Abstract
This paper considers law’s engagement with pregnancy/workplace conflicts. Drawing on recent research, including original empirical research conducted by the author, I consider how law’s response is ineffective. The nature of this ‘ineffective response’ is explored and in particular I consider the gap between, on the one hand, legal prescriptions and policy ambitions and, on the other hand, the reality of pregnancy/workplace conflicts. In essence, law fails to capture the experiences of pregnant women and new mothers at work and this is reflected in the high number of women experiencing pregnancy discrimination, the low number of women invoking the law in order to gain redress when they do experience pregnancy/workplace conflicts and the low success rate amongst the few women that do bring claims against employers in such circumstances.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Adams, L., McAndrew, F. & Winterbotham, M., Pregnancy Discrimination at Work: A Survey of Women (E.O.C. Paper Series 24, Manchester: E.O.C., 2005)
Barlow A. & Duncan S. Family Law, Moral Rationalities and New Labour’s Communitarianism: Part II, Journal of Social Welfare and Family Law 22(2) (2000), 129–143
Barlow A., Duncan S., James G. & Park A. Cohabitation, Marriage and the Law: Social Change and Legal Reform in 21st Century Britain (Oxford: Hart Publishing, 2005)
Berns S. Women Going Backwards: Law and Change in a Family-Unfriendly Society (Aldershot: Ashgate, 2002)
Bistine S.M. Making Room for Baby, Association Management 37 (1985), 96–98
Boch C. Commentary: Case C-32/93, Webb v E.M.O. v. Air Cargo (U.K.) Ltd., [1994] E.C.R. 1-3567 Common Market Law Review 33(1996) 560–563
Boyd, S.B., “Challenging the Public/Private Divide: An Overview”, in Challenging the Public/Private Divide, ed. S.B. Boyd (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1997), 3–36
Caracciolo di Torella E., & Masselot A. Pregnancy, Maternity and the Organization of Family Life: An Attempt to Classify the Case Law of the Court of Justice, European Law Review 26(2002), 239–260
Coghlan, A., “Stress Can Make Pregnant Women Miscarry”, New Scientist 2473 (November 2004)
Collinson D., Knights D. & Collinson M., Managing to Discriminate (London: Routledge, 1990).
Conaghan J. Pregnancy, Equality and the European Court of Justice, International Journal of Discrimination Law 3 (1998), 115–133.
Conaghan, J., “Feminism and Labour Law: Contesting the Terrain”, in Feminist Perspectives on Employment Law, eds. A. Morris & T. O’Donnell (London: Cavendish, 1999), 13–41
Conaghan, J., “Work, Family, and The Discipline of Labour Law”, in Labour Law, Work, and Families: Critical and Comparative Perspectives, eds. J. Conaghan, & K. Rittich (Oxford: O.U.P., 2005), 19–42
Conaghan, J. & Rittich, K. (eds.), Labour Law, Work, and Families: Critical and Comparative Perspectives (Oxford: O.U.P., 2005)
Desai, T., Gregg, P., Steer, J. & Wadsworth, J., “Gender in the Labour Market”, in The State of Working Britain, eds. P. Gregg & J. Wadsworth (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1999), 168–184
Diduck A. In Search of the Feminist Good Mother, Social & Legal Studies 7(1) (1998), 129–136
D.T.I., Fairness at Work Cmnd 3968 (London: H.M.S.O., 1998)
D.T.I., Work and Parents: Competitiveness and Choice Cmnd 5005 (London: H.M.S.O., 2000)
D.T.I., Work and Families: Choice and Flexibility: A Consultation Document (London: H.M.S.O., 2005)
D.T.I. Work and Families Bill (London: H.M.S.O., 2006a)
D.T.I. Work and Families: Choice and Flexibility: Additional Paternity Leave and Pay – A Consultation Document (London: H.M.S.O., 2006b)
Duffield M. Trends in Female Employment 2002 Labour Market Trends 110(11) (2002), 605–616
Dunstan R. Birth Rights: A CAB Evidence Report on Maternity and Paternity Rights at Work (London: National Association of Citizens Advice Bureaux, 2001)
Employment Tribunals Service, Annual Report and Accounts 2004–2005 (London: T.S.O., 2005)
E.O.C., Greater Expectations: Final Report of the E.O.C.’s Investigation into Discrimination Against New and Expectant Mothers in the Workplace (Manchester: E.O.C., 2005a).
E.O.C., “Press Release: Sacked for being Pregnant” (Manchester: E.O.C., February 2005b, available at http://www.eoc.org.uk/cseng/news/o2_feb_pregnancy)
European Commission, Employment in Europe 2001 (Brussels: European Commission, 2001).
European Commission, Report from the Commission on Equality between Women and Men (Brussels: European Commission, 2005).
Felstiner W.L.F., Abel R.L. & Sarat A. The Emergence and Transformation of Disputes: Naming, Blaming, Claiming…, Law and Society Review 14(1980–1981), 631–654
Fredman S. A Difference with Distinction: Pregnancy and Parenthood Reassessed The Law Quarterly Review 110 (1994), 106–123
Fredman S. Women and the Law (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1997)
Fredman, S., “Precarious Norms for Precarious Work”, in Precarious Work, Women and the New Economy: The Challenge to Legal Norms, eds. J. Fudge & R. Owens (Oxford: Hart Publishing, 2006), 177–200
Fudge, J. & Owens, R. (eds.), Precarious Work, Women and the New Economy: The Challenge to Legal Norms (Oxford: Hart Publishing, 2006)
Genn H. Paths to Justice: What People Do and Think about Going to Law (Oxford: Hart Publishing, 1999)
Gregory J. Pregnancy Discrimination at Work: A Review of Employment Tribunal Decisions from May 2002 to December 2003 (Manchester: E.O.C., 2004)
Halpert J.A., Wilson M.L. & Hickman J.L. Pregnancy as a Source of Bias in Performance Appraisal Journal of Organizational Behaviour 14(1993), 649–663.
Hattery A. Women, Work, and Family: Balancing and Weaving (London: Sage, 2001)
Houston D. & Marks G. The Role of Planning and Workplace Support in Returning to Work after Maternity Leave, British Journal of Industrial Relations 41(2) (2003), 197–214
Houston, D. (ed.) Work-Life Balance in the 21st Century (Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 2005)
James G. The Work and Family Bill: Legislation to Improve Choice and Flexibility?, Industrial Law Journal 35(3) (2006), 272–278
James, G., Regulating Pregnancy and Parenting at Work (working title) (London: Routledge Cavendish, forthcoming)
Labour Party, Labour Party Manifesto (London: Labour Party, 1997)
Lewis, S. & Lewis, J. (eds.), The Work-Family Challenge: Rethinking Employment (London: Sage, 1996)
Leighton P. & Evans R. Pregnant Women at Work: A Survey of Small Business Employers in Wales (Manchester: E.O.C., 2004)
Leonard A. The First Eight Years: A Profile of Applicants to the Industrial Tribunals Under the Sex Discrimination Act 1975 and the Equal Pay Act 1970 (Manchester: E.O.C., 1986)
Leonard A. Pyrrhic Victories: Winning Sex Discrimination and Equal Pay Cases in the Industrial Tribunals, 1980–84 (London: H.M.S.O., 1987a)
Leonard A. Judging Inequality: The Effectiveness of the Tribunal System in Sex Discrimination and Equal Pay Cases (London: Cobden Trust, 1987b).
MacKinnon C. Feminism Unmodified: Discourses on Life and Law (Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press, 1987)
McGlynn, C., “Work, Family, and Parenthood: The European Union Agenda”, in Labour Law, Work, and Families: Critical and Comparative Perspectives, eds. J. Conaghan & K. Rittich (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2005), 217–236
McKie, L., Cunningham-Burley, S. & McKendrick, J., “Families and Relationships: Boundaries and Bridges”, in Families in Society: Boundaries and Relationships, eds. L. McKie & S. Cunningham-Burley (Bristol: Policy Press, 2005)
McRae S. Maternity Rights in Britain: The Experience of Women and Employers (London: Policy Studies Institute, 1991).
McRae S. Returning to Work after Childbirth: Opportunities and Inequalities, European Sociological Review 9(2)(1993), 125–138
M.O.R.I., Big Employers Childcare Survey (London: Daycare Trust, 2002, available at www.mori.com/polls/2002/daycaretrust.2002.shtml)
O’Grady, F. & Wakefield H. Women Work and Maternity: The Inside Story (London: Maternity Alliance, 1989)
Pattison H.M. & Gross H. Pregnancy, Work and Women’s Well-Being Work and Stress 10(1) (1996), 72–87
Pleasence P., Buck A., Balmer N., O’Grady A., Genn H. & Smith M. Causes of Action: Civil Law and Social Justice (London: H.M.S.O., 2004)
Rake K. Women’s Incomes over a Lifetime: Report to the Women’s Unit (London: H.M.S.O., 2000)
Rodmell S. & Smart L. Pregnant at Work: The Experiences of Women (Milton Keynes: Open University Press, 1982)
Salmon N. Lesbian Perspectives on Pregnancy and the ‘Written Statement’ of Rights and Responsibilities Proposed by the EOC (Cardiff: E.O.C. Wales, 2006).
Smart C. Law, Crime and Sexuality (London: Sage Publications, 1995).
Sohrab J.A. Avoiding the ‘Exquisite Trap’: A Critical Look at the Equal Treatment/Special Treatment Debate in Law Feminist Legal Studies 1(2) (1993) 141–162
Spelman E. Inessential Woman: Problems of Exclusion in Feminist Thought (London: The Women’s Press Ltd., 1988)
Tabor M. Pregnancy and Heavy Work, Occupational Health and Safety 2 (1983), 17–18
Thornton, M. (ed.), Public and Private: Feminist Legal Debates (Melbourne: Oxford University Press, 1995)
Weir, G., “The Economically Inactive Who Look After the Family or Home”, Labour Market Trends (November 2002), 577–587
Williams J. Unbending Gender: Why Family and Work Conflict and What To Do About It (New York: O.U.P., 2000)
Wilson, A., “Sectorial and Occupational Change: Prospects for Women’s Employment”, in Labour Market Structures and Prospects for Women, ed. R. Lindley (Manchester: E.O.C., 1994)
Wynn M. Pregnancy Discrimination: Equality, Protection or Reconciliation?, Modern Law Review 62(3) (1999), 435–447
Young V. & Morrell, J. Pregnancy Discrimination at Work: A Survey of Employers (Manchester: E.O.C., 2005)
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
James, C.G. Law’s Response to Pregnancy/Workplace Conflicts: A Critique. Feminist Legal Stud 15, 167–188 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10691-007-9055-0
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10691-007-9055-0