Abstract
From a larger longitudinal study of 610 fourth graders in 17 inner city schools, 40 students were randomly selected from 10 classrooms rated high (i.e., top quartile) or low (i.e., bottom quartile) in quality of writing instruction in grades 3 and 4. The written compositions of these students were scored in three ways: (1) according to a rating scale within a reliable scoring rubric, (2) according to countable surface features such as words correctly sequenced, and (3) according to the frequency of specific phonological, morphosyntactic, and orthographic errors in the children’s writing. A multivariate analysis of variance was conducted to examine whether quality of writing instruction in grades 3 and 4 predicted students’ writing performance at the end of grade 4. Students who received high quality instruction in fourth grade wrote longer compositions with more correctly spelled words than those who had poor quality writing instruction. There was a tendency for two years of quality instruction to be better than one, and, among students who had poor quality instruction in grade 3, compositions were longer in grade 4 when they received quality instruction in fourth grade. Foundational problems of language formulation, production and representation, however, were ubiquitous across the sample. Although these students were within the average range on standardized reading tests, spelling and writing were not developing at average levels. The study confirms the urgent need for more and better writing instruction for high risk, minority children.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Anglin, J. M. (1993). Vocabulary development: A morphological analysis. Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development, 58 (Serial No. 238).
C. Bereiter M. Scardamalia (1987) The psychology of written composition Erlbaum Hillsdale, NJ
V. Berninger (2000) ArticleTitleDevelopment of language by hand and its connections to language by ear, mouth, and eye Topics in Language Disorders 20 65–84 Occurrence Handle10.1097/00011363-200020040-00007
V. W. Berninger A. C. Cartwright C. M. Yates H. L. Swanson R. D. Abbott (1994) ArticleTitleDevelopmental skills related to writing and reading acquisition in the intermediate grades: Shared and unique functional systems Reading and Writing 6 161–196 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF01026911
V. W. Berninger H. L. Swanson (1994) Modifying Hayes and Flower’s model of skilled writing to explain beginning and developing writing E. C. Butterfield (Eds) Children’s writing: Toward a process theory of the development of skilled writing JAI Press Greenwich, CT 57–81
V. Berninger K. Vaughan R. Abbott S. Abbot A. Brooks L. Rogan L. Woodruff A. Brooks E. Reed S. Graham (1997) ArticleTitleTreatment of handwriting fluency problems in beginning writing: Transfer from handwriting to composition Journal of Educational Psychology 89 652–666 Occurrence Handle10.1037/0022-0663.89.4.652
P. Bryant T. Nunes M. Bindman (2000) ArticleTitleThe relations between children’s linguistic awareness and spelling: The case of the apostrophe Reading and Writing 12 253–276 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1008152501105
B. Blachman (2000) Phonological awareness M. L. Kamil P. B. Mosenthal P. D. Pearson R. Barr (Eds) Handbook of reading research NumberInSeries3 Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Mahwah, NJ 483–502
J. Carlisle (1996) ArticleTitleAn exploratory study of morphological errors in children’s written stories Reading and Writing 8 61–72 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00423925
J. Carlisle (2003) Morphological processes that influence learning to read C. A. Stone E. R. Silliman B. J. Ehren K. Apel (Eds) Handbook of language and literacy Guilford Press New York 318–339
M. Cassar R. Treiman L. Moats T. C. Polo B. Kessler (2005) ArticleTitleHow do the spellings of children with dyslexia compare with those of nondyslexic children? Reading and Writing 18 27–49 Occurrence Handle10.1007/s11145-004-2345-x
H. W. Catts M. Fey X. Zhang J. B. Tomblin (1999) ArticleTitleLanguage basis of reading and spelling disabilities: Evidence from a longitudinal study Scientific Studies of Reading 3 331–361 Occurrence Handle10.1207/s1532799xssr0304_2
A. H. Charity H. S. Scarborough D. M. Griffin (2004) ArticleTitleFamiliarity with school English in African American children and its relation to early reading achievement Child Development 75 IssueID5 1340–1356 Occurrence Handle10.1111/j.1467-8624.2004.00744.x
C. Cooper (1977) Holistic evaluation of writing C. Cooper L. Odell (Eds) Evaluating writing National Council of Teachers of English Urbana, IL 3–31
B. R. Foorman D. T. Chen C. Carlson L. Moats D. J. Francis J. Fletcher (2003) ArticleTitleThe necessity of the alphabetic principle to phonemic awareness instruction Reading and Writing 16 289–324 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1023671702188
B. R. Foorman D. J. Francis J. M. Fletcher C. Schatschneider P. Mehta (1998) ArticleTitleThe role of instruction in learning to read: Preventing reading failure in at-risk children Journal of Educational Psychology 90 37–55 Occurrence Handle10.1037/0022-0663.90.1.37
B. R. Foorman D. J. Francis S. E. Shaywitz B. A. Shaywitz J. M. Fletcher (1997) The case for early reading interventions B. Blachman (Eds) Foundations of reading acquisition and dyslexia: Implications for early intervention Erlbaum Mahwah, NJ 243–264
B. R. Foorman L. C. Moats (2004) ArticleTitleConditions for sustaining research-based practices in early reading instruction Remedial and Special Education 25 IssueID1 51–60 Occurrence Handle10.1177/07419325040250010601
B. R. Foorman C. Schatschneider (2003) Measurement of teaching practices during reading/language arts instruction and its relationship to student achievement S. Vaughn K. L. Briggs (Eds) Reading in the classroom: Systems for observation of teaching and learning Brookes Publishing Co Baltimore, MD 1–30
Foorman, B. R., Schatschneider, C., Eakin, M. N., Fletcher, J. M., Moats, L. C., & Francis, D. J. (in press). The impact of instructional practices in grades 1 and 2 on reading and spelling achievement in high poverty schools. Contemporary Educational Psychology.
J. Frost (2001) ArticleTitlePhonemic awareness, spontaneous writing, and reading and spelling development from a preventive perspective Reading and Writing 14 487–513 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1011143002068
S. Graham (1997) ArticleTitleExecutive control in the revising of students with learning and writing difficulties Journal of Educational Psychology 89 223–234 Occurrence Handle10.1037/0022-0663.89.2.223
E. Greenwald H. Persky J. Campbell J. Mazzeo (1999) National assessment of educational progress: 1998 report card for the nation and the states U.S. Department of Education Washington, DC
M. A. K. Halliday (1985) Spoken and written language Deakin University Press Victoria, Australia
J. R. Hayes (2000) A new framework for understanding cognition and affect in writing R. Indrisano J.R. Squire (Eds) Perspectives on writing: Research, theory, and practice International Reading Association Newark, DE 6–44
V. Jacobs (1997) The use of connectives in low-income children’s writing: Linking reading, writing, and language skill development L. Putnam (Eds) Readings in language and literacy: Essays in honor of Jeanne S. Chall Brookline Books Cambridge, MA 100–130
J. R. Jenkins E. Johnson J. Hileman (2004) ArticleTitleWhen reading is also writing: Sources of individual differences on the new reading performance assessments Scientific Studies of Reading 8 125–151 Occurrence Handle10.1207/s1532799xssr0802_2
A. S. Kaufman N. L. Kaufman (1985) Kaufman test of educational achievement. American Guidance Service Circle Pines, MN
P. Mehta B. R. Foorman L. Branum-Martin W. P. Taylor (2005) ArticleTitleLiteracy as a unidimensional multilevel construct: Validation, sources of influence, and implications in a longitudinal study in grades 1–4 Scientific Studies of Reading 9 IssueID2 85–116 Occurrence Handle10.1207/s1532799xssr0902_1
L. C. Moats (1996) ArticleTitlePhonological spelling errors in the writing of dyslexic adolescents Reading and Writing 8 105–119 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00423928
No Child Left Behind Act (2001). PL 107–110, 115 Stat. 1425, 20 U.S.C. §§ 6301 et seq.
H. Persky M. Daane Y. Jin (2003) The nation’s report card: Writing U.S. Department of Education Washington, DC
Reading Excellence Act (1998). Part C, Title II of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act of 1965, 20 U.S.C. §§ 6601 et seq.
Seals, L. M. (2001). Does sensitivity to African-American vernacular English affect phonological awareness testing? Master’s thesis, University of Houston.
B. D. Singer A. S. Bashir (2004) Developmental variations in writing composition skills C. A. Stone E. R. Silliman B. J. Ehren K. Apel (Eds) Handbook of language and literacy: Development and disorders Guilford Press New York 559–582
Texas Education Agency (2004–2006). Texas Primary Reading Inventory (TPRI). Austin, TX: Texas Education Agency/University of Texas System (see www.tpri.org).
R. S. Wheeler R. Swords (2004) ArticleTitleCodeswitching: Tools of language and culture transform the dialectally diverse classroom Language Arts 81 IssueID6 470–480
R. W. Woodcock M. B. Johnson (1989) Woodcock–Johnson Psycho-Educational Battery-Revised DLM Teaching Resources Allen, TX
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Moats, L., Foorman, B. & Taylor, P. How Quality of Writing Instruction Impacts High-risk Fourth Graders’ Writing. Read Writ 19, 363–391 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11145-005-4944-6
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11145-005-4944-6