Summary
We have independently repeated the computer simulations on which Nei and Tateno (1978) base their criticism of REH theory and have extended the analysis to include mRNAs as well as proteins. The simulation data confirm the correctness of the REH method. The high average value of the fixation intensity μ2 found by Nei and Tateno is due to two factors: 1) they reported only the five replications in which μ2 was high, excluding the forty-five replications containing the more representative data;and 2) the lack of information, inherent to protein sequence data, about fixed mutations at the third nucleotide position within codons, as the values are lower when the estimate is made from the mRNAs that code for the proteins. REH values calculated from protein or nucleic acid data on the basis of the equiprobability of genetic events underestimate, not overestimate, the total fixed mutations. In REH theory the experimental data determine the estimate T2 of the time average number of codons that have been free to fix mutations during a given period of divergence. In the method of Nei and Tateno it is assumed, despite evidence to the contrary, that every amino acid position may fix a mutation. Under the latter assumption, the measure X2 of genetic divergence suggested by Nei and Tateno is not tenable: values of X2 for theα hemoglobin divergences are less than the minimum number of fixed substitutions known to have occurred.
Within the context of REH theory, a paradox, first posed by Zuckerkandl, with respect to the high rate of covarion turnover and the nature of general function sites in proteins is resolved.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Czelusniak J, Goodman M, Moore GW (1978) J Mol Evol 11:67–74
Dayhoff MO, Eck RV, Park CM (1972) Atlas of protein sequence and structure 5:89–99
Dayhoff MO, McLaughlin PJ (1972) Atlas of protein sequence and structure 5:111–118
Dickerson R (1971) J Mol Evol 1:26–45
Fitch W, Markowitz E (1970) Biochem Genet 4:579–593
Fitch W (1971) J Mol Evol 1:84–96
Fitch W (1972) Hematologie und Bluttransfusion 10:177–215
Fitch W (1976) J Mol Evol 8:13–40
Hewett-Emmett D, Cook CN, Barnicot NA (1976) Old world monkey hemoglobins: Deciphering phylogeny from complex pattems of molecular evolution. In: Goodman M, Tashian R, Tashian J (eds) Molecular anthropology. John Wiley, New York, p 257
Holmquist R (1972 a) J Mol Evol 1:211–222
Holmquist R (1972 b) J Mol Evol 1:115–133
Holmquist R (1973) J Mol Evol 2:145–148
Holmquist R (1976 a) J Mol Evol 8:337–349
Holmquist R (1976 b) Random and nonrandom processes in the molecular evolution of higher organisms. In: Goodman M, Tashian RE, Tashian JH (eds) Molecular anthropology. Plenum Press, New York, p 89
Holmquist R (1978 a) J Mol Evol 12:17–24
Holmquist R (1978 b) J Mol Evol 11:361–374
Holmquist R (1978 c) J Mol Evol 11:349–360
Holmquist R (1979 a) J Mol Evol 13:173–178
Holmquist R (1979 b) Science 203:1012–1014
Holmquist R (1980) J Mol Evol 15:149–159
Holmquist R, Pearl D (1980) J Mol Evol 16:211–267
Holmquist R, Jukes TH, Moise H, Goodman M, Moore GW (1976) J Mol Biol 105:39–74
Holmquist R, Cantor C, Jukes TH (1972) J Mol Biol 64:145–161
Jukes TH, Cantor C (1969) Evolution of protein molecules. In: Munro HN (ed) Mammalian Protein Metabolism III. Academic Press, New York, p 21
Jukes TH, Holmquist R (1972) J Mol Biol 64:163–179
Jukes TH, Holmquist R, Moise H (1975) Science 189:50–51
Karon J (1979) J Mol Evol 12:197–218
Kimura M (1977) Nature 267:275–276
Kimura M, Ohta T (1972) J Mol Evol 2:87–90
Moore GW, Goodman M, Callahan C, Holmquist R, Moise H (1976) J Mol Biol 105:15–37
Moore GW (1977) J Theoret Biol 66:95–106
Nei M, Chakraborty R (1976) J Mol Evol 7:313–323
Nei M, Tateno Y (1978) J Mol Evol 11:333–347
Nei M, Tateno Y (1979) J Mol Evol 13:167–171
Noguchi T (1977) A hybrid model for molecular evolution and an evolutionary clock. In: Matsubara H, Yamanaka T (eds) Evolution of Protein Molecules. The Scientific Societies Press, Tokyo, p 61
Noguchi T (1978) Origins of Life: 489–494
Ratner VA (1978) Mathematical Biology and Medicine 1:210–257
Tateno Y, Nei M (1978) J Mol Evol 11:67–73
Wilson AC, Carlson S, White TJ (1977) Ann Rev Biochem 46:573–639
Zuckerkandl E (1976) J Mol Evol 7:167–183
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Holmquist, R., Conroy, T. The estimation of genetic divergence. J Mol Evol 17, 167–181 (1981). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01733911
Received:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01733911