Abstract
We analyze the interaction of climate and development policy that has taken place since the early 1990s. Increasing dissatisfaction about the results of traditional development cooperation and the appeal of climate policy as a new policy field led to a rapid reorientation of aid flows. At the turn of the century, over 7% of aid flows were spent on greenhouse gas emissions mitigation. However, the contribution of emissions mitigation projects to the central development objective of poverty reduction as specified in the Millennium Development Goals is limited and other project types are likely to be much more effective. Adaptation to climate change can be expected to have higher synergies with poverty alleviation than mitigation, primarily through its impact on health, the conservation of arable land and the protection against natural disasters. An analysis of the Clean Development Mechanism shows that projects addressing the poor directly are very rare; even small renewable energy projects in rural areas tend to benefit rich farmers and the urban population. Use of development aid for CDM projects and / or their preparation via capacity building is thus clearly not warranted. We further analyze whether the use of development aid for climate policy could be justified as a countermeasure against the emission increase related to successful development itself. However, countries that are achieving an improvement of human development from a low level are unlikely to increase their energy consumption substantially. Only at a level where the middle class expands rapidly, energy consumption and greenhouse gas emissions soar. Thus targeting middle class energy consumption by appliance efficiency standards and public transport-friendly urban planning are the most effective measures to address developing country emissions. Rural renewable energy provision in poor countries has a much higher impact on poverty, but a much lower impact on greenhouse gas emissions. We conclude that while there are valid reasons for long-term collaboration with emerging economies on greenhouse gas mitigation, there should be a separate budget line for such activities to avoid “obfuscation” of a decline of resources aimed at poverty alleviation. Nevertheless, mitigation will remain attractive for donors because it ensures quick disbursements and relatively simple measures of success. Moreover, mitigation activities in developing countries provide politicians in industrialized countries with a welcome strategy to divert the attention of their constituencies from the lack of success in reducing greenhouse gas emissions domestically.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
AfDB et al. (2003) Poverty and climate change: reducing the vulnerability of the poor through adaptation. World Bank Group, Washington
Altenburg T, Holger L, Michaelowa A, Scholz I (2005) Thesenpapier zum DIE-Workshop ‘Energie- und klimapolitische Kooperation mit Ankerländern’ am 7.7.2005 in Bonn (Theses for workshop ‘Cooperation with anchor countries in energy and climate policy”), German Institute of Development, Bonn, mimeo
Barter P, Kenworthy J (1997) Urban transport and land use patterns challenges and opportunities of high density cities in East and Southeast Asia, Working Paper No. 81, Asia Research Centre, Murdoch University, Perth
Bernard J-M, Simon O, Vianou K (2005) Le redoublement: mirage de l’école africaine?, (Grade repetition: mirage of the African school?), PASEC/CONFEMEN, Dakar
Berthélemy J-C (2006) Bilateral donors interest vs. recipients development motives in aid allocation: do all donors behave the same?. Rev Dev Econ 10(2):179–194
Berthélemy J-C, Tichit A (2004) ‘Bilateral donors’ aid allocation decisions: A three-dimensional panel analysis. Int Rev Econ Finance 10(2):253–274
Bourdon J, Frölich M, Michaelowa K (2006) Broadening access to primary education: contract teacher programs and their impact on education outcomes in Africa – an econometric evaluation for the Republic of Niger. In: Menckhoff L (ed) Pro-poor growth: issues, policies, and evidence. Duncker & Humblot, Berlin, pp117–149
Caparrós A, Pereau J-C (2005) Climate change abatement and development aid in North–South differential games, mimeo, Madrid
Cling J-P, Roubaud F (2002) The PRSP initiative: old wine in new bottles?, mimeo, DIAL/IRD, Paris, http://www.dial.prd.fr/dial_evenements/conf_scientifique/pdf/abcde2002/razafindrakoto.pdf (accessed on 6/10/05)
Danida (2004) Environmental strategy. Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Denmark, Copenhagen
Dutschke M, Michaelowa A (2006) Development assistance and the CDM – how to interpret ‘financial additionality.’ Environ Dev Econ 11(2):235–246
Easterly W (2002) The cartel of good intentions: markets vs. bureaucracy in foreign id, Working Paper No. 4, Center for Global Development, Washington
GEF (2005a) Achieving the millennium development goals: a GEF progress report, Washington, http://www.theGRF.org (accessed on 3/10/05)
GEF (2005b) GEF data base, http://www.gefonline.org/projectList.cfm (accessed on 7/10/05)
Glewwe P, Kremer M (2006) Schools, teachers, and education outcomes in developing countries. In: Hanushek E, Welch F (eds) Handbook on the economics of education, vol. 2. Elsevier, New York, pp 945–1017
Klasen S (2004) In search of the holy grail: How to achieve pro-poor growth?. In: Krakowski M (ed) Attacking poverty, What makes growth pro-poor?, HWWA Studies, no. 75. Nomos, Baden–Baden, pp 89–119
Lahiri S, Michaelowa K (eds) (2006) ‘The political economy of aid,’ Special edition of the Review of Development Economics 10(2): 177–178
Menzel U (1992) Das Ende der Dritten Welt und das Scheitern der großen Theorie (The end of the Third World and the failure of the grand theory). Suhrkamp, Frankfurt
Michaelowa A (2005) Carbon capture and geological storage research – a capture by fossil fuel interests?. In: Sugiyama T (ed) Struggles for global framework beyond Kyoto, IISD, Ottawa, pp 69–129
Michaelowa A (2004) CDM incentives in industrialized countries – the long and winding road. International Review for Environmental Strategies 5(1):217–231
Michaelowa K (2001a) Die Bedeutung von Bildung in Niedrigeinkommensländern: Das Beispiel Afrika (Returns to education in low income countries: evidence for Africa). In: Schubert R (ed) Entwicklungsperspektiven von Niedrigeinkommensländern – zur Bedeutung von Wissen und Institutionen (Development perspectives of low-income countries – the relevance of knowledge and institutions). Duncker&Humblot, Berlin, pp 127–152
Michaelowa K (2001b) Primary education quality in francophone sub-Saharan Africa: determinants of learning achievement and efficiency considerations. World Dev 29(10):1699–1716
Mosley P, Suleiman A (2007) Aid, agriculture and poverty in developing countries. Rev Dev Econ 11(1):139–158
Müller-Pelzer F, Michaelowa A (2005) Experiences from German ODA-financed greenhouse gas reduction and sequestration projects and lessons for the CDM. In: Sugiyama T (ed) Struggles for global framework beyond Kyoto. IISD, Winnipeg, pp 119–129
OECD/DAC (2002a) The DAC guidelines: integrating the Rio conventions into development co-operation, Paris
OECD/DAC (2002b) Aid targeting the objectives of the rio conventions 1998–2000, Paris
OECD/DAC (2004) ODA eligibility of expenditures under the clean development mechanism, DAC/CHAIR(2004)4/FINAL, Paris
OECD/DAC (2005) The DAC journal development co-operation report 2004, 6(1), Paris
Rabinovitch J, Leitman J (1996) Urban planning in Curitiba, a Brazilian City challenges conventional wisdom and relies on low technology to improve the quality of urban life. Scientific American, March 1996, pp 46–53
UN (2005) The millennium development goals report 2005, New York, http://unstats.un.org/unsd/mi/pdf/MDG%20Book.pdf (accessed on 3/10/05)
UNDP (2005) Energizing the millennium development goals, New York
UNFCCC (2005) Clean development mechanism (CDM home), http://cdm.unfccc.int/ (accessed on 7/10/05)
World Bank (2005) World Bank Group progress on renewable energy and energy efficiency: 1990–2004, Washington
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Michaelowa, A., Michaelowa, K. Climate or development: is ODA diverted from its original purpose?. Climatic Change 84, 5–21 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10584-007-9270-3
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10584-007-9270-3