Abstract
The purpose of this paper is to examine the concept of Schadenfreude - the pleasure felt at another’s misfortune - and to argue that feeling it in the course of health care work, as elsewhere, is evidence of a deficient character. In order to show that Schadenfreude is an objectionable emotion in health care work, I first offer some conceptual remarks about emotions generally and their differential treatment in Kantian and Aristotelian thought. Second, I argue that an appreciation of the rationality of the emotions is crucial to our self-understanding as persons in general and nurses in particular. Third, I present a critique of Portmann’s (2000, When Bad Things Happen to Other People. London: Routledge) defence of Schadenfreude with examples from both nursing and medical scenarios. Specifically, I show how his exculpation of the emotion in terms of low self-esteem and a commitment to justice are not compelling. I argue that we are active in the construction of our emotional experiences of Schadenfreude, how we may indeed ‘nurse’ the emotion, and thus become culpable for them in ethical terms.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Armon-Jones C.: 1991, Varieties of Affect. Toronto: University of Toronto Press
Baier A.C.: 1994, Moral Prejudices. Cambridge: Harvard University Press
Baier A.C.: 1990, What Are Emotions About? Philosophical Perspectives 4, 1–29
Baron M.: 1995, Kantian Ethics almost Without Apology, Ithaca: Cornell University Press
Blum L.: 1994, Moral Perception and Particularity. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
Ellington J.W.: 1994, Immanuel Kant: Ethical Philosophy, 2nd edition, Cambridge: Hackett Publishing Company
Engstrom S., Whiting J. (eds) (1998) Aristotle, Kant and the Stoics: Rethinking Happiness and Duty, Cambridge; Cambridge University Press
Flanagan O.: 1991, Varieties of Moral Personality, Harvard: Harvard University Press
Griffiths P.: 1997, What Emotions Really Are. The Problem of Psychological Categories, Chicago: University of Chicago Press
Guyer : 1993, Kant and the Experience of Freedom, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
Hochschild A.: 1983, The Managed Heart, Berkeley: University of California Press
Hunter B.: 2001, Emotion Work in Midwifery: A Review of Current Knowledge. Journal of Advanced Nursing 34(4), pp. 436–444
Herzog D.: 2001, ‘Envy’ in: R.C. Solomon (ed.), Wicked Pleasures (Oxford), pp. 141–160
Kant, I.: 1974, Anthropology from a Pragmatic Point of View (Trans: M. Gregor). The Hague: Nijhoff
Kant, I.: 1993, Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals (Trans. J.W. Ellington). Hackett: Indianapolis
Kenny A.J.: 1963, Act, Emotion, Will, London: Routledge
Kristjansson K.: 2003, ‘Fortunes-of-others and Justice’, Journal of Philosophical Research 28, 107–130
MacKinnon, C.: 1999, Character, Virture Theory and the Vices, Broadview: New York
McNamee M.J.: 2003 Schadenfreude in sport; envy, justice and self-esteem. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 30(1), 1–16
Montada L.: 1993, ‘Understanding Oughts by Assessing Moral Reasoning or Moral Emotions’, in G.G. Noam, T. Wren (eds.), The Moral Self, London: MIT Press, pp. 292–309
Neu J.: 2002, A Tear is an Intellectual Thing: The Meanings of Emotion, Oxford: Oxford University Press
Nozick R.: 1980, Anarchy, State, Utopia, Oxford: Blackwell
Nussbaum M.C.: 2001, Upheavals of Thought. The Intelligence of the Emotions, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
Paley J.: 2002, Virtues of Autonomy: The Kantian Ethics of Care, Nursing Philosophy 3, 133–143
Plato : 1955, Republic, London: Penguin
Portmann J.: 2000, When Bad Things Happen to Other People, London: Routledge
Rawls J.: 1972, A Theory of Justice, Oxford: Clarendon Press
Roberts R.C.: 1988, What an Emotion is: A Sketch The Philosophical Review, XCVII(2), 183–209
Rorty A.O.: 1988, Introduction In A.O. Rorty (ed.) Explaining Emotion, Berkeley: University of California Press
Scott P.A.: 2000, Emotion, Moral Perception and Nursing Practice Nursing Philosophy 1(2), 123–133
Sherman N.: 1989, The Fabric of Character: Aristotle’s Theory of Virtue, Oxford: Clarendon
Sherman N.: 1997, Making a Virtue of Necessity, Oxford: Clarendon
Solomon R.C.: 2001, ‘Introduction’, in: R. C. Solomon (ed.), Wicked Pleasures. Oxford: Oxford University Press
Taylor C.: 1985, Human Agency and Language: Philosophical Papers 1, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
Tronto J.C.: 1993, Moral Boundaries: A Political Argument, London: Routledge
Whelton B.J.B.: 2002, The Multifaceted Structure of Nursing Nursing Philosophy 3(3), 193–204
Williams B.A.O.: 1973, Problems of the Self, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
Wollheim R.: 1999, The Emotions, London: Yale University Press
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
McNamee, M.J. Nursing Schadenfreude: The culpability of emotional construction. Med Health Care and Philos 10, 289–299 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11019-007-9051-9
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11019-007-9051-9