1 Introduction

As of today, deterioration of the ecological situation is observed in the world. This deterioration is connected with increase in the unfavourable load upon the environment, as well as with general depletion of natural resources. One of the tasks for improvement of situation in this sphere is solving the problem with the solid municipal waste, volumes of accumulation of which increase from year to year.

In accordance with the data of the World Bank (https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/feature/2013/10/30/global-waste-on-pace-to-triple), annual production of the solid municipal waste is equal to 2.01 billion tons; however, at least 33% of these waste is not utilised with the help of any environmentally friendly method. The world volume of the SMW, which is generated per capita during a day, is equal to 0.74 kg upon the average. However, this indicator varies in wide limits from 0.11 up to 4.54 kg per capita during a day. In spite of the fact that only 16% of population of the world live in the higher-income countries, these countries produce approximately 34% of the world SMW (or 683 million tons). It is expected that global generation of waste will increase up to 3.4 billion tons by 2050. In principle, there exists positive correlation between generation of waste and income level. According to the existing forecasts, by 2050, daily production of the SMW per head of the population in the higher-income countries will be increased only by 19% as compared with the countries with low- and average-income levels, where (as it is expected) this increase will be approximately equal to 40% and more.

As concerns the world structure of the waste allocation, then approximately 38.5% of waste are utilised in one or another form at landfills, 8% of which are utilised at sanitary landfills, which are equipped with the systems of collection of the landfill gas. Share of the open dumping is equal to approximately 32.5% of waste, 19% of waste are destroyed through recycling and composting, while 11% are incinerated (https://datatopics.worldbank.org/what-a-waste/trends_in_solid_waste_management.html). Intentional SMW handling and utilisation are usual processes in the countries with high- and average-income levels. As a rule, countries with lower incomes use open dumping (allocation) of the SMW. 93% of waste are allocated in the countries with low-income level, while only 2% of waste are allocated in the higher-income countries. Three regions openly toss more than one-half of their generated SMW: the Middle East, North Africa, and South Asia. Practice of the SMW incineration is widely distributed in the developed countries, in the higher-income countries, as well as in the countries with small/limited territories.

In accordance with calculations (taking into consideration volume of the generated SMW, their composition, and method of the SMW handling), in 2018, 1.6 billion tons of the greenhouse gas emissions in carbon dioxide (CO2) equivalent were generated due to allocation of the SMW (this volume is equal to 5% of the general volume of emissions). In principle, this fact is connected with allocation of waste at the open landfills and other landfills, which are not equipped with the systems for collection of the landfill gas. Food waste generates almost 50% of emissions. It is expected that volume of those emissions, which are connected with the SMW, will increase up to 2.38 billion tons (CO2-equivalent) for a twelvemonth by 2050, if there would be no any improvements in this sector (Cohen et al. 2017; Cervelin and De Boni 2019).

As of today, the East Asia includes the more rapidly developing economies in the world as concerns volumes of the generated SMW. It is expected that generation of waste in the urban areas of Asia in the near future will achieve 1.8 million tons per day (The World Bank 2016). In 2004, China has exceeded the USA as the most powerful generator of the SMW in the world. The Chinese government has developed a number of laws and plans of development, which are connected with the SMW handling. In accordance with the data of the World Bank, by 2030, volume of the SMW, which would be generated in China, will achieve 1.6 million tons per day. The most share of waste in China is delivered to landfills or to the uncontrolled dumping sites outside of great cities. Landfills of China are overfilled. Therefore, cities apply technologies of the SMW incineration in order to generate electric power (Rubbish 2015). According to the existing forecasts, quantity of plants for the SMW incineration within the entire China will increase from 93 in 2009 up to 250 in 2020, thus increasing daily indicators of decrease in the accumulated SMW from 55.4 up to 140 tons. However, there is increase in the public concernment in respect of the environmental indicators of the plants, which are intended for incineration of waste, as well as in respect of their influence upon the environment and health of population (Food Waste et al. 2014; Martins et al. 2018).

As concerns the countries of the European Union, it should be noted that they are in the permanent search of new procedures and methods of management of handling of the solid municipal waste and these countries develop joint policy in this sphere. Level of waste recycling and utilisation in the countries of the European Union varies in the range from 60 up to 95%. In such countries as Denmark, Sweden, Belgium, Netherlands, Germany, and Austria, lesser than 5% of the solid municipal waste are subject to burial ground disposal, 35% are recycled, 15% are directed to composting and generation of the biogenic gas, while the rest share of the SMW is directed to incineration plants (https://eurlex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:52014PC0397). Table 1 presents specific features of the SMW handling systems in certain countries of the EU.

Table 1 Specific features of the waste handling in certain countries of the EU (Navrotsky 2016)
Full size table

The Republic of Kazakhstan has introduced programme for modernisation of the system for management of the solid municipal waste for the period from 2014 to 2050 (https://greenkaz.org/images/for_news/pdf/npa/programma-modernizacii-tbo.pdf). This system was developed on the basis of the Concepts of transition of the Republic of Kazakhstan to the “green economy” for the period from 2014 to 2020 (https://tengrinews.kz/zakon/pravitelstvo_respubliki_kazahstan_premer_ministr_rk/hozyaystvennaya_deyatelnost/id-P1300000750). Strategy of this programme is as follows: increase in efficiency, reliability, ecological suitability, and social acceptability of the package of services (collection, transportation, utilisation, recycling, and burial ground disposal of the solid municipal waste); increase in share of the SMW recycling; assurance of the safe burial ground disposal of waste.

The programme, which was proposed, envisages the following: (1) improvement of the SMW recycling system; (2) recultivation of the existing SMW landfills and construction of new SMW landfills, which comply with the modern requirements of sanitary regulations in respect of the comprehensive infrastructure of acceptance, sorting, recycling, and burial ground disposal of the SMW; (3) modernisation of the entire system of the SMW collection and transportation; (4) general introduction of separate waste collection from educational institutions; (5) improvement of the system of dangerous municipal waste recycling; (6) introduction and systematic increase in recycling of the solid municipal waste within the framework and in accordance with the principles and concepts of development of the “green economy”; (7) general introduction of separate collection of dangerous waste from educational institutions; (8) improvement of the system of recycling of dangerous municipal waste; (9) general introduction of separate collection of the oversize bulky waste from educational institutions; (10) improvement of the system for treatment of other municipal waste; (11) improvement of the system for utilisation of the automobile tyres and used motor vehicles.

The most part of the above-listed tasks of the programme regulate the problems, which are connected with the life cycle of the SMW, namely from the moment of their generation to the moment of their delivery to the place of utilisation, site of burial ground disposal, or place of recycling. That is, these problems create joint specific logistic system (conventional name of this system: “from waste generator to the waste user”) along with the main components of this system: collection and transportation of waste, routes of transportation, destination points of waste delivery. As of today, problem of interaction between these components (in respect of development of the logistic system for the SMW handling) is investigated insufficiently and it requires detailed analysis and research. Then, it would be possible to determine the goal and tasks of the entire investigation.

Goal of this article is to develop the efficient logistic system of handling of the solid municipal waste through development of the relevant models and algorithms of transportation of waste from the places of their generation to the places of their utilisation and recycling.

Goals of the investigation are as follows:

  • to analyse the main directions, strategies, and mechanisms in order to ensure solving the problems, which are connected with the solid municipal waste, with the waste transportation and utilisation;

  • to develop model of the logistic system for the waste handling in general form;

  • to formulate the comprehensive model of processes for development of the efficient logistic system for collection and transportation of waste to the places of its utilisation and recycling, as well as to make mathematical description of this model;

  • to develop algorithm for selection of the optimal carrier of the solid municipal waste on the basis of the multi-criteria analysis.

2 Literature review

Problem of the SMW handling is sufficiently diversified. It includes the problem of the SMW allocation (waste burial, open dumping, recycling, and utilisation), use of the SMW as the sources of heat and electric power, and so on. Therefore, it is important to analyse modern approaches, mechanisms, directions, as well as scientific approaches to solving the problem of the SMW accumulation on a worldwide scale.

Wright et al. (2011) states that the key component of the governmental efforts (which are aimed at increase in volumes of recycling and utilisation of waste) of any country is development of the governmental programmes. Haupt et al. (2017) describes analysis of material flows within the Swiss system of the waste management, as well as programme processes of the waste handling. In Switzerland, one-half of the solid municipal waste is recycled, while the second half is thermally treated in order to generate electric power. In addition, this article presents assessment of contribution of the integrated management of the SMW to the closed cycle of economy.

Bajdor and Grabara (2013) describe technology of introduction of the process of thermal treatment of waste in Czestochowa city (Poland). In order to implement this process, it is necessary to make essential changes in organisation of logistical processes of the waste handling over the entire city. This project of the SMW handling will help to decrease influence upon environment and to improve heat and electric power supply of this city. This investigation was continued later on, and these processes are described in Albores et al. (2016).

Kunelbayev et al. (2017) describes analysis of the problems, which are connected with the search of alternative power sources. Despite the fact that this article is devoted to generation of the biogenic gas from the animal pus, the proposed technology can be useful procedure for the SMW landfills.

Demajorovic et al. (2016) and Oliveira Neto et al. (2018) have determined certain main problems and prospects, which are connected with introduction of the reverse logistics in Brazil. The programmes of the waste handling, which were developed on the basis of investigations, are innovation programmes for the countries of South America.

Sukholthaman and Sharp (2016) describes assessment of influence of the efficient separation of funding sources upon the waste collection and transportation. Such assessment is ensured by the special tool: the decision-making support procedure. This tool helps to understand cause–effect relations of various variables within the system of the SMW management in Bangkok, Thailand.

The model, which was proposed in the Esmaeiliana et al. (2018), recommends taking into consideration the data on the life cycle of the products in the sphere of the waste management and handling. In addition, it was proposed to use technologies of the data tracking and exchange in order to ensure discussion of problems of the SMW management. Banguera et al. (2017) presents analysis of various modern structures, methodologies, and mathematical models for solving the problem of the reverse logistics. These methodologies and models are connected with the existing difficulties in the course of the products return, inventory management, and decision-making. Authors of this article have separated four main stages, which deserve attention, namely waste storage, collection, sorting, and utilisation of waste. It is emphasised that taking into consideration of the above-named of aspects in the course of investigation of problems of the reverse logistics will help to achieve the best understanding of the life cycle of the products, paying attention to the environmental, economical, and social influence.

Zacho and Mosgaard (2016) is devoted to determination of those methods, which ensure increase in the population’s interest in the problem of the SMW generation and ensure provision of the public with information on environmental and social programmes. These programmes will be task-oriented procedures, which will motivate people in households to decrease volumes of the generated waste. Glouche et al. (2016) presents procedure of development and introduction of the system, which helps people to sort and utilise the SMW in proper manner. Authors of the article Rybova and Slavik (2016) have assessed influence of the demographic changes upon the dynamics of the SMW generation in the Czech Republic. Results of this assessment have shown that demographic changes explain only 4% of all changes in the structure of the SMW generation of the Czech Republic.

Goulart Coelho et al. (2017) presents review of the multi-criteria approaches to the decision-making procedure in the course of management of the SMW handling. These authors state that selection of the multi-criteria method of the decision-making procedure is a difficult task, because of there exist several approaches to the decision-making procedure. Each approach uses many various criteria, each of which has a great quantity of variants, application of which depends on availability of information and on the goal of investigation. On the basis of the relevant investigations, propositions were made for the future work operations in this sphere. Bilqis et al. (2018) is devoted to the reverse-logistical processes in the course of development of the efficient management of the waste of production enterprises of the Nigerian companies. Rehman et al. (2017) and Hosseini et al. (2015) are devoted to investigation of the problem of the reverse logistics in the course of the waste management, including management of the SMW in the automobile and construction industries (Rehman et al. 2017; Hosseini et al. 2015). The multi-criteria and multi-factor analyses were used in these articles.

The author team of Gutierrez et al. (2015) has shown, in which manner integration of the Internet technologies (hereinafter to be referred to as the IT) with data access networks and with geographical information systems (GIS) can help to improve systems of the SMW management in cities, as well as in which manner combinatorial optimisation and electronic engineering can promote improvement of the municipal systems of the SMW management. This scenario is practically implemented with the help of the open data, which were provided by the city of Copenhagen (Denmark). This solution is based on provision of special trash containers with the artificial intelligence facilities due to the Internet of Things prototype (IoT), which is in-built to the containers along with the sensors that can read, collect, and transfer information concerning volume of the accumulated trash through the Internet. These data, which would be included to the relevant space–time context and be processed with the help of algorithms of optimisation of the theory of graphs, can be used for dynamic and efficient management of strategies of the waste collection and utilisation. Similar system was proposed in Lata and Singh (2016), namely development of the “trash container with artificial intelligence”. This container will be technologically equipped with proper facilities for sending information on the level of overfilling of trash containers to the node of the relevant coordinator. Due to such intelligence and information approach and due to utilisation of relevant facilities, responsible local authorities will have possibilities to take further steps for removal the SMW from containers. Lundin et al. (2017) has proposed to use the sensor, which will make it possible to improve monitoring and collection of waste from the containers, which are intended for the SMW. This system consists of the wireless modules, which use ultrasonic sensors for measurement of the empty space in the trash containers, as well as the device that sends information to the server, which analyses received data.

Use of the technologies, which were proposed in the Gutierrez et al. (2015), Lata and Singh (2016), Lundin et al. (2017), will make it possible to optimise processes of the waste collection, to decrease probability of overfilling of the trash containers, as well as to improve (in principle) operation of the logistic system, which is intended for the SMW handling.

The author team of Kartava et al. (2014) states that integration of environmental principles to the strategic planning of logistics, coordination of the ecological management at the strategic, commercial, functional, and organisational levels, as well as detailed hierarchy of the decision-making procedure in the logistical processes will make it possible to implement strategy of the ecological logistics in the course of development of regional programmes of the SMW handling. Kotsiuba (2017) is also devoted to the environmental aspect of the logistic system of the SMW handling. The article analyses role of the logistical processes in decreasing volumes of the SMW and in achievement of relevant economic, social, and environmental goals. This article emphasises importance of the ecological and environmental information.

Jalil et al. (2016) is devoted to research of interaction between the system of the SMW generation and the system, which is intended for solving problems of the reverse-logistical processes in the sphere of the SMW utilisation. The article contains empirical conclusions concerning two-phase, multi-methodological approach, which includes successive inductive and deductive investigations. Analysis has revealed essential interaction between situational and personality factors, particularly, demographic factors, which influence upon the SMW generation (that is, factor of population was revealed).

Bearzotti et al. (2017) is devoted to development of the conceptual system of the decision-making support (DSS), which makes it possible to ensure efficient interaction between great companies, which generate solid municipal waste within the city (for example, restaurants, medical and educational institutions, food markets) and those companies, which are situated outside the city limits and which are responsible for utilisation of waste (special landfills, compost companies, utilisation companies, and waste incineration plants). The DSS proposes detailing both the process of the SMW collection and further processes, which are necessary for existence of the entire SMW handling system.

Therefore, analysis of the existing literature sources confirms that there exists permanent scientific search of mechanisms for solving the problem of the SMW handling. Scientists argue that it is necessary to ensure permanent improvement of the already existing methods of the SMW handling. The approaches, which were already developed for the reverse-logistical processes, do not provide detailed recommendations in respect of development of the efficient logistic systems of the SMW handling. Reverse logistics envisages direct processes for transfer of the used commodities to the points of their recycling. However, problems of the transport logistic system for the SMW handling are more complex. They include all interconnected processes and stages of the life cycle of the SMW. As of today, it is possible to state that problem of the SMW collection and delivery to the destination points of utilisation with the least possible environmental and economic losses is unsolved. Therefore, it is the topical problem, which needs attention of the scientific community and relevant investigations.

3 Materials and methods

The following methods of investigation were used in this article: analysis and synthesis, analytical simulation, systems theory (investigation of properties and factors of influence upon the volume of the SMW accumulation; development of model of the logistic system of handling of the solid municipal waste in general form) (Sadovsky 1974); comparison and analogy, generalisation and abstraction; theory of graphs and theory of sets, theory of transport systems and theory of transport logistics (comprehensive model of the processes for development of the efficient logistic system for collection and transportation of waste to the places of its utilisation and recycling; mathematical description of this model) (Smehov 1995; Diestel 2005; Ziuziun 2017); system analysis, parametric analysis, method of construction of morphological matrices, method of the multi-criteria analysis, method of the expert appraisal (determination of the criteria for selection of the SMW carrier and assessments of these criteria) (Diestel 2005; Sharapov 2003); project management (planning and development of further logistical projects of the SMW transportation) (Ziuziun 2017).

Now let us to form the step-by-step algorithm of our investigation (Fig. 1) on the basis of the above-named methods.

Fig. 1
figure 1

Step-by-step algorithm of investigation

Full size image

In order to determine the most optimal and important criteria, it is necessary to organise and perform relevant expert appraisal. Therefore, it is necessary to select the following experts: officials and employees of various municipal departments, who are engaged in the sphere of the waste handling, ecologist-experts, and representatives of the public, who are users of services of one or another carrier. Such expert appraisal shall be performed in accordance with the scale of relative weights of various criteria (Table 2).

Table 2 Scale of relative weights of various criteria (Ziuziun 2017)
Full size table

4 Results and discussion

In order to ensure detailed presentation of the comprehensive interrelations between logistical activity of the condition of management of the system of the SMW handling and the environmental consequences and losses, which are connected with this system, we have to construct model of the logistic system of handling of the solid municipal waste in general form (Fig. 2). In addition, it is necessary to develop the comprehensive model, which would characterise all the processes that are necessary for development of the efficient logistic system for the waste collection and transportation to the places of their utilisation and recycling. Figure 3 presents this comprehensive model.

Fig. 2
figure 2

Model of the logistic system of handling of the solid municipal waste in general form

Full size image
Fig. 3
figure 3

Comprehensive model of processes for development of the efficient logistic system for collection and transportation of waste to the places of its utilisation and recycling

Full size image

Taking into consideration that environmental influences in the course of transportation of the solid municipal waste occur (for the most part) due to those operations, which are connected with the transport and warehouse activity (waste allocation), it is necessary to take into consideration environmental influences in the course of the waste warehousing, transportation, and logistics of the information activity (IT). The proposed model (Fig. 3) can be equally used for output movement of material flows (classic logistics in respect of supplies of resources and materials), as well as for the reverse flows over the chain of deliveries (logistics of waste).

It is possible to separate three blocks of additive components within the proposed model. These additive components determine development of the efficient logistic system (ELS) for handling of the solid municipal waste. From the mathematical point of view, it is possible to describe the proposed comprehensive model with the help of the aggregate of sets (1):

$${\text{ELS}} = \left\{ {\begin{array}{*{20}l} {A = \left( {A_{1} ,A_{2} ,A_{3} ,A_{4} ,A_{5} ,A_{6} ,A_{7} ,A_{8} ,A_{9} } \right)} \hfill \\ {B = \left( {B_{1} ,B_{2} ,B_{3} ,B_{4} ,B_{5} ,B_{6} ,B_{7} ,B_{8} ,B_{9} ,B_{10} } \right)} \hfill \\ {C = \left( {C_{1} ,C_{2} ,C_{3} ,C_{4} ,C_{5} ,C_{6} ,C_{7} ,C_{8} ,C_{9} } \right)} \hfill \\ \end{array} } \right.$$
(1)

The first block is characterised by the set A = (A1, A2, A3, A4, A5, A6, A7, A8, A9), which determines specific features of organisation of material flows. The following notations are used within this block: A1—structure of deliveries, A2—efficiency of the transportation route, A3—loading capacity, A4—efficiency of use of the motor vehicle during transportation, A5—factor of reverse routes and their relative weight in the system, A6—classification of motor vehicles (volume of ton/km per vehicle, weight, and kind of vehicle), A7—quantity of road traffic congestions, A8—spatial structure of deliveries, and A9—warehousing and recycling of the solid municipal waste.

The second block is characterised by the set B = (B1, B2, B3, B4, B5, B6, B7, B8, B9, B10), which takes into consideration environmental influences that can be determined by the output environmental and economic indicators, as well as by monetary value. The following notations are used within this block: B1—volume of the waste, which was warehoused or utilised, B2—volume of the waste, which was transported by motor vehicles, B3—volume of the waste, which was shipped (tons), B4—general volume of the waste, which was transported, ton-km, B5—general quantity of transport routes, which are connected with the solid municipal waste, ton-km, B6—influence of the logistic system of the SMW upon the traffic congestions in the city, B7—energy consumption, B8—power of external sources, B9—noise, vibration, road traffic accidents, other accidents, and B10—other contaminating materials.

Interconnection between input material flows (the SMW) and output economic indicators (taking into consideration influence of the logistical activity upon a number of the main parameters of environment) is characterised by the third block of indicators, which includes the set of nine key parameters of analysis of the logistical process

$$C = \, (C_{1} ,C_{2} ,C_{3} ,C_{4} ,C_{5} ,C_{6} ,C_{7} ,C_{8} ,C_{9} ).$$

In order to ensure analysis of the kind of transport (C1), it is necessary to determine share of the SMW, which are transported by various kinds of transport. The obtained results are normalised for certain kinds of transport. This model characterises transportation of waste with the help of the goods-carrying lorries, which are used as the main method of the waste delivery within the borders of a country (because of many countries use river and sea transport facilities for the SMW transportation). Factor of the average use of transport (C2) is determined as the ratio of the SMW weight to the quantity of the loading-and-unloading operations taking into consideration the fact that various SMW can be loaded to various means of transportation several times within one and the same logistical chain. Average length of route (C3) is the average length of each section within the logistical chain of deliveries (on the condition of recalculation of the SMW weight in metric tons (tons) and in tonne-kilometres (ton-km). Average load on the route (C4) and average percentage of empty running (C5) are two key parameters, which characterise level of utilisation of the transport vehicle. As a rule, average load is measured taking into consideration the transport vehicle weight. However, in the situations, where average density of freight is decreased due to various objective reasons, then these parameters are determined by dimensions of motor vehicle. In the situations, where SMW contains great quantity of filtrate, it is advisable to determine volume of the transport vehicle. Energy efficiency (C6) is characterised as the ratio of the route length to the power, which is consumed. This parameter is determined as the function of characteristics of the transport vehicle, driving style/behaviour of the relevant driver, and traffic conditions.

Emissions per unit of power (C7) include volumes of CO2, CO, CH, and other contaminating substances (as of today, it is very important to take into consideration emissions of formaldehydes), which are generated per unit of the power consumed. This parameter can change depending on kind of power/fuel, characteristics of engine during transformation of this power in the course of logistical activity [driving, heating, cooling, information processes (IT)], as well as on the motor vehicle exhaust gases from its filtration system. In order to perform the comprehensive assessment, it is necessary to take into consideration emissions of various contaminating substances.

There also exist additional external factors of influence of single transport vehicle upon the unit of productivity. These factors do not take into account the functions, which are connected with consumption of power (C8). These factors can be determined as social and environmental effects, for example, noise, vibrations, and road accidents. In addition, they can be determined in absolute values or they can be determined in respect of transport vehicles taking into consideration processing capacity of various landfills, sorting stations, and utilisation plants.

Total monetary estimate of various factors, which exert influence upon the environment (C9), is the final stage in the course of assessment of influence of the logistics processes upon the environment, which is expressed in monetary terms. Money is the equivalent general measure, which makes it possible to compare various influences upon the environment. In addition, such monetary estimate makes it possible to determine, whether ecological expenses comply with the taxes, which are levied from the logistical activity.

Therefore, we have developed the comprehensive model, which ensures introduction of the efficient logistic system taking into consideration environmental factors of the SMW transportation. This model makes let us to separate three blocks of the key indicators, adjustment of which makes it is possible to ensure essential decrease in influence of the logistical activity upon the environment, as well as to increase efficiency of the entire logistic system.

Selection of carrier is one of the most important stages in the course of development of the logistic system for handling the solid municipal waste. Carrier is the key object within the logistic system of the SMW handling. Therefore, in order to ensure proper selection of the relevant carrier, it is necessary to take into consideration great quantity of various parameters and criteria.

In order to determine relevant criteria and parameters for selection of the optimal carrier, which would be capable of ensuring development of the efficient logistic system for the SMW handling, we will apply method of parametric analysis, which is a component of the system analysis.

Functional components of the system, which ensures “selection of carrier”, include many various criteria: material-and-technical, legislative, economical, environmental, professional, social, and exploitative ones. In respect of each functional component, Table 3 presents the main parameters, which exert influence upon achievement of the established goal: proper selection of relevant carrier.

Table 3 Parametric analysis of the logistic system for the SMW handling in order to determine relevant criteria for proper selection of relevant carrier
Full size table

Now let us construct (with the help of the above-listed criteria) the morphological matrix of the relevant criteria for selection of the optimal carrier in the course of development of the efficient logistic system for handling of the solid municipal waste (Table 4).

Table 4 Morphological matrix of the criteria for selection of the SMW carrier
Full size table

It is possible to present all these criteria (in accordance with their conventional designations, which are shown in Table 3) and the matrix from Table 4 in the form of the aggregate of the morphological sets (2)

$$\left\{ {\begin{array}{*{20}l} {x_{1.1} ;x_{1.2} ;x_{1.3} ;x_{1.4} ;x_{1.5} ;x_{1.6} ;x_{1.7} } \hfill \\ {x_{2.1} ;x_{2.2} ;x_{2.3} ;x_{2.4} ;x_{2.5} ;x_{2.6} ;x_{2.7} ;x_{2.8} } \hfill \\ {x_{3.1} ;x_{3.2} ;x_{3.3} ;x_{3.4} ;x_{3.5} } \hfill \\ {x_{4.1} ;x_{4.2} ;x_{4.3} } \hfill \\ {x_{5.1} ;x_{5.2} ;x_{5.3} ;x_{5.4} ;x_{5.5} ;x_{5.6} } \hfill \\ {x_{6.1} ;x_{6.2} ;x_{6.3} ;x_{6.4} ;x_{6.5} ;x_{6.6} } \hfill \\ {x_{7.1} ;x_{7.2} ;x_{7.3} ;x_{7.4} ;x_{7.5} ;x_{7.6} x_{7.7} ;x_{7.8} ;x_{7.9} ;x_{7.10} ;x_{7.11} ;x_{7.12} } \hfill \\ \end{array} } \right.$$
(2)

In principle, in order to determine the criteria, which can be more important in the course of selection of the optimal carrier, it is necessary to perform relevant expert appraisal. Therefore, we will perform such expert appraisal through questioning of the officials and employees of various municipal departments, who are engaged in the sphere of the waste handling, ecologist-experts, and representatives of the public, who are users of services of carriers. We perform this expert appraisal with the help of the questioning technology, as well as with the help of the relative weights of criteria (Table 2).

Table 5 presents results of the expert appraisal.

Table 5 Table of results of the expert appraisal of the criteria for selection of the carrier for development of the efficient logistic system for handling of the SMW
Full size table

On the basis of the data of the expert appraisal (Table 4), it is possible to present the optimal package of the criteria with the help of the following morphological model (3):

$$\left[ \begin{gathered} \left( {x_{1.1} ;x_{1.3} ;x_{1.7} } \right) + \left( {x_{2.1} ;x_{2.2} ;x_{2.5} } \right) + \left( {x_{3.1} ;x_{3.3} ;x_{3.4} } \right) \hfill \\ + \left( {x_{4.1} ;x_{4.3} } \right) + \left( {x_{5.1} ;x_{5.2} ;x_{5.6} } \right) + \left( {x_{6.1} ;x_{6.2} } \right) + \left( {x_{7.1} ;x_{7.2} } \right) \hfill \\ \end{gathered} \right]$$
(3)

Therefore, the optimal carrier must be the carrier, which has the purpose-built vehicle (X1.1) that is equipped with the GPS-control (X1.3); which has own sorting station (X1.7); and which has certificate of conformity of service (X2.1), permit for removal of domestic waste (X2.2), and permits, which were issued by relevant local authorities (X2.5). In addition, motor vehicles of this carrier must generate minimal emissions of the contaminating substances, they must be sources of minimal noise and vibration loads (X3.1) and minimal environmental-and-economical load (X3.3), and these motor vehicles must not create any pollution of the neighbouring territories (X3.4). The carrier’s company must not have any debts (X4.1), and it must have possibility for future investments (X4.3). The carrier must have the staff consisting of the experienced (X5.1) and qualified employees (X5.2), and the carrier must not have violations of law, which were registered by the Environmental Inspectorate (X5.6). In addition, this carrier must ensure quality (X6.1) and timely (X6.2) removal of waste with the help of new motor vehicles (X7.1) and new containers (X7.4).

Therefore, within this investigation we have developed the comprehensive model of the logistic system for the SMW handling, as well as algorithm for selection of carrier, which are equipped with the tools that can be adapted to any reverse-logistical process. These special tools were developed by other researchers. Therefore, it is possible to state that the tools, which we have proposed in this article, form essential addition to the system of mechanisms of the SMW handling of the world.

5 Conclusions

Results of our investigation are as follows: we have developed the comprehensive model of processes for development of the efficient logistic system for collection and transportation of waste to the places of its utilisation and recycling. This model makes it possible to analyse all components of chains of the logistic system for the SMW handling. In addition, it makes it possible to reveal critical issues, which needs attention in the first turn, namely availability and competency of carriers; availability of enterprises and companies, which are engaged in utilisation and recycling of waste; influence upon the environment; and so on.

The algorithm for selection of the optimal carrier of the SMW has important practical significance. This algorithm is implemented with the help of the multi-criteria analysis and expert appraisal. Application of this algorithm would make it possible to reveal the most important criteria, namely availability of the purpose-built vehicles, containers, sorting stations; emissions of various contaminating substances; environmental-and-economical load upon the environment; as well as quality of the services, which are provided, and observance of the schedule of servicing. In addition, the following criteria are very important: life duration: availability of new equipment and new motor vehicles; term of operation of transport vehicles. Availability of own repair station and washing plant is very important criterion for normal functioning of the logistical enterprise, which is engaged in solving problems that are connected with the SMW transportation.

In the course of future investigations, it would be reasonable to pay attention to the routes of transportation of the solid municipal waste and to the structure of these routes depending on the city planning. These routes have to be laid down outside the inhabited locality limits in the maximum possible degree, and they must exert minimum influence upon the environment. At the same time, they must be very short in order to prevent economic losses of the carrier. Therefore, it is necessary to find out relevant balance between the ecological (green technologies) and economical components at the stage of development of logistical routes of the SMW transportation. It is important problem, which needs deepened analysis and further scientific investigations.