the specimen. Essentially all of the dispersed photons were upconverted. Lateral attenuation of the red photons was very low throughout the specimen, resulting in a significant portion of incident photons losing coherence, dispersing, and being upconverted. Attenuation at the laser exit point was so high that nearly total internal reflection occurred, aiding dispersion significantly (Fig. 1a). Simply, the response of the structure of the transparent material to each of the lasers was such that it did not allow the incident lasers to pass through.

A significant portion of incident photons were converted into the energy needed to upconvert the dispersed photons. While the conversion mechanism is not yet fully identified, the extra energy needed for the 2:3 upconversion ratio was likely obtained from an amplification of the non-upconverted portion of the incident laser photons via a photon–phonon evanescence. Amplified photon–phonon evanescence is substantiated by the lack of laser-induced thermal change and the minimal amount of incident laser that passed through the transparent specimen. Furthermore, photon anti-propagation was strongly enhanced by phonons, thus contributing to the dispersed upconversion [9, 25]. In summary, the material used the amplified energy of the red photons to generate dispersed 2:3 red-to-violet upconverted photons at a 3.0 shift multiplicity with a 78 % efficiency by volume (Table 2).

Micro-lasing seemed to act as a form of photonic energy redistribution, resulting in the dispersed upconversion. The density of micro-lasing increased in negative correlation with incident laser frequency. Furthermore, upconversion occurred at the lowest of the three laser frequencies, which correlated to the greatest micro-lasing density (Fig. 6). Micro-lasing may be the physical mechanism through which sufficient energy was distributed to cause upconversion via dispersed evanescent photon–phonon amplification.

Fig. 6
figure 6

Photonic absorption versus micro-lasing density versus incident laser frequencies

Full size image

This research had several unprecedented analytical results. Spectrophotometric, spectroscopic, polariscopic, laser and UV analyses of the research material revealed properties that may be useful for many applications, such as: solar cells, imaging, photsonic-based power transfer, photonic switch, memory, and fiber-optic efficiency. Future research will include using this material as a possible template for engineering advanced photonic materials. The realization of extremely energy efficient upconversion of visible light photons at stable, ambient temperatures, with multi-directionality, while using non-toxic materials may be significant.