Abstract
Past studies on the Racketeering Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act (criminal RICO) are merged with research on organized crime and recently collected information on the presence of informants in appellate cases. After identifying problems associated with the statute since its enactment in 1970, attention is directed toward the place of informants within court proceedings applying criminal RICO. The central finding points to a relatively high presence of informants in such cases. The explanation that follows accounts for the prevalence of informants in RICO cases by combining: (1) the statute’s liberal construction, (2) an increasing acceptance amongst government and law-enforcement officials that the use of informants is essential to the fight against the apparent organized crime threat, and (3) the rationalization that extends from the prosecutorial success that has been documented within the United States and in other countries that have adopted similar forms of legislation.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
P.A. Adler (1985) Wheeling and Dealing: Ethnography of an Upper-Level Drug Dealing and Smuggling Community Columbia University Press New York
J.L. Albini (1971) The American Mafia: Genesis of a Legend Meredith New York
P. Arlacchi (1994) Addio Cosa Nostra: la vita di Tommaso Buscetta Rizzoli Milan
P. Arlacchi (1992) Gli uomini del disonore: la mafia siciliana nella vita del grande pentito Antonio Calderone Arnoldo Mondadori Milan
J. Atkinson (1978) ArticleTitleRacketeer influenced and corrupt organizations, 18 U.S.C §§ 1961–1968: Broadest of the federal criminal statutes Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology 69 1–18
J.P. Barry (1990) ArticleTitleWhen protestors become ‘racketeers’, RICO runs afoul of the first amendment St. John’s Law Review 64 899–916
R. Billingsley T. Nermitz P. Bean (2001) Informers: Policing, Policy, and Practice Willan Portland
G.R. Blakey (1994) RICO: The federal experience (criminal and civil) and an analysis of attacks against the statute R.J. Kelly K-L. Chin R. Schatzberg (Eds) Handbook of Organized Crime in the United States Greenwood Press Westport
G.R. Blakey (1990) ArticleTitleForeword: Debunking RICO’s myriad myths St. John’s Law Review 64 701–724
G.R. Blakey JC Coffee SuffixJr. PE Coffey LG Crontz (1990) ArticleTitleWhat’s next?: The future of RICO Notre Dame Law Review 65 1073–1105
G.R. Blakey R. Goldstock (1980) ArticleTitle‘On the waterfront’: RICO and labor racketeering American Criminal Law Review 17 341–365
Blakey, G.R. and Gettings, B. (1980). Racketeer influenced and corrupt organizations (RICO): Basic concepts–criminal and civil remedies. Temple Law Quarterly 53, pp. 1009–1048.
A. Block (1979) ArticleTitleThe Snowman cometh: Coke in progressive New York Criminology 17 75–99
A. Block (1978) ArticleTitleHistory and the study of organized crime Urban Life 6 455–474
A. Block W.J. Chambliss (1981) Organizing Crime Elsevier New York
R.L. Bourgeois SuffixJr. SP Hennessey J Moore ME Tschupp (2000) ArticleTitleRacketeer influenced and corrupt organizations American Criminal Law Review 37 879–940
C.M. Bradley (1984) ArticleTitleRacketeering and the federalization of crime American Criminal Law Review 22 213–266
J.-P. Brodeur (1992) ArticleTitleUndercover Policing in Canada: wanting what is wrong Crime Law, and Social Change 18 105–136
J.D. Calder (2000) ArticleTitleRICO’s ‘troubled . . . transition’: Organized crime, strategic institutional factors, and implementation delay, 1971–1981 Criminal Justice Review 25 31–75
D.R. Cressey (1969) Theft of the Nation: The Structure and Operations of Organized Crime in America Harper and Row New York
D. DaCosta (1980) ArticleTitleLiberal construction of title IX of the organized crime control act of 1970: Section 904(a) v the doctrine of strict construction Rutgers Law Journal 12 69–97
S. Dash (1970) ArticleTitleThe American bar association’s impact on the organized crime control act of 1970 American Criminal Law Quarterly 9 1–162
J. Dombrink J.W. Meeker (1994) Organized crime in the ‘twilight of the mob’: Groups, enterprise, and legal innovation from 1967–1992 JA Conley (Eds) The 1967 President’s Crime Commission Report: Its Impact 25 Years Later Anderson Cincinnati
R. Ericson (1981) Making Crime: A Study of Detective Work Butterworths Toronto
G. Falcone (1991) Cose di Cosa Nostra Rizzoli Milan
D. Fried (1988) ArticleTitleRationalizing criminal forfeiture Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology 79 328–436
W.R. Geary (2000) ArticleTitleThe creation of RICO: Law as a knowledge diffusion process Crime Law, and Social Change 33 329–367
Goldsmith, M. (1988). “RICO and enterprise criminality: A response to Gerard E. Lynch. Columbia Law Review 88, pp.774–801.
R. Goldstock M Marcus TD Thacher JB Jacobs (1990) Corruption and Racketeering in the New York City Construction Industry: Final Report of the New York State Organized Crime Task Force New York University Press New York
Gravel, S. and Bordelais, S. (1993). Le recours aux délateurs dans le contexte de l’administration de la justice québécoise. Report, International Center for Comparative Criminology, Université de Montréal.
C. Greek (1991) ArticleTitleIs this the end of RICO or only the beginning?: The ongoing debate over the expanded use of criminal and civil RICO. Free Inquiry in Creative Sociology 19 11–22
S. Greer (2001) Where the grass is greener? supergrasses in comparative perspective R. Billingsley T. Nermitz P. Bean (Eds) Informers: Policing, Policy, and Practice Willan Portland
M.H. Haller (1992) ArticleTitleBureaucracy and the mafia: an alternate view Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice 8 1–10
Haller, M.H. (1991). Life Under Bruno: The Economics of an Organized Crime Family. Pennsylvania Crime Commission.
M.H. Haller (1990) ArticleTitleIllegal Enterprise: A Theoretical and Historical Interpretation Criminology 28 207–235
G. Hawkins (1969) ArticleTitleGod and the Mafia The Public Interest 14 24–51
W.J. Hughes (1990) ArticleTitle“RICO Reform: How Much Is Needed Vanderbilt Law Review 43 639–649
F.J. Ianni (1972) A Family Business Russell Sage Foundation New York
J.B. Jacobs C. Friel R. Radick (1999) Gotham Unbound: How New York City Was Liberated from the Grip of Organized Crime New York University Press New York
J.B. Jacobs L.P. Gouldin (1999) Cosa nostra: The final chapter M Tonry (Eds) A Review of Research 25 Crime and Justice University of Chicago Press Chicago
C. Panarella J. Worthington (1994) Busting the Mob: United States v New York University Press Cosa Nostra. New York
R.J. Kelly R. Schatzberg K.-L. Chin (1994) Without fear of retribution: the witness security program R.J. Kelly K-L. Chin R. Schatzberg (Eds) Handbook of Organized Crime in the United States Greenwood Press Westport
D. Kurzweil (1996) ArticleTitleCriminal and civil RICO: Traditional canons of statutory interpretation and the liberal construction cause Columbia Journal of Law and Social Problems 30 41–90
M. Levi A. Smith (2002) A Comparative Analysis of Organised Crime Conspiracy Legislation and Practice and Their Relevance to England and Wales, Home Office Online Report Home Office Research Development and Statistics Directorate London
G.E. Lynch (1990) ArticleTitleA conceptual, practical, and political guide to RICO reform Vanderbilt Law Review 43 769–803
G.E. Lynch (1987a) ArticleTitleRICO: The crime of being a criminal, Parts I and II Columbia Law Review 87 661–764
G.E. Lynch (1987b) ArticleTitleRICO: The crime of being a criminal, Part III and IV Columbia Law Review 87 920–984
G.T. Magarity (1980) ArticleTitleRICO investigations: A case study American Criminal Law Review 17 367–378
P.K. Manning (1980) The Narc’s Game: Organizational and Informational Constraints on Drug Law-Enforcement MIT Press Cambridge
Ministére de la Sécurité publique du Québec (2000). Rapport sur l’utilisation des témoins repentis en 1998. Quebec: Minister of Justice
R.T. Naylor (1997) ArticleTitleMafia, markets, and myths: On the theory and practice of enterprise crime Transnational Organized Crime 3 1–45
R.T. Naylor (1995) ArticleTitle“From cold war to crime war: The search for a new ‘National Security’ threat Transnational Organized Crime 1 37–56
T.S. O’Neill (1989) ArticleTitleFunctions of the RICO enterprise concept Notre Dame Law Review 64 646–721
G.W. Potter (1994) Criminal Organizations: Vice, Racketeering, and Politics in an American City Waveland Press Prospect Heights
InstitutionalAuthorNamePresident’s Commission on Law Enforcement Administration of Justice (1967) Task Force Report: Organized Crime. U.S. Government Printing Office Washington, DC
J.G. Randolph (1995) ArticleTitle“RICO–The rejection of an economic motive requirement The Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology 85 1189–1222
R.K. Rasmussen (1990) ArticleTitle“Introductory remarks and a comment on civil RICO’s remedial provisions Vanderbilt Law Review 43 623–637
T.G. Reed (1990) ArticleTitle“The defense case for RICO reform Vanderbilt Law Review 43 691–733
P. Reuter (1983) Disorganized Crime: The Economics of the Invisible Hand MIT Press Cambridge
P. Reuter J. Haaga (1989) The Organization of High-Level Drug Markets: An Exploratory Study Rand Santa Monica
W.L. Schmidt (1980) ArticleTitleThe racketeer influenced and corrupt organizations act: an analysis of the confusion in its application and a proposal for reform Vanderbilt Law Review 33 441–480
A.J. Schreiber (2001) ArticleTitleDealing with the devil: an examination of the FBI’s troubled relationship with its confidential informants Columbia Journal of Law and Social Problems 34 301–369
J.H. Skolnick (1966) Justice Without Trial: Law Enforcement in Democratic Society John Wiley & Sons New York
D.C. Smith (1975) The Mafia Mystique Basic Books New York
N. South (2001) Informers, agents, and accountability R. Billingsley T. Nermitz P. Bean (Eds) Informers: Policing, Policy, and Practice Willan Portland
Woods, J.G. and Beare, M. (1984). La Loi sur les R.I.C.O.. Special Report, Solicitor General of Canada.
M. Zalman (1994) The influence of the courts task force report JA Conley’s (Eds) The 1967 President’s Crime Commission Report: Its Impact 25 Years Later Anderson Cincinnati
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
We would like to thank Pierre Tremblay and Marie-Andrée Bertrand for their comments and suggestions on past versions of this paper. We also show our gratitude to Gerard Lynch for his help during early phases of this research.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Morselli, C., Kazemian, L. Scrutinizing RICO. Crit Crim 12, 351–369 (2004). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10612-004-3880-0
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10612-004-3880-0