Abstract
This article argues that the analogy between conceptual changes in the history of science and conceptual changes in the development of young children is problematic. We show that the notions of ‘conceptual change’ in Kuhn and Piaget’s projects, the two thinkers whose work is most commonly drawn upon to support this analogy, are not compatible in the sense usually claimed. We contend that Kuhn’s work pertains not so much to the psychology of individual scientists, but to the way philosophers and historians should describe developments in communities of scientists. Furthermore, we argue that the analogy is based on a misunderstanding of the nature of science and the relation between science and common sense. The distinctiveness of the two notions of conceptual change has implications for science education research, since it raises serious questions about the relevance of Kuhn’s remarks for the study of pedagogical issues.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Boden MA (1979) Piaget. Harvester Press, Brighton
Butterfield H (1931) The Whig interpretation of history. Bell, London
Carey S (1986) Cognitive science and science education. Am Psychol 41(10):1123–1130
Cawthron ER, Rowell JA (1978) Epistemology and science education. Stud Sci Educ 5:31–59
Chi MTH, Roscoe RD (2002) The processes and challenges of conceptual change. In: Limón M, Mason L (eds) Reconsidering conceptual change. issues in theory and practice. Kluwer, Dordrecht, pp 3–27
Clement J (1982) Students’ preconception in introductory mechanics. Am J Phys 50(1):66–71
Cook J (1969) Human beings. In: Winch P (ed) Studies in the philosophy of Wittgenstein. Routledge & Kegan Paul, London, pp 117–151
Coulter J (1989) Mind in action. Polity, Cambridge
di Sessa AA (1982) Unlearning Aristotelian physics: a study of knowledge-based learning. Cognitive Sci 6(1):37–75
Driver R (1983) The pupil as scientist? Open University Press, Milton Keynes
Driver R, Asoko H, Leach J, Mortimer E, Scott P (1994) Constructing scientific knowledge in the classroom. Educ Res 23(7):5–12
Duit R, Treagust DF (2003) Conceptual change: a powerful framework for improving science teaching and learning. Int J Sci Educ 25(16):671–688
Evans-Pritchard EE (1937) Witchcraft, oracles and magic among the Azande. Clarendon Press, Oxford
French J (1989) Accomplishing scientific instruction. In: Millar R (ed) Doing science: images of science in science education. Falmer, London, pp 10–37
Garfinkel H (1967) Studies in ethnomethodology. Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ
Garrison JW, Bentley ML (1990) Science education, conceptual change and breaking with everyday experience. Stud Philos Educ 10:19–35
Gibson BS (1985) The convergence of Kuhn and cognitive psychology. New Ideas Psychol 2(3):211–221
Gilbert JK, Osborne RJ, Fensham PJ (1982) Children’s science and its consequence for teaching. Sci Educ 66(4):623–633
Gruber H (1973) Courage and cognitive growth in children and scientists. In: Schwebel M, Raph J (eds) Piaget in the classroom. Basic Books, New York, pp 73–105
Hewson PW (1981) A conceptual change approach to learning science. Eur J Sci Educ 3(4):383–396
Hewson PW, Hewson MG (1984) The role of conceptual conflict in conceptual change and the design of science instruction. Instruct Sci 13(1):1–13
Kitcher P (1988) The child as parent of the scientist. Mind & Language 3(3):217–228
Kitchener RF (1987) Genetic epistemology: equilibration and the rationality of scientific change. Stud History Philos Sci 18(3):339–366
Kuhn D (1989) Children and adults as intuitive scientists. Psychol Rev 96(4):674–689
Kuhn TS (1957) The Copernican revolution: planetary astronomy in the development of Western thought. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA
Kuhn TS (1970a) Logic of discovery or psychology of research? In: Lakatos I, Musgrave A (eds) Criticism and the growth of knowledge. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 1–23
Kuhn TS (1970b) Reflections on my critics. In: Lakatos I, Musgrave A (eds) Criticism and the growth of knowledge. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 231–278
Kuhn TS (1977 [1959]) The essential tension: tradition and innovation in scientific research. In: Kuhn TS (ed) The essential tension: selected studies in scientific tradition and change. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp 225–239. Originally published 1959 in Taylor CW (ed), The Third (1959) University of Utah research conference on the identification of scientific talent. University of Utah Press, Salt Lake City
Kuhn TS (1977 [1964]) A function for thought experiments. In: The essential tension: selected studies in scientific tradition and change. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp 240–265. Originally published 1964 in L’aventure de la science. Mélanges Alexandre Koyré, Hermann, Paris
Kuhn TS (1977 [1971]) Concepts of cause in the development of physics. In: The essential tension: selected studies in scientific tradition and change. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp 21–30. Originally published 1971 as ‘Les notions de causalité dans le developpement de la physique’ in Edudes d’épistémologie génétique 25
Kuhn TS (1977 [1974]) Second thoughts on paradigms. In: The essential tension: selected studies in scientific tradition and change. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp 293–319. Originally published 1974 in Suppe F (ed) The structure of scientific theories. University of Illinois Press, Urbana
Kuhn TS (1989a) Possible worlds in history of science. In: Allén S (ed) Possible worlds in humanities, arts and sciences. Walter de Gruyter, Berlin, pp 9–32
Kuhn TS (1989b) Speaker’s reply. In: Allén S (ed) Possible worlds in humanities, arts and sciences. Walter de Gruyter, Berlin pp 49–51
Kuhn TS (1990) The road since structure. In: PSA 1990, vol. 2, pp 3–13
Kuhn TS (1996) The structure of scientific revolutions, 3rd edn. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Lakatos I, Musgrave A (eds) (1970) Criticism and the growth of knowledge. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Leach J, Scott P (2003) Individual and sociocultural views of learning in science education. Sci & Educ 12(1):91–113
Levine AT (2000) Which ways is up? Thomas S. Kuhn’s analogy to conceptual development in childhood. Sci & Educ 9(1/2):107–122
Loving CC, Cobern WW (2000) Invoking Thomas Kuhn: what citation analysis reveals about science education. Sci & Educ 9(1/2):187–206
Lynch M, Macbeth DH (1998) Demonstrating physics lessons. In: Greeno JG, Goldman SV (eds) Thinking practices in mathematics and science learning. Lawrence Erlbaum, Mahwah, NJ, pp 269–297
Macbeth DH (2000) On an actual apparatus for conceptual change. Sci Educ 84(2):228–264
Macbeth DH (2005) Respecifying concepts: the case of classroom research. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association (AERA), Montreal, April 2005
Matthews MR (2000) Editorial. Sci & Educ 9(1/2):1–10
Matthews MR (2003) Thomas Kuhn’s impact on science education: what lessons can be learned?. Sci Educ 88(1):90–118
Maxwell G, Feigl H (1961) Why ordinary language needs reforming. J Philos 58(18):488–498
McCloskey M (1983) Naive theories of motion. In: Gentner D, Stevens AL (eds) Mental models. Lawrence Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ, pp 299–324
Nersessian NJ (1989) Conceptual change in science and in science education. Synthese 80(1):163–183
Osborne RJ (1980) Some aspects of students’ views of the world. Res Sci Educ 10:11–18
Piaget J (1930) The child’s conception of physical causality. Routledge, London
Piaget J (1970) Genetic epistemology. Columbia University Press, New York
Popper KR (1970) Against “Normal science”. In: Lakatos I, Musgrave A (eds) Criticism and the growth of knowledge. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 51–58
Posner GJ, Strike KA, Hewson PW, Gertzog WA (1982) Accommodation of a scientific conception: toward a theory of conceptual change. Sci Educ 66(2):211–227
Reiner M, Chi MTH, Resnick LB (1988) Naive materialistic belief: an underlying epistemological commitment.In: Proceedings of the tenth annual conference of the Cognitive Science Society (August 17–19, 1988, Montreal, Canada). Lawrence Erlbaum, NJ, pp 544–551
Resnick LB (1983) Mathematics and science learning: a new conception. Science 220(4596):477–478
Rotman B (1977) Jean Piaget: psychologist of the real. Harvester Press, Hassocks
Ryle G (1954a) The world of science and the everyday world. In: Ryle G (ed) Dilemmas. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 68–81
Ryle G (1954b) Technical and untechnical concepts. In: Ryle G (ed) Dilemmas. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 82–92
Schütz A (1962a) Common-sense and scientific interpretation of human action. In: Collected papers I: studies in social theory. Martinus Nijhoff, The Hague, pp 3–47
Schütz A (1962b) On multiple realities. In: Collected papers I: studies in social theory. Martinus Nijhoff, The Hague, pp 207–259
Shanker SG (2004) The roots of mindblindness. Theory Psychol 14(5):685–703
Sharrock WW, Anderson DC (1982) The persistent evasion of technical issues in media studies. Sociology 16(1):108–115
Sharrock WW, Read R (2002) Kuhn: philosopher of scientific revolution. Polity, Oxford
Siegel H (1982) On the parallel between Piagetian cognitive development and the history of science. Philos Soc Sci 12(4):375–386
Vosniadou S (1989) On the nature of children’s naive knowledge. In: Proceedings of the eleventh annual conference of the Cognitive Science Society (August 16–19, 1989, Ann Arbor, Michigan). Lawrence Erlbaum, NJ, pp 404–411
Vosniadou S, Brewer WF (1987) Theories of knowledge restructuring in development. Rev Educ Res 57(1):51–67
Vosniadou S, Brewer WF (1992) Mental models of the earth: a study of conceptual change in childhood. Cognitive Psychol 24(4):535–585
Vosniadou S, Ioannides C (1998) From conceptual development to science education: a psychological point of view. Int J Sci Educ 20(10):1213–1230
Winch P (1964) Understanding a primitive society. Am Philos Quart 1:304–324
Wittgenstein L (1953) Philosophical investigations (Translated by GEM Anscombe). Basil Blackwell, Oxford
Wittgenstein L (1979) Remarks on Frazer’s “Golden Bough”. In: Luckhardt CG (ed) Wittgenstein: sources and perspectives. Harvester Press, Hassocks, pp 61–81
Woodfield A (1987) On the very idea of acquiring a concept. In: Russell J (ed) Philosophical perspectives on developmental psychology. Basil Blackwell, Oxford, pp 17–30
Wolpert L (1992) The unnatural nature of science. Faber and Faber, London
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank Wes Sharrock and two anonymous reviewers for helpful comments and criticisms on an earlier version. Christian Greiffenhagen would like to thank the British Academy for a Postdoctoral Fellowship to support work on this paper.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Greiffenhagen, C., Sherman, W. Kuhn and conceptual change: on the analogy between conceptual changes in science and children. Sci & Educ 17, 1–26 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11191-006-9063-5
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11191-006-9063-5