Abstract
Einstein, who had already developed the light-quantum theory, knew the inadequacy of Maxwell’s theory in the microscopic sphere. Therefore, in writing his paper on special relativity, he had to set up the light-velocity postulate independently of the relativity postulate in order to make the electromagnetic foundation of physics compatible with Planck’s radiation formula. This constitutes the essential difference between the theories of Lorentz-Poincaré and Einstein. The reason that students of the history of special relativity hitherto overlooked this fact lies in a crucial error contained in Einstein’s ‘Autobiographical Notes’. The correction, introduced first in the German edition of 1955, revealed that the first core ingredient of Einstein’s research program was ‘thermodynamics’. Einstein’s theory survived the quantum revolution, while Lorentz-Poincaré’s did not. Some educational implications are also discussed.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
S. Abiko (1981) Physics along Its History Tokyo-Kyogakusya Tokyo 120–133
S. Abiko (1991) ArticleTitle‘On the Chemico-Thermal Origins of Special Relativity’ HSPS 22 IssueID1 1–24
S. Abiko (2000a) ArticleTitle‘Einstein’s Theories of the Fluctuation and the Thermal Radiation: the First Quantum Theory through Statistical Thermodynamics’ Historia Scientiarum 10 IssueID2 130–147 Occurrence HandleMR1845720
S. Abiko (2000b) ArticleTitle‘Einstein’s Kyoto Address: “How I Created the Theory of Relativity” HSPS 31 IssueID1 1–35
S. Abiko (2003) ArticleTitle‘On Einstein’s Distrust of the Electromagnetic Theory: The Origin of the Light-Velocity Postulate’ HSPS 33 IssueID2 193–215
Abiko, S. 2004 ‘Reply to Olivier Darrigol’, HSPS34(2), to be published.
N. Bohr (1913) ArticleTitle‘On the Constitution of Atoms and Molecules (Part I)’ Philosophical Magazine 26 IssueID(6 1–25
Born M., 1956 ‘Physics and Relativity’, in A. Mercier, M. Kervaire (eds.), Fünfzig Jahre Relativitätstheorie, Basel, pp. 244–260; also in M. Born, 1969, Physics in My Generation (second edition), Springer, New York NY, pp. 100–115.
de Broglie, L.: 1923, ‘Waves and Quanta’, Nature 112, 540.
S. Brush (1976) The Kind of Motion We Call Heat, Book 1 North-Holland Amsterdam 35–51
O. Darrigol (1996) ArticleTitle‘The Electrodynamic Origins of Relativity Theory’ HSPS 26 IssueID2 241–312
Dirac, P.A.M.: 1928, ‘The Quantum Theory of the Electron’, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London117, 610–624; 118, 351–361.
A. Einstein (1895) ArticleTitle‘On a Investigation of the State of the Ether in a Magnetic Field’ CPEE 1 4–6
A. Einstein (1902) ArticleTitle‘Kinetic Theory of Thermal Equilibrium and of the Second Law of Thermodynamics’ CPEE 2 30–47
A. Einstein (1903) ArticleTitle‘A Theory of the Foundation of Thermodynamics’ CPEE 2 48–77
A. Einstein (1904) ArticleTitle‘On the General Molecular Theory of Heat’ CPEE 2 48–77
Einstein, A. 1905a ‘A New Determination of Molecular Dimensions’, Brownian, pp. 36–62; CPEE 2, 104–122; Miraculous, pp. 45–69.
Einstein, A.: 1905b, ‘On the Movement of Small Particles Suspended in Stationary Liquids Required by the Molecular-Kinetic Theory of Heat’,Brownian, pp. 118,CPEE 2, 123–134; Miraculous, pp. 85–98.
Einstein, A.: 1905c, ‘On a Heuristic Point of View Concerning the Production and Transformation of Light’, CPEE 2, 86–103; Miraculous, pp. 177–198.
Einstein, A.: 1905d,‘On the Electrodynamics of Moving Bodies’, PR, pp. 35–65; CPEE 2, 140–171; Miraculous, pp. 123–160.
A. Einstein (1906) ArticleTitle‘On the Theory of Light Production and Light Absorption’ CPEE 2 192–199
A. Einstein (1907) ArticleTitle‘Planck’s Theory of Radiation and the Theory of Specific Heat’. cpee 2 214–224
A. Einstein (1909) ArticleTitle‘On the Present Status of the Radiation Problem’ CPEE 2 357–375
A. Einstein L. Hopf (1910) ArticleTitle‘Statistical Investigation of a Resonator’s Motion in a Radiation Field’ CPEE 3 220–230
A. Einstein (1911) ArticleTitleDiscussion Following Lecture, “The Present State of the Problem of Specific Heats” CPEE 3 426
A. Einstein L. Infeld (1938) The Evolution of Physics Simon and Shuster New York
Einstein, A.: 1949 ‘Autobiographical Notes’, in Schilpp (ed.), Albert Einstein: Philosopher-Scientist (first edition), Evanston, pp. 1–95.
A. Einstein (1955) ‘Autobiographisches’ P.A. Schilpp (Eds) Albert Einstein als Philosoph und Naturforscher Kohlhammer Stuttgart 1–36
R. Feynman R. Leighton M. Sands (1965) The Feynman Lectures on Physics Addison-Wesley Reading
S. Goldberg (1967) ArticleTitle‘Henri Poincare and Einstein’s Theory of Relativity’ AJP 35 934–944
Hertz, H. 1893 Electric Waves, London; reprint, New York, 1962.
Hirosige, T. 1960,‘Factors of the Special Theory of Relativity’, Kagakusi Kenkyu 55, 14–19; also in S. Nisio (ed.), 1980, The Formation of the Relativity Theory,Tokyo, pp. 76–87 (in Japanese).
Holton, G.: 1960, ‘On the Origins of the Special Theory of Relativity’,AJP 28, 627–636; Origins, pp. 165–183.
Holton, G.: 1969, ‘Einstein, Michelson, and the “Crucial” Experiment’,Isis 60, 133–197; Origins, pp. 261–351.
M. Klein (1967) ArticleTitle‘Thermodynamics in Einstein’s Thought’ Science 157 509–516
Landau, L., Lifshitz, E.: 1975, The Classical Theory of Field, Fourth Revised English Edition, Pergamon, Oxford; originally in Russian, Moscow, 1948.
Langevin, P., de Broglie, M. (eds.): 1912, La théorie du rayonnement et les quanta. Rapports et discussions de la réunion tenue à Bruxelles, du 30 octobre au 3 novembre 1911, sous les auspices de M. E. Solvay, Gauthier-Villars, Paris.
Laue, M.: 1911 Das Relativitätstheorie, Vieweg.
H. A. Lorentz (1895) ArticleTitleVersuch einer Theorie der elektrischen und optischen Erscheinungen in bewegten Körpern Leiden, LCP 5 1–138
Lorentz, H. A.: 1904,‘Electromagnetic Phenomena in a System Moving with Any Velocity Less Than That of Light’, LCP 5, 172–197; PR, pp. 9–34.
H. Poincaré (1905) ArticleTitle‘Sur la dynamique de l’electron’ Comptes Rendus de l’Academie des Science 140 1504–1508
H. Poincaré (1906) ArticleTitle‘Sur la dynamique de l’electron’ Rendiconti del Circolo Mathematico di Palermo 21 129–176
I. Prigogine (1996) The End of Certainty, Time, Chaos and the New Laws of Nature Free Press New York
Sommerfeld, A.: 1916, ‘Zur Quantentheorie der Spektrallinien’, Annalen der Physik 51, 1–94, 125–167.
Wertheimer, M. 1959 Productive Thinking. (enlarged edition), New York, pp. 213–233.
Whittaker, E.: 1953, ‘Chap.2 The Relativity Theory of Poincaré and Lorentz’, in A History of Aether and Electricity, Vol. 2 The Modern Theories 1900-1926, London, pp. 27–77.
Zahar, E.: 1973, ‘Why Did Einstein’s Programme Supersede Lorentz’s?’, British Journal for Philosophy of Science 24, 95–123, 223–262.
J. Ziman (1980) Teaching and Learning about Science and Society Cambridge University Press Cambridge
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Abiko, S. The Light-Velocity Postulate. Sci Educ 14, 353–365 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11191-004-7938-x
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11191-004-7938-x