Abstract
This paper discusses the ethical and regulatory issues raised by “intragenics” – organisms that have been genetically modified using gene technologies, but that do not contain DNA from another species. Considering the rapid development of knowledge about gene regulation and genomics, we anticipate rapid advances in intragenic methods. Of regulatory systems developed to govern genetically modified organisms (GMOs) in North America, Europe, Australia, and New Zealand, the Australian system stands out in explicitly excluding intragenics from regulation. European systems are also under pressure to exclude intragenics from regulation. We evaluate recent arguments that intragenics are safer and more morally acceptable than transgenic organisms, and more acceptable to the public, which might be thought to justify a lower standard of regulation. We argue that the exemption of intragenics from regulation is not justified, and that there may be significant environmental risks associated with them. We conclude that intragenics should be subject to the same standard of regulation as other GMOs.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
APHIS (USDA Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service) (1992). Response to Calgene petition for determination of regulatory status, 1992, Petition no.92-196-01, USDA
Baumgartner C. (2006). Exclusion by Inclusion? On Difficulties with Regard to an Effective Ethical Assessment of Patenting in the Field of Agricultural Bio-technology. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics, 19, 521–539
Bhattacharya, S. (2003). Glowing red GM fish to sell in US. NewScientist.com news service, 24 November 2003. Retrieved Jan 11, 2007, from http://www.newscientist.com/article.ns?id=dn4411
Bodmer, W. (1992), “Patent Absurdity.” Science and Public Affairs, Summer, 3–4
Brown N., M. Michael (2001). Transgenics, Uncertainty and Public Credibility. Transgenic Research 10, 279–283
Bruce D. M. (2002). A Social Contract for Biotechnology: Shared Visions for Risky Technologies? Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics, 15, 279–289
Buiatii M. (2005). Biologies, Agricultures, Biotechnologies. Tailoring Biotechnologies, 1(2), 9–30
Burrows B. (2001). Safety First. In B. Tokar (ed.), Redesigning Life? The Worldwide Challenge to Genetic Engineering. London: Zed Books
Busch L. (2002). The Homiletics of Risk. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics, 15, 17–29
Carman J. (2004). Is GM Food Safe to Eat? In R. Hindmarsh, G. Lawrence (eds.), Recoding Nature: Critical Perspectives on Genetic Engineering. Sydney: UNSW Press
Castrillo L. A., R. E. Lee, J. A. Wyman, M. R. Lee, S. T. Rutherford (2001). Field Persistence of Ice-nucleating Bacteria in Overwintering Colorado Potato Beetles. Biological Control, 21(1), 11–18
CFIA (Canadian Food Inspection Agency) (2004). Updated Directive 94-08 (Dir94-08) Assessment Criteria for Determining Environmental Safety of Plants With Novel Traits. Ottawa: CFIA
Cohen J. I. (2001). Harnessing Biotechnology for the Poor: Challenges Ahead for Capacity, Safety and Public Investment. Journal of Human Development, 2(2), 239–263
Conner, A. J., and J. M. E. Jacobs “GM Plants Without Foreign DNA: Implications from New Approaches in Vector Development,” in Proceedings of the Ninth International Symposium on the Biosafety of Genetic Modified Organisms: Biosafety Research and Environmental Risk Assessment (Jeju Island, Korea, 2006) September 24–29, pp. 195–201
Cormick C. (2003). Perceptions of Risk Relating to Biotechnology in Australia. International Journal of Biotechnology 5(2), 95–104
Crouch M. L. (2001). From Golden Rice to Terminator Technology: Agricultural Biotechnology Will Not Feed the World or Save the Environment. In B. Tokar (ed.), Redesigning Life? The Worldwide Challenge to Genetic Engineering. London: Zed Books
Dall, D. and G. Neumann, Daughterless Carp: An Analysis of Legal, Technical and Other Risks to Delivery. A report to the Pest Animal Control CRC (Canberra, 2004)
Davidson S. (2002). Carp Crusades. ECOS, 112, 8–12
De Cock Buning T., E. T. Lammerts van Bueren, M. A. Haring, H. C. De Vriend, P. C. Struik (2006). Correspondence. Nature Biotechnology, 24(11), 1329–1331
Dennis C. (2002). Gene Regulation: The Brave New World of RNA. Nature, 418, 122–124
Devlin R. H., T. Y. Yesaki, C. A. Biagi, E. M. Donaldson, P. Swanson, W. K. Chan (1994). Extraordinary Salmon Growth. Nature, 371, 209–210
Devlin R. H., C. A. Biagi, T. Y. Yesaki (2004). Growth, Viability and Genetic Characteristics of GH Transgenic Coho Salmon Strains. Aquaculture, 236, 607–632
Devlin R. H., L. F. Sundström, W. M. Muir (2006). Interface of Biotechnology and Ecology for Environmental Risk Assessments of Transgenic Fish. Trends in Biotechnology, 24(2), 89–97
Dick, A. (2004), “Sons, No Daughters,” The Land 12, 32
European Parliament, “Directive 2001/18/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 12 March 2001 on the deliberate release into the environment of GMOs and repealing Council Directive 90/220/EEC,” Offical Journal of European Community L106 (2001), 1–38
EU SCP (European Union Scientific Committee on Plants) (1998). Opinion of the Scientific Committee on Plants Regarding Submission for Placing on the Market under Directive 90/220/EEC of Genetically Modified Processing Tomato Line TGT7F Notified by Zeneca. Notification C/ES/96/01 [available at http://ec.europa.eu/food/fs/sc/scp/out19_en.html, accessed 9 Jan 07]
Ferrara J., M. K. Dorsey (2001). Genetically Engineered Foods: A Minefield of Safety Hazards. In B. Tokar (ed.), Redesigning Life? The Worldwide Challenge to Genetic Engineering. London: Zed Books
Giddings L. V. (2006). Correspondence. Nature Biotechnology, 24(11), 1329
Groot A. T., M. Dicke (2002). Insect-resistant Transgenic Plants in a Multi-trophic Context. The Plant Journal, 31(4), 387–406
Hallerman, E. M. (2004), “GloFish, the first GM animal commercialized: profits amid controversy.” ISB News Report, June 2004
Hallerman E. M., E. McLean, I. A. Fleming (2007). Effects of Growth Hormone Transgenes on the Behaviour and Welfare of Aquacultured Fishes: A Review Identifying Research Needs. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 104(3–4), 265–294
Hoedemaekers R. (2001). Commercialisation, Patents and Moral Assessment of Biotechnology Products. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy, 26(3), 273–284
Jacobsen E., H. J. Schouten (2007). Cisgenesis Strongly Improves Introgression Breeding and Induced Translocation Breeding of Plants. Trends in biotechnology, 25(5), 219–223
Jasanoff S. (1995). Product, Process, or Programme: Three Cultures and the Regulation of Biotechnology. In M. Bauer (ed.), Resistance to New Technology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
Jefferson R. A. (2001). Trancending Transgenics: Are There Babies in the Bathwater, or is That a Dorsal Fin? In P. G. Pardey (ed.), The Future of Food: Biotechnology Markets and Policies in an International Setting (pp. 75–95). Washington, DC: John Hopkins Press
Jones D. A., M. H. Ryder, B. G. Clare, S. K. Farrand, A. Kerr (1988). Construction of a Tra- Deletion Mutant of pAgK84 to Safeguard the Biological Control of Crown Gall. Molecular and General Genetics, 212, 207–214
Kramer M., R. Sanders, H. Bolkan, C. Waters, R. E. Sheehy, W. R. Hiatt (1992). Postharvest Evalutation of Transgenic Tomatoes with Reduced Levels of Polygalacturonase: Processing, Firmness and Disease Resistance. Postharvest Biology and Technology, 1, 241–255
Krimsky S. (1991). Biotechnics in Society: The Rise of Industrial Genetics. New York: Praeger
Lammerts Van Bueren E. T., H. Verhoog, M. Tiemens-Hulscher, P. C. Struik, M. Haring, (2007). Organic Agriculture Requires Process Rather Than Product Evaluation of Novel Breeding Techniques. NJAS Wageningen Journal of Life Sciences, 54, 401–412
Lehrman S. (1992). US Proposes Relaxing Rules on Trials of Biotech Crops. Nature, 360, 94
Levidow L. (2005). Divergent Concepts of Sustainability: The Case of GM Crops. In G. Banse, I. Hronszky, G. Nelson (eds.), Rationality in an Uncertain World (pp. 133–144). Berlin: Edition Sigma
Levidow L., A. Carr, R. von Schomberg, D. Wield (1996). Regulating Agricultural Biotechnology in Europe: Harmonisation Difficulties, Opportunities, Dilemmas. Science and Public Policy 23(3), 135–157
Logar N., L. K. Pollock (2005). Transgenic Fish: Is a New Policy Framework Necessary for a New Technology? Environmental Science and Policy, 8, 17–27
Madsen K. H., P. B. Hom, J. Lassen, P. Sandoe, (2002). Ranking Genetically Modified Plants According to Familiarity. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics, 15, 267–278
Marsden, T. (In press). Agri-food Contestations in Rural Space: GM in its Regulatory Context. Geoforum. Available on-line at: doi:10.1016/j.geoforum.2006.11. 013
McNally R., P. Wheale (1996). Biopatenting and Biodiversity: Comparative Advantages in the New Global Order. The Ecologist, 26(5), 222–228
Millstone E., E. Brunner, S. Mayer (1999). Beyond ‹substantial equivalence’. Nature, 401, 525–526
Muir W. M., R. D. Howard (2004). Characterization of Environmental Risk of Genetically Engineered (GE) Organisms and Their Potential to Control Exotic Invasive Species. Aquatic Sciences 66, 414–420
Myskja, B. K., “Is there a moral difference between intragenic and transgenic modification of plants?” Paper presented at EurSafe 2004: 5th Congress of the European Society for Agricultural and Food Ethics (Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Belgium, 2004)
Myskja B. K. (2006). The Moral Difference Between Intragenic and Transgenic Modification of Plants. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 19, 225–238
Nam Y. K., J. K. Noh, Y. S. Cho, H. J. Cho, K.-N. Cho, C. G. Kim, D. S. Kim (2001). Dramatically Accelerated Growth and Extraordinary Gigantism of Transgenic Mud Loach Misgurnus mizolepis. Transgenic Research 10, 353–362
Nam Y. K., I.-S. Park, D. S. Kim (2004). Triploid Hybridization of Fast-Growing Transgenic Mud Loach Misgurnus mizolepis Male to Cyprinid Loach Misgurnus anguillicaudatus Female: The First Performance Study on Growth and Reproduction of Transgenic Polyploid Hybrid Fish. Aquaculture 231, 559–572
Nelkin D. (2002). Patenting Genes and the Public Interest. American Journal of Bioethics, 2(3), 13–14
Nielsen K. M. (2003). Transgenic Organisms – Time for Conceptual Diversification? Nature Biotechnology 21, 227–228
Noble D. (2006). The Music of Life: Biology Beyond the Genome. Oxford: Oxford University Press
OECD (Organisation for Economic Co-operation, Development) (1993). Safety considerations for biotechnology: scale-up of crop plants. Paris: OECD
O’Neill, G. (2004), “Silence of the Genes.” Australian Life Scientist Oct/Nov 2004, 12–14
Orser, C. S., R. Lotstein, B. J. Staskawicz, D. Dahlbeck, E. Lahue, D. K. Willis, S. E. Lindow, and N. J. Panopoulos, “Molecular Genetics of Bacterial Ice Nucleation.” In Proceedings of the 2nd Working Group on Pseudomonas Syringae Pathovars (The Hellenic Phytophathological Society, Athens, 1984)
Piller C. (1986). From Ice-nine to Ice-minus; Regulating Altered Genes. The Nation, 243, 400–402
Pollan M. (2003). The Botany of Desire: A Plant’s Eye View of the World. London: Bloomsbury
Rhein, R. Jr “‹Ice-minus’ May End Killer Frosts – And Stop the Rain...” Business Week, Nov 25, 1985, 42–43
Rommens C. M. (2004). All-native DNA Transformation: A New Approach to Plant Genetic Engineering. TRENDS in Plant Science 9(9), 457–464
Rommens C. M., J. M. Humara, J. Ye, H. Yan, C. Richael, L. Zhang, R. Perry, K. Swords (2004). Crop Improvement Through Modification of the Plant’s own Genome. Plant Physiology, 135, 421–431
Russell A. W. (2001). Gene Technology in R&D Provision to the Australian Sugar Industry: Sweetening up Public Research? Rural Society, 11(3), 163–180
Russell, A. W., “GMOs and Their Contexts: A Comparison of Potential and Actual Performance of GM Crops in a Local Agricultural Setting.” Geoforum. Available on-line at: doi:10.1016/j.geoforum.2007.04.001
Sagoff M. (2002). Intellectual Property and Products of Nature. American Journal of Bioethics, 2(3), 12–13
Schmitz S. A. (2001). Cloning Profits: The Revolution in Agricultural Biotechnology. In B. Tokar (ed.), Redesigning Life? The Worldwide Challenge to Genetic Engineering. London: Zed Books
Schouten H. J., F. A. Krens, E. Jacobsen (2006a). Cisgenic Plants are Similar to Traditionally Bred Plants. EMBO Reports 7(7), 750–753
Schouten H. J., F. A. Krens, E. Jacobsen (2006b). Do Cisgenic Plants Warrant Less Stringent Oversight? Nature Biotechnology 24(7), 753
Schouten H. J., F. A. Krens, E. Jacobsen (2006c). Correspondence: Schouten and Colleagues Respond. Nature Biotechnology 24(11), 1331–1333
Schubert D. (2002). A Different Perspective on GM Food. Nature Biotechnology, 20(10), 969
Schubert D., D. Williams (2006). Correspondance. Nature Biotechnology 24(11), 1327–1328
Seralini G. E., D. Cellier, J. S. de Vendomois (2007). New Analysis of a Rat Feeding Study with a Genetically Modified Maize Reveals Signs of Hepatorenal Toxicity. Archives of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology, 52(4), 596–602
Shiva V. (1997). Biopiracy: The Plunder of Nature and Knowledge. Boston, MA: South End Press
Shohet S. (1996). Biotechnology in Europe: Contentions in the Risk-Regulation Debate. Science and Public Policy, 23(2), 117–122
Snow A. (2003). Unnatural Selection. Nature 424, 619
Stephenson J. R., A. Warnes (1996). Release of Genetically Modified Micro-organisms into the Environment. Journal of Chemical Technology and Biotechnology, 65, 5–14
Stotzky G. (2000). Persistence and Biological Activity in Soil of Insecticidal Proteins from Bacillus thuringiensis and of Bacterila DNA Bound on Clays and Humin acids. Journal of Environmental Quality, 29(3), 691–705
Timbs, S., K. Adams, and W. M. Rogers (2006) Statutory Review of the Gene Technology Act 2000 and The Gene Technology Agreement. Retrieved 23 Mar, 2007 from: http://www.health.gov.au/internet/wcms/publishing.nsf/Content/gtreview-report.htm
Tokar B. (2001). Redesigning Life? The Worldwide Challenge to Genetic Engineering. London: Zed Books
van den Eede G., H.-J. Aarts, H. Buhk, G. Corthier, H. J. Flint, W. Hammes, B. Jacobsen, T. Midtvedt, J. van der Vossen, A. von Wright, W. Wackernagel, A. Wilcks (2004) The Relevance of Gene Transfer to the Safety of Food and Feed Derived from Genetically Modified (GM) Plants. Food and Chemical Toxicology, 42, 1127–1156
Wright S. (1994). Molecular Politics: Developing American and British regulatory Policy for Genetic Engineering, 1972–1982. Chicago: University of Chicago Press
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Russell, A.W., Sparrow, R. The case for regulating intragenic GMOs. J Agric Environ Ethics 21, 153–181 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10806-007-9074-5
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10806-007-9074-5