Abstract
Are liberal trade policies good for growth? Sceptics often point to the late nineteenth century as a period when protectionist policies promoted economic development. This apparent blueprint for the benefits of protectionism paradoxically comes from a period that is often described as the first era of globalization. In this paper we reassess the empirical evidence about the relationship between tariffs and growth between 1870 and 1914. Our key findings challenge the idea that in the nineteenth century countries that raised tariffs thereby increased their own growth rate. Using new and improved data and employing a whole portfolio of econometric tests we do not find evidence that increased protectionism raised the rate of individual countries’ growth. While some positive cross-sectional correlation exists between tariffs and growth, this may reflect unobserved country traits rather than a causal relation. There is equally little evidence that other external factors, such as real exchange rates and terms of trade changes, were key drivers of economic performance. A paradox of this first era of globalization is not that free trade was bad for growth; it is that international economic policies seem to have mattered little to countries’ growth trajectories.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Acemoglu D., Robinson J. A., Johnson S. (2001) The colonial origins of comparative development: An empirical investigation. American Economic Review 91: 1369–1401
Arellano M., Bond S. (1991) Some tests of specification for panel data: Monte Carlo evidence and an application to employment equations. Review of Economic Studies 58(2): 277–297
Arellano M., Bover O. (1995) Another look at the instrumental-variable estimation of error-components models. Journal of Econometrics 68: 29–51
Ashley R. (2009) Assessing the credibility of instrumental variables inference with imperfect instruments via sensitivity analysis. Journal of Applied Econometrics 24: 325–337
Bairoch, P. (1989). European trade policy, 1815–1914. In P. Mathias & S. Pollard (Eds.), The industrial economies: The development of economic and social policies, the cambridge economic history of europe (Vol. VIII, pp. 1–60). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Bairoch P. (1996) Economics and world history. Harvester Wheatsheaf, Brighton
Baltagi B. H. (2006) Panel data econometrics: Theoretical contributions and empirical applications. Elsevier, UK
Bassanini A., Scarpetta S. (2002) Does human capital matter for growth in OECD countries? A pooled mean-group approach. Economics Letters 74(3): 399–405
Bazzi, S., & Clemens, M. (2009). Blunt instruments: A cautionary note on establishing the causes. Center for Global Development, Working Paper 171, May (revised July 2010).
Ben-David D. (1993) Equalizing exchange: Trade liberalization and income convergence. Quarterly Journal of Economics 108(3): 653–679
Blattman C., Hwang J., Williamson J.G. (2007) The impact of the terms of trade on economic development in the periphery, 1870–1939: Volatility and secular change. Journal of Development Economics 82(1): 156–179
Blundell R., Bond S. (1998) Initial conditions and moment restrictions in dynamic panel data models. Journal of Econometrics 87(1): 115–143
Bond, S., Hoeffler, A., & Temple, J. R. W. (2001). GMM Estimation of empirical growth models. CEPR Discussion Paper No.3048, November.
Bowsher C. G. (2002) On testing overidentifying restrictions in dynamic panel data models. Economics Letters 77: 211–220
Bun M., Windmeijer F. (2010) The weak instrument problem of the system GMM estimator in dynamic panel data models. Econometrics Journal 13: 95–126
Catao, L. A. V., & Solomou, S. N. (2005). Effective exchange rates and the classical gold standard adjustment. American Economic Review, September, pp. 1259–1275.
Clemens M. A., Williamson J. G. (2004) Why did the tariff-growth correlation reverse after 1950?. Journal of Economic Growth 9(1): 5–46
Dollar D. (1992) Outward-oriented developing economies really do grow more rapidly: Evidence from 95 LDCs, 1976–85. Economic Development and Cultural Change 40(3): 523–544
Durlauf, S. N., Johnson, P. A., & Temple, J. R. W. (2005). Growth econometrics. In P. Aghion & S. N. Durlauf (Eds.), Handbook of economic growth (Vol. 1A, pp. 555–677). Amsterdam: North-Holland.
Edwards S. (1998) Openness, productivity and growth: What do we really know?. Economic Journal 108(447): 383–398
Eichengreen, B. (2008). The real exchange rate and economic growth. Commission on Growth and Development Working Paper No. 4.
Eichengreen, B., & Irwin, D. A. (2009). The slide to protectionism in the great depression: Who succumbed and why? NBER Working Paper No. 15142.
Estevadeordal, A., & Taylor, A. M. (2008). Is the washington consensus dead? Growth, openness, and the great liberalization, NBER Working Paper 14264, August.
Estevadeordal A., Frantz B., Taylor A. (2003) The rise and fall of world trade, 1870–1939. Quarterly Journal of Economics 118(2): 359–407
Frankel J. A., Romer D. (1999) Does trade cause growth?. American Economic Review 89(3): 379–399
Galor O., Mountford A. (2008) Trading population for productivity: Theory and evidence. Review of Economic Studies 75(4): 1143–1179
Haber, S. (2005). Development strategy or endogenous process? The industrialization of Latin America. Mimeo.
Hadass Y., Williamson J. G. (2003) Terms of trade shocks and economic performance 1870–1940: Prebisch and singer revisited. Economic Development and Cultural Change 51(3): 629–656
Hauk W. R., Wacziarg R. (2009) A Monte Carlo study of growth regressions. Journal of Economic Growth 14: 103–147
Hayakawa K. (2007) Small sample bias properties of the system GMM estimator in dynamic panel data models. Economics Letters 95: 32–38
Irwin D. A. (2002) Interpreting the tariff-growth correlation in the late nineteenth century. American Economic Review (Papers & Proceedings) 92: 165–169
Jacks D. S. (2006) New results on the tariff-growth paradox. European Review of Economic History 10: 205–230
Jacks D.S., Meissner C., Novy M.D. (2010) Trade costs in the first wave of globalization. Explorations in Economic History 47(2): 127–141
Jones C. I. (2001) Introduction to economic growth. Norton, New York
Judson R. A., Owen A. L. (1999) Estimating dynamic panel data models: A guide for macroeconomists. Economics Letters Elsevier 65(1): 9–15
Kiviet, J. F. (2009). Strength and weakness of instruments in IV and GMM estimation of dynamic panel data models. University of Amsterdam, Mimeo, January.
Lee K., Pesaran M., Smith R. (1997) Growth and convergence in multi country empirical stochastic solow model. Journal of Applied Econometrics 12(4): 357–392
Lee K., Pesaran M. H., Smith R. (1998) Growth empirics: A panel data approach—A comment. Quarterly Journal of Economics 113(1): 319–323
Lehmann, S., & O’Rourke, K. (2008). The structure of protection and growth in the late 19th century. NBER Working Paper 14493.
Levine R., Renelt D. (1992) A sensitivity analysis of cross-country growth regressions. American Economic Review 82(4): 942–963
Loayza N., Ranciere R. (2006) Financial development, financial fragility, and growth. Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking 38(4): 1051–1076
Madsen J. B. (2009) Trade barriers, openness, and economic growth. Southern Economic Journal 76(2): 397–418
Mankiw N. G., Romer D., Weil D. N. (1992) A contribution to the empirics of economic growth. Quarterly Journal of Economics 107(2): 407–437
Newey W., Windmeijer F. (2009) Generalized method of moments with many weak moment conditions. Econometrica 77: 687–719
Nugent J. B. (1973) Exchange-rate movements and economic development in the late nineteenth century. Journal of Political Economy 81(5): 1110–1135
O’Rourke K. (2000) Tariffs and growth in the late 19th century. Economic Journal 110: 456–483
Pesaran M. H., Smith R. (1995) Estimating long-run relationships from dynamic heterogenous panels. Journal of Econometrics 68: 79–113
Pesaran M. H., Yongcheol S., Smith R. P. (1999) Pooled mean group estimation of dynamic heterogeneous panels. Journal of the American Statistical Association 94: 621–633
Prebisch R. (1950) The economic development of Latin America and its principal problems, United Nations, Department of Economic Affairs, 1950. Economic Bulletin for Latin America 7: 1–22
Rodríguez F., Rodrik D. (2001) Trade policy and economic growth: A skeptic’s guide to the cross-national evidence. In: Bernanke B., Rogoff K. (eds) NBER macroeconomics annual 2000. National Bureau of Economic Research. 2000, Cambridge, MA
Rodrik, D. (2008). The real exchange rate and economic growth. Brookings Paper on Economic Activity. Fall.
Roodman, D. (2005). XTABOND2: Stata module to extend xtabond dynamic panel data estimator. http://ideas.repec.org/c/boc/bocode/s435901.html.
Roodman, D. (2008). A note on the theme of too many instruments. Center for Global Development Working Paper No. 125, May.
Sachs J.D., Warner A. (1995) Economic reform and the process of global integration. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity 1: 1–118
Schularick M. (2006) A tale of two ‘Globalizations’: Capital flows from rich to poor in two eras of global finance. International Journal of Finance and Economics 11(4): 339–354
Schularick M., Steger T. (2010) Financial integration, investment, and economic growth—Evidence from two eras of financial globalization. Review of Economics and Statistics 92(4): 756–768
Solomou S. (1998) Economic cycles: Long cycles and business cycles since 1870. Manchester University Press, Manchester
Solomou S., Wu W. (2002) Macroeconomic effects of weather shocks 1870–1913. Climate Research 20: 153–166
Tan K. Y. (2009) A pooled mean group analysis on aid and growth. Applied Economics Letters 16(16): 1597–1601
Taylor A. (1999) Sources of convergence in the late 19th century. European Economic Review 43: 1621–1645
Taylor A., Williamson J. (1997) Convergence in an age of mass migration. European Review of Economic History 1: 27–63
Vamvakidis A. (2002) How Robust is the growth-openness connection? Historical evidence. Journal of Economic Growth 7: 57–80
Wacziarg R. (2001) Measuring the dynamic gains from trade. World Bank Economic Review 15: 393–429
Wacziarg R., Welch K. H. (2008) Trade liberalization and growth: New evidence. World Bank Economic Review 22: 187–231
Williamson J. (2006) Globalization and the poor periphery before 1950. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA
Williamson J. (2008) Globalization and the great divergence: Terms of trade booms and volatility in the poor periphery 1782–1913. European Review of Economic History 12(3): 355–391
Yanikkaya H. (2003) Trade openness and economic growth: A cross-country empirical investigation. Journal of Development Economics 72: 57–89
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Schularick, M., Solomou, S. Tariffs and economic growth in the first era of globalization. J Econ Growth 16, 33–70 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10887-011-9061-6
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10887-011-9061-6