Abstract
Outbreeding has been shown to decrease fitness in a variety of species, including several species of fish. An understanding of the general outcomes following outbreeding is required in order to understand the consequences of conservation-related actions and hybridization in aquaculture. A meta-analysis was conducted on outbreeding studies in fishes using 670 comparisons between parent populations and their hybrid progeny. Five hundred and seventy-six comparisons involved first generation hybrids (F1), and a much smaller number (94) involved second generation hybrids (F2). The overall response to outbreeding in the F1 and F2 generations was positive and significant (F1: d *i+ = 0.425 ± 0.121; F2: d *i+ = 0.548 ± 0.295, where d *i+ is the effect size of studies within generations); however, responses differed when studies were separated into groups describing the experimental environment, taxon, or trait. Findings may be biased by a few studies of large effect. Genetic distance explained little of the variance in effect sizes across studies. Results of the meta-analysis suggest that there is no reliable predictor for the effects of outbreeding in fishes, although inconsistencies in experimental design were noted across studies. Future research should include comparisons in both parental environments in order to detect the underlying mechanisms of outbreeding depression, and should focus on measurement of equivalent sets of fitness-related traits. Experimental design should permit estimation of genetic distances based on quantitative traits, which may in turn be meaningful predictors of the outcomes of outbreeding depression. Concerted and consistent research in this area will provide information of relevance to conservation, aquaculture and evolutionary studies.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Allendorf FW, Leary RF, Spruell P, Wenburg JK (2001) The problems with hybrids: setting conservation guidelines. Trends Ecol Evol 16:613–622
Allendorf FW, Thorgaard GH (1984) Tetraploidy and the evolution of salmonid fishes. In: Turner BJ (ed) Evolutionary genetics of fishes. Plenum Press, New York, pp 1–53
Andersen DH, Pertoldi C, Scali V, Loeschcke V (2002) Intraspecific hybridization, developmental stability and fitness in Drosophila mercatorum. Evol Ecol Res 4:603–621
Aspi J (2000) Inbreeding and outbreeding depression in male courtship son characters in Drosophila montana. Heredity 84:273–282
Bams RA (1976) Survival and propensity for homing as affected by presence or absence of locally adapted paternal genes in two transplanted populations of pink samon (Oncorhynchus gorbuscha). J Fish Res Board Can 33:2716–2725
Beacham TD, Withler RE, Murray CB, Barner LW (1988) Variation in body size, morphology, egg size, and biochemical genetics of pink salmon in British Columbia. Trans Am Fish Soc 117:109–126
Beckman BR, Larsen DA, Moriyama S, Lee-Pawlak B, Dickhoff WW (1998) Insulin-like growth factor-I and environmental modulation of growth during smoltification of spring chinook salmon (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha). Gen Comp Endocrinol 109:325–335
Burton RS (1987) Differentiation and integration of the genome in populations of the marine copepod Tigriopus californicus. Evolution 41:504–513
Carvalho GR (1993) Evolutionary aspects of fish distribution: genetic variability and adaptation. J Fish Biol 43:53–73
Chakraborty R, Leimar O (1987) Genetic variation within a subdivided population. In: Ryman N, Utter F (eds) Population genetics and fishery management. University of Washington Press, Seattle, pp 89–120
Chiyokubo T, Shikano T, Nakajima M, Fujio Y (1998) Genetic features of salinity tolerance in wild and domestic guppies (Poecilia reticulata). Aquaculture 167:339–348
Clarke WC, Withler RE, Shelbourn JE (1992) Genetic control of juvenile life history pattern in chinook salmon (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha). Can J Fish Aquat Sci 49:2300–2306
Cohen J (1969) Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences. Academic Press, New York
Coltman DW, Slate J (2003) Microsatellite measures of inbreeding: a meta-analysis. Evolution 57:971–983
Cooke SJ, Kassler TW, Philipp DP (2001) Physiological performance of largemouth bass related to local adaptation and interstock hybridization: implications for conservation and management. J Fish Biol 59:248–268
Cooke SJ, Philipp DP (2005) Influence of local adapatiation and interstock hybridization on the cardiovascular performance of largemouth bass Micropterus salmoides. J Exp Biol 208:2055–2062
Crnokrak P, Roff DA (1999) Inbreeding depression in the wild. Heredity 83:260–279
de Innocentiis S, Sola L, Cataudella S, Bentzen P (2001) Allozyme and microsatellite loci provide discordant estimates of population differentiation in the endangered dusky grouper (Epinephelus marginatus) within the Mediterranean Sea. Mol Ecol 10:2163–2175
Devlin RH (1993) Sequence of sockeye type I and type 2 growth hormone genes and the relationships of rainbow trout with Atlantic and Pacific salmon. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 54:1865–1872
Dowling TE, Secor CL (1997) The role of hybridization and introgression in the diversification of animals. Annu Rev Ecol Syst 28:593–619
Edmands S (1999) Heterosis and outbreeding depression in interpopulation crosses spanning a wide range of divergence. Evolution 53:1757–1768
Edmands S (2002) Does parental divergence predict reproductive compatibility? Trends Ecol Evol 17:520–527
Edmands S, Feaman HV, Harrison JS, Timmerman CC (2005) Genetic consequences of many generations of hybridization between divergent copepod populations. J Hered 96:114-123
Edmands S, Harrison JS (2003) Molecular and quantitative trait variation within and among populations of the intertidal copepod Tigriopus californicus. Evolution 57:2277–2285
Edmands S, Timmerman CC (2003) Modeling factors affecting the severity of outbreeding depression. Conserv Biol 17:883–892
Einum S, Fleming IA (1997) Genetic divergence and interactions in the wild among native, farmed and hybrid Atlantic salmon. J Fish Biol 50:634–651
Emlen JM (1991) Heterosis and outbreeding depression: a multilocus model and an application to salmon production. Fish Res 12:187–212
Falconer DS, Mackay TFC (1996) Introduction to quantitative genetics. Prentice Hall, San Francisco
Fenster CB, Galloway LF (2000) Inbreeding and outbreeding depression in natural populations of Chamaecrista fasciculata (Fabaceae). Conserv Biol 14:1406–1412
Fleming IA, Gross MR (1990) Latitudinal clines: a trade-off between egg number and size in Pacific salmon. Ecology 71:1–11
Fleming IA, Hindar K, Mjolnerod IB, Jonson B, Balstad T, Lamberg A (2000) Lifetime success and itneractions of farm salmon invading a native population. Proc R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 267:1517–1523
Foote CJ, Wood CC, Clarke WC, Blackburn J (1992) Circannual cycle of seawater adaptability in Oncorhynchus nerka: genetic differences between sympatric sockeye salmon and kokanee. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 49:99–109
Foote CJ, Wood CC, Withler RE (1989) Biochemical genetic comparison of sockeye salmon and kokanee, the anadromous and nonanadromous forms of Oncorhynchus nerka. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 46:149–158
Frankham R (1999) Quantitative genetics in conservation biology. Genet Res 74:237–244
Frankham R, Ballou JD, Briscoe DA (2002) Introduction to conservation genetics. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Gausen D, Moen V (1991) Large-scale escapes of farmed Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) in Norwegian rivers threaten natural populations. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 48:426–428
Gerber AS, Tibbets CA, Dowling TE (2001) The role of introgressive hybridization in the evolution of the Gila robusta complex (Teleostei: Cyprinidae). Evolution 55:2028–2039
Gharrett AJ, Smoker WW (1991) Two generations of hybrids between even- and odd-year pink salmon (Oncorhynchus gorbuscha): a test for outbreeding depression? Can J Fish Aquat Sci 48:1744–1749
Gharrett AJ, Smoker WW, Reisenbichler RR, Taylor SG (1999) Outbreeding depression in hybrids between odd- and even-broodyear pink salmon. Aquaculture 173:117–129
Gilk SE, Wang IA, Hoover CL, Smoker W, Taylor SG, Gray AK, Gharrett AJ (2004) Outbreeding depression in hybrids between spatially separated pink salmon, Oncorhynchus gorbuscha, populations: marine survival, homing ability, and variability in family size. Environ Biol Fishes 69:287–297
Gjerde B, Reddy PVGK, Mahaptra KD, Saha JN, Jana RK, Meher PK, Sahoo M, Lenka S, Govindassamy P, Rye M (2002) Growth and survival in wo complete diallele crosses with five stocks of Rohu carp (Labeo rohita). Aquaculture 209:103–115
Granath KL, Smoker W, Gharrett AJ, Hard JJ (2004) Effects on embryo development time and survival of intercrossing three geographically separate populations of southeast Alaska coho salmon, Onchorynchus kistuch. Environ Biol Fishes 69:299–306
Gurevitch J, Hedges LV (1999) Statistical issues in ecological meta-analysis. Ecology 80:1142–1149
Gurevitch J, Hedges LV (2001) Meta-analysis: combining the results of independent experiments. In: Scheiner SM, Gurevitch J (eds) Design and analysis of ecological experiments. Chapman and Hall, New York, pp 378–398
Gurevitch J, Morrow LL, Wallace A, Walsh JS (1992) A meta-analysis of competition in field experiments. Am Nat 140:539–572
Hatfield T (1997) Genetic divergence in adaptive characters between sympatric species of stickleback. Am Nat 149:1009–1029
Hatfield T, Schluter D (1999) Ecological speciation in sticklebacks: environment-dependent hybrid fitness. Evolution 53:866–873
Hayward RS, Wang HP (2002) Inherent growth capacity and social costs of Bluegill and hybrids of Bluegill and Green Sunfish: which fish really grows faster? N Am J Aquac 64:34–46
Hedgecock D, Davis JP (2000) Improving Pacific oyster broodstock through crossbreeding. J Shellfish Res 19:614–615
Hedges LV, Olkin I (1985) Statistical methods for meta-analysis. Academic Press Inc., San Diego
Hedrick PW (1999) Perspective: highly variable loci and their interpretation in evolution and conservation. Evolution 53:313–318
Heschel MS, Paige KN (1995) Inbreeding depression, environmental stress, and population size variation in scarlet gilia (Ipomopsis aggregata). Conserv Biol 9:126–133
Hindar K, Ryman N, Utter F (1991) Genetic effects of cultured fish on natural fish population. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 48:945–955
Hordvik I, Lindstrom CD, Voie AM, Jacob ALJ, Endresen C (1997) Structure and organization of the immunoglobulin M heavy chain genes in Atlantic salmon, Salmo salar. Mol Immunol 34:631–639
Johnsson JI, Clarke WC, Withler RE (1993) Hybridization with domesticated rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) reduces seasonal variation in growth of steelhead trout (O. mykiss). Can J Fish Aquat Sci. 50:480–487
Kalinowski ST (2002) Evolutionary and statistical properties of three genetic distances. Mol Ecol 11:1263–1273
Krueger CC, Perkins DL, Everett RJ, Schreiner D, May B (1994) Genetic variation in naturalized rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) from Minnesota tributaries to Lake Superior. J Great Lakes Res 20:299–316
Lachance S, Magnan P (1990) Performance of domestic, hybrid and wild strains of brook trout, Salvelinus fontinalis, after stocking: the impact of intra- and interspecific competition. Can J Fish Aquat Sci. 47:2278–2284
Land ED, Lacy RC (2000) Introgression level achieved through Florida panther genetic restoration. Endanger Species Update 17:99–103
Leary RF, Allendorf FW, Knudsen KL (1985) Developmental instability and high meristic counts in interspecific hybrids of salmonid fishes. Evolution 39:1318–1326
Leberg PL (1993) Strategies for population reintroduction: effects of genetic variability on population growth and size. Conserv Biol 7:194–199
Linder CR, Taha I, Seiler GJ, Snow AA, Rieseberg LH (1998) Long-term introgression of crop genes into wild sunflower populations. Theor Appl Genet 96:339–347
Lynch M (1991) The genetic interpretation of inbreeding depression and outbreeding depression. Evolution 45:622–629
Lynch M (2000) The limits to knowledge in quantitative genetics. Evol Biol 32:225–237
Lynch M, Walsh B (1998) Genetics and analysis of quantitative traits. Sinauer Associates, Inc., Sunderland Massachusetts
Marengoni NG, Onoue Y, Oyama T (1998) Offspring growth in a diallele crossbreeding with three strains of Nile tilapia Oreochromis niloticus. J World Aquacult Soc 29:114–119
Matthews MA, Poole WR, Thompson CE, McKillen J, Ferguson A, Hindar K, Wheelan KF (2000) Incidence of hybridization between Atlantic salmon, Salmo salar L., and brown trout, Salmo trutta L., in Ireland. Fish Manag Ecol 7:337–347
McClelland EK, Myers JM, Hard JJ, Park LK, Naish KA (2005) Two generations of outbreeding in coho salmon (Oncorhynchus kisutch): effects on size and growth. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 62:2538–2547
McKay JK, Latta RG (2002) Adaptive population divergence: markers, QTL and traits. Trends Ecol Evol 17:285–291
Miller LM, Close T, Kapuscinski AR (2004) Lower fitness of hatchery and hybrid rainbow trout compared to naturalized populations in lake Superior tributaries. Mol Ecol 13:3379–3388
Mitchell M (2002) Engauge digitizer v 2.14 available at http://www.digitizersourceforge.net
Moller AP, Thornhill R (1997) A meta-analysis of the heritability of developmental stability. J Evol Biol 10:1–16
Montalvo AM, Ellstrand NC (2001) Nonlocal transplantation and outbreeding depression in the subshrub Lotus scoparius (Fabaceae). Am J Bot 88:258–269
Nakadate M, Shikano T, Taniguchi N (2003) Inbreeding depression and heterosis in various quantitative traits of the guppy, Poecilia reticulata. Aquaculture 220:219–226
Nguenga D, Teugels GG, Ollevier F (2000) Fertilization, hatching, survival and growth rates in reciprocal crosses of two strains of an African catfish Heterobranchus longifilis Valenciennes 1940 under controlled hatchery conditions. Aquac Res 31:565–573
Nilsson J (1993) Arctic charr strain crosses: effects on growth and sexual maturity. J Fish Biol 43:163–171
O’Hara RB, Merila J (2005) Bias and precision in Q(ST) estimates: problems and some solutions. Genetics 171:1331–1339
Orwin RG (1983) A fail-safe N for effect size in meta-analysis. J Educ Stat 8:157–159
Osenberg CW, Sarnelle O, Cooper SD, Holt RD (1999) Resolving ecological questions through meta-analysis: goals, metrics, and models. Ecology 80:1105–1117
Parker KM, Sheffer RJ, Hedrick PW (1999) Molecular variation and evolutionarily significant units in the endangered gila topminnow. Conserv Biol 13:108–116
Pelabon C, Carlson ML, Hansen TF, Armbruster WS (2005) Effects of crossing distance on offspring fitness and developmental stability in Dalechampia scandens (Euphorbiaceae). Am J Bot 92:842–851
Perry GML, Audet C, Bernatchez L (2005) Maternal genetic effects on adaptive divergence between anadromous and resident brook charr during early life history. J Evol Biol 18:1348–1361
Petersson E, Jarvi T, Steffner NG, Ragnarsson B (1996) The effect of domestication on some life history traits of sea trout and Atlantic salmon. J Fish Biol 48:776–791
Pfrender ME, Spitze K, Hicks J, Morgan K, Latta L, Lynch M (2000) Lack of concordance between genetic diversity estimates at the molecular and quantitative-trait levels. Conserv Genet 1:263–269
Quilichini A, Debussche M, Thompson JD (2001) Evidence for local outbreeding depression in the Mediterranean island endemic Anchusa crispa Viv. (Boraginaceae). Heredity 87:190–197
Quinton CD, McKay LR, McMillan I (2004) Strain and maturation effects on female spawning time in diallele crosses of three strains of rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss). Aquaculture 234:99–110
Reed DH, Frankham R (2001) How closely correlated are molecular and quantitative measures of genetic variation? A meta-analysis. Evolution 55:1095–1103
Reisenbichler RR, Rubin SP (1999) Genetic changes from artificial propagation of Pacific salmon affect the productivity and viability of supplemented populations. ICES J Mar Sci 56:459–466
Rhymer JM, Simberloff D (1996) Extinction by hybridization and introgression. Annu Rev Ecol Syst 27:83–109
Roff DA, Mousseau TA (1987) Quantitative genetics and fitness – lessons from Drosophila. Heredity 58:103–118
Rogers SM, Gagnon V, Bernatchez L (2002) Genetically based phenotype–environment association for swimming behavior in lake whitefish ecotypes (Coregonus clupeaformis Mitchill). Evolution 56:2322–2329
Rosenberg MS (2005) The file-drawer problem revisited: a general weighted method for calculating fail-safe numbers in meta-analysis. Evolution 59:464–468
Rosenthal R (1991) Meta-analytic procedures for social research. Sage Publications, London
Rosenthal R (1995) Writing meta-analytic reviews. Psychol Bull 118:183–192
Shearer KD, Swanson P (2000) The effect of whole body lipid on early sexual maturation of 1+ age male chinook salmon (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha). Aquaculture 190:343–367
Sheffer RJ, Hedrick PW, Velasco AL (1999) Testing for inbreeding and outbreeding depression in the endangered Gila topminnow. Anim Conserv 2:121–129
Shikano T, Taniguchi N (2002a) Heterosis for neonatal survival in the guppy. J Fish Biol 60:715–725
Shikano T, Taniguchi N (2002b) Relationships between genetic variation measured by microsatellite DNA markers and fitness-related trait in the guppy (Poecilia reticulata). Aquaculture 209:77–90
Smoker WW, Wang IA, Gharrett AJ, Hard JJ (2004) Embryo survival and smolt to adult survival in second-generation outbred coho salmon. J Fish Biol 65:254–262
Spitze K (1993) Population structure in Daphnia obtusa: quantitative genetic and allozymic variation. Genetics 135:367–374
Tallmon DA, Luikart G, Waples RS (2004) The alluring simplicity and complex reality of genetic rescue. Trends Ecol Evol 19:489–496
Tave D, Smitherman RO, Jayaprakas V, Kuhlers DL (1990) Estimates of additive genetic effects, maternal genetic effects, individual heterosis, maternal heterosis and egg cytoplasmic effects for growth in Tilapia nilotica. J World Aquacult Soc 21:263–270
Taylor EB (1991) A review of local adaptation in Salmonidae, with particular reference to Pacific and Atlantic salmon. Aquaculture 98:185–207
Taylor EB, McPhail JD (2000) Historical contingency and ecological determinism interact to prime speciation in sticklebacks, Gasterosteus. Proc R Soc Biol Sci Ser B 267:2375–2384
Teel DJ, Milner GB, Winans GA, Grant WS (2000) Genetic population structure and origin of life history types in chinook salmon in British Columbia, Canada. Trans Am Fish Soc 129:194–209
Templeton AR (1979) The unit of selection in Drosophila mercatorum II. Genetic revolution and the origin of coadapted genomes in parthenogenetic strains. Genetics 92:1265–1282
Templeton AR (1986) Coadaptation and outbreeding depression. In: Soule ME (eds) Conservation biology: the science of scarcity and diversity. Sinauer Associates Inc., Sunderland, pp 105–116
Templeton AR, Hemmer H, Mace GM, Seal US, Shields WM, Woodruff DS (1986) Local adaptation, coadaptation, and population boundaries. Zoo Biol 5:115–125
Tymchuk WE, Biagi CA, Withler RE, Devlin RH (2006) Growth and behavioral consequences of introgression of a domesticated aquaculture genotype into a native strain of coho salmon. Trans Am Fish Soc 135:442–455
Tymchuck WE, Devlin RH (2005) Growth differences among first and second generation hybrids of domesticated and wild rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss). Aquaculture 245:295–300
Vamosi SM, Hatfield T, Schluter D (2000) A test of ecological selection against young-of-the-year hybrids of sympatric sticklebacks. J Fish Biol 57:109–121
Wallace B (1968) Topics in population genetics. W. W. Norton and Company Inc., New York
Wangila BCC (1994) Electrophoretic characterization of three hatchery-reared strains of rainbow trout, Oncorhynchus mykiss (Walbaum). Aquacult Fish Manag 25:565–570
Wangila BCC, Dick TA (1988) Influence of genotype and temperature on the relationship between specific growth rate and size of rainbow trout. Trans Am Fish Soc 117:560–564
Waples RS (1991) Genetic interactions between hatchery and wild salmonids: lessons from the Pacific Northwest. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 48:124–133
Waser NM (1993) Population structure, optimal outbreeding, and assortative mating in angiosperms. In: Thornhill NW (ed) The natural history of inbreeding and outbreeding. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp 173–199
Waser NM, Price MV, Shaw RG (2000) Outbreeding depression varies among cohorts of Ipomopsis aggregata planted in nature. Evolution 54:485–491
Wessel M, Smoker WW, Fagen RM, Joyce J (2006) Variation in agonistic behavior among juvenile Chinook salmon (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha) of hatchery, hybrid and wild origin. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 63:438–447
Westemeier RL, Brawn JD, Simpson SA, Esker TL, Jansen RW, Walk JW, Kershner EL, Bouzat JL, Paige KN (1998) Tracking the long-term decline and recovery of an isolated population. Science 282:1695–1698
Willi Y, Van Buskirk J (2005) Genomic compatibility occurs over a wide range of parental genetic similarity in an outcrossing plant. Proc R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 272:1333–1338
Wolf FM (1986) Meta-analysis: quantitative methods for research synthesis. SAGE Publications, Beverly Hills
Acknowledgments
We would like to thank the following for providing data for this study; Dr. B. Gjerde, AKVAFORSK, for providing data from Gjerode et al. 2002; and Dr. L. Miller for providing data from Miller et al. 2004. We would also like to thank three anonymous referees whose suggestions have greatly improved this manuscript.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
McClelland, E.K., Naish, K.A. What is the fitness outcome of crossing unrelated fish populations? A meta-analysis and an evaluation of future research directions. Conserv Genet 8, 397–416 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10592-006-9178-x
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10592-006-9178-x