Abstract
Everyday there are revelations of organizations behaving in discreditable ways. Sometimes these actions result in damage to an organization’s reputation, but often they do not. In this article, we examine the question of why external stakeholders may overlook disclosed discreditable actions, even those entailing ethical breaches. Drawing on stigmatization theory, we develop a model to explain the likelihood of reputational loss following revelations of discreditable actions. The model integrates four properties of actions (perceived control, perceived certainty, perceived threat, and perceived deviance), stakeholder motivation, and media coverage. Implications for theory and for practitioners concerned with reputation management are discussed.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Aaker, J. S., S. Fournier and S. A. Brasel: 2004, ‹When Good Brands do Bad’, Journal of Consumer Research 31, 1–16.
Ackman, D.: 2002a, ‹How Andersen Blew It’, Forbes.com, April 29
Ackman, D.: 2002b, ‹Andersen Guilty; Enron Still Unindicted’, Forbes.com, June 17
Ahluwalia, R.: 2002, ‹How Prevalent is the Negativity Effect in Consumer Environments?’, Journal of Consumer Research 29, 270–279.
Akst, D.: 2003, ‹Illegal Immigration: So Harmful and So Beneficial’, New York Times December 7, 2003
Andrade, E. B. and J. B. Cohen: 2007, ‹On the Consumption of Negative Feelings’, Journal of Consumer Research 34, 283–300.
Arpan, L. M. and A. A. Raney: 2003, ‹An Experimental Investigation of News Source and the Hostile Media Effect’, Journalism and Mass Communication Quarterly 80, 265–281.
Ashforth, B. and B. Gibbs: 1990, ‹The Double Edge of Organizational Legitimation’, Organization Science 1, 177–194.
Bansal, P. and I. Clelland: 2004, ‹Talking Trash: Legitimacy, Impression Management, and Unsystematic Risk in the Context of the Natural Environment’, Academy of Management Journal 47, 93–103.
Bargh, J. and M. Ferguson: 2002, ‹Beyond Behaviorism: On the Automaticity of Higher Mental Processes’, Psychological Bulletin 126, 925–945.
Baron, D. P.: 2006, ‹Persistent Media Bias’, Journal of Public Economics 90, 1–36.
Biernat, M. and J. Dovidio: 2000, ‹Stigma and Stereotypes’, in T. Heatherton, R. Kleck, M. Hebl and J. Hull (eds.), The Social Psychology of Stigma (The Guilford Press, New York), pp. 88–125.
Bikhchandani, S., D, Hirshleifer and I. Welch: 1992, ‹A Theory of Fads, Fashion, Custom, and Cultural Change as Informational Cascades’, Journal of Political Economy 100, 992–1026.
Brickman, P., V. C. Rabinowitz Jr., J. Karuza, D. Coates, E. Cohn and L. Kidder: 1982, ‹Models of Helping and Coping’, American Psychologist 37, 368–384.
Celsi, R. and J. Olson: 1988, ‹The Role of Involvement in Attention and Comprehension Processes’, Journal of Consumer Research 16, 210–224.
Chen, S., D. Shechter and S. Chaiken: 1996, ‹Getting at the Truth or Getting Along: Accuracy- Versus Impression-Motivated Heuristic and Systematic Processing’, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 75, 262–275.
Crandall, C. S.: 2000, ‹Ideology and Lay Theories of Stigma: The Justification of Stigma’, in T. Heatherton, R. Kleck, M. Hebl and J. Hull (eds.), The Social Psychology of Stigma (The Guilford Press, New York), pp. 126–150.
Crocker, J., B. Major and C. Steele: 1998, ‹Social Stigma’, in S. Fiske and G. Lindzey (eds.), Handbook of Social Psychology, 4th edition, volume 2 (McGraw-Hill, Boston), pp. 504–533.
Davidson, W. N. III. and D. L. Worrell: 1988, ‹The Impact of Announcements of Corporate Illegalities on Shareholder Returns’, Academy of Management Journal 31, 195–200.
Davidson, W. N. III. and D. L. Worrell: 1992, ‹The Effect of Product Recall Announcements on Shareholder Wealth’, Strategic Management Journal 13, 467–473.
Davidson, W. N. III., D. L. Worrell and C. I. Lee: 1994, ‹Stock Market Reactions to Announced Corporate Illegalities’, Journal of Business Ethics 13, 979–987.
Dignan, L.: 2002, ‹After Andersen, Accounting Worries Stick’, Cnet.com, June 17
Dutton, J., J. Dukerich and C. Harquail: 1994, ‹Organizational Images and Member Identification’, Administrative Science Quarterly 39, 239–263.
Elsbach, K. D.: 1994, ‹Managing Organizational Legitimacy in the California Cattle Industry: The Construction and Effectiveness of Verbal Accounts’, Administrative Science Quarterly 39, 57–88.
Elsbach, K. and R. Sutton: 1992, ‹Acquiring Legitimacy Through Illegitimate Actions: A Marriage of Institutional and Impression Management Theories’, Academy of Management Journal 35, 699–738.
Esch, K.: 2001, ‹PayPal’s Growing Pains’, Fortune Small Business, September 3
Fiol, C. M., E. J. O’Connor and H. Aguinis: 2001, ‹All for One and One for All? The Development and Transfer of Power Across Organizational Levels’, Academy of Management Review 26, 224–242.
Folkes, V. S. and M. Kamins: 1999, ‹Effects of Information About Firms’ Ethical and Unethical Actions on Consumers’ Attitudes’, Journal of Consumer Psychology 8, 243–259.
Folkes, V. S., S. Koletsky and J. Graham: 1987, ‹A Field Study of Causal Inferences and Consumer Reaction: The View from the Airport,’ Journal of Consumer Research 13, 534–539.
Fombrun, C. J.: 1996, Reputation: Realizing Value From the Corporate Image (Harvard Business School Press, Boston).
Gioa, D. and J. Thomas: 1996, ‹Identity, Image and Issue Interpretation: Sensemaking During Strategic Change in Academia’, Administrative Science Quarterly 41, 370–403.
Goffman, E.: 1963, Stigma: Notes on the Management of Spoiled Identity (Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ).
Grant, S. J. and A. M. Tybout: 2008, ‹The Effect of Temporal Frame on Information Considered in New Product Evaluation: The Role of Uncertainty,’ Journal of Consumer Research 34, 897–913.
Hawkins, S. and S. Hoch: 1992, ‹Low-Involvement Learning: Memory Without Evaluation’, Journal of Consumer Research 19, 212–226.
Hudson, B. A.: 2008, ‹Against All Odds: A Consideration of Core-Stigmatized Organizations’, Academy of Management Review 33, 252–266.
Hudson, B. A. and G. A. Okhuysen: 2009, ‹Not With a Ten-Foot Pole: Core Stigma, Stigma Transfer and Improbable Persistence of Men’s Bathhouses’, Organization Science 21, 134–153.
Janiszewski, C.: 1993, ‹Preattentive Mere Exposure Effects’, Journal of Consumer Research 20, 376–393.
Janiszewski, C. and T. Meyvis: 2001, ‹Effects of Brand Logo Complexity, Repetition, and Spacing on Processing Fluency and Judgment’, Journal of Consumer Research 28, 18–32.
Johnson, B. and A. Eagley: 1989, ‹The Effects of Involvement on Persuasion: A Meta-Analysis’, Psychological Bulletin 106, 290–314.
Jones, E., A. Farina, A. H. Hastorof, H. Markus, D. T. Miller and R. A. Scott: 1984, Social Stigma: The Psychology of Marked Relationships (Freeman, New York).
Kane, M.: 2002, ‹eBay maps out Billpoint’s demise’, CNET News.com
Keller, K.: 1993, ‹Conceptualizing, Measuring, and Managing Customer-Based Brand Equity’, Journal of Marketing 57, 1–22.
Krazit, T.: 2003, ‹Futuremark Says Nvidia Didn’t Cheat But Broke Rules’, www.infoworld.com, June 3
Kroloff, G.: 1988, ‹At home and Abroad: Weighing In’, Public Relations Journal, October 8
MacLean, T. L.: 2008, ‹Framing and Organizational Misconduct: A Symbolic Interactionist Study’, Journal of Business Ethics 78, 3–16.
Maheswaran, D.: 1994, ‹Country of Origin as a Stereotype: Effects of Consumer Expertise and Attribute Strength on Product Evaluations,’ Journal of Consumer Research 21, 354–365.
Maheswaran, D. and S. Chaiken: 1991, ‹Promoting Systematic Processing in Low-Involvement Settings: Effect of Incongruent Information on Processing and Judgment’, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 61, 13–25.
Markoff, J.: 2002, ‹VeriSign’s Marketing is Subject of F.T.C. Investigation’, New York Times, August 7, C2
Matta, S. and V. S. Folkes: 2005, ‹Inferences about the Brand from Counterstereotypical Service Providers’ Journal of Consumer Research 32, 196–206.
McQuail, D.: 1984, Mass Communication Theory: An Introduction (Sage, London).
McQuail, D.: 1985, ‹The Sociology of Mass Communications’, Annual Review of Sociology 11, 93–111.
Min, Y.: 2002, ‹Intertwining of Campaign News and Advertising: The Content and Electoral Effects of Newspaper Ad Watches’, Journalism and Mass Communication Quarterly 79, 927–945.
Mizerski, R.: 1982, ‹An Attribution Explanation of the Disproportionate Influence of Unfavorable Information’, Journal of Consumer Research 9, 301–310.
Neuberg, S. L., D. M. Smith and T. Asher: 2000, ‹Why People Stigmatize: Toward A Biocultural Framework’, in T. Heatherton, R. Kleck, M. Hebl and J. Hull (eds.), The Social Psychology of Stigma (The Guilford Press, New York), pp. 31–61.
O’Guinn, T. and L. J. Shrum: 1997, ‹The Role of Television in the Construction of Consumer Reality’, Journal of Consumer Research 23, 278–294.
Overfelt, M.: 2003, ‹4 Great Picks and 2 Misses ….’, Fortune Small Business 13, 42.
Patrizio, A.: 2001, ‹Reviewers Condemn Video Tweaks’, www.wired.com, November 28
Patsuris, P.: 2002, ‹Andersen Clients Evacuate Post-Verdict’, Forbes.com, August 18
Petty, R. E. and J. Cacioppo: 1986, Communication and Persuasion: Central and Peripheral Routes to Persuasion (Springer, New York).
Pozner, J.-E.: 2008, ‹Stigma and Settling Up: An Integrated Approach to the Consequences of Organizational Misconduct for Organizational Elites’, Journal of Business Ethics 80, 141–150.
Rao, H., H. R. Greve and G. F. Davis: 2001, ‹Fool’s Gold: Social Proof in the Initiation and Abandonment of Coverage by Wall Street Analysts’, Administrative Science Quarterly 46, 502–527.
Riffe, D., S. Lacy and F. Fico: 1998, Analyzing Media Messages: Using Quantitative Content Analysis in Research (Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah, NJ).
Schudson, M.: 1978, Discovering the News (Basic Books, New York).
Shah, D. V., M. D. Watts, D. Domke and D. P. Fan: 2002, ‹News Framing and Cueing of Issue Regimes: Explaining Clinton’s Public Approval in Spite of Scandal’, Public Opinion Quarterly 66, 339–370.
Shaughnessy, J. J., E. B. Zechmeister and J. S. Zechmeister: 2006, Research Methods in Psychology, 7th edition (McGraw-Hill, London).
Shoemaker, P. and S. Reese: 1990, ‹Exposure to What? Integrating Media Content and Effects Studies’, Journalism Quarterly 67, 649–652.
Shrum, L. J.: 2002, ‹Media Consumption and Perceptions of Social Reality: Effects and Underlying Processes’, in J. Bryant and D. Zillmann (eds.), Media Effects: Advances in Theory and Research (Lawrence Erlbaum, Mahwah NJ), pp. 69–95.
Skowronski, J. J. and D. E. Carlston: 1987, ‹Negativity and Extremity in Impression Formation: A Review of Explanations’, Psychological Bulletin 105, 131–142.
Squires, S., C. Smith, L. McDougall and W. Yeack: 2003, Inside Arthur Andersen: Shifting Values, Unexpected Consequences (Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ).
Stuart, T. E., H. Hoang and R. Hybels: 1999, ‹Interorganizational endorsements and the performance of entrepreneurial ventures’, Administrative Science Quarterly 44, 315–349.
Suchman, M. C.: 1995, ‹Managing Legitimacy: Strategic and Institutional Approaches’, Academy of Management Review 20, 571.
Sutton, R. and A. Callahan: 1987, ‹The Stigma of Bankruptcy: Spoiled Organizational Image and its Management’, Academy of Management Journal 30, 405–436.
Vaughan, D.: 1999, ‹The Dark Side of Organizations: Mistake, Misconduct, and Disaster’, Annual Review of Sociology 25, 271–305.
Wiesenfeld, B. M., K. Wurthmann and D. C. Hambrick: 2008, ‹The Stigmatization and Devaluation of Elites Associated With Corporate Failures: A Process Model’, Academy of Management Review 33, 231–251.
Wolverton, T.: 2002, ‹Judge Rejects PayPal Arbitration’, Vol. 2002: CNETNews.com
Wood, W.: 2000, ‹Attitude Change: Persuasion and Social Influence’, Annual Review of Psychology 51, 539–570.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Reuber, A.R., Fischer, E. Organizations Behaving Badly: When Are Discreditable Actions Likely to Damage Organizational Reputation?. J Bus Ethics 93, 39–50 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-009-0180-3
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-009-0180-3