Abstract
Conservation scientists are arguing whether naturalness provides a reasonable “imperative” for conservation. To clarify this debate and the interpretation of the term “natural,” I analyze three management strategies – ecosystem preservation, ecosystem restoration, and ecosystem engineering – with respect to the naturalness of their outcomes. This analysis consists in two parts. First, the ambiguous term “natural” is defined in a variety of ways, including (1) naturalness as that which is part of nature, (2) naturalness as a contrast to artifactuality, (3) naturalness as an historical independence from human actions, and (4) naturalness as possession of certain properties. After that, I analyze the different conceptions with respect to their implications for the three management strategies. The main conclusion is that there exists no single conception of naturalness that could distinguish between the outcomes of the three management methods. Therefore, as long as the outcomes of the different methods are regarded as being of a different value in conservation, we should either abandon the idea of naturalness as the guiding concept in conservation or use the term “natural” only in the ways that take both its historical and feature dependent meanings into consideration.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
J.E. Anderson (1991) ArticleTitleA Conceptual Framework for Evaluating and Quantifying Naturalness Conservation Biology 5 347–352
P. Angermeier (1994) ArticleTitleDoes Biodiversity Include Artificial Diversity? Conservation Biology 8 600–602
P. Angermeier (2000) ArticleTitleNatural Imperative for Biological Conservation Conservation Biology 14 373–381
P.L. Angermeier J.R. Karr (1994) ArticleTitleBiological Integrity versus Biological Diversity as Policy Directives Bioscience 44 690–697
Aristotele (1984) Physics J. Barnes (Eds) The Complete Works of Aristotle: The Revised Oxford Translation Princeton University Press Princeton 315–446
Banko, G., “Assessing and monitoring nature protection value of European landscapes using remote sensing and GIS tools”, in www.geoweb.cslm.hu/vhost/geoinfo/events/SAT/cd/pdf/GebhardBankoenvip.pdf, 2001.
B.W. Bowen (1999) ArticleTitlePreserving Genes, Species, or Ecosystems Healing the Fractured Foundations of Conservation Policy Molecular Ecology 8 5–10
A. Brennan (1984) ArticleTitleThe Moral Standing of Natural Objects Environmental Ethics 6 35–56
F.W. Burley (1988) The Tropical Forestry Action Plan: Recent Progress and New Initiatives E.O. Wilson (Eds) Biodiversity National Academy Press Washington, DC 403–408
J. Cairns (1988) Increasing Diversity by Restoring Damaged Ecosystems Wilson E.O. (Eds) Biodiversity National Academy Press Washington, DC 333–343
J.B. Callicott (1996) ArticleTitleDo Deconstructive Ecology and Sociobiology Undermine Leopold’s Land Ethics? Environmental Ethics 18 353–372
J.B. Callicott L.B. Crowder K. Mumford (2000) ArticleTitleNormative Concepts in Conservation Biology: Reply to Willers and Hunter Conservation Biology 14 575–578
N.L. Christensen A.M. Bartuska J.H. Brown S. Carpenter C. D’Antonio R. Francis J.F. Franklin J.A. MacMahon R.F. Noss D.J. Parsons C.H. Peterson M.G. Turner R.G. Woodmansee (1996) ArticleTitleThe Report of the Ecological Society of America Committee on the Scientific Basis for Ecosystem Management Ecological Applications 6 665–691
P. Comer (1997) ArticleTitleAn Unnamed Letter Conservation Biology 11 301–303
C.M. Cowell (1993) ArticleTitleEcological Restoration and Environmental Ethics Environmental Ethics 15 19–32
D. Davidson (1980) Actions, Reasons, and Causes D. Davidson (Eds) Essays on Actions and Events Clarendon Press Oxford 3–19
E. Elliot (1982) ArticleTitleFaking Nature Inquiry 25 81–93
R.E. Grumbine (1994a) ArticleTitleWhat is Ecosystem Management? Conservation Biology 8 27–38
R.E. Grumbine (1994a) ArticleTitleWildness, Wise Use, and Sustainable Development Environmental Ethics 16 227–249
Y. Haila (1997) ArticleTitleA ‘Natural’ Benchmark for Ecosystem Function Conservation Biology 11 300–301
E.S. Higgs (1997) ArticleTitleWhat is Good Ecological Restoration? Conservation Biology 11 338–348
R. Hilpinen (1993) ArticleTitleAuthors and Artifacts Proceedings of Aristotelian Society 93 155–178
R. Hilpinen (1995) ArticleTitleBelief Systems as Artifacts The Monist 78 136–155
M. Hunter (1996) ArticleTitleBenchmarks for Managing Ecosystems: Are Human Activities Natural? Conservation Biology 10 695–697
K. Jax C.G. Jones T.A. Pickett (1998) ArticleTitleSelf-identity of Ecological Units Oikos 82 253–264
W.R. Jordan (1988) Ecological Restoration: Reflection on a Half-Cebtury of Experience at the University of Wisconsin-Madison Arboretum E.O. Wilson (Eds) Biodiversity National Academy Press Washington, DC 311–316
N. Karafyllis (2003) ArticleTitleRenewable Resources and the Idea of Nature – What Has Biotechnology Got to Do with it? Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 16 3–28
E. Katz (1997a) The Big Lie: Human Restoration of Nature E. Katz (Eds) Nature as Subject: Human Obligations and Natural Community Rowan & Littlefield Lanham 93–108
E. Katz (1997b) Artifacts and Functions E. Katz (Eds) Nature as Subject:Human Obligations and Natural Community Rowan & Littlefield Lanham 121–132
K. Lee (1999) The Natural and the Artefactual: The Implications of Deep Science and Deep Technology for Environmental Philosophy Lexington Books Lanham
K. Lee (2003) Philosophy and Revolutions in Genetics: Deep Science and Deep Technology Palgrave MacMillan Basingstoke
K.H. Madsen P.B. Holm J. Lassen P. Sandøe (2003) ArticleTitleRanking Genetically Modified Plants According to Familiarity Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 15 267–278
E. Matthews (1988) ArticleTitleAids and Sexual Morality Bioethics 2 119–128
B. McKibben (1989) The End of Nature Random House New York
Merriam-Webster Dictionary. www.m-w.com/cgi-bin/dictionary. 2003.
M. Midgley (1995) Do What’s Natural, You Say? C. Pierce D. VanDeVeer (Eds) People, Penguins, and Plastic Trees Wadsworth Publishing Company Belmont 103–105
J.S. Mill (1969) Collected Works of John Stuart Mill, part 10: Essays on Ethics, Religion and Society Toronto University Press Toronto
Odum, H. T., Center for Wetlands at the University of Florida: Ecological Engineering. www.cfw.ufl., 2003.
M. Oelschlaeger (1999) ArticleTitleOn the Conflation of Humans and Nature Environmental Ethics 21 223–224
D. l. Perlman G. Adelson (1997) Biodiversity: Exploring Values and Priorities in Conservation Blackwell Science Cambridge
T. Povilitis (2001) ArticleTitleToward a Robust Natural Imperative for Conservation Conservation Biology 15 533–535
J. Radcliffe (1984) The Sceptical Feminist Penguin Books Harmondsworth
M. Ruse (2003) Darwin and Design: Does evolution have a purpose? Harvard University Press Cambridge
Räikkä, J. and Rossi, K. Geenit ja etiikka: Kysymyksiä uuden geeniteknologian arvoista (WSOY, Helsinki, 2003). (In Finnish) [Genes and Ethics: Questions about Values of New Gene Technologies].
H. Siipi (2003) ArticleTitleArtefacts and Living Artefacts Environmental Values 12 413–430
G. Snyder (1990) The Practice of the Wild North Point Press New York
Society for Ecological Restoration International Science & Policy Working Group, The SER Primer on Ecological Restoration. www.ser.org., 2002.
K. Soper (1995) What is Nature? Blackwell Publishers Oxford
J. Todd (1988) Restoring Diversity: The Search for a Social and Economic Context E.O. Wilson (Eds) Biodiversity National Academy Press Washington, DC 344–352
C. Uhl (1988) Restoration of Degraded Lands in the Amazon Basin E.O. Wilson (Eds) Biodiversity National Academy Press Washington, DC 326–332
G.E. Varner (1990) ArticleTitleBiological Functions and Biological Interests Southern Journal of Philosophy 28 251–270
H. Verhoog M. Matze E.L. van Bueren T. Baars (2003) ArticleTitleThe Role of the Concept of Natural (Naturalness) in Organic Farming Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 16 29–49
S. Vogel (2003) ArticleTitleEnvironmental Philosophy after the End of Nature Environmental Ethics 24 23–39
R. Wachbroit (1994) ArticleTitleNormality as a Biological Concept Philosophy of Science 61 579–591
R. Williams (1982) Ideas of Nature R. Williams (Eds) Problems in Materialism and Culture Verso Editors and NLB London 67–85
H. Zechmeister A. Tribsch D. Moser T. Wrbka (2002) ArticleTitleDistribution on Endangered Bryophytes in Austrian Agricultural Landscapes Biological Conservation 103 173–182
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Siipi, H. Naturalness In Biological Conservation. J Agric Environ Ethics 17, 457–477 (2004). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10806-004-1466-1
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10806-004-1466-1