Abstract
We prove some interesting arithmetic properties of theta function identities that are analogous to q-series identities obtained by Michael D. Hirschhorn. In addition, we find infinite family of congruences modulo powers of 2 for representations of a non-negative integer n as \(\triangle _1+4\triangle _2\) and \(\triangle +k\square \).
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
1 Introduction
Let \(a_k(n)\) be the number of representations of n as \(\triangle _1+2k\triangle _2\) and \(b_k(n)\) be the number of representations of n as \(\triangle +k\square \). Then
Hirschhorn and Sellers [3] used some interesting q-series identities to obtain results of congruences modulo 5 for 4-colored Frobenius partitions, and Hirschhorn [2] proved equivalent results of q-series identities that are used in [3]: If
where \((a;q)_\infty =\prod \limits _{n\ge 0}(1-aq^n)\), then
and
Motivated by these works, in Sect. 3, we establish arithmetic properties of representations of a number \(\triangle _1+2k\triangle _2\) and \(\triangle +k\square \). In addition, we also find certain congruences modulo powers of 2 for number of representations of a non-negative integer n as \(\triangle _1+4\triangle _2\) and \(\triangle +k\square \). We list our main results in the following theorems and corollaries.
Theorem 1.1
Let \(a_k(n)\) and \(b_k(n)\) be the number of representations of n as \(\triangle _1+2k\triangle _2\) and \(\triangle +k\square \), respectively. Then
where k is a positive integer so that \(2k+1\) is odd prime.
Theorem 1.2
Let \(a_2(n)\) and \(b_2(n)\) be the number of representations of n as \(\triangle _1+4\triangle _2\) and \(\triangle +2\square \), respectively. Then
The identities (1.5) and (1.6) are analogous to the Hirschhorn [2] identities
Corollary 1.1
Let \(b_{k}(n)\) be the number of representations of n as \(\triangle +k\square \). Then for each n, \(\alpha \ge 0\),
Corollary 1.2
Let \(a_2(n)\) and \(b_2(n)\) be the number of representations of n as \(\triangle _1+4\triangle _2\) and \(\triangle +2\square \), respectively. Then for all n, \(\alpha \ge 0\),
2 Preliminaries
For \(|ab|<1\), Ramanujan’s general theta function \(f\left( a,b\right) \) is defined by
Important special cases of \(f\left( a,b\right) \) are
and
From (2.3) and (2.4), we can see that
3 Proofs of main results
Proof of Theorem 1.1
Let us write
Using (2.4) in \(E_k\left( q\right) \), we obtain
Replacing q by \(q^8\) and then multiplying both sides of (3.1) by \(q^{2k+1}\), we find that
If we write
where \(E^i_k\left( q\right) \) consists of all those terms in \(E_k\left( q\right) \) in which powers of q are congruent to i modulo \(2k+1\), then from (3.2) and (3.3), we see that
where \(x^2+2ky^2\equiv 0\ (\text {mod}\ 2k+1)\). The solution of \(x^2+2ky^2\equiv 0\ (\text {mod}\ 2k+1)\) is \(x\equiv \pm y \ (\text {mod}\ 2k+1)\), and from (3.4) it follows that
In the first sum of (3.5), we have \(x\equiv y\ (\text {mod}\ 2k+1)\), \(4m+1\equiv 4n+1 \ (\text {mod}\ 2k+1)\), \(m-n\equiv 0 \ (\text {mod}\ 2k+1)\), \(m-n=(2k+1)u\), \(m+2kn=(2k+1)v\), \(m=2ku+v\), \(n=v-u\),
In the second sum of (3.5), \(x\equiv -y \ (\text {mod}\ 2k+1)\), \(4m+1\equiv -4n-1\ (\text {mod}\ 2k+1)\), \(4(m+n)\equiv -2 \ (\text {mod}\ 2k+1)\), \(4(m+n)\equiv -2+2(2k+1) \ (\text {mod}\ 2k+1)\), \(m+n\equiv k \ (\text {mod}\ 2k+1)\), \(m+n=(2k+1)v+k\), \(m-2kn=(2k+1)u+k\), \(m=u+2kv+k\), \(n=v-u\),
In the third sum of (3.5),
Employing (3.6), (3.7), and (3.8) in (3.5), we obtain
On simplification, the above equation reduces to
From (2.3), (2.4), and (3.9), we have
From (2.5) and (3.10), we find that
The identity (3.11) can be written as
Now replacing \(q^{2k+1}\) by q in (3.12), we arrive at (1.1).
Let us write \(F_2(q)=\psi (q)\varphi (q)\), and using (2.5), we find that
Replacing q by \(q^8\) and then multiplying both sides of (3.13) by q, we obtain
If we write
where \(F^i_2(q)\) consists of all those terms in \(F_2(q)\) in which powers of q are congruent to i modulo 3, then from (3.14) and (3.15), we see that
where, in both sums, \(x^2+2y^2\equiv 0 \ (\text {mod}\ 3)\). The solution of \(x^2+2y^2\equiv 0 \ (\text {mod}\ 3)\) is \(x\equiv \pm y \ (\text {mod}\ 3)\), and from (3.16) it follows that
In the first sum of (3.17), we have \(4m+1\equiv 4n \ (\text {mod}\ 3)\), \(4(m-n)\equiv -1\ (\text {mod}\ 3)\), \(4(m-n)\equiv -1+9\ (\text {mod}\ 3)\), \(m-n\equiv 2 \ (\text {mod}\ 3)\), \(m-n\equiv -1 \ (\text {mod}\ 3)\), \(m+2n\equiv -1 \ (\text {mod}\ 3)\), \(m-n=-3u-1\), \(m+2n=-3v-1\), \(m=-v-2u-1\), \(n=u-v\),
In the second sum of (3.17), \(4m+1\equiv -4n\ (\text {mod}\ 3)\), \(4(m+n)\equiv -1\ (\text {mod}\ 3)\), \(4(m+n)\equiv -1+9\ (\text {mod}\ 3)\), \(m+n\equiv 2\ (\text {mod}\ 3)\), \(m+n\equiv -1 \ (\text {mod}\ 3)\), \(m-2n\equiv -1 \ (\text {mod}\ 3)\), \(m+n=-3u-1\), \(m-2n=-3v-1\), \(m=-v-2u-1\), \(n=v-u\),
In the third sum of (3.17),
In the fourth sum of (3.17), \(4m+1\equiv 4n+2 \ (\text {mod}\ 3)\), \(4(m-n)\equiv 1\ (\text {mod}\ 3)\), \(m-n\equiv 1\ (\text {mod}\ 3)\), \(m+2n\equiv -2 \ (\text {mod}\ 3)\), \(m-n=3u+1\), \(m+2n=-3v-2\), \(m=2u-v\), \(n=-u-v-1\),
In the fifth sum of (3.17), \(4m+1\equiv -4n-2 \ (\text {mod}\ 3)\), \(4(m+n)\equiv -3\ (\text {mod}\ 3)\), \(m+n\equiv 0\ (\text {mod}\ 3)\), \(m-2n\equiv 0 \ (\text {mod}\ 3)\), \(m+n=3u\), \(m-2n=-3v\), \(m=2u-v\), \(n=u+v\),
In the sixth sum of (3.17),
Invoking (3.18), (3.19), (3.20), (3.21), (3.22), and (3.23) in (3.17), we arrive at
Dividing throughout by q, replacing \(q^8\) by q, and separating the terms of u and v in the above equation, we obtain
The above identity can be written as
Dividing throughout by q and then replacing \(q^3\) by q in (3.24), we obtain (1.2).
Let \(F_4(q)=\psi (q)\varphi (q^{2})\), and using (2.5), we find that
Replacing q by \(q^8\) and then multiplying throughout by q in the above equation, we obtain
Let us write
where \(F^i_4(q)\) consists of all those terms in \(F_4(q)\) in which powers of q are congruent to i modulo 5. From (3.26) and (3.27), we see that
where, in both sums, \(x^2+4y^2\equiv 0 \ (\text {mod}\ 5)\). The solution of \(x^2+4y^2\equiv 0 \ (\text {mod}\ 5)\) is \(x\equiv \pm y \ (\text {mod}\ 5),\) and it follows that
In the first sum of (3.29), we have \(x\equiv y \ (\text {mod}\ 5)\), \(4m+1\equiv 4n \ (\text {mod}\ 5)\), \(4(m-n)\equiv -1 \ (\text {mod}\ 5)\), \(m-n\equiv 1 \ (\text {mod}\ 5)\), \(m+4n\equiv 1 \ (\text {mod}\ 5)\), \(m-n=5u+1\), \(m+4n=5v+1\), \(m=4u+v+1\), \(n=v-u\),
In the second sum of (3.29), \(4m+1\equiv -4n \ (\text {mod}\ 5)\), \(4(m+n)\equiv -1\ (\text {mod}\ 5)\), \(4(m+n)\equiv -1+5\ (\text {mod}\ 5)\), \(m+n\equiv 1 \ (\text {mod}\ 5)\), \(m-4n\equiv 1 \ (\text {mod}\ 5)\), \(m+n=5u+1\), \(m-4n=5v+1\), \(m=4u+v+1\), \(n=u-v\),
In the third sum of (3.29),
In the fourth sum of (3.29), \(4m+1\equiv 4n+2 \ (\text {mod}\ 5)\), \(4(m-n)\equiv 1\ (\text {mod}\ 5)\), \(m-n\equiv -1\ (\text {mod}\ 5)\), \(m+4n\equiv -1\ (\text {mod}\ 5)\), \(m-n=-5u-1\), \(m+4n=5v-1\), \(m=v-4u-1\), \(n=u+v\),
In the fifth sum of (3.29), \(4m+1\equiv -4n-2 \ (\text {mod}\ 5)\), \(4(m+n)\equiv -3\ (\text {mod}\ 5)\), \(m+n\equiv -2\ (\text {mod}\ 5)\), \(m-4n\equiv 3\ (\text {mod}\ 5)\), \(m+n=-5u-2\), \(m-4n=5v+3\), \(m=v-4u-1\), \(n=-v-u-1\),
In the sixth sum of (3.29),
Employing (3.30), (3.31), (3.32), (3.33), (3.34), and (3.35) in (3.29), we obtain
Dividing throughout by q, replacing \(q^8\) by q, and then separating the terms containing u and v in the above equation, we find that
Using (2.3) and (2.4) in (3.36), we obtain
From (2.5) and (3.37), we see that
From (3.38), it follows that
Dividing throughout by \(q^3\) and then replacing \(q^5\) by q in (3.39), we arrive at (1.3).
Let \(F_6(q)=\psi \left( q\right) \varphi \left( q^3\right) \), and using (2.5), we find that
Replacing q by \(q^8\) and then multiplying both sides of (3.40) by q, we see that
If we write
where \(F^i_6(q)\) consists of all those terms in \(F_6(q)\) in which powers of q are congruent to i modulo 7, then from (3.41) and (3.42), we find that
where, in both sums, \(x^2+6y^2\equiv 0 \ (\text {mod}\ 7)\). The solution of \(x^2+6y^2\equiv 0 \ (\text {mod}\ 7)\) is \(x\equiv \pm y \ (\text {mod}\ 7),\) and from (3.43), it follows that
In the first sum of (3.44), we have \(4m+1\equiv 4n \ (\text {mod}\ 7)\), \(4(m-n)\equiv -1\ (\text {mod}\ 7)\), \(4(m-n)\equiv -8\ (\text {mod}\ 7)\), \( m-n\equiv -2\ (\text {mod}\ 7)\), \(m+6n\equiv -2\ (\text {mod}\ 7)\), \(m-n=-7v-2\), \(m+6n=-7u-2\), \(m=-u-6v-2\), \(n=v-u\),
In the second sum of (3.44), \(4m+1\equiv -4n \ (\text {mod}\ 7)\), \(4(m+n)\equiv -1\ (\text {mod}\ 7)\), \(4(m+n)\equiv -8\ (\text {mod}\ 7)\), \(m+n\equiv -2\ (\text {mod}\ 7)\), \(m-6n\equiv -2\ (\text {mod}\ 7)\), \(m+n=-7v-2\), \(m-6n=-7u-2\), \(m=-6v-u-2\), \(n=u-v\),
In the third sum of (3.44),
In the fourth sum of (3.44), \(4m+1\equiv 4n+2 \ (\text {mod}\ 7)\), \(4(m-n)\equiv 1\ (\text {mod}\ 7)\), \(m-n\equiv 2\ (\text {mod}\ 7)\), \(m+6n\equiv -5\ (\text {mod}\ 7)\), \(m-n=7v+2\), \(m+6n=-7u-5\), \(m=6v-u+1\), \(n=-v-u-1\),
In the fifth sum of (3.44), \(4m+1\equiv -4n-2 \ (\text {mod}\ 7)\), \(4(m+n)\equiv -3\ (\text {mod}\ 7)\), \(m+n\equiv 1\ (\text {mod}\ 7)\), \(m-6n\equiv 1\ (\text {mod}\ 7)\), \(m+n=7v+1\), \(m-6n=-7u+1\), \(m=6v-u+1\), \(n=u+v\),
In the sixth sum of (3.44),
Invoking (3.45), (3.46), (3.47), (3.48), (3.49), and (3.50) in (3.44), we find that
After simplification of (3.51), we obtain
Dividing throughout by q, replacing \(q^8\) by q, and separating the terms of u and v in (3.52), we obtain
From (2.3), (2.4), and (3.53), we see that
From (2.5) and (3.54), we obtain
The above equation can be written as
Dividing throughout by \(q^6\) and then replacing \(q^7\) by q in (3.56), we arrive at (1.4). This completes the proof. \(\square \)
Proof of Theorem 1.2
Put \(k=2\) in (1.1), we find that
which yields
From (1.3), it follows that
Equating coefficients of \(q^{5n}\) in (3.59), we obtain
Equations (1.5) and (1.6) follow from (3.58) and (3.60). This completes the proof. \(\square \)
Proof of Corollary 1.1
From Eq. (1.2), we see that
Equating coefficients of \(q^{3n}\) on both sides of (3.61), we find that
From (3.62) and by mathematical induction, we arrive at (1.7). Similarly, we obtain (1.8) and (1.9) from (1.3) and (1.4), respectively. This completes the proof. \(\square \)
Proof of Corollary 1.2
In view of Eq. (1.5), we see that
By mathematical induction on n in (3.63), we arrive at (1.10). Similarly, we obtain (1.11) from (1.6). This completes the proof. \(\square \)
References
Berndt, B.C.: Ramanujan’s Notebooks, Part III. Springer, New York (1991)
Hirschhorn, M.D.: Some interesting q-series identities. Ramanujan J. 36, 297–304 (2015)
Hirschhorn, M.D., Sellers, J.A.: Infinitely many congruences modulo 5 for 4-colored Frobenius partitions. Ramanujan J. (2014). doi:10.1007/s11139-014-9652-x
Acknowledgments
The authors would like to thank the anonymous referee for helpful suggestions and comments which greatly improved the original version of the manuscript.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
This research was partially supported by DST Govt. of India under the Project Grant SR/S4/MS:739/11.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Naika, M.S.M., Gireesh, D.S. Arithmetic properties arising from Ramanujan’s theta functions. Ramanujan J 42, 601–615 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11139-015-9751-3
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11139-015-9751-3