Abstract
Chest pain is among the most common symptoms of post-COVID-19 Conditions (PCC) that prompts medical attention. Because the SARS-CoV-2 virus has proclivity for many organs and organ systems in the chest, ranging from the heart, lungs, great vessels, lymphatics, and peripheral nerves, clinicians evaluating patients with chest pain must consider a broad differential diagnosis and take a comprehensive approach to management.
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
Introduction
Chest pain is among the most common symptoms of post-COVID-19 Conditions (PCC) that prompts medical attention. A tenet of medicine is to focus one’s attention on common conditions. The COVID-19 pandemic in some ways challenges this tenet and serves as a reminder for the medical community, perhaps like no other in the past century of the importance of keeping an open mind, the power of listening and observing, and that new knowledge does indeed have a place in contemporary medicine.
For early-, mid-, and late-career clinicians the overarching message is to develop an understanding of COVID-19- a complex viral illness of a protean nature and a proclivity for vascular endothelial cells, tissue injury, up-regulating and altering immune responses, and impairing normal reparative processes in multiple organ systems (reviewed in Becker and Khan [1,2,3]. Honoring the medical community’s pledge to apply science and service for the betterment of humankind, a thoughtful and comprehensive, yet targeted approach to evaluating patients with chest pain and PCC encourages and necessitates, “permission to think outside of the box”.
COVID-19 and post-COVID-19 conditions
COVID-19 is a systematic viral infection. Like many viral illnesses there are localized symptoms that reflect a combination of direct organ or organ system involvement and mild, moderate, or large effects stemming from multiple stages, phases, or waves of innate and humoral immune responses. The resulting inflammatory state and in some instances marked “resetting” of innate and adaptive immune memory as determined by memory B cells, memory CD4 + T cells, and memory CD8 + T cells are major determinants of acute, subacute, and chronic disease phenotypes [4,5,6,7].
Systemic symptoms in the acute phase of infection such as fever, chills, headaches, bone pain, myalgias, fatigue, exhaustion, and arthralgias while not unique to SARS-COV-2 infections, may be more pronounced and longer-lasting than comparable viral illnesses like influenza A and B [8, 9]. This may reflect heightened immune and inflammatory responses to a new pathogen [10] and be responsible for cytokine release and resulting biomarkers in the peripheral blood that include but are not limited to elevated ferritin, C-reactive protein, erythrocyte sedimentation rate, D-dimers, lactate dehydrogenase (LDH), Interleukin (IL)-1, IL-6, fibrinogen, von Willebrand protein and Factor VIII activity [11].
Post-COVID Conditions as defined by the Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and World Health Organization (WHO) is the continuation or development of new symptoms 1 month or 3 months after the initial SARS-CoV-2 infection, respectively, with these symptoms lasting for at least 2 months with no other explanation (Table 1) (www.CDC.gov;accessed March 18,2023; www.who.int; accessed March 23, 2023). Symptoms often occur in clusters that may represent phenotypes from one organ system or multiple organ systems (Table 1). Preexisting medical conditions are known to be a contributing factor (Fig. 1). Developing systems-based nomenclatures for PCC is a priority for the scientific and medical communities [1, 12].
A pragmatic approach to patients with chest pain following COVID-19
Patients with chest pain following COVID-19 can be separated into groups based on the severity or acuity of their initial illness. Patients with severe or critical COVID-19 (Group1) (World Health Organization Ordinal Scale 4–7) [13, 14] often experience life-threatening conditions that cause persisting or recurring symptoms 4 to 8 weeks following hospital discharge, including chest pain. The most common conditions that fall into this category include multi-lobar pneumonia, acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS), prolonged invasive mechanical ventilation, barotrauma and pneumothorax, pneumomediastinum, alveolar hemorrhage, spontaneous pulmonary hematoma, empyema (often from a secondary bacterial pneumonia and need for chest tube placement), veno-venous or venous-arterial extracorporeal membrane oxygenation, acute myocardial infarction (coronary artery dissection or coronary artery thrombosis with or without plaque rupture), cardiac arrest with cardiopulmonary resuscitation, myocarditis, pericarditis, cardiac tamponade, pulmonary embolism, pulmonary embolism with infarction, pulmonary embolism with pleuritis, aortic dissection, aortitis, aortic thrombosis, aortic aneurysm rupture, aortic ulcer, aortic intramural hematoma, transverse colitis, and esophageal rupture [15,16,17,18,19,20,21] ). Acute chest syndrome in patients with sickle cell disease (SCD) and COVID-19 must never be overlooked, including for those in whom the diagnosis of SCD has not been secured previously. Pulmonary fat embolism, veno-occlusive crisis and pulmonary infarction from microvascular platelet-fibrin thrombosis are frequent contributors [22]. Rib infarctions have also been reported [23].
While some patients in Group 1 develop PCC, the point of transition from recovery following an acute and complicated initial illness to more classical pathophysiological signatures of PCC is difficult to discern in the absence of clear diagnostic markers or signatures that distinguish prolonged recovery from PCC or a combination of both. It is also important for clinicians to be aware that patients with severe COVID-19 are at heightened risk for future cardiovascular events following hospital discharge [20]. Accordingly, a high index of suspicion for cardiovascular causes of chest pain must be maintained even among patients who appear to be recovering uneventfully from their initial infection [24]. Symptom severity often correlates with functional difficulties and limitations as well as overall health [25].
Patients with mild-to-moderate symptoms at the time of initial infection (Group 2) (WHO Ordinal Scale 0–3) [13] can also experience PCC and present to their primary care provider or cardiologist for evaluation of chest pain. Our COVID-19 Recovery Clinic established in March 2020 has seen many such patients who often have a period of quiescence following their initial infection and then develop chest pain [1]. Accompanying symptoms frequently include fatigue, dyspnea, and an elevated heart rate at rest (˃ 90 beats per minute) that increases suddenly after modest physical activity. The episodes of tachycardia and dyspnea may worsen their chest pain and culminate in exhaustion that can persist for hours or sometimes days.
While our experience is somewhat weighted toward a group of patients with PCC and autonomic dysfunction [26], we remain vigilant as a group and take a thorough and systems-based approach to all patients (see Fig. 1and Table 2). In addition to the 26 conditions summarized by the CDC, we would add coronary artery microvascular dysfunction to the list having seen several patients with this condition following COVID-19 [27], [28]. It is also important for clinicians to remember that these patients may have preexisting medical conditions that worsen after contracting COVID-19. Last, patients can develop non-COVID related illnesses.
We have worked closely and collaboratively with colleagues in cardiology, vascular medicine, pulmonary medicine, neurology, rheumatology, immunology, interventional radiology, dermatology, and physical medicine and rehabilitation to consider all potential etiologies of chest pain-being mindful that there can be more than one cause. These group discussions are designed with the express intent to “think outside the box”. The subsequent sections represent the cumulative output.
A clinician’s lens for assessing Post-COVID Condition chest pain
The approach to patient-centered care must always include a wide-angle lens. This better assures equity, inclusion, empathy and underscores the “power of why” as a foundation for many healthcare providers who view medicine as an art and a science without a ceiling [2].
Sternum: basic anatomy
The sternum represents the most anterior aspect of the chest and consists of three component parts- the manubrium, body, and xiphoid process. Each has distinct articulation points that include the clavicle, sternoclavicular joint (SCJ), manubrial-sternal joint (MSJ), chondral cartilage, sternocostal joint (SCoJ), and xipho-sternal joint. The joints themselves comprise primarily synovial and cartilaginous joint types. Common congenital variants of the sternum include pectus excavation, pectus carinatum, sternal bands, bars and clefts, sternal foramen, and episternal ossicles. The most common degenerative and inflammatory conditions are osteoarthritis (SCJ, MSJ), rheumatoid arthritis (SCJ, MSJ), seronegative arthritis (SCJ, MSJ), septic arthritis (SCJ), and osteomyelitis. Metabolic conditions and disorders include Paget’s disease and renal osteodystrophy [29, 30] (Fig. 2).
Chest wall vasculature
The vascular architecture of the chest wall is well-defined and may offer clues to understanding potential causes of chest pain among patients with COVID-19-a virus known to have a proclivity for vascular endothelial cells and other organ systems with a high concentration of angiotensin-converting enzyme (ACE) 2 receptors [31].
The anterior chest or torso is richly supplied by superficial and deep arteries and arterioles (reviewed in Palmer) [32] The internal thoracic arteries and deep epigastric arteries are the primary source of the cutaneous, intercostal, and intermuscular circulation. Parasternal perforating vessels from the right and left internal thoracic arteries interconnect with the lateral thoracic vessels and course below the ribs along with veins and nerves that collectively make up the intercostal bundles. There are anterior and posterior intercostal arteries with interconnecting vessels that branch to perfuse the pectoralis major muscle and integument through large cutaneous perforating vessels (Fig. 3).
Inflammation of the chest wall vasculature is a consideration among patients with PCC and chest pain.
Pericardial circulation
Vascular channels including arteries, veins, and nerves are located within adipose tissue beneath the visceral pericardium and on the mediastinal aspect of the parietal pericardium [33]. The arteries of the pericardium arise from the internal thoracic arteries and their musculophrenic branches and from the descending aorta. There are also branches and anastomoses of the coronary arteries with pericardial fat originating from the internal thoracic, anterior mediastinal, pericardial, bronchial, superior, and inferior phrenic, intercoastal and esophageal branches of the aorta [34]. Inflammation of these vessels could be a cause of chest pain among patients with COVID-19. As with several other anatomical locations in the chest or torso, imaging modalities to determine tissue and vascular inflammation are not readily available. This limits a clinician’s ability to secure a diagnosis.
Epicardial and Pericardial Fat
Early pathological descriptions of COVID-19 decedents identified SARS-COV-2 virus in adipocytes [35]. Indeed, the presence of fatty tissue reservoirs has been postulated to be a potential contributor to post-COVID conditions [36]. In either case, adipocytes are known to have a high metabolic capacity and produce a wide variety of inflammatory mediators.
Epicardial and pericardial fatty tissue found underneath the visceral pericardium or on top of the parietal pericardium, respectively, is not evenly distributed but rather confined to areas coursing with epicardial and pericardial vessels [37]. Epicardial fat pads that contain parasympathetic ganglia are found in three discrete areas- the junction of the right atrium and right superior pulmonary vein, the junction of the inferior vena cava and the right atrium, and between the superior vena cava and aortic root [38]. Any or each of the epicardial and pericardial fatty tissues could be a site of inflammation and resulting chest pain among patients with COVID-19.
Fat necrosis can be identified by MRI using the Dixon method [39]. The presence of epicardial fat deposits by cardiac MRI or CT has been postulated to be a marker of inflammation-particularly chronic inflammation [40]. Might these tools be capable of shedding light on one or more causes of chest pain in patients with PCC? Further investigation is warranted.
Lymphatic system
The lymphatic system, also referred to as the lymphatic vasculature consists of a network of thin walled, highly permeable initial lymphatics that first drain into pre-collecting lymphatic vessels, merging into larger secondary collecting lymphatics. The unidirectional valves control the transport of lymph back to the blood circulation. Lymph is transferred to pre-nodal collecting lymphatics, also called afferent lymphatics, leading to lymph nodes. The lymph exits lymph nodes through post-nodal collecting lymphatics, eventually draining into the thoracic duct and the right lymphatic duct, which, in turn, discharge lymph into the large veins at the base of the neck (reviewed in Singhal) [41] (Fig. 4).
Inflammation, NETs, and coagulation of pulmonary lymphatic vessels draining from the lungs have been described in patients with severe COVID-19 pneumonia [42]. Damage to germinal centers within the lymphatic system could contribute to impaired immune responses, lymphatic dysfunction, and an inflammatory state [43]. Because the vascular endothelium and lymphatic system glycocalyx’s share many similarities and the glycocalyx is known to be a common site of injury in COVID-19, prolonged dysfunction may be a consideration among patients with PCC and chest pain [44]. MRI and lymphangiography are the preferred imaging modalities for evaluating the lymphatic system of the mediastinum and chest.
Muscular-skeletal chest Pain
Muscular-skeletal chest wall pain includes a wide range of causes including cervicothoracic angina, intercostal myalgia, segmental thoracic dysfunction, pectoral myalgia, fibrositis, costochondritis, Tietze syndrome, fibromyalgia, and sternoclavicular disease (reviewed in Stochkendahl) [45]. The neurovascular bundle inflammation described with COVID-19, coupled with cytokine-mediated arthralgias and arthritis, autoimmune profile, and skeletal inflammation [46] detected in some patients by magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) suggests that many of the muscular-skeletal causes of chest pain should be included in the differential diagnosis in patients with PCC and chest pain. The overall clinical context must be considered carefully.
Polychondritis, relapsing polychondritis, and dermatomyositis have been described in autoimmune diseases and viral infections such as HIV, Hepatitis C, and herpes simplex. The COVID-19 experience and its impact on rare and complex connective tissue diseases has been captured in the European Network of Rare and Complex Connective Tissue and Musculoskeletal Disease (ERN-ReCONNECT) [47]. While cutaneous features and muscle weakness are expected in dermatomyositis, the phenotype is heterogeneous. Muscle biopsies from patients with COVID-19 show abnormal presence of Myxovirus resistance protein A in muscle fibers and capillaries. Myxovirus resistance protein A is one of the IFN1-inducible proteins, is overexpressed in biopsy muscle specimens from DM patients and may be a more sensitive marker of DM, suggesting that autoimmune myositis may be caused by COVID-19 [48, 49].
What is the mechanism for myalgias, arthralgia, and bone pain in viral illnesses?
In most infections muscle, joint, and bone pain have been attributed to immune responses. Many inflammatory proteins, cytokines, and chemokines are released from osteoblasts for the purpose of stimulating bone remodeling. These include but are not limited to macrophage colony-stimulating factor, IL-6, and IL-11 [50]. There are bacteria and viruses that can infect bones either through direct contact or by hematogenous spread, typically beginning in the metaphyseal region of the tubular bones. Bacteria such as staphylococcus aureus, staphylococcus epidermis, pseudomonas aeruginosa, Serratia marcescens, and Escherichia coli possess receptors that permit direct binding to adhesive matrix proteins ( [51]. Viral illnesses can cause infectious bone and joint degeneration by promoting osteoclastogenesis [52, 53].
An existing literature considers constitutional symptoms including pain to be neurogenic in origin [54]. Specifically, the central and peripheral nervous systems’ nociceptors are stimulated and transduced into pain impulses transmitted by first-order neurons (nerve fibers C and Ay). The stimulus itself can prompt the release of inflammatory cytokines that further stimulate nociceptors. First-order neurons synapse with second-order neurons to form spinothalamic tracts that course to the thalamus, synapsing with third-order neurons projecting to the somatosensory cortex and limbic system [55].
Inflammatory responses are governed by several coordinated processes and trigger granulopoieses in the bone marrow [56]. S100A8/A9-NLRP3-IL-1β signaling induces the accumulation of inflammasome- primed neutrophils within the bone marrow. In turn, the primed neutrophils secrete IL-1β triggering additional granulopoiesis. The entire process is localized to the bone marrow limiting systemic release and off-target effects. Bone marrow NLRP3 inflammasome-IL-1β signaling also stimulate megakaryocyte development and platelet production [57]. Emergency granulopoiesis is stimulated by G-CSF [58].
Arthritis, arthralgia, and muscular-skeletal pain are common with viral illnesses, including SARS-COV-2 (and other Coronaviruses), parvovirus, influenza, hepatitis, and human immunodeficiency virus [54]. In some cases, the severity of symptoms correlates with viral load, the concentration of pro-inflammatory cytokines and detection of immune complexes in inflamed joints [59]. The joints involved depend on the viral pathogen and at times can be difficult to distinguish from traditional autoimmune arthritis, particularly in cases where the viral pathogen and immune response induce autoimmunity and inflammatory molecular mimicry.
The autoantigen atlas of COVID-19 identified many proteins with structural and functional roles in the musculoskeletal system. They include various isoforms of actin, actinin, collagen, filamin, fibronectin, fibulin, dynactin, dynein, lamin, myosin, nestin, nexilin, profilin, plectin, plastin, proteoglycan, septin, spectrin, talin, tropomyosin, tubulin, vinculin, and vimentin. These proteins are major components of the extracellular matrix, basement membrane, cell cytoskeleton, cytoskeletal motors, muscle filaments, and contractile motors of muscle cells [60].
Tachycardia and chest pain
Many of our patients in the COVID-19 Recovery Clinic who have heart racing alone or as a part of a symptom cluster that includes chest pain also experience fatigue and exhaustion after physical activity. In many instances high heart rates appear to proceed or precipitate other limiting symptoms, including in patients with PCC and chest pain in the absence of coronary artery disease, microvascular dysfunction, or pulmonary conditions (i.e., normal CT chest, pulmonary CT angiography, ventilation-perfusion scan, pulmonary function studies, maximum inspiratory pressure, and maximum expiratory pressure). The work of Hsueh and colleagues identified the posterior insular cortex as a potential mediator of bottom-up cardiac interoceptive processing and found that optogenetic inhibition of this brain region attenuated the behaviors that were induced by cardiac pacing [61]. In other words, pacing the heart to high heart rates under experimental conditions stimulate areas of the brain associated with the central autonomic network such as the insular cortex, gustatory area and agranular insular area, prefrontal cortex, including the infralimbic area, prelimbic area and anterior cingulate area, and brainstem, including the pons and medulla. These areas are responsible for human emotions such as anxiety, blood pressure regulation, environmental responses, complex cognitive behavior, decision making, sensory processing to include pain, and sleep patterns that govern REM (rapid eye movement)- restful sleep.
Neuropathic pain
COVID-19 has been associated with both peripheral and central nervous system complications either through direct invasion of the nervous system or post viral immune responses [62]. Several viruses are known to cause post viral neuropathic pain- the most common of which is herpes zoster with a prevalence of approximately 6 to 10% in the year following initial infection [63]. Other virus that can cause neuropathic pain include human immunodeficiency virus, enterovirus, poliovirus, Zika virus, Epstein Barr virus, cytomegalovirus, hepatitis, and influenza A [64]. Chest pain of potential neuropathic origin has been reported in up to 20% of patients with PCC [65, 66]. The overall prevalence may be higher among patients with 5 or more symptoms attributable to PCC [67]-a phenotype considered to represent severe PCC.
Small Fiber neuropathy
Small fiber neuropathy has been described following COVID-19 and can present weeks to months following initial infection. The common symptoms include localized, generalized, or migrating burning, deep aching, tingling, or squeezing pain [68] that occurs along with fatigue, muscle pain or fasciculations, or dysautonomia [69]. A multi-system cluster has also been described [70].
Assessment of chest Pain
Our approach to the comprehensive evaluation of patients with PCC and chest pain is summarized below:
Step one:
-
1.
Perform a thorough past medical history, social history, family history, 10- system review of systems, and symptoms at the time of initially confirmed COVID-19, persisting or recurring symptoms, current symptoms, prior diagnostic tests, and conduct a detailed physical examination.
-
2.
Perform vital signs (blood pressure, heart rate, and pulse oximetry) in the supine, sitting, and standing positions.
-
3.
Perform a surface 12- lead electrocardiogram, complete blood count, cytokine 13 panel, a comprehensive autoimmune panel, and a paraneoplastic antibody screen.
Step 2: Based on the overall findings from step 1 and a moderate-to-high clinical index of suspicion, the following diagnostic tests should be considered:
-
1.
Cardiac MRI with and without gadolinium.
-
2.
CT angiogram of the coronary arteries, thoracic aorta, or pulmonary arteries-all three could be conducted together if dictated by clinical suspicion(s).
-
3.
Ventilation- perfusion (V/Q) scan.
-
4.
Cardiac PET-CT scan.
-
5.
7-day cardiac event monitor.
-
6.
Tilt Table test.
-
7.
Pulmonary function studies to include response to bronchodilator, MIP (maximum inspiratory pressure), and MEP (maximum expiratory pressure).
Step 3: Based on the findings from diagnostic tests performed during steps 1 and 2 of the evaluation, the following specialized diagnostic tests could be considered:
-
1.
Bone scan.
-
2.
FDG-PET scan.
-
3.
Skin biopsy.
-
4.
Muscle biopsy.
-
5.
Nerve biopsy.
-
6.
MRI of the neck, chest, or cervical and thoracic spine.
-
7.
Dedicated lymphangiogram.
Treatment
The treatment of patients with PCC and chest pain is determined only after considering the patient, the past medical history, and the collective results and interpretation of carefully selected diagnostic tests. Cardiac, vascular, pulmonary, rheumatologic, neurologic, musculoskeletal, and oncologic findings may require additional testing for confirmation of a particular diagnosis or condition. Appropriate treatment and a plan of care should then follow.
In patients with resting tachycardia or inappropriate sinus tachycardia and accompanying chest pain, low dose cardio-selective β-blockers should be considered and titrated according to heart rate, blood pressure, and symptoms. Our threshold is low for prescribing β-blockers for several reasons. As a pharmacological class of drug, they (1) reduce sympathetic tone, (2) reduce inflammation, (3) attenuate heart-brain signaling, (4) lesson autonomic imbalance that contributes to many symptoms in PCC, (5) improve endothelial function, (6) reduce oxidative stress, and (7) may play a role in reducing future cardiovascular events in patients with COVID-19 and PCC [71, 72]. Ivabradine has been used successfully in patients with PCC, including postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome, inappropriate sinus tachycardia and in patients who experience worsening of fatigue even with low dose, β- selective agents [73]. It is important to emphasize that clinicians evaluating and managing patients with PCC should be part of a multidisciplinary team of providers to limit unnecessary testing and treatments that are outside one’s area of expertise.
We recommend follow-up every 12 weeks, either in the clinic or utilizing telehealth, to assess patient progress, response to treatment, and to detect the emergence of new symptoms that may offer insight for making a unifying diagnosis of PCC, non-COVID related illnesses, and other potential causes of chest pain.
Management
Several guidelines including those from the CDC have provided strategies for managing PCC. However, while empirical evidence is still lacking, the consensus is to closely monitor patients with symptoms and adopt a symptom-based approach for targeted management. Appropriate diagnostic tests and treatments should be guided by clinical symptoms and the best available evidence. A dedicated COVID-19 Recovery Clinic is an ideal environment for patient assessment, management, and for participating in clinical trials to scientifically address a large gap in the understanding of PCC and its heterogeneous phenotypes. In addition to the CDC, other institutions like the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) have released guidelines for health care practitioners to identify, assess, investigate, manage and monitor patients with ongoing or recurring symptoms after COVID-19 [74, 75].
Conclusions and future directions
Chest pain is common among patients with COVID-19- both in the acute phase and in those with PCC. An understanding of the former informs the latter and prepares clinicians to take a comprehensive approach to assessment and management. PCC include the remnants and recrudescence of acute conditions that occur in the setting of moderate-to-severe-to-critical infection, as well as new or worsening symptoms that follow mild infections or reinfections. We encourage practicing clinicians to be prepared and to “think outside of the box”. Patients will be grateful beneficiaries of both, but providers must remember that thinking outside of the box to secure a diagnosis and select the best available treatment is not a license to practice medicine that lacks a clear biological premise, precedent, or evidence of benefit. In such circumstances, we strongly encourage all providers to identify clinical research opportunities and to be active supporters of scientific initiatives designed specifically for establishing optimal care [76]. Your patients, your community, and society will be the beneficiaries [77, 78].
References
Becker RC (2021) COVID-19 and its sequelae: a platform for optimal patient care, discovery and training. J Thromb Thrombolysis 51:587–594
Becker RC (2020) Toward understanding the 2019 Coronavirus and its impact on the heart. J Thromb Thrombolysis 50:33–42
Khan MH, Becker RC Cardiopulmonary phenotypes of Post-Acute Sequelae of severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome Coronavirus 2: a narrative review.Cardiology in Review. 9000 Cardiol Rev. 2023 May-Jun 01;31(3):117–127.
McNaughton AL, Paton RS, Edmans M, Youngs J, Wellens J, Phalora P, Fyfe A, Belij-Rammerstorfer S, Bolton JS, Ball J, Carnell GW, Dejnirattisai W, Dold C, Eyre DW, Hopkins P, Howarth A, Kooblall K, Klim H, Leaver S, Lee LN, López-Camacho C, Lumley SF, Macallan DC, Mentzer AJ, Provine NM, Ratcliff J, Slon-Compos J, Skelly D, Stolle L, Supasa P, Temperton N, Walker C, Wang B, Wyncoll D, Simmonds P, Lambe T, Baillie JK, Semple MG, Openshaw PJ, Obolski U, Turner M, Carroll M, Mongkolsapaya J, Screaton G, Kennedy SH, Jarvis L, Barnes E, Dunachie S, Lourenço J, Matthews PC, Bicanic T, Klenerman P, Gupta S, Thompson CP (2022) Fatal COVID-19 outcomes are associated with an antibody response targeting epitopes shared with endemic coronaviruses.JCI Insight; 7
Aguilar-Bretones M, Fouchier RA, Koopmans MP, van Nierop GP (2023) Impact of antigenic evolution and original antigenic sin on SARS-CoV-2 immunity.The Journal of clinical investigation; 133
Wang X, Sanborn MA, Dai Y, Rehman J (2022) Temporal transcriptomic analysis using TrendCatcher identifies early and persistent neutrophil activation in severe COVID-19.JCI Insight; 7
Purbey PK, Roy K, Gupta S, Paul MK (2023) Mechanistic insight into the protective and pathogenic immune-responses against SARS-CoV-2. Mol Immunol 156:111–126
Lee B, Ashcroft T, Agyei-Manu E, Farfan de los Godos E, Leow A, Krishan P, Kulkarni D, Nundy M, Hartnup K, Shi T, McSwiggan E, Nair H (2022) Theodoratou E and McQuillan R. Clinical features of COVID-19 for integration of COVID-19 into influenza surveillance: a systematic review. J global health 12:05012
Zayet S, Kadiane-Oussou NdJ, Lepiller Q, Zahra H, Royer P-Y, Toko L, Gendrin V, Klopfenstein T (2020) Clinical features of COVID-19 and influenza: a comparative study on Nord Franche-Comte cluster. Microbes Infect 22:481–488
Nikolich-Zugich J, Knox KS, Rios CT, Natt B, Bhattacharya D, Fain MJ (2020) SARS-CoV-2 and COVID-19 in older adults: what we may expect regarding pathogenesis, immune responses, and outcomes. GeroScience 42:505–514
Gorog DA, Storey RF, Gurbel PA, Tantry US, Berger JS, Chan MY, Duerschmied D, Smyth SS, Parker WAE, Ajjan RA, Vilahur G, Badimon L, Berg JMt C, Ht, Peyvandi F, Wang TT, Becker RC (2022) Current and novel biomarkers of thrombotic risk in COVID-19: a Consensus Statement from the International COVID-19 thrombosis biomarkers Colloquium. Nat Reviews Cardiol 19:475–495
Becker RC, Gorog DA (2021) International COVID-19 biomarkers colloquium. J Thromb Thrombolysis 52:983–984
Marshall JC, Murthy S, Diaz J, Adhikari N, Angus DC, Arabi YM, Baillie K, Bauer M, Berry S (2020) Blackwood B. A minimal common outcome measure set for COVID-19 clinical research. Lancet Infect Dis 20:e192–e197
Rubio-Rivas M, Mora-Luján JM, Formiga F, Arévalo-Cañas C, Lebrón Ramos JM, Villalba García MV, Fonseca Aizpuru EM, Díez-Manglano J, Arnalich Fernández F, Romero Cabrera JL, García García GM, Pesqueira Fontan PM, Vargas Núñez JA, Freire Castro SJ, Loureiro Amigo J, Pascual Pérez MLR, Alcalá, Pedrajas JN, Encinas-Sánchez D, Mella Pérez C, Ena J (2022) Gracia Gutiérrez A, Esteban Giner MJ, Varona JF, Millán Núñez-Cortés J and Casas-Rojo JM. WHO Ordinal Scale and Inflammation Risk Categories in COVID-19. Comparative Study of the Severity Scales. Journal of general internal medicine;37:1980–1987
Ramandi A, Akbarzadeh MA, Khaheshi I, Khalilian MR (2022) Aortic dissection and Covid-19; a comprehensive systematic review.Current problems in cardiology:101129
Silvestri V, Recchia GE (2021) Aortic Pathology during COVID – 19 pandemics. Clinical reports in literature and open questions on the two co-occurring conditions. Ann Vasc Surg 75:109–119
Cannata S, Birkinshaw A, Sado D, Dworakowski R, Pareek N (2020) Spontaneous coronary artery dissection after COVID-19 infection presenting with ST segment elevation. Eur Heart J 41:4602–4602
Czerny M, van den Berg J, Chiesa R, Jacobs M, Jakob S, Jenni H-J, Lorusso R, Pacini D, Quintana E, Rylski B, Staier K, Tsilimparis N, Wyss T, Gottardi R, Schmidli J (2021) Management of acute and chronic aortic disease during the COVID-19 pandemic—results from a web-based ad hoc platform. J Card Surg 36:1683–1692
Faria D, Moll-Bernardes RJ, Testa L, Moniz CMV, Rodrigues EC, Rodrigues AG, Araujo A, Alves MJNN, Ono BE, Izaias JE, Salemi VMC, Jordão CP, Amaro-Vicente G, Rondon MUPB, Ludwig KR, Craighead DH, Rossman MJ, Consolim-Colombo FM, Angelis KD, Irigoyen MCC, Seals DR (1979) Negrão CE and Sales ARK. Sympathetic Neural Overdrive, Aortic Stiffening, Endothelial Dysfunction, and Impaired Exercise Capacity in Severe COVID-19 Survivors: A Mid-Term Study of Cardiovascular Sequelae. Hypertension (Dallas, Tex: 2023;80:470–481
Wiemken TL, McGrath LJ, Andersen KM, Khan F, Malhotra D, Alfred T, Nguyen JL, Puzniak L, Thoburn E (2022) Jodar L and McLaughlin JM. Coronavirus disease 2019 severity and risk of subsequent Cardiovascular events. Clin Infect Dis 76:e42–e50
Bonaffini PA, Franco PN, Bonanomi A, Giaccherini C, Valle C, Marra P, Norsa L, Marchetti M, Falanga A, Sironi S (2022) Ischemic and hemorrhagic abdominal complications in COVID-19 patients: experience from the first italian wave. Eur J Med Res 27:165
Curtis S, Henny B, Joanna S, Betancourt J, Thomas M, Vattappally L, Crouch A, Caterina M (2023) Excess deaths among adults with sickle cell disease in 2020 compared to prior years. Ann Hematol 102:41–44
Rucknagel DL, Rucknagel DL, Kalkinyak KA, Gelfand MJ (1991) Rib infarcts and acute chest syndrome in sickle cell diseases. The Lancet 337:831–833
Wan EYF, Mathur S, Zhang R, Yan VKC, Lai FTT, Chui CSL, Li X, Wong CKH, Chan EWY, Yiu KH, Wong ICK (2023) Association of COVID-19 with short- and long-term risk of cardiovascular disease and mortality: a prospective cohort in UK Biobank.Cardiovascular Research.
Sivan M, Parkin A, Makower S, Greenwood DC (2022) Post-COVID syndrome symptoms, functional disability, and clinical severity phenotypes in hospitalized and nonhospitalized individuals: a cross-sectional evaluation from a community COVID rehabilitation service. J Med Virol 94:1419–1427
Becker RC (2021) Autonomic dysfunction in SARS-COV-2 infection acute and long-term implications COVID-19 editor’s page series. J Thromb Thrombolysis 52:692–707
Doeblin P, Steinbeis F, Scannell CM, Goetze C, Al-Tabatabaee S, Erley J, Faragli A, Pröpper F, Witzenrath M, Zoller T, Stehning C, Gerhardt H, Sánchez-González J, Alskaf E, Kühne T, Pieske B, Tschöpe C, Chiribiri A, Kelle S (2022) Brief Research Report: quantitative analysis of potential coronary microvascular disease in suspected Long-COVID syndrome. Front Cardiovasc Med 9:877416
Drakos S, Chatzantonis G, Bietenbeck M, Evers G, Schulze AB, Mohr M, Fonfara H, Meier C, Yilmaz A (2021) A cardiovascular magnetic resonance imaging-based pilot study to assess coronary microvascular disease in COVID-19 patients. Sci Rep 11:15667
Murphey MD, Sartoris DJ, Quale JL, Pathria MN, Martin NL (1993) Musculoskeletal manifestations of chronic renal insufficiency. Radiographics 13:357–379
Park ET, Kim S-e, Radiography (2010) Bone scan, and F-18 FDG PET/CT imaging findings in a patient with Paget’s Disease. Nuclear Med Mol Imaging 44:87–89
Becker RC (2020) COVID-19-associated vasculitis and vasculopathy. J Thromb Thrombolysis 50:499–511
Palmer JH, Ian Taylor G (1986) The vascular territories of the anterior chest wall. Br J Plast Surg 39:287–299
Rodriguez ER, Tan CD (2017) Structure and anatomy of the human pericardium. Prog Cardiovasc Dis 59:327–340
Hudson CL, Moritz AR, Wearn JT (1932) THE EXTRACARDIAC ANASTOMOSES OF THE CORONARY ARTERIES. J Exp Med 56:919–925
Stefan N (2023) SARS-CoV-2 fires up inflammation in adipose tissue. Nat Reviews Endocrinol 19:8–9
Saccon TD, Mousovich-Neto F, Ludwig RG, Carregari VC, dos Anjos Souza AB, dos Passos ASC, Martini MC, Barbosa PP, de Souza GF, Muraro SP, Forato J, Amorim MR, Marques RE, Veras FP, Barreto E, Gonçalves TT, Paiva IM, Fazolini NPB, Onodera CMK, Martins Junior RB, de Araújo PHC, Batah SS, Viana RMM, de Melo DM, Fabro AT, Arruda E, Queiroz Cunha F, Cunha TM, Pretti MAM, Smith BJ, Marques-Souza H, Knittel TL, Ruiz GP, Profeta GS, Fontes-Cal TCM, Boroni M, Vinolo MAR, Farias AS, Moraes-Vieira PMM, Bizzacchi JMA, Teesalu T, Chaim FDM, Cazzo E, Chaim EA, Souza D, Osako MK, Leiria LO, Mori MA (2022) SARS-CoV-2 infects adipose tissue in a fat depot- and viral lineage-dependent manner. Nat Commun 13:5722
D’AVILA A, SCANAVACCA M, SOSA E (2003) RUSKIN JN and REDDY VY. Pericardial anatomy for the interventional electrophysiologist. J Cardiovasc Electrophys 14:422–430
Randall WC, Ardell JL (1985) Selective parasympathectomy of automatic and conductile tissues of the canine heart. Am J Physiol 248:H61–H68
Salari R, Ballard DH, Hoegger MJ, Young D, Shetty AS (2022) Fat-only Dixon: how to use it in body MRI. Abdom Radiol 47:2527–2544
Tarsitano MG, Pandozzi C, Muscogiuri G, Sironi S, Pujia A, Lenzi A, Giannetta E (2022) Epicardial adipose tissue: a novel potential imaging marker of comorbidities caused by chronic inflammation. Nutrients 14:2926
Singhal D, Börner K, Chaikof EL, Detmar M, Hollmén M, Iliff JJ, Itkin M, Makinen T, Oliver G, Padera TP, Quardokus EM, Radtke AJ, Suami H, Weber GM, Rovira II, Muratoglu SC, Galis ZS (2023) Mapping the lymphatic system across body scales and expertise domains: A report from the 2021 National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute workshop at the Boston Lymphatic Symposium. Frontiers in Physiology;14
MacDonald ME, Weathered RK, Stewart EC, Magold AI, Mukherjee A, Gurbuxani S, Smith H, McMullen P, Mueller J, Husain AN, Salles CM, Briquez PS, Rouhani SJ, Yu J, Trujillo J, Pyzer AR, Gajewski TF, Sperling AI, Kilarski WW, Swartz MA (2022) Lymphatic coagulation and neutrophil extracellular traps in lung-draining lymph nodes of COVID-19 decedents. Blood Adv 6:6249–6262
Son A, O’Donnell TF (2023) Lymphatic disease. In: Murga A, Teruya TH, Abou-Zamzam AM Jr, Bianchi C (eds) The vascular surgery In-Training examination review (VSITE). Springer International Publishing, Cham, pp 439–447
Gianesini S, Rimondi E, Raffetto JD, Melloni E, Pellati A, Menegatti E, Avruscio GP, Bassetto F, Costa AL, Rockson S (2023) Human collecting lymphatic glycocalyx identification by electron microscopy and immunohistochemistry. Sci Rep 13:3022
Stochkendahl MJ, Christensen HW (2010) Chest pain in focal musculoskeletal disorders. Med Clin N Am 94:259–273
Filippetti L, Pace N, Louis JS, Mandry D, Goehringer F, Rocher MS, Jay N, Selton-Suty C, Hossu G, Huttin O, Marie PY (2022) Long-lasting myocardial and skeletal muscle damage evidenced by serial CMR during the First Year in COVID-19 patients from the First Wave. Front Cardiovasc Med 9:831580
Talarico R, Aguilera S, Alexander T, Amoura Z, Antunes AM, Arnaud L, Avcin T, Beretta L, Bombardieri S, Burmester GR, Cannizzo S, Cavagna L, Chaigne B, Cornet A, Costedoat-Chalumeau N, Doria A, Ferraris A, Fischer-Betz R, Fonseca JE, Frank C, Gaglioti A, Galetti I, Grunert J, Guimarães V, Hachulla E, Houssiau F, Iaccarino L, Krieg T, Limper M, Malfait F, Mariette X, Marinello D, Martin T, Matthews L, Matucci-Cerinic M, Meyer A, Montecucco C, Mouthon L, Müller-Ladner U, Rednic S, Romão VC, Schneider M, Smith V, Sulli A, Tamirou F, Taruscio D, Taulaigo AV, Terol E, Tincani A, Ticciati S, Turchetti G, van Hagen PM, van Laar JM, Vieira A, de Vries-Bouwstra JK, Cutolo M, Mosca M (2021) The impact of COVID-19 on rare and complex connective tissue diseases: the experience of ERN ReCONNET. Nat Rev Rheumatol 17:177–184
Imanishi Y, Mitogawa Y, Takizawa M, Konno S, Samuta H, Ohsawa A, Kawaguchi A, Fujikawa M, Sakaida H, Shinagawa T, Yamashita H (1999) Relapsing polychondritis diagnosed by Tc-99m MDP bone scintigraphy. Clin Nucl Med 24:511–513
Qian J, Xu H (2022) COVID-19 disease and dermatomyositis: a mini-review. Front Immunol 12:5924
Newell KL, Waickman AT (2022) Inflammation, immunity, and antigen persistence in post-acute sequelae of SARS-CoV-2 infection. Curr Opin Immunol 77:102228
Nair SP, Meghji S, Wilson M, Reddi K, White P, Henderson B (1996) Bacterially induced bone destruction: mechanisms and misconceptions. Infect Immun 64:2371–2380
Awosanya OD, Dadwal UC, Imel EA, Yu Q, Kacena MA (2022) The impacts of COVID-19 on Musculoskeletal Health. Curr Osteoporos Rep 20:213–225
Awosanya OD, Dalloul CE, Blosser RJ, Dadwal UC, Carozza M, Boschen K, Klemsz MJ, Johnston NA, Bruzzaniti A, Robinson CM, Srour EF, Kacena MA (2022) Osteoclast-mediated bone loss observed in a COVID-19 mouse model. Bone 154:116227
Widyadharma IPE, Dewi PR, Wijayanti IAS, Utami DKI (2020) Pain related viral infections: a literature review. Egypt J Neurol Psychiatr Neurosurg 56:105–105
Rossi P, Vollono C, Valeriani M, Sandrini G (2011) The contribution of clinical neurophysiology to the comprehension of the tension-type headache mechanisms. Clin neurophysiology: official J Int Federation Clin Neurophysiol 122:1075–1085
Sreejit G, Nooti SK, Jaggers RM, Athmanathan B, Park KH, Al-Sharea A, Johnson J, Dahdah A, Lee MKS, Ma J, Murphy AJ, Nagareddy PR (2022) Retention of the NLRP3 inflammasome–primed neutrophils in the bone marrow is essential for myocardial Infarction–Induced Granulopoiesis. Circulation 145:31–44
Wang Y, Jiang H, Hu X, Fu W (2021) Bone marrow NLRP3 inflammasome-IL-1β signal regulates post-myocardial infarction megakaryocyte development and platelet production. Biochem Biophys Res Commun 585:96–102
Meizlish ML, Pine AB, Bishai JD, Goshua G, Nadelmann ER, Simonov M, Chang C-H, Zhang H, Shallow M, Bahel P, Owusu K, Yamamoto Y, Arora T, Atri DS, Patel A, Gbyli R, Kwan J, Won CH, Dela Cruz C, Price C, Koff J, King BA, Rinder HM, Wilson FP, Hwa J, Halene S, Damsky W, van Dijk D, Lee AI, Chun HJ (2021) A neutrophil activation signature predicts critical illness and mortality in COVID-19. Blood Adv 5:1164–1177
Vassilopoulos D, Calabrese LH (2008) Virally associated arthritis 2008: clinical, epidemiologic, and pathophysiologic considerations. Arthritis Res Ther 10:215
Wang JY, Zhang W, Roehrl VB, Roehrl MW, Roehrl MH (2022) An Autoantigen Atlas from Human Lung HFL1 cells offers clues to neurological and diverse autoimmune manifestations of COVID-19.Frontiers in immunology; 13
Hsueh B, Chen R, Jo Y, Tang D, Raffiee M, Kim YS, Inoue M, Randles S, Ramakrishnan C, Patel S, Kim DK, Liu TX, Kim SH, Tan L, Mortazavi L, Cordero A, Shi J, Zhao M, Ho TT, Crow A, Yoo A-CW, Raja C, Evans K, Bernstein D, Zeineh M, Goubran M, Deisseroth K (2023) Cardiogenic control of affective behavioural state. Nature 615:292–299
Helms J, Kremer S, Merdji H, Clere-Jehl R, Schenck M, Kummerlen C, Collange O, Boulay C, Fafi-Kremer S, Ohana M (2020) Neurologic features in severe SARS-CoV-2 infection. N Engl J Med 382:2268–2270
Johnson RW, Rice AS (2014) Postherpetic neuralgia. N Engl J Med 371:1526–1533
Attal N, Martinez V, Bouhassira D (2021) Potential for increased prevalence of neuropathic pain after the COVID-19 pandemic.Pain reports; 6
Carfì A, Bernabei R, Landi F (2020) Group ftGAC-P-ACS. Persistent symptoms in patients after Acute COVID-19. JAMA 324:603–605
Meyer-Frießem CH, Gierthmühlen J, Baron R, Sommer C, Üçeyler N, Enax-Krumova EK (2021) Pain during and after COVID-19 in Germany and worldwide: a narrative review of current knowledge. Pain Rep 6:e893
Zhao Y, Shi L, Jiang Z, Zeng N, Mei H, Lu Y, Yang J, Jin F, Ni S, Wu S, Su S, Zheng Y, Yuan K, Yan W, Sun S, Meng S, Sun J, Khan Z, Aarsland D, Shi J, Li X, Bao Y, Lu L (2023) The phenotype and prediction of long-term physical, mental and cognitive COVID-19 sequelae 20 months after recovery, a community-based cohort study in China.Molecular Psychiatry.
Abrams RMC, Simpson DM, Navis A, Jette N, Zhou L, Shin SC (2022) Small fiber neuropathy associated with SARS-CoV-2 infection. Muscle Nerve 65:440–443
Ghosh R, Roy D, Sengupta S, Benito-León J (2020) Autonomic dysfunction heralding acute motor axonal neuropathy in COVID-19. J Neurovirol 26:964–966
Novak P, Mukerji SS, Alabsi HS, Systrom D, Marciano SP, Felsenstein D, Mullally WJ, Pilgrim DM (2022) Multisystem involvement in Post-Acute Sequelae of Coronavirus Disease 19. Ann Neurol 91:367–379
Evans PC, Rainger GE, Mason JC, Guzik TJ, Osto E, Stamataki Z, Neil D, Hoefer IE, Fragiadaki M, Waltenberger J, Weber C, Bochaton-Piallat ML (2020) And Bäck M. endothelial dysfunction in COVID-19: a position paper of the ESC Working Group for Atherosclerosis and Vascular Biology, and the ESC Council of Basic Cardiovascular Science. Cardiovasc Res 116:2177–2184
Vrablik M, Corsini A, Tůmová E (2022) Beta-blockers for atherosclerosis Prevention: a missed opportunity? Curr Atheroscler Rep 24:161–169
Ormiston CK, Świątkiewicz I, Taub PR (2022) Postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome as a sequela of COVID-19. Heart Rhythm 19:1880–1889
Excellence N, for H, Practitioners C, SIGN HIS (2020) RC of G,. COVID-19 rapid guideline: managing the long-term effects of COVID-19. National Institute for Health and Care Excellence, London.
Covid N rapid guideline: managing the long-term effects of COVID-19. National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) Priya Venkatesan NICE guideline on long COVID. Lancet 9;2:P129, FEBRUARY 2021.
London AJ, Seymour CW (2023) The Ethics of Clinical Research: managing persistent uncertainty. JAMA 329:884–885
Ceban F, Leber A, Jawad MY, Yu M, Lui LM, Subramaniapillai M, Di Vincenzo JD, Gill H (2022) Rodrigues NB and Cao B. registered clinical trials investigating treatment of long COVID: a scoping review and recommendations for research. Infect Dis 54:467–477
Collins F, Adam S, Colvis C, Desrosiers E, Draghia-Akli R, Fauci A, Freire M, Gibbons G, Hall M, Hughes E (2023) The NIH-led research response to COVID-19. Sci (New York NY) 379:441–444
Acknowledgements
I would like to acknowledge all members of the University of Cincinnati COVID-19 Recovery Clinic for their commitment, compassion, and willingness to enter a new discipline of medicine, or more accurately stated a group of post-viral conditions that have stimulated many questions without clear and well validated answers. Freely admitting that one neither knows nor has ready access to the answers can be an uncomfortable and unfamiliar position for many clinicians. Yet, what is science and medicine if not the willingness to seek, inquire, and commit to filling knowledge gaps for the sake of our patients?
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher’s Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Electronic supplementary material
Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Becker, R.C. Evaluating chest pain in patients with post COVID conditions permission to think outside of the box. J Thromb Thrombolysis 55, 592–603 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11239-023-02808-8
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11239-023-02808-8