Abstract
The EU Water Framework Directive requires European Union Member States to establish ‘type-specific biological reference conditions’ for streams and rivers. Types can be defined by using either a fixed typology (System-A), defined by ecoregions and categories of altitude, catchment area and geology, or by means of an alternative characterisation (System-B) that can use a variety of physical and chemical factors. Several European countries also have existing RIVPACS-type models that give site (rather than stream type) specific predictions of benthic macroinvertebrate communities. In this paper we compare the Water Framework Directive (WFD) System-A physical typology and three existing European multivariate RIVPACS-type models as alternative methods of establishing reference conditions. This work is carried out in Great Britain – using RIVPACS, Sweden – using SWEPACSRI and the Czech Republic – using PERLA. We found that in all three countries, all seasons and season combinations, and for all biotic indices tested, RIVPACS-type models were more effective (lower standard deviations of O/E ratios) than models based solely on the WFD System-A variables or null models (based on a single expectation for all sites). We also investigated the explanatory power of whole groups of WFD System-A variables and RIVPACS-type model variables, and the explanatory power of individual variables. We found that variables used in the RIVPACS-type models were often better correlates of macroinvertebrate community variation than the WFD System-A variables. We conclude that this is primarily because while the latter use very broad categories of map-derived variables, the former are based on continuous variables selected for their ecological significance.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
P. Armitage J. Blackburn (1985) ArticleTitleChironomidae in the Pennine stream system receiving mine drainage and organic enrichment Hydrobiologia 121 165–172 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00008720
R. T. Clarke J. F. Wright M. T. Furse (2003) ArticleTitleRIVPACS models for predicting the expected macroinvertebrate fauna and assessing the ecological quality of rivers Ecological Modelling 160 219–233 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0304-3800(02)00255-7
InstitutionalAuthorNameCouncil of the European Communities (2000) Directive 2000/60/EC, Establishing a Framework for Community Action in the Field of Water Policy European Commission PE-CONS 3639/1/100 Rev 1 Luxembourg
CSN 75 7716, 1998. Water quality, biological analysis, determination of saprobic index. Czech Technical State Standard. Czech Standards Institute, Prague, 174 pp
F. H. Dawson D. D. Hornby J. H. Hilton (2002) ArticleTitleA method for the automated extraction of environmental variables to help the classification of rivers in Britain Aquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems 12 391–403 Occurrence Handle10.1002/aqc.534
C. A. Extence D. M. Balbi R. P. Chadd (1999) ArticleTitleRiver flow indexing using British benthic macroinvertebrates: a framework for setting hydroecological objectives Regulated Rivers Research and Management 15 543–574 Occurrence Handle10.1002/(SICI)1099-1646(199911/12)15:6<545::AID-RRR561>3.0.CO;2-W
J. W. Feminella (2000) ArticleTitleCorrespondence between stream macroinvertebrate assemblages and 4 ecoregions of the southeastern USA Journal of the North American Benthological Society 19 442–461 Occurrence Handle10.2307/1468106
M. T. Furse (2000) The application of RIVPACS procedures in headwater streams – an extensive and important national resource J. F. Wright D. W. Sutcliffe M. T. Furse (Eds) Assessing the Biological Quality of Fresh Waters Freshwater Biological Association Ambleside 79–91
C. P. Hawkins R. H. Norris J. N. Hogue J. W. Feminella (2000) ArticleTitleDevelopment and evaluation of predictive models for measuring the biological integrity of streams Ecological Applications 10 1456–1477 Occurrence Handle10.2307/2641298
C. P. Hawkins M. R. Vinson (2000) ArticleTitleWeak correspondence between landscape classifications and stream macroinvertebrate assemblages: implications for bioassessment Journal of the North American Benthological Society 19 501–517 Occurrence Handle10.2307/1468111
J. Heino T. Muotka R. Paavola (2003) ArticleTitleDeterminants of macroinvertebrate diversity in headwater streams: regional and local influences Journal of Animal Ecology 72 425–434 Occurrence Handle10.1046/j.1365-2656.2003.00711.x
J. Illies (1978) Limnofauna Europaea Gustav Fisher Verlag Stuttgart
R. K. Johnson L. Sandin (2001) Development of a Prediction and Classification System for Lake (Littoral) and Stream (Riffle) Macroinvertebrate Communities. Stencil Department of Environmental Assessment, SLU Uppsala
Johnson, R. K., K. Aagaard, K. J. Aanes, N. Friberg, G. M. Gislason, H. Lax & L. Sandin, 2001. Macroinvertebrates. In Skriver, J. (ed), Biological Monitoring in Nordic Rivers and Lakes. TemaNord Environment 513: 43–52
J. Kokeš S. Zahrádková D. Němejcová J. Hodovský J. Jarkovský T. Soldán (2006) ArticleTitleThe PERLA system in the Czech Republic: a multivariate approach for assessing the ecological status of running waters Hydrobiologia 566 343–354
P. Logan M. Furse (2002) ArticleTitlePreparing for the European Water Framework Directive – making the links between habitat and aquatic biota Aquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems 12 425–437 Occurrence Handle10.1002/aqc.535
Marvan, P., 1969. Primechania k primeneniu statisticheskich metodov po opredeleniu saprobnosti. Symposium SEV Voprosy saprobnosti, Zivohost, 19–43
D. Moss M. T. Furse J. F. Wright P. D. Armitage (1987) ArticleTitleThe prediction of the macro-invertebrate fauna of unpolluted running-water sites in Great Britain using environmental data Freshwater Biology 17 41–52 Occurrence Handle10.1111/j.1365-2427.1987.tb01027.x
InstitutionalAuthorNameNational Water Council (1981) River Quality: The 1980 Survey and Future Outlook National Water Council London
E. Pantle H. Buck (1955) ArticleTitleDie biologische Uberwachung der Gewasser und die Darstellung der Ergebnisse Gas und Wasserfach. 96 604
C. F. Rabeni K. E. Doisy (2000) ArticleTitleCorrespondence of stream benthic invertebrate assemblages to regional classification schemes in Missouri Journal of the North American Benthological Society 19 419–428 Occurrence Handle10.2307/1468104
D. M. Rosenberg T. B. Reynoldson V. H. Resh (2000) Establishing reference conditions in the Fraser River catchment, British Columbia, Canada, using the BEAST (BEnthic Assessment of SedimenT) predictive model J. F. Wright D. W. Sutcliffe M. T. Furse (Eds) Assessing the Biological Quality of Fresh Waters Freshwater Biological Association Ambleside 181–194
L. Sandin R. K. Johnson (2000) ArticleTitleEcoregions and benthic macroinvertebrate assemblages of Swedish streams Journal of the North American Benthological Society 19 462–474 Occurrence Handle10.2307/1468107
J. C. Simpson R. H. Norris (2000) Biological assessment of river quality: development of AusRivAS models and outputs J. F. Wright D. W. Sutcliffe M. T. Furse (Eds) Assessing the Biological Quality of Fresh Waters Freshwater Biological Association Ambleside 125–142
R. Sweeting (2001) Classification of ecological status of lakes and rivers – biological elements in the classification S. Back K. Karttunnen (Eds) Classification of Ecological Status of Lakes and Rivers TemaNord Environment 2001:584, Nordic Council of Ministers Copenhagen 9
C. J. F. ter Braak I. C. Prentice (1988) ArticleTitleA theory of gradient analysis Advances in Ecological Research 18 271–317 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0065-2504(08)60183-X
ter Braak, C. J. F. & P. Smilauer, 2002. CANOCO Reference Manual and CanoDraw for User’s Guide: Software for Canonical Community Ordination (version 4.5). Microcomputer Power (Ithaca NY, USA), 500 pp
J. Sickle ParticleVan R. M. Hughes (2000) ArticleTitleClassification strengths of ecoregions, catchments, and geographical clusters for aquatic vertebrates in Oregon Journal of the North American Benthological Society 19 370–384 Occurrence Handle10.2307/1468101
J. Sickle ParticleVan C. P. Hawkins D. P. Larsen A. H. Herlihy (2005) ArticleTitleA null model for the expected macroinvertebrate assemblage in streams Journal of the North American Benthological Society 24 178–191 Occurrence Handle10.1899/0887-3593(2005)024<0178:ANMFTE>2.0.CO;2
P. F. M. Verdonschot R. C. Nijboer (2004) ArticleTitleTesting the European stream typology of the Water Framework Directive for macroinvertebrates Hydrobiologia 516 35–54 Occurrence Handle10.1023/B:HYDR.0000025257.30311.b7
I. R. Waite A. T. Herlihy D. P. Larsen D. J. Klemm (2000) ArticleTitleComparing strengths of geographic and non-geographic classifications of stream benthic macroinvertebrates in the Mid-Atlantic Highlands, USA Journal of the North American Benthological Society 19 429–441 Occurrence Handle10.2307/1468105
Wilander, A., R. K. Johnson & W. Goedkoop, 2003. Riksinventering 2000: En synoptisk studie av vattenkemi och bottenfauna i svenksa sjöar och vattendrag. Department of Environmental Assessment, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Uppsala, Report 2003, 1 pp
J. F. Wright D. Moss P. D. Armitage M. T. Furse (1984) ArticleTitleA preliminary classification of running water sites in Great Britain based on macro-invertebrate species and prediction of community type using environmental data Freshwater Biology 14 221–256 Occurrence Handle10.1111/j.1365-2427.1984.tb00039.x
J. F. Wright (2000) An introduction to RIVPACS J. F. Wright D. W. Sutcliffe M. T. Furse (Eds) Assessing the Biological Quality of Fresh Waters Freshwater Biological Association Ambleside 1–24
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Davy-Bowker, J., Clarke, R.T., Johnson, R.K. et al. A comparison of the European Water Framework Directive physical typology and RIVPACS-type models as alternative methods of establishing reference conditions for benthic macroinvertebrates. Hydrobiologia 566, 91–105 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10750-006-0068-5
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10750-006-0068-5