Abstract
This article argues (a) that universities are profoundly ambivalent institutions; (b) that this ambivalence explains a great deal about their behavior that would otherwise remain inexplicable; (c) that one of the most striking manifestations of this ambivalence can be found in universities’ attitudes towards change; and (d) that this ambivalence has its roots in a fundamental tension in modern society about the university’s purposes. There is good reason to believe that this set of observations holds true for universities everywhere, albeit to different degrees and in different ways. As a case in point, this article focuses on the process of change (and non-change) in German higher education over the past ten years.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
P.G. Altbach (Eds) (1996) The International Academic Profession: Portraits of Fourteen Countries The Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching Princeton
Z. Bauman (1991) Modernity and Ambivalence Polity Press Cambridge
P. Berman (1992) Debating P.C. The Controversy over Political Correctness on College Campuses Laurel New York
H. Böhme K. Scherpe (Eds) (1996) Literatur und Kulturwissenschaften - Positionen, Theorien, Modelle Rowohlt Hamburg
W.G. Bowen D. Bok (1998) The Shape of the River: Long-Term Consequences of Considering Race in College and University Admissions Princeton University Press Princeton
W.B. Carnochan (1993) The Battleground of the Curriculum: Liberal Education and American Experience Stanford University Press Stanford
B.R. Clark (1998) Creating Entrepreneurial Universities: Organizational Pathways of Transformation Pergamon Oxford
M.D. Cohen J.G. March (1986) Leadership and Ambiguity: The American College President EditionNumber2nd edn. Harvard Business School Press Boston
S.L. Cole (1985) The Absent One: Mourning Ritual, Tragedy, and the Performance of Ambivalence The Pennsylvania State University Press University Park, PA and London
Dahrendorf, R. (1965). Gesellschaft und Demokratie in Deutschland. München: Piper (English (1967): Society and Democracy in Germany. Garden City, NY: Doubleday).
M. Daxner (1999) Die blockierte Universität: Warum die Wissensgesellschaft eine andere Hochschule braucht Campus Frankfurt/Main
S. Dutta (2000) Ambivalence in Hardy: A Study of His Attitude to Women Macmillan London
J. Enders (1998) ‘Berufsbild der Hochschullehrer’, in Teichler Ulrich H-D. Daniel J. Enders (Eds) Brennpunkt Hochschule: Neuere Analysen zu Hochschule, Beruf und Gesellschaft : Campus Frankfurt/Main 55–78
J. Enders B.M. Kehm U. Schimank (2002) ‘Structures and problems of research in German higher education: an overview and an agenda for further studies’ R. McC. Adams (Eds) American Academy of Arts and Sciences Trends in American and German Higher Education Cambridge 85–119
D. Fallon (1980) The German University: A Heroic Ideal in Conflict with the Modern World Colorado Associated University Press Boulder
S. Frosh (1997) ‘Fathers’ ambivalence (too)’ W. Hollway B. Featherstone (Eds) Mothering and Ambivalence Routledge London 37–53
S. Fuller (2000) The Governance of Science: Ideology and the Future of the Open Society Open University Press Buckingham
C. Geertz (1983) Local Knowledge: Further Essays in Interpretive Anthropology Basic Books New York
S. Harding (1986) The Science Question in Feminism Cornell University Press Ithaca
W. Hollway B. Featherstone (Eds) (1997) Mothering and Ambivalence Routledge London
J.A.M. Meerloo (1954) The Two Faces of Man: Two Studies on the Sense of Time and on Ambivalence International Universities Press New York
R.K. Merton (1976) Sociological Ambivalence and Other Essays The Free Press New York
J. Mittelstraß (1994) Die unzeitgemäße Universität Suhrkamp Frankfurt/Main
Montaigne (1998) Essais de Michel Montaigne, Livre II, XVI Imprimerie nationale Paris
D. Müller-Böling E. Mayer A.J. MacLachlan J. Fedrowitz (Eds) (1998) University in Transition: Research Mission--Interdisciplinarity--Governance Bertelsmann Foundation Publishers Gütersloh
D. Müller-Böling (2000) Die entfesselte Hochschule Verlag Bertelsmann Stiftung Gütersloh
S. Muller (Eds) (1996) Universities in the Twenty-First Century. Berghahn Providence, RI
M.C. Nussbaum (1997) Cultivating Humanity: A Classical Defense of Reform in Liberal Education Harvard University Press Cambridge
D. Ottmann (1990) Angrenzende Rede: Ambivalenzbildung und Metonymisierung in Ludwig Tiecks späten Novellen Tübingen Stauffenburg
A.M. Rothfuß (1997) Hochschulen in den USA und Deutschland: Ein Vergleich aus ökonomischer Sicht Nomos Baden-Baden
B. Smart (1999) Facing Modernity: Ambivalence, Reflexivity and Morality Sage London
Stifterverband für die Deutsche Wissenschaft (ed.) (2002). 10 Jahre danach: Zur Entwicklung der Hochschulen und Forschungseinrichtungen in den neuen Ländern und Berlin. Essen: Stifterverband.
U. Teichler H-D. Daniel J. Enders (Eds) (1998) Brennpunkt Hochschule: Neuere Analysen zu Hochschule, Beruf und Gesellschaft Campus Frankfurt/Main
G. Thom (1984) The Human Nature of Social Discontent: Alienation, Anomie, Ambivalence Rowman & Allanheld Totowa, NJ
B. Wächter (Eds) (1999) Internationalisation in Higher Education Lemmens Bonn
A.J. Weigert (1991) Mixed Emotions: Certain Steps Toward Understanding Ambivalence State University of New York Press Albany
H.N. Weiler (1993) ‘Control versus legitimation: the politics of ambivalence’ J. Hannaway M. Carnoy (Eds) Decentralization and School Improvement Jossey-Bass San Fransico 55–83
H.N. Weiler (1996) ‘The changing world of knowledge and the future of higher education: reflections on the creation of a new university’ S. Muller (Eds) Universities in the Twenty-First Century Berghahn Providence and Oxford 129–137
H.N. Weiler (1998a) ‘Different ways of decision-making in higher education and higher education policy in Germany and the US’ D. Müller-Böling (Eds) et al. University in Transition: Research Mission--Interdisciplinarity--Governance Bertelsmann Foundation Publishers Gütersloh 287–293
H.N. Weiler (1998b) ‘Wissenschaft an der Grenze Westdeutscher Verlag, pp. 80–100 Zum besonderen Profil der Europa-Universität Viadrina in Frankfurt (Oder)’, in Söllner, A. and Walkenhaus, R. (eds.), Ostprofile–Universitätsentwicklungen in den Neuen Bundesländern. Opladen
H.N. Weiler (1999) ‘Higher education reform between utopia and reality: a report from Atlantis II’, in Bartels, D. Challenges for the 21st Century. Berlin: Berliner Debatte Wissenschaftsverlag, pp. 57–64 and Petersen, H-G. (eds.), Higher Education Reform in Germany and Australia
H.N. Weiler (2000) ‘Universities, markets and the state: higher education financing as a laboratory of change’, in Peschar, J.L. Changing Relations Between State, Market and Civil Society in Modern European Education. Lisse: Swets & Zeitlinger, pp. 79–92 and van der Wal, M. (eds.), Education Contested
H.N. Weiler (2001a) ‘Changing patterns of governance and finance in German higher education’, in Breinig, H Educational Philosophies and Political Systems. Münster: LIT Verlag, pp. 41–58 et al. (eds.), German and American Higher Education
H.N. Weiler (2001b) ‘Knowledge, politics, and the future of higher education: critical observations on a worldwide transformation’, in Hayhoe, R A Contribution to Dialogue Among Civilizations. Hong Kong: Comparative Education Research Centre, pp. 25–43 and Pan, J. (eds.), Knowledge Across Cultures
H.N. Weiler (2001c) “Sowohl–als auch” und “Ja, aber”–Zur Ambivalenz von Hochschulen im allgemeinen und der Viadrina im besonderen’, in Knefelkamp, U 10 Jahre Europa-Universität Viadrina. Berlin: scripvaz-Verlag, pp. 111–121 (ed.), “Blütenträume” und “Wolkenkuckucksheim” in “Timbuktu”
H. N. Weiler (2002) ‘Amerika, Du hast es besser–Was man vom Hochschulwesen der USA lernen könnte’, in Buhr, H.J. Universitätsklinikum Benjamin Franklin, pp. 7–20 and Germer, C.-T. (eds.), Benjamin Franklin Lecture 2001. Berlin
Wissenschaftsrat (2000) Empfehlungen zur Einführung neuer Studienstrukturen und -abschlüsse (Bakkalaureus/Bachelor–Magister/Master) in Deutschland Wissenschaftsrat Köln
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Weiler, H.N. Ambivalence and the politics of knowledge: The struggle for change in German higher education. High Educ 49, 177–195 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10734-004-2921-7
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10734-004-2921-7