Abstract
Despite its great importance, many students and even their teachers still cannot recognize the relevance of models to build up physical knowledge and are unable to develop qualitative explanations for mathematical expressions that exist within physics. Thus, it is not a surprise that analogies play an important role in science education, since students’ construction of mental models of abstract phenomena need to be rooted in some existing or previous experience in order to interpret more complex ideas. The present article focuses on some of these issues by analyzing some specific instances of the historical development of the electromagnetic theory. Using the mental models framework, the importance of mechanical analogies to understand some of the electromagnetic concepts are emphasized.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Achinstein P. (1964). Models, Analogies, and Theories. Philosophy of Science 31(4):328–350
Barquero, B.: 1995, La Representatión de Estados Mentales en la Comprensión de Textos desde el Enfoque Teórico de los Modelos Mentales, Doctorate thesis, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, Madrid
Adúriz-Bravo A., Morales L. (2002). El Concepto de Modelo en la Enseñanza de la Física – Consideraciones Epistemológicas, Didácticas y Retóricas. Caderno Brasileiro de Ensino de Física 19(1):79–92
Borges A.T. (1998). Models of Magnetism. International Journal of Science Education 20(3):361–378
Clement J. (1989). Learning Via Model Construction and Criticism. In: Glover G., Ronning R., Reynolds C. (eds). Handbook of Creativity: Assessment, Theory, and Research. Plenum, New York, pp. 341–81
Clement J. (2000). Model Based Learning as a Key Research Area for Science Education. International Journal of Science Education 22(9):1041–1053
Coll R.K., France B., Taylor I. (2005). The Role of Models/and Analogies in Science Education: Implications from Research. International Journal of Science Education 27(2):183–198
Crowe J.M. (1967). A History of Vector Analysis: the Evolution of the Idea of a Vectorial System. University of Notre Dame Press, London
Darrigol O. (2000). Electrodynamics from Ampère to Einstein. Oxford University Press, New York
DeKleer J., Brown J.S. (1983). Assumptions and Ambiguities in Mechanistic Mental Models. In: Gentner D., Stevens A.L. (eds). Mental Models. Lawrence Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ
Duit R. (1991). On the Role of Analogies and Metaphors in Learning Science. Science Education 75(6):649–672
Gentner D., Stevens A.L. (1983). Mental Models. Lawrence Erlbaum, Hillsdale NJ
Giere R.N. (1992). Cognitive Models of Sciece. In: Giere R. (eds). Minnesota Studies in the Philosophy of Science. University of Minneapolis Press, Minneapolis
Gilbert J.K., Boulter C.J. (eds) (2000). Developing Models in Science Education, Kluwer, Dorbrecht
Gilbert J.K., Boulter C.J., Elmer R. (2000). Positioning Models in Science Education and in Design and Technology Education. In: Gilbert J.K., Boulter C.J. (eds). Developing Models in Science Education. Kluwer, Dorbrecht
Greca I.M., Moreira M.A. (1998). Modelos Mentales y Aprendizaje de Física en Electricidad y Magnetismo. Enseñanza de las ciencias 16(2):289–303
Greca I.M., Moreira M.A. (2000). Mental Models, Conceptual Models, and Moddeling. International Journal of Science 22(1):1–11
Greca I.M., Moreira M.A. (2002). Mental, Physical, and Mathematical Models in the Teaching and Learning of Physics. Science Education 85(6):106–121
Hesse M. (1972). Models and Analogy in Science. In: Edwards P. (eds). The Encyclopedia of Philosophy. MacMillan, New York, vol. 5 pp. 354–359
Heywood D. (2002). The Place of Analogies in Science Education. Cambridge Journal of Education 32(2):233–247
Isla S.M., Pesa M.A. (2003). ¿Qué Rol Asignan los Profesores de Física de Nivel Medio a los Modelos Científicos y a las Actividades de Modelado?. Enseñanza de las ciencias 21:57–66
Johnson-Laird P.N. (1983). Mental Models. Harvard University Press, Cambridge
Justi R.S., Gilbert J.K. (2002). Science Teachers’ Knowledge about and Attitudes towards the Use of Models and Modelling in Learning Science. International Journal of Science Education 24(12):1273–1292
Kipnis N. (2005). Scientific Analogies and Their Use in Teaching Science. Science & Education 14:199–233
Lozano S.R., Cardenas M. (2002). Some Learning Problems Concerning the Use of Symbolic Language in Physics. Science & Education 11:589–599
Maxwell J.C. (1861). On Physical Lines of Force, part II. Philosophical Magazine 21:281–91
Maxwell J.C. (1954). Treatise on Electricity and Magnetism. Dover, New York
Maxwell J.C. (1965). The Scientific Papers. Dover, New York Volume 1
Nersessian N.J. (1992). How Do Scientistis Think? Capturing the Dynamics of Conceptual Change in Science. In: Giere R. (eds). Minnesota Studies in the Philosophy of Science. University of Minneapolis Press, Minneapolis
Nersessian N. (1995). Should Physicists Preach what They Practice?. Science & Education 4:203–226
Nersessian N.J. (2002). Maxwell and the “Method of Physical Analogy”: Model-based Reasoning, Generic Abstraction, and the Conceptual Change. In: Malament D. (eds). Reading Natural Philosophy: Essays in the History and Philosophy of Science and Mathematics. Open Court, Lassalle, pp. 129–166
Rainson S., Transtromer G., Viennot L. (1994). ‘Students’ Understanding of Superposition of Electric Fields’. American Journal of Physics 62(11):1026–1032
Silva, C.C.: 2002, Da Força ao Tensor: Evolução do Conceito Físico e da Representação Matemática do Campo Eletromagnético. Doctorate dissertation. Universidade Estadual de Campinas. Instituto de Física “Gleb Wataghin”, Campinas-Brazil
Silva C.C., Martins R.A. (2003). William Thomson e o Uso de Analogias e Modelos no Eletromagnetismo. Epistemología e Historia de la Ciencia 9:401–409
Silva, C.C. & Pietrocola, M.: 2003, ‘O Papel Estruturante da Matemática na Teoria Eletromagnética: um Estudo Histórico e Suas Implicações Didáticas’, paper presented at the IV ENPEC (IV National Meeting of Researchers on Science Teaching), Bauru-Brazil
Thagard P. (1992). Analogy, Explanation and Education. Journal of Research in Science Teaching 29(6):537–544
Thomson W. (1872). On the Uniform Motion of Heat in Homogeneous Solid Bodies and its Connection with Mathematical Theory of Electricity. In: Thomson W. (eds). Reprint of Papers on Electrostatic and Magnetism. MacMillan & Co, London, pp. 1–14
Thomson W. (1882/1911). On a Mechanical Representation of Electric, Magnetic, and Galvanic Forces. In Thomson W. (eds). Mathematical and Physical Papers of William Thomson. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, vol. 1 pp. 76–80
Thomson, W.: 1884, Notes of Lectures on Molecular Dynamics and the Wave Theory of Light. Delivered at the John Hopkins University of Baltimore. Stenographically reported by A. S. Hathaway
Van Driel I., Verloop N. (1999). Teachers’ Knowledge of Models and Modelling Science. International Journal of Science Education 21(11):1141–1153
Acknowledgements
I appreciate the reviewers’ comments and recommendations. I wish to thank Roberto de Andrade Martins and Maurício Pietrocola who provided stimulating discussions. I am also thankful to The State of Sao Paulo Research Foundation and to The National Council for Scientific and Technological Development.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Silva, C.C. The Role of Models and Analogies in the Electromagnetic Theory: A Historical Case Study. Sci & Educ 16, 835–848 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11191-006-9008-z
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11191-006-9008-z