Abstract
Experiences of moral distress encountered in psychiatric practice were explored in a hermeneutic phenomenological study. Moral distress is the state experienced when moral choices and actions are thwarted by constraints. Psychiatrists describe struggling ‘to do the right thing’ for individual patients within a societal system that places unrealistic demands on psychiatric expertise. Certainty on the part of the psychiatrist is an expectation when judgments of dangerousness and/or the need for coercive treatments are made. This assumption, however, ignores the uncertainty and complexity of reality. Society entrusts psychiatrists to care for and treat those among its most vulnerable members: persons deemed to have a severely diminished capacity for autonomy due to a mental disorder. Simultaneously, psychiatrists are held accountable by society for the protection of the public. Moral distress arose for psychiatrists in their efforts to fulfill both roles. They described an ‘outsider/insider’ status and the ways in which they attempted to cope with moral distress.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Adshead G. 1996, Ethics in Psychiatric Research and Practice. Current Opinion in Psychiatry 9, 348–351
Appelbaum P. 1997, Ethics in Evolution: The Incompatibility of Clinical and Forensic Functions. American Journal of Psychiatry 154(4), 445–446
Appelbaum P. 2005, Dangerous Severe Personality Disorders: England’s Experiment in Using Psychiatry for Public Protection. Psychiatric Services, 56(4), 397–399
Arboleda-Flórez J. (2006). The Ethics of Forensic Psychiatry. Current Opinion in Psychiatry 19, 544–546
Austin W., Bergum V., Goldberg L. 2003, Unable to Answer the Call of our Patients: Mental Health Nurses’ Experience of Moral Distress. Nursing Inquiry 10(3), 177–183
Austin W., Rankel M., Kagan L., Bergum V., Lemermeyer G. 2005, To Stay or to Go, To Speak or Stay Silent, To Act or Not to Act: Moral Distress as Experienced by Psychologists. Ethics & Behavior 15(3), 197–212
Barker P. 1991, Regeneration. New York: Plume
Bloche G. 2005, Clinical Loyalties and the Social Purposes of Medicine. Journal of the American Medical Association 281(3), 268–274
Dudley D., Gale F. 2002, Psychiatrists as a Moral Community? Psychiatry under the Nazis and its Contemporary Relevance. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry 36, 585–594
Edwards, R.B. (ed.): 1997, Ethics of Psychiatry: Insanity, Rational Autonomy, and Mental Health Care. Amherst: Prometheus Books
Griffith E.H., Delphin M., Norko M.A. 2004, An American Cultural View of the British DSPD Proposals. Journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law 32, 124–131
Grunberg, F.: 2002, “Patients and Society: The Double Allegiance of Psychiatrists.” CPA Bulletin October, 9–11
Hanna D.R. 2004, Moral Distress: The State of the Science. Research and Theory for Nursing Practice: An International Journal 18(1), 73–93
Hobbes T.: 2002, Leviathan. Peterborough: Broadview Press. (orig. 1651)
Jameton A. 1984, Nursing Practice: The Ethical Issues. Englewood Cliffs: Prentice-Hall
Jameton A. 1993, Dilemmas of Moral Distress: Moral Responsibility and Nursing Practice. AWONN’s Clinical Issues in Perinatal and Women’s Health Nursing 4(4), 542–551
Kälvemark S., Högland A.T., Hansson M.G., Westerholm P., Arnetz B. 2004, Living with Conflicts-Ethical Dilemmas and Moral Distress in the Health Care System. Social Science and Medicine 58, 1075–1084
Kim S.Y.H. 2004, The Dilemma of Hidden Ethical Dilemmas. Academic Psychiatry 28(3), 168–169
Løvseth L., Aasland O.G., Götestam K.G. 2005, Professional Secrecy as a Stressor Among Norwegian Physicians. European Journal of Psychiatry 19(3), 159–164
MacDonald C. 2002, Relational Professional Autonomy. Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics 11, 282–289
McMillan J.R. 2003, Dangerousness, Mental Disorder, and Responsibility. The Journal of Medical Ethics 29, 232–235
McNamee S., Gergen, K.J. 1999, Relational Responsibility: Resources for Sustainable Dialogue. Thousand Oaks: Sage
Maier G.J. 1999, Sexual Predators and the Abuse of Psychiatry. Psychiatric Services 50(3), 295
Nathaniel, A.: 2002, “Moral Distress among Nurses,” The American Nurses Association Ethics and Human Rights: Issues Update 1(3), http://www.nursingworld.org/ethics/update/vo11no3a.htm (accessed June 28, 2005)
Robitscher J. 1980, The Power of Psychiatry. Boston: Houghton Mifflin
Shooter, M.: 2001, White Paper on the Reform of the Mental Health Act 1983: Letter from the Chair of the College’s Public Policy Committee. http://www.rcpsych.ac.uk/pressparliament/collegeresponses/wpreg/aspx (accessed January 2, 2007).
Sporrong S.K., Höglund A.T., Arnetz B. 2006, Measuring Moral Distress in Pharmacy and Clinical Practice. Nursing Ethics 13(4), 416–427
Sporrong S.K., Höglund A.T., Hansson M.G., Westerholm P. 2005, ‘We are white coats whirling round’ – moral distress in Swedish pharmacies. Pharmacy World Scientific, 27, 223–229
Strasburger L.H., Gutheil T.G., Brodsky A. 1997, On Wearing Two Hats: Role Conflict in Serving as Both Psychotherapist and Expert Witness. The American Journal of Psychiatry 154(4), 448–456
Thatcher, V.S. and A. McQueen, (eds.): 1984, The New Webster Encyclopedic Dictionary of the English Language. New York: Avenel Books
Tomm, K.: 1999, ‘Co-constructing Responsibility’, in: S. McNamee and K.J. Gergen (eds.), Relational Responsibility: Resources for Sustainable Dialogue. Thousand Oaks: Sage, pp. 129–137
Veatch, R.M.: 1997, ‘The Medical Model: Its Nature and Problems’, in: R.B. Edwards (ed.), Ethics of Psychiatry: Insanity, Rational Autonomy, and Mental Health Care. Amherst: Prometheus Books, pp. 108–129. First published in 1973 Hastings Centre Studies 1, 59–76
Walker M. 1997, Geographies of Responsibility. Hastings Center Report 27(1), 38–44
Wolgast E.H. 1992, Ethics of an Artificial Person: Lost Responsibility in Professions and Organizations. Stanford: Stanford University Press
Acknowledgements
This research project was funded by the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada (SSHRC).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Austin, W.J., Kagan, L., Rankel, M. et al. The balancing act: psychiatrists’ experience of moral distress. Med Health Care and Philos 11, 89–97 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11019-007-9083-1
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11019-007-9083-1