Abstract
Drawing on panel data from the European Community Household Panel (ECHP), the British Household Panel Survey (BHPS) and the German Socio-Economic Panel Study (SOEP), we compare the economic performance of immigrants to Great Britain, West Germany, Denmark, Luxembourg, Ireland, Italy, Spain and Austria to that of the respective indigenous population. The unit of analysis is the individual in the household context. This allows us to define immigrants’ state of integration into the host society at the family level taking into account issues such as immigrant/native intermarriage. Economic performance is measured in terms of the country-specific pre-government income position and change in the relative income position due to redistribution processes within the respective tax and social security systems. Our work is based on the premise that countries may be categorized – similarly to existing categorizations based on the type of welfare regime – according to the nature of their immigration policy. From an economic point of view, a successful and integrative immigration policy should result – at least when controlling for background characteristics such as education – in a non-significant differential between the economic performance of immigrants and that of the indigenous population. At first glance, our results indicate that this “ideal” is not attained in all of the countries analysed, particularly not in Germany and Denmark, where the economic performance of immigrants is much lower than that of the indigenous population. However, results from GLS random-effects models show that immigrants to these countries improve their economic situation rapidly with increasing duration of stay in the host country. This implies that these countries also do fairly well in fostering in the economic integration of immigrants. Our empirical results further reveal that the substantial cross-country differences in the immigrant/native-born performance differential persist even when controlling in detail for socioeconomic characteristics of the household and for indicators of the state of the immigrants’ integration, such as years since migration and immigrant/native intermarriage. This suggests that not only the conditions of entry to a country impact on immigrants’ economic performance, but also country-specific institutional aspects such as restrictions on access to the labour market and parts of the social security system that are related to citizenship or immigrant status. There still is a great deal of heterogeneity across EU member states in this respect. This should be taken into account when working towards the harmonization of national EU immigration policies.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
M. Baker D. Benjamin (1995) ArticleTitleThe receipt of transfer payments by immigrants to Canada Journal of Human Resources 30 IssueID4 650–676
M. Baker D. Benjamin (1997) ArticleTitleThe role of the family in immigrants’ labor market activity: An evaluation of alternative explanations American Economic Review 87 IssueID4 705–727
Bardasi E., Jenkins S.P., Rigg J.A. (1999). Documentation for derived current and annual net household income variables, BHPS waves 1-7. Unpublished manuscript. Colchester, ISER.
A. Barrett (1998) ArticleTitleThe effect of immigrant admission criteria on immigrant labour–market characteristics Population Research and Policy Review 17 439–456
T. Bauer M. Lofstrom K.F. Zimmermann (2000) ArticleTitleImmigration policy, assimilation of immigrants and natives’ sentiments towards immigrants: Evidence from 12 OECD-countries Swedish Economic Policy Review 7 11–53
C.M. Beach C. Worswick (1993) ArticleTitleIs there a double-negative effect on the earnings of immigrant women? Canadian Public Policy 19 IssueID1 36–53
G.J. Borjas (1994) ArticleTitleThe economics of immigration Journal of Economic Literature 32 IssueID4 1667–1717
G.J. Borjas L. Hilton (1996) ArticleTitleImmigration and the welfare state. Immigrant participation in means-tested entitlement programs. Quarterly Journal of Economics 111 IssueID2 575–604
G.J. Borjas S.J. Trejo (1991) ArticleTitleImmigrant participation in the welfare system Industrial and Labor Relations Review 44 IssueID2 195–211
H. Brücker G.S. Epstein B. McCormick G. Saint-Paul A. Venturini K. Zimmermann (2002) Managing migration in the European Welfare State T. Boeri G. Hanson B. McCormick (Eds) Immigration policy and the welfare system. A report for the Fondazione Rodolfo Debenedetti. Oxford University Press Oxford 1–168
Büchel F., Frick J.R. (forthcoming). Immigrants in Great Britain and in West Germany: Relative income position, income portfolio, and redistribution effects. Journal of Population Economics.
R.V. Burkhauser M. Kreyenfeld G.G. Wagner (1997) ArticleTitleThe German Socio-Economic Panel Study: A representative sample of reunified germany and its parts Applied Economics Quarterly–Vierteljahrshefte zur Wirtschaftsforschung 66 IssueID1 7–16
R.V. Burkhauser B.A. Butrica M.C. Daly D.R. Lillard (2001) The Cross- National Equivalent File: A product of cross-national research I. Becker N. Ott G. Rolf (Eds) Soziale Sicherung in einer dynamischen Gesellschaft. Papers in Honour of the 65th Birthday of Richard Hauser. Campus Frankfurt/New York 354–376
E.J. Castranova H. Kayser J.R. Frick G.G. Wagner (2001) ArticleTitleImmigrants, natives and social assistance: Comparable take-up under comparable circumstances International Migration Review 35 IssueID3 726–748
W.A.V. Clark F. Schultz (1997) ArticleTitleEvaluating the local impacts of recent immigration to California: Realism versus racism Population Research and Policy Review 16 IssueID5 475–492
S. Cummings T. Lambert (1998) ArticleTitleImmigration restrictions and the American worker: An examination of competing interpretations Population Research and Policy Review 17 IssueID6 497–520
Duleep H.O., Regets M.C. (2002). The elusive concept of immigrant quality: evidence from 1970-1990. IZA Discussion Paper No. 631. Bonn, Institute for the Study of Labor.
H.O. Duleep S. Sanders (1993) ArticleTitleThe decision to work by married immigrant women Industrial and Labor Relations Review 46 IssueID4 677–690
M.E. Enchautegui (1997) ArticleTitleImmigration and county employment growth Population Research and Policy Review 16 IssueID5 493–511
J. Ekberg (1999) ArticleTitleImmigration and the public sector: Income effects for the native population in Sweden Journal of Population Economics 12 411–430
G. Esping-Andersen (1990) The three worlds of welfare capitalism. Princeton University Press Princeton, NJ
M. Ferrara (1999) ArticleTitleThe “southern model” of welfare in social Europe Journal of European Social Policy 6 IssueID1 179–189
Fertig M., Schmidt C.M. (2002). The perception of foreigners and Jews in Germany: A structural analysis of a large opinion survey. IZA Discussion Paper No. 431. Bonn, Institute for the Study of Labor.
A.J. Fielding (1995) ArticleTitleMigration and social change: a longitudinal study of the social mobility of “immigrants” in England and Wales European Journal of Population 11 IssueID2 107–121
R.M. Friedberg J. Hunt (1995) ArticleTitleThe impact of immigrants on host country wages, employment and growth Journal of Economic Perspectives 9 IssueID2 23–44
R. Fry B.L. Lowell (1997) ArticleTitleThe incidence of subminimum pay among native and immigrant workers Population Research and Policy Review 16 IssueID4 363–381
I.N. Gang F.L. Rivera-Batiz (1994) ArticleTitleLabor market effects of immigration in the United States and Europe: Substitution vs. complementarity. Journal of Population Economics 7 IssueID2 157–175
Goodin B., Headey B., Muffels R., Dirven H.-J. (1999). The real worlds of welfare capitalism. Cambridge University Press.
B. Gustafsson T. Österberg (2001) ArticleTitleImmigrants and the public sector budget-accounting Journal of Population Economics 14 689–708
W. Hu (1998) ArticleTitleElderly immigrants on welfare Journal of Human Resources 33 IssueID3 711–741
R.J. LaLonde R.H. Topel (1991) ArticleTitleImmigrants in the American labor market: Quality, assimilation, and distributional effects American Economic Review 81 IssueID2 297–302
J.-S. Pischke J. Velling (1997) ArticleTitleEmployment effects of immigration to Germany: An analysis based on local labor markets Review of Economics and Statistics 79 IssueID4 594–604
J.G. Reitz J.R. Frick T. Calabrese G.G. Wagner (1999) ArticleTitleThe institutional framework of ethnic employment disadvantage: A comparison of Germany and Canada Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 25 IssueID3 397–444
Reyneri E. (2001). Migrants in irregular employment in the Mediterranean countries of the European Union. International Migration Papers Series No. 46. Geneva, International Labor Organization.
R.T. Riphahn (1998) ArticleTitleImmigrant participation in the German welfare program Finanzarchiv 55 IssueID2 163–185
Rotte R. (1998). Sorties from the fortress: The current system of anti-immigration policies in Germany. IZA Discussion Paper No. 13. Bonn, Institute for the Study of Labor.
T.P. Schultz (1998) ArticleTitleImmigrant quality and assimilation: A review of the US literature Journal of Population Economics 11 IssueID2 239–252
Schwarze J. (1995). Simulating German income and social security tax payments using the GSOEP. Cross-national studies in ageing. Project Paper No. 19. Syracuse University, Maxwell School, Center for Policy Research.
InstitutionalAuthorNameSOEP Group (2001) ArticleTitleThe German Socio-Economic Panel (GSOEP) after more than 15 years: An overview Applied Economics Quarterly–Vierteljahrshefte zur Wirtschaftsforschung 70 IssueID1 7–14
C.K. Spiess F. Büchel G.G. Wagner (2003) ArticleTitleChildren’s school placement in Germany: Does kindergarten attendance matter? Early Childhood Research Quarterly 18 255–270
M.F. Taylor (Eds) (1998) British Household Panel Survey user manual: introduction, technical reports and appendices. University of Essex, Economic and Social Research Council Colchester UK
G.G. Wagner R.V. Burkhauser F. Behringer (1993) ArticleTitleThe English language public use file of the German Socio-Economic Panel Study Journal of Human Resources 28 IssueID2 429–433
R. Weber T. Straubhaar (1996) ArticleTitleImmigration and the public transfer system: some empirical evidence for Switzerland Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv 132 IssueID2 330–355
C. Wirtz L. Mejer (2002) ArticleTitleThe European Community Household Panel (ECHP) Schmollers Jahrbuch–Journal of Applied Social Science Studies 122 143–154
K.F. Zimmermann (1995) ArticleTitleTackling the European migration problem Journal of Economic Perspectives 9 IssueID2 45–62
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
This paper benefited substantially from discussions at the EEA 2003 Conference in Stockholm, Sweden, and the EPUNet 2003 Conference in Colchester, UK. We also acknowledge very helpful comments resulting from the reviewing process
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Büchel, F., Frick, J.R. Immigrants’ economic performance across Europe – does immigration policy matter?. Popul Res Policy Rev 24, 175–212 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11113-004-1370-4
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11113-004-1370-4