Abstract
This paper examines the claim made by certain virtue epistemologists that intellectual character virtues like fair-mindedness, open-mindedness and intellectual courage merit an important and fundamental role in epistemology. I begin by considering whether these traits merit an important role in the analysis of knowledge. I argue that they do not and that in fact they are unlikely to be of much relevance to any of the traditional problems in epistemology. This presents a serious challenge for virtue epistemology. I go on to examine the work of two other virtue epistemologists in light of this challenge and then sketch an alternative approach that reveals how the intellectual virtues might merit a substantial role in epistemology even if not a role in connection with more traditional epistemological projects.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
W. Alston (2000) ArticleTitle‘Virtue and Knowledge’ Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 60 186–191
G. Axtell (1997) ArticleTitle‘Recent Work in Virtue Epistemology’ American Philosophical Quarterly 34 1–27
Baehr, J. (2004): ‘Virtue Epistemology’, in James Fieser (ed.), The Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy, (URL=<http://www.iep.utm.edu/v/VirtueEp.htm).
L. BonJour (1990) ArticleTitle‘Review of Lorraine Code’ Epistemic Responsibility, Philosophical Review 99 123–126
L. Code (1987) Epistemic Responsibility University Press of New England Hanover NH
E. Conee F. Richard (1985) ArticleTitle‘Evidentialism’ Philosophical Studies 48 15–34
R. Crisp (Eds) (1996) How Should One Live? Oxford University Press Oxford
R. Crisp M. Slote (Eds) (1997) Virtue Ethics Oxford University Press Oxford
M. DePaul L. Zagzebski (Eds) (2003) Intellectual Virtue: Perspectives from Ethics and Epistemology Oxford University Press Oxford
Driver, J. (1996): ‘The Virtues and Human Nature’, in Crisp (1996), pp. 111–130.
Goldman, A. (1979): ‘What Is Justified Belief?’, Reprinted in Goldman (1992), pp. 105–126.
A. Goldman (1992) Liaisons: Philosophy Meets the Cognitive and Social Sciences MIT Press Cambridge, MA
J. Greco (1999) ‘Agent Reliabilism’, Philosophical Perspectives 13 Atascadero, CA Ridgeview Publishing Co
J. Greco (Eds) (1999) The Blackwell Guide to Epistemology Blackwell Oxford
J. Greco (2000) ArticleTitle‘Two Kinds of Intellectual Virtue’ Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 60 180–185
Greco, J. (2002): ‘Virtue Epistemology’, in Edwards N. Salta (ed.), The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, (URL = <http://plato.stanford. edu/archives/fall 2002/entries/epistemology-virtue/).
Greco, J. (2003). ‘Knowledge as Credit for True Belief’, in DePaul and Zagzebski (eds.), 2003, pp. 111–134.
Hookway, C. (2003): ‘How to be a Virtue Epistemologist’, in DePaul and Zagzebski (eds.), 2003, pp. 183–202.
T. Hurka (2001) Virtue, Vice, and Value Oxford University Press Oxford
R. Hursthouse (1999) On Virtue Ethics Oxford University Press Oxford
C. Korsgaard (1983) ArticleTitle‘Two Distinctions in Goodness’ The Philosophical Review 92 169–195
J. Kvanvig (1992) The Intellectual Virtues and the Life of the Mind, Savage MD Rowman & Littlefield
J. Montmarquet (1993) Epistemic Virtue and Doxastic Responsibility Lanham, MD Rowman & Littlefield
W. Riggs (2002) ArticleTitle‘Reliability and the Value of Knowledge’ Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 64 79–96
Roberts, R.C. and Wood, W. J. (2003): ‘Humility and Epistemic Goods’, in DePaul and Zagzebski (eds.), 2003, pp. 257–280.
Slote, M. (1997): ‘Agent-Based Virtue Ethics’, in Crisp and Slote (eds.), 1997, pp. 239–262.
E. Sosa (1991) Knowledge in Perspective Cambridge University Press Cambridge
L. Zagzebski (1996) Virtues of the Mind Cambridge University Press Cambridge
L. Zagzebski (1998) ‘Virtue Epistemology’ Craig Edward (Eds) Encyclopedia of Philosophy Routledge London
L. Zagzebski (1999) ‘What Is Knowledge?’ Greco John Sosa Ernest (Eds) The Blackwell Guide to Epistemology Blackwell Oxford
L. Zagzebski (2000) ArticleTitle‘Précis’ Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 60 IssueID2000 169–177
L. Zagzebski (2000) ArticleTitle‘Responses’ Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 60 IssueID2000 209–221
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Baehr, J.S. Character in Epistemology. Philos Stud 128, 479–514 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11098-004-7483-0
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11098-004-7483-0