Abstract
The new Social Studies curriculum recently introduced in Alberta proposes to encourage students to affirm their place as citizens in a democratic society. Grounded in Biesta’s (2007) argument that regardless of a Program of Studies’ best stated goals and intentions, if a school is not structured democratically the chances of the program being successful are limited. In this article, I question what makes a school democratic as opposed to undemocratic by proposing that the new curriculum is grounded in a representational view of knowledge which leads to a document that is overly conceptualized and presents a view of citizenship as one that can be achieved rather than one that is practiced (Biesta & Lawy, 2006). I argue that it is the representational curriculum and the public school’s organizational structure with its emphasis on duties and responsibilities and the virtual absence of freedom and rights that make these schools fundamentally undemocratic places. In order to pursue this line of inquiry, I juxtapose schools in the public system with a private school which claims to be a participative democracy. This juxtaposition revealed that a school that gives students freedom first and trusts that they will act responsibly with it, is more likely to lead to a citizenship that is practiced rather than one that is simply achieved. While it is not the intention of this paper, to recommend that all schools adopt the model of the private school in this study, it does help us understand why Biesta (2007) is not overly optimistic regarding schools being able to achieve a citizenship that is practiced as opposed to one that is achieved.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Alberta Education: (2005) Social studies program of studies – K-12. Alberta Government, Edmonton, AB, Canada
Apple M.W., Beane J.A. (2007) Democratic schools: Lessons in powerful education. Heineman, Portsmouth, NH
Biesta G.J.J. (2003) Demokrati – ett problem for utbildning eller ett utbildnings problem?[Democracy: A problem for education or an educational problem?]. Utbildning & Demokrati 21(1): 59–80
Biesta, G. (March, 2007). Education and the democratic person: Towards a political conception of democratic education. Teachers College Record, 109(3), 740-769.
Biesta, G. & Lawy, R. (March, 2006). From teaching citizenship to learning democracy: Overcoming individualism in research, policy and practice. Cambridge Journal of Education, 36(1), 63-79.
Biesta G.J.J., Osberg D. (2007) Beyond re/presentation: A case for updating the epistemology of schooling. Interchange 38(1): 15–29
Caspary W.R. (2000) Dewey on democracy. Cornell University Press, Ithaca, NY
Couto, R.A. (2005). Courses in courage: Antioch College and the social sciences. Xlibris Corporation.
Cremin, L.A. (2007, July). Public education and the education of the public. Teachers College Record, 109(7), 1545-1558.
Dewey, J. (1966). Democracy and education. New York: The Free Press. (Original work published 1916)
Dictionary.com. (2008). Retrieved July 19, 2008 from: http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/affirm
Edgar, E., Patton, J.M. & Day-Vines, M. (2002, July). Democratic dispositions and cultural competency: Ingredients for school renewal. Remedial and Special Education, 23(4), 231-241.
Eisner E. (2002) The arts and the creation of mind. R.R. Donnelly & Sons, Harrisonburg, VA
Garratt D. (2000) Democratic citizenship in the curriculum: Some problems and possibilities. Pedagogy, Culture and Society 8: 323–341
Golding (2008). Book review of Burgh, G., Field, T., & Freakley, M. Ethics and the community of inquiry: Education for deliberative democracy. Educational Philosophy and Theory, 40(3), 460-461.
Graham, L.J. (2007, April). (Re)visioning the centre: Education reform and the ‘ideal’ citizen of the future. Educational Philosophy and Theory, 39(2), 197-215.
Greenberg D. (1995) Free at last: The Sudbury Valley school. Sudbury Valley Press, Framingham
Greenberg, D. (2005). The core ideas of the Sudbury Model. Essay based on a talk delivered at the 2005 Summer workshop for staff of Sudbury schools and startup groups. Retrieved June 15, 2008 from: http://www.sudval.org/essays/052008.shtml
Greenberg D., Sadofsky M. (1992) Legacy of trust: Life after the Sudbury Valley school experience. Sudbury Valley School Press, Framingham, MA
Greenberg, M. (2002). A Sudbury valley education: The view from inside. Speech given at Liberty Valley School, Joliet, Illinois.
Indigo Sudbury Campus (ISC). Homepage. (2007) . Retrieved September 8, 2007 from: http://www.indigosudburycampus.com/
Johnston J.S. (2005) Rawls’s Kantian educational theory. Educational Theory 55(2): 153–165
Kluger J. (2008) Simplexity: Why simple things become complex (and how complex things can be made simple). Hyperion Books, New York, NY
Lawy, B. & Biesta, G.J.J. (2006, March). Citizenship-as-practice: The educational implications of an inclusive and relational understanding of citizenship. British Journal of Educational Studies, 54(1), 34-50.
Lister, M. (2005). ‘Marshall-ing’ social and political citizenship: Towards a unified conception of citizenship. Government and Opposition Ltd. 471-491.
Marshall T.H. (1950) Citizenship and social class. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK
McMillan, J.H., Singh, J., & Simonetta, L.G. (2001, Winter). The tyranny of self-oriented self-esteem. Educational Horizons, 92-95.
Mollenhaur K. (1983) Vergessene Zzsamenhange. Juventa, Weinheim
National Foundation for Educational Research. (2004). National Evaluation of Post-16.
Noddings N. (1984) Caring: A feminist approach to ethics & moral education. University of California Press, Berkeley, CA
Osberg D., Biesta G.J.J. (2007) Beyond presence: Epistemological and pedagogical implications of ‘strong’ emergence. Interchange 38(1): 31–51
Rockefeller Archive Center. (2008). Retrieved July 16, 2008 from: http://archive.rockefeller.edu/bio/jdrjr.php
Sudbury Valley School Homepage. Retrieved October 11, 2007 from: http://www.sudval.org/
Tupper, J.A. (2007, Fall). From care-less to care-full: Education for citizenship in schools and beyond. Alberta Journal of Educational Research, 53(3), 259-272.
Vanderstraeten, R. & Biesta, G.J.J. (June, 2006). How is education possible? Pragmatism, communication and the social organization of education. British Journal of Educational Studies, 54(2), 160-174.
Wikipedia. Definition of democracy. Retrieved June 7, 2008 from: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democracy
Wilkins, C. (2003, June). Teachers and young citizens: Teachers talk about their role as social educators. Westminster Studies in Education, 26(1), 63-75.
Young-Bruehl E. (2006) Why Arendt matters. Yale University Press, London, UK
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Skogen, R. The Missing Element to Achieving a Citizenship-as-Practice: Balancing Freedom and Responsibility in Schools Today. Interchange 41, 17–43 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10780-010-9107-2
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10780-010-9107-2