Abstract
With marine biodiversity conservation the primary goal for reserve planning initiatives, a site's conservation potential is typically evaluated on the basis of the biological and physical features it contains. By comparison, socio-economic information is seldom a formal consideration of the reserve system design problem and generally limited to an assessment of threats, vulnerability or compatibility with surrounding uses. This is perhaps surprising given broad recognition that the success of reserve establishment is highly dependent on widespread stakeholder and community support. Using information on the spatial distribution and intensity of commercial rock lobster catch in South Australia, we demonstrate the capacity of mathematical reserve selection procedures to integrate socio-economic and biophysical information for marine reserve system design. Analyses of trade-offs highlight the opportunities to design representative, efficient and practical marine reserve systems that minimise potential loss to commercial users. We found that the objective of minimising the areal extent of the reserve system was barely compromised by incorporating economic design constraints. With a small increase in area (<3%) and boundary length (<10%), the economic impact of marine reserves on the commercial rock lobster fishery was reduced by more than a third. We considered also how a reserve planner might prioritise conservation areas using information on a planning units selection frequency. We found that selection frequencies alone were not a reliable guide for the selection of marine reserve systems, but could be used with approaches such as summed irreplaceability to direct conservation effort for efficient marine reserve design.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
M. Mangel, L.M. Talbot, G.K. Meffe, T. Agardi and P.K. Dayton, Principles for the conservation of wild living resources, Ecol. Appl. 6(2) (1996) 338–362.
C.M. Roberts, G. Branch, R.H. Bustamante, J.C. Castilla, J. Dugan, B. Halpern, K.D. Lafferty, H. Leslie, J. Lubchenco, D. McArdle, M. Ruckelshaus and R.R. Warner, Application of ecological criteria in selecting marine reserves and developing reserve networks, Ecol. Appl. 13(1) (2003) S215–S228.
M.T. Agardy, Advances in marine conservation, the role of marine protected areas, Trends Ecol. Evol. 9 (1994) 267–270.
F. Badalamenti, A.A. Ramos, E. Voultsiadou, S. Lizaso, G. D'Anna, C. Pipitone, J. Mas, J.A. Ruiz Fernandez, D. Whitmarsh and S. Riggio, Cultural and socio-economic impacts of Mediterranean marine protected areas, Environ. Conserv. 27(2) (2000) 110–125.
N.R.C. Marine Protected Areas: Tools for Sustaining Ocean Ecosystems. Committee on the Evaluation, Design and Monitoring of Marine Reserves and Protected Areas in the United States. Ocean Studies Board Commission on Geosciences, Environment, and Resources. National Research Council. National Academy Press 2001.
U.R. Sumaila, S. Guenette, J. Alder and R. Chuenpagdee, Addressing ecosystem effects of fishing using marine protected areas, ICES J. Mar. Sci. 57(3) (2000) 752–760.
C.P. Dahlgren and J. Sobel, Designing a dry Tortugas ecological reserve: how big is big enough?...to do what?, Bull. Mar. Sci. 66 (3) (2000) 707–719.
R.J. Carleton, Coastal-marine protected areas: agonies of choice, Aquat. Conserv.: Mar. Freshw. Ecosyst. 9 (1999) 607–614.
W.J. Ballantine, Marine reserves in New Zealand. The development of the concept and the principles. KORDI, Korea: Paper for Workshop on MPAs November (1999).
D.P. Faith and P.A. Walker, Integrating conservation and development: effective trade-offs between biodiversity and cost in the selection of protected areas, Biodivers. Conserv. 5 (1996) 431–446.
P. Ticco, The use of marine protected areas to preserve and enhance marine biological diversity: a case study approach, Coast. Manage. 23 (1995) 309–314.
R.L. Pressey, S. Ferrier, C.D. Hutchinson, D.P. Sivertsen and G. Manion, Planning for negotiation: using an interactive geographic information system to explore alternative protected area networks, in: Nature Conservation 4: The Role of Networks, eds. D.A. Saunders, J.L. Craig and E.M. Mattiske (Surrey Beatty & Sons, 1995) pp. 23–33.
G. Kelleher and R. Kenchington, Guidelines for Establishing Marine Protected Areas. A Marine Conservation and Development Report (IUCN, 1992).
M. Mangel, Trade-offs between fish habitat and fishing mortality and the role of reserves, Bull. Mar. Sci. 66(3) (2000) 663–674.
G.W. Allison, J. Lubchenco and M.H. Carr, Marine Reserves are necessary but not sufficient for marine conservation, Ecol. Appl. 8(Suppl.) (1998) S79–S92.
S. Jennings and M.J. Kaiser, The effects of fishing on marine ecosystems, Adv. Mar. Biol. 34 (1998) 201–350.
F. Chapin, E.S. Zavaleta, V.T. Eviners, R.L. Naylor, P.M. Vitousek, H.L. Reynolds, D.U. Hooper, S. Lavorel, O.E. Sala, S.E. Hobbie, M.C. Mack and S. Diaz, Consequences of changing biodiversity, Nature 405 (2000) 234–242.
J.W. Milon, Pastures, fences, tragedies and marine reserves, Bull. Mar. Sci. 66(3) (2000) 901–916.
T. Polacheck, Year around closed areas as a management tool, Nat. Resour. Model 4(3) (1990) 327–354.
D.S. Holland and R.J. Brazee, Marine reserves for fisheries management, Marin. Resour. Econ. 11 (1996) 157–171.
M.J. Fogarty, Essential habitat, marine reserves and fishery management, Trends Ecol. Evol. 14(4) (1999) 133–134.
A. Hastings and L.W. Botsford, Equivalence in yield from marine reserves and traditional fisheries management, Science 284 (1999) 1537–1538.
D.S. Holland, A bioeconomic model of marine sanctuaries on Georges Bank, Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 57 (2000) 1307–1319.
J.N. Sanchirico and J.E. Wilen, A bioeconomic model of marine reserve creation, J. Environ. Econ. Manage. 42 (2001) 257–276.
J.N. Sanchirico and J.E. Wilen, Bioeconomics of spatial exploitation in a patchy environment, J. Environ. Econ. Manage. 37 (1999) 129–150.
M.D. Smith and J.E. Wilen, Economic impacts of marine reserves: the importance of spatial behaviour, J. Environ. Econ. Manage. 46 (2003) 183–206.
G.N. Tuck and H.P. Possingham, Marine protected areas for spatially structured exploited stocks, Mar. Ecol., Prog. Ser. 192 (2000) 89–101.
T. Lauck, C.W. Clark, M. Mangal and G.R. Munro, Implementing the precautionary principle in fisheries management through marine reserves, Ecol. Appl. 8(Suppl. 1) (1998) S72–S78.
A. Ando, J. Camm, S. Polasky and A. Solow, Species distributions, land values, and efficient conservation, Science 279(5359) (1998) 2126–2128.
M. McDonnell, H.P. Possingham, I.R. Ball and E. Cousins, Mathematical methods for spatially cohesive reserve design, Environ. Model. Assess. 7(2) (2002) 107–114.
R.L. Pressey and A.O. Nicholls, Efficiency in conservation evaluation: scoring versus iterative approaches, Biol. Conserv. 50 (1989) 199–218.
S. Freitag, A.O. Nicholls and A.S. van Jaarsveld, Nature reserve selection in the Transvaal, South Africa: what data should we be using, Biodivers. Conserv. 5 (1996) 685–698.
A.S.L. Rodrigues, R. Tratt, B.D. Wheeler and K.J. Gaston, The performance of existing networks of conservation areas in representing biodiversity, Proc. R. Soc. Lond., Ser. B. Biol. Sci. 266 (1999) 1453–1460.
M.B. Araujo, Distribution patterns of biodiversity and the design of a representative reserve network in Portugal, Divers. Distrib. 5 (1999) 151–163.
R.L. Pressey, Ad hoc reservations – Forward or backward steps in developing representative reserve systems, Conserv. Biol. 8(3) (1994) 662–668.
M. Bedward, R.L. Pressey and D.A. Keith, A new approach for selecting fully representative reserve networks – Addressing efficiency, reserve design and land suitability with an iterative analysis, Biol. Conserv. 62(2) (1992) 115–125.
R.L. Pressey, H.P. Possingham, V.S. Logan, J.R. Day and P.H. Williams, Effect of data characteristics on the results of reserve selection algorithms, J. Biogeogr. 26(1) (1999) 179–191.
R.L. Pressey, C.J. Humphries, C.R. Margules, R.I. Vane-Wright and P.H. Williams, Beyond opportunism – Key principles for systematic reserve selection, Trends Ecol. Evol. 8(4) (1993) 124–128.
R.R. Stewart, T. Noyce and H.P. Possingham, Opportunity cost of ad hoc marine reserve design decisions: an example from South Australia, Mar. Ecol., Prog. Ser. 253 (2003) 25–38.
S. Ferrier, Pressey RL and Barrett TW. A new predictor of the irreplaceability of areas for achieving a conservation goal, its application to real-world planning, and a research agenda for further refinement, Biol. Conserv. 93 (2000) 303–325.
R.L. Pressey, I.R. Johnson and P.D. Wilson, Shades of irreplaceability – Towards a measure of the contribution of sites to a reservation goal, Biodivers. Conserv. 3(3) (1994) 242–262.
Government of South Australia, Our Seas and Coasts: A Marine and Estuarine Strategy for South Australia. The Marine and Estuarine Steering Committee for the South Australian Government (1998).
M. Cabeza and A. Moilanen, Design of reserve networks and the persistence of biodiversity, Trends Ecol. Evol. 16(5) (2001) 242–248.
G.W. Allison, S. Gaines, J. Lubchenco and H.P. Possingham, Ensuring persistence of marine reserves: catastrophes require adopting an insurance factor, Ecol. Appl. 13(1) (2003) S8–S24.
H. Leslie, M. Ruckelshaus, I.R. Ball, S. Andelman and H.P. Possingham, Using siting algorithms in the design of marine reserve networks, Ecol. Appl. 13(1) (2003) S185–S198.
I.R. Ball, Mathematical Applications for Conservation Ecology: The Dynamics of Tree Hollows and the Design of Nature Reserves. Ph.D. Thesis Department of Applied Mathematics (University of Adelaide, Adelaide, 2000) p. 179.
I.R. Ball and H.P. Possingham, Marxan v1.8.6. Marine reserve design using spatially explicit annealing. http://www.ecology.uq.edu.au/marxan.htm (2000).
H.P. Possingham, I. Ball and S. Andelman, Mathematical methods for identifying representative reserve networks, in: Quantitative Methods for Conservation Biology, eds. S. Ferson and M. Burgman (Springer, Berlin Heidelberg New York, 2000) pp. 291–306.
L.C. Mendel and J.B. Kirkpatrick, Historical progress of biodiversity conservation in the protected-area system of Tasmania, Australia, Conserv. Biol. 16(6) (2002) 1520–1529.
C.R. Margules and R.L. Pressey, Systematic conservation planning, Nature 405(6783) (2000) 243–253.
C.M. Roberts and J.P. Hawkins, Fully-protected marine reserves: a guide, WWF Endangered Seas Campaign (2000).
Plan Development Team. The potential of marine fishery reserves for reef fish management in the U.S. Southern Atlantic. NOAA Technical Memorandum NMFS-SEFC-261 (1990).
A. Man, R. Law and N.V.C. Polunin, Role of marine reserves in recruitment to reef fisheries; a metapopulation model, Biol. Conserv. 71 (1995) 197–204.
L.W. Botsford, A. Hastings and S.D. Gaines, Dependence of sustainability on the configuration of marine reserves and larval dispersal distance, Ecol. Lett. 4 (2001) 144–150.
IUCN World Parks Congress, Vth IUCN World Parks Congress. 8–17 September 2003. Recommendation 5.22. Durban, South Africa: IUCN, 2003.
R.L. Pressey, H.P. Possingham and C.R. Margules, Optimality in reserve selection and algorithms: when does it matter and how much?, Biol. Conserv. 76 (1996) 259–267.
R.L. Pressey, H.P. Possingham and J.R. Day, Effectiveness of alternative heuristic algorithms for identifying indicative minimum requirements for conservation reserves, Biol. Conserv. 80(2) (1997) 207–219.
R. McGarvey, Estimating historical catches inside state waters of the major Marine Fishing Areas in the South Australian Rock Lobster Fishery. South Australian Research and Development, Aquatic Sciences (2003).
C.D. Buxton and M.J. Smale, Abundance and distribution patterns of three temperate marine reef fish (Teleostei: Sparidae) in exploited and unexploited areas off the Southern Cape Coast, J. Appl. Ecol. 26 (1989) 441–451.
R.C. Babcock, S. Kelly, N.T. Shears, J.W. Walker and T.J. Willis, Changes in community structure in temperate marine reserves, Mar. Ecol., Prog. Ser. 189 (1999) 125–134.
D.C. Zeller and G.R. Russ, Marine reserves: patterns of adult movement of the coral trout (Plectropomus leopardus) Serranidae, Can. J. Fish. Aquatz. Sci. 55 (1998) 917–924.
S. Guenette, T. Lauck and C. Clark, Marine reserves: from Beverton and Holt to the present, Rev. Fish. Biol. Fish. 8 (1998) 251–272.
R.R. Stewart and H.P. Possingham, A framework for systematic marine reserve design in South Australia: a case study, in: Proceedings of the Inaugural World Congress of Aquatic Protected Areas, August 14–17, 2004, eds. J.P. Beumer, A. Brant, D.C. Smith (Cairns, Australia, 2002) pp. 132–143.
R.L. Pressey and S.L. Tully, The cost of ad hoc reservation – a case-study in Western New-South-Wales, Aust. J. Ecol. 19(4) (1994) 375–384.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Stewart, R.R., Possingham, H.P. Efficiency, costs and trade-offs in marine reserve system design. Environ Model Assess 10, 203–213 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10666-005-9001-y
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10666-005-9001-y