Abstract
A defining feature of retributive conceptions of karma is their regarding of suffering or misfortune as consequent upon sins committed in previous lives. Some critical non-believers in karma take offence at this view, considering it to involve unjustly blaming the victim. Defenders of the view demur, and argue that a belief in retributive karma in fact provides a motivation for benevolent action. This article elucidates the debate, showing that its depth is such that it is best characterized as a disagreement in form of life (in Wittgenstein’s sense) rather than as a disagreement in opinions. Also briefly discussed is an example of a non-retributive form that belief in karma and reincarnation can take.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Barnes C. (1994) Disabled people in Britain and discrimination: A case for anti-discrimination legislation, 2nd impression. Hurst & Co, London
BBC News (1999a). More bad karma for Hoddle, January 30. Retrieved November 5, 2011 from http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/sport/football/265903.stm.
BBC News (1999b). Should Hoddle quit?, January 30. Retrieved November 5, 2011 from http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/talking_point/265976.stm.
BBC News (1999c). A victory for football, February 2. Retrieved November 5, 2011 from http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/270753.stm.
BBC News (1999d). Hoddle sacked, February 3. Retrieved July 7, 2012 from http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/sport/football/270194.stm.
Besant A. (1917) A study in karma (2nd ed.). Adyar, The Theosophist Office
Clarke P. B. (1999) A bibliography of Japanese new religious movements. Japan Library, Richmond
Dalal A. K., Pande N. (1988) Psychological recovery of accident victims with temporary and permanent disability. International Journal of Psychology 23(1–6): 25–40
Dickinson, M. (1999). Hoddle puts his faith in God and England. In The Times, January 30. London: Times Newspapers Limited.
Dickinson, M., & Farrell, S. (1999). Hoddle says disabled are paying price of sin. In The Times, January 30. London: Times Newspapers Limited.
Editors of Hinduism Today Magazine (Eds.). (2007). What is Hinduism? Modern adventures into a profound global faith. Kapaa: Himalayan Academy Publications.
Edwards P. (2002) Reincarnation: A critical examination. Prometheus, Amherst
Evans-Pritchard E. E. (1937) Witchcraft, oracles and magic among the Azande. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Gosling D. (1974) Scientific perspectives on rebirth. Religion 4(1): 47–58
Gosling D. (1977) Thai Buddhism in transition. Religion 7(1): 18–34
Hardo T. (2007) The karma handbook: Reincarnation and healing. Jaico, Mumbai
Humphreys C. (1983) Karma and rebirth (2nd ed.). Curzon Press, London
Kisala R. (1994) Contemporary karma: Interpretations of karma in Tenrikyō and Risshō Kōseikai. Japanese Journal of Religious Studies 21(1): 73–91
Krishan Y. (1997) The doctrine of karma: Its origin and development in Brāhmanical, Buddhist and Jaina traditions. Motilal Banarsidass, Delhi
La Fontaine J. (2009) Child witches in London: Tradition and change in religious practice and belief. In: La Fontaine J. (Ed.) The Devil’s children: From spirit possession to witchcraft: New allegations that affect children. Ashgate, Farnham, pp 117–127
McClelland N. (2010) Encyclopedia of reincarnation and karma. McFarland & Co, Jefferson
Nussbaum M. C. (1999) Sex and social justice. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Obeyesekere G. (2002) Imagining karma: Ethical transformation in Amerindian, Buddhist, and Greek rebirth. University of California Press, Berkeley
Olivelle, P., & Olivelle, S. (Eds. and Trans.) (2005). Manu’s code of law: A critical edition and translation of the “Mānava-Dharmaśāstra”. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Pavri P., Jinarajadasa C. (1927) First book of Theosophy in questions and answers. Theosophical Publishing House, Adyar
Prabhu J. (1989) The idea of reincarnation. In: Davis S. T. (Ed.) Death and afterlife. St Martin’s Press, New York, pp 65–80
Purton, A. C. (1992). Wittgenstein and pictures of rebirth. In P. S. Thera, L. Perera, & K. Goonesena (Eds.), Buddhist essays—A miscellany: A memorial volume in honour of Venerable Hammalawa Saddhatissa (pp. 253–261). London: Sri Saddhatissa International Buddhist Centre. Retrieved August 14, 2011 from http://www.dwelling.me.uk/WittRebirth.htm.
Ross, J. J. (2009). Reading Wittgenstein’s “Philosophical investigations”: A beginner’s guide. Lanham: Lexington Books.
Rukwong P., Chirawatkul S., Markovic M. (2007) Quality of life perceptions of middle-aged women living with a disability in Muang District, Khon Kaen, Thailand: WHOQOL perspective. Journal of the Medical Association of Thailand 90(8): 1640–1646
Shakespeare T. (2006) Disability rights and wrongs. Routledge, Abingdon
Shakespeare T. (2007) Disability and equity: Should difference be welcomed?. In: Ashcroft R. E., Dawson A., Draper H., McMillan J. R. (Eds.) Principles of health care ethics (2nd ed.). Wiley, Chichester, pp 421–426
Sharma, A. (1999). Karma was fouled! Why Hoddle did no wrong to the disabled. Hinduism Today, September 1999. Retrieved November 5, 2011 from http://www.hinduismtoday.com/modules/smartsection/item.php?itemid=4345.
Sharma A. (2008) Karma, rebirth, and the problem of evil: An interjection in the debate between Whitley Kaufman and Monima Chadha and Nick Trakakis. Philosophy East and West 58(4): 572–575
Slutwalk (2011). Slut means speak up!. Retrieved May 27, 2012 from http://slutmeansspeakup.org.uk/.
SlutWalk Toronto (2012). Retrieved May 27, 2012 from http://www.slutwalktoronto.com/.
Spiro M. E. (1982) Buddhism and society: A great tradition and its Burmese vicissitudes. University of California Press, Berkeley
Stevenson I. (1977) The explanatory value of the idea of reincarnation. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease 164(5): 305–326
Stevenson I. (1997) Reincarnation and biology: A contribution to the etiology of birthmarks and birth defects. Praeger, Westport
Tucker J. B. (2009) Life before life: A scientific investigation of children’s memories of previous lives. Piatkus, London
Willson M. (1987) Rebirth and the western Buddhist (2nd ed.). Wisdom Publications, London
Wittgenstein, L. (1966). Lectures and conversations on aesthetics, psychology and religious belief. Ed. C. Barrett. Oxford: Blackwell.
Wittgenstein, L. (2009 [1953]). Philosophical investigations (4th ed.). Trans. G. E. M. Anscombe, P. M. S. Hacker & J. Schulte. Malden: Wiley-Blackwell.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Burley, M. Retributive karma and the problem of blaming the victim. Int J Philos Relig 74, 149–165 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11153-012-9376-z
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11153-012-9376-z