Abstract
Throughout its long history, the conceptual change literature assumed that student ‘misconceptions’ in mechanics have been formed prior to instruction. As an attempt to shed light on conceptual change, this paper examines some of the trends in the literature and argues that misconceptions may be spontaneous rather than preformed, that schema theory may be the most appropriate theory to take into account this spontaneity, that misconceptions should also be viewed through the lens of the subject as a system of well-defined concepts and that any conceptual change model may have to be prescriptive and engage the student with a meta-discourse concerning the abstract nature of the subject.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
A.B. Arons (1990) A Guide to Introductory Physics Teaching J. Wiley and Sons New York
J. Berry E. Graham (1991) ArticleTitle‘Using Concept Questions in Teaching Mechanics’ Internation Journal of Mathematical Education Science and Technology 22 749–757
H.J.A. Biemans O.R. Deel P. Robert-Jan Simons (2001) ArticleTitle‘Differences Between Successful and less Successful Students While Working with the CONTACT-2 Strategy’ Learning and Instruction 11 IssueID4–5 265–282 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0959-4752(00)00033-5
B. Boeha (1990) ArticleTitle‘Aristotle, Alive and Well in Papua New Guinea Science Classrooms’ Physics Education 25 280–283 Occurrence Handle10.1088/0031-9120/25/5/314
J. Bliss J. Ogborn (1994) ArticleTitle‘Force and Motion from the Beginning’ Learning and Instruction 4 7–25 Occurrence Handle10.1016/0959-4752(94)90016-7
N. Burbles M. Linn (1988) ArticleTitle‘Response to Contradiction: Scientific Reasoning During Adolescence’ Journal of Educational Psychology 80 IssueID1 67–75 Occurrence Handle10.1037/0022-0663.80.1.67
S. Caravita (2001) ArticleTitle‘Commentary: A Re-framed Conceptual Change Theory?’ Learning and Instruction 11 IssueID4–5 421–429 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0959-4752(00)00039-6
A. Champagne L. Klopfer R. Gunstone (1982) ArticleTitle‘Cognitive Research and the Design of Science Instruction’ Educational Psychology 17 IssueID1 31–53
M.T.H. Chi J.D. Slotta N. Leeuw Particlede (1994) ArticleTitle‘From Things to Processes: A Theory of Conceptual Change for Learning Science Concepts’ Learning and Instruction 4 27–43 Occurrence Handle10.1016/0959-4752(94)90017-5
V.V. Davydov (1988) ArticleTitle‘Problems of Developmental Teaching: The Experience of Theoretical and Experimental Psychological Research (part 2)’ Soviet Education 30 IssueID9 3–83
A.A. diSessa (1993) ArticleTitle‘Towards an Epistemology of Physics’ Cognition and Instruction 10 IssueID2 & 3 105–225 Occurrence Handle10.1207/s1532690xci1002&3_2
A.A. diSessa B.L. Sherin (1998) ArticleTitle‘What Changes in Conceptual Change?’ International Journal of Science Education 20 1155–1191
R. Driver J. Easley (1978) ArticleTitle‘Pupils and Paradigms: A Review of Literature Related to Concept Development in Adolescent Students’ Studies in Science Education 5 61–84
R. Driver H. Asoko J. Leach E. Mortimer P. Scott (1994) ArticleTitle‘Constructing Scientific Knowledge in the Classroom’ Educational Researcher 23 IssueID7 5–12 Occurrence Handle10.2307/1176933
Duit, R.: 2002, “Conceptual Change – Still a Powerful Frame for Improving Science Teaching and Learning”, Proceedings of the Third European Symposium on Conceptual Change: A process approach to conceptual change, June 26–28, 2002, Turku, Finland
J. Gilbert M. Watts R. Osborne (1982) ArticleTitle‘Student’s Conceptions of Ideas in Mechanics’ Physics Education 17 62–66 Occurrence Handle10.1088/0031-9120/17/2/309
R.R. Hake (1987) ArticleTitle‘Promoting Student Crossover to the Newtonian World’ American Journal of Physics 55 878–884 Occurrence Handle10.1119/1.14945
I. Halloun (1998) ArticleTitle‘Schematic Concepts for Schematic Models of the Real World: The Newtonian Concept of Force’ Science Education 82 IssueID2 239–264 Occurrence Handle10.1002/(SICI)1098-237X(199804)82:2<239::AID-SCE7>3.0.CO;2-F
I. Halloun D. Hestenes (1987) ArticleTitle‘Modeling Instructions in Mechanics’ American Journal of Physics 55 455–462 Occurrence Handle10.1119/1.15130
H. Helm (1980) ArticleTitle‘Misconceptions in Physics Among South African Students’ Physics Education 15 92–97 Occurrence Handle10.1088/0031-9120/15/2/308
D. Hestenes (1987) New Foundations of Classical Mechanics Reidel Boston
D. Hestenes (1992) ArticleTitle‘Modeling Games in the Newtonian World’ American Journal of Physics 60 IssueID8 732–748 Occurrence Handle10.1119/1.17080
R. Howard (1987) Concepts and Schemata Cassell Educational London
J. Jagger (1985) ArticleTitle‘Introducing Mechanics – A Response’ Mathematics in Schools 14 24–25
J. Kuiper (1994) ArticleTitle‘Student Ideas of Science Concepts: Alternative Frameworks?’ International Journal of Science Education 16 IssueID3 279–292
J. Leach P. Scott (2003) ArticleTitle‘Individual and Sociocultural Views of Learning in Science Education’ Science and Education 12 IssueID1 91–113 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1022665519862
L. Leboutet-Barrell (1976) ArticleTitle‘Concepts of Mechanics Among Young People’ Physics Education 11 462–466 Occurrence Handle10.1088/0031-9120/11/7/308
M. Limón (2001) ArticleTitle‘On the Cognitive Conflict as an Instructional Strategy for Conceptual Change: a Critical Appraisal’ Learning and Instruction 11 IssueID4–5 357–380 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0959-4752(00)00037-2
C.J. Linder (1993) ArticleTitle‘A Challenge to Conceptual Change’ Science Education 77 IssueID3 293–300 Occurrence Handle10.1002/sce.3730770304
M. McCloskey A. Caramazza B. Green (1980) ArticleTitle‘Curvilinear Motion in the Absence of External Forces: Naïve Beliefs About the Motion of Objects’ Science 219 1139–1141 Occurrence Handle10.1126/science.210.4474.1139
MA.: 1965, A Second Report on the Teaching of Mechanics in Schools, Mathematics Association, G. Bell & Sons Ltd., London
F. Marton (1986) ArticleTitle‘Phenomenography – A Research Approach to Investigating Different Understandings of Reality’ Journal of Thought 21 IssueID3 28–49
L. Mason (2001) ArticleTitle‘Introduction’ Learning and Instruction 11 IssueID4–5 259–263 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0959-4752(00)00032-3
M.R. Matthews (1994) Science Teaching: The Role of History and Philosophy of Science Routledge London
M.R. Matthews (2000) Time for Science Education: How teaching the History and Philosophy of Pendulum Motion can Contribute to Science Literacy Kluwer New York
P.T. Mildenhall J.S. Williams (2001) ArticleTitle‘Instability in Students’ Use of Intuitive and Newtonian Models to Predict Motion: The Critical Effect of the Parameters Involved’ International Journal of Science Education 23 IssueID6 643–660 Occurrence Handle10.1080/09500690010006545
J. Minstrell (1982) ArticleTitle‘Explaining the “At Rest” Condition of an Object’ The Physics Teacher 20 10–14 Occurrence Handle10.1119/1.2340924
E.F. Mortimer (1995) ArticleTitle‘Conceptual Change or Conceptual Profile Change?’ Science and Education 4 IssueID3 267–285 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00486624
N. Nersessian (1992) Constructing and Instructing: The Role of “Abstraction Techniques” in Creating and Learning Physics A. Duschl R. Hamilton (Eds) Philosophy of Science, Cognitive Psychology, and Educational Theory and Practice State University of New York Press Albany
Nikolaou, L. & Watson, R.: 2004, “Analyzing Student’s Ideas About Force and Motion Using Vygotsky’s Theory of Concept Formation”, paper presented at NARST Conference, Vancouver, BC, 1–3 April
A. Orton (1992) Learning Mathematics: Issues, Theory and Classroom Practice Cassell Educational London
D. Perkins R. Simmons (1988) ArticleTitle‘Patterns of Misunderstanding: An Integrative Model for Science, Math, and Programming’ Review of Educational Research 58 IssueID3 303–326 Occurrence Handle10.2307/1170257
P. Peters (1982) ArticleTitle‘Even Honors Students have Conceptual Difficulties with Physics’ American Journal of Physics 50 501–508 Occurrence Handle10.1119/1.12797
G.J. Posner K.A. Strike P.W. Hewson W. Gertzog (1982) ArticleTitle‘Accommodation of a Scientific Conception: Towards a Theory of Conceptual Change’ Science Education 66 IssueID2 211–227 Occurrence Handle10.1002/sce.3730660207
Pnevmatikos, D.: 2002, “Conceptual Change, Mental Models and Their Internal Consistency Within the Religious Domain of Knowledge”, Proceedings of the Third European Symposium on Conceptual Change: A process approach to conceptual change, June 26–28, 2002, Turku, Finland
S. Rowlands E. Graham J. Berry (1999) ArticleTitle‘Can we Speak of Alternative Frameworks and Conceptual Change in Mechanics?’ Science and Education 8 IssueID3 241–271 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1008631623632
Soto-Lombana, C. & Sanjose, V.: (2002), “Research on Conceptual Change: A Review in Science Education”, Proceedings of the Third European Symposium on Conceptual Change: A process approach to conceptual change, June 26–28, 2002, Turku, Finland
A. Stinner (1994) ArticleTitle‘The Story of Force: From Aristotle to Einstein’ Physics Education 29 77–85 Occurrence Handle10.1088/0031-9120/29/2/005
K.A. Strike G.J. Posner (1992) A Revisionist Theory of Conceptual Change R. Duschl R. Hamilton (Eds) Philosophy of Science, Cognitive Psychology and Educational Theory and Practice SUNY Albany
R. Trumper (1990) ArticleTitle‘Energy and a Constructivist Way of Teaching’ Physics Education 25 IssueID4 208–212 Occurrence Handle10.1088/0031-9120/25/4/306
Tynjäjä, P., Merenluoto, K. & Murtonen, M.: 2002, “What Has Been meant by ‘Concept’ and ‘Change’ in Conceptual Change Studies? A Framework for a MetaAnalytical Study”, Proceedings of the Third European Symposium On Conceptual Change: A process approach to conceptual change, June 26–28, 2002, Turku, Finland
Vamvakoussi, X. & Vosniadou, S.: 2002, “Conceptual Change in Mathematics, From the Set of Natural to the Set of Rational Numbers”, Proceedings of the Third European Symposium on Conceptual Change: A process approach to conceptual change, June 26–28, 2002, Turku, Finland
L. Viennot (1979) ArticleTitle‘Spontaneous Reasoning in Elementary Dynamics’ European Journal of Science Education 1 205–221
L. Viennot (1985) ArticleTitle‘Analyzing Student’s Reasoning: Tendencies in Interpretation’ American Journal of Physics 53 432–436 Occurrence Handle10.1119/1.14194
E. Von Glasersfeld (1995) Radical Constructivism: A Way of Knowing and Learning The Falmer Press London
S. Vosniadou C. Ioannides A. Dimitrakopoulou E. Papademetriou (2001) ArticleTitle‘Designing Learning Environments to Promote Conceptual Change in Science’ Learning and Instruction 11 IssueID4–5 381–419 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0959-4752(00)00038-4
L. Vygotsky (1987) The Collected Works of L. S. Vygotsky, Volume 1 Problems of general Psychology Plenum Press New York
R.T. White (1994) ArticleTitle‘Commentary: Conceptual and Conceptional Change’ Learning and Instruction 4 117–121 Occurrence Handle10.1016/0959-4752(94)90022-1
M. Wiser T. Amin (2001) ArticleTitle‘Is Heat Hot?’ Inducing Conceptual Change by Integrating Everyday and Scientific Perspectives on Thermal Phenomena’ Learning and Instruction 11 IssueID4–5 331–355 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0959-4752(00)00036-0
L. Wittgenstein (1974) Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus Routledge and Kegan Paul London
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Rowlands, S., Graham, T., Berry, J. et al. Conceptual Change Through the Lens of Newtonian Mechanics. Sci Educ 16, 21–42 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11191-005-1339-7
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11191-005-1339-7