Abstract
Under present accounting rules, lessees frequently structure contracts for leased assets, in situations where they enjoy benefits similar to outright ownership, in a way that keeps both the leased assets and related liabilities off their books. This method of accounting creates off-balance sheet financing and is called operating lease accounting. The paper debates the ethicality of intentionally structuring lease contracts to avoid disclosing leased asset and liability amounts and describes the “slippery slope” of rule-based accounting for synthetic leases and special purpose entities, that, in the author’s opinion, led to the accounting debacles at Enron and other companies. The ethical intent that is implicit in the Securities and Exchange Commission and Financial Accounting Standards Board regulations is discussed and suggestions for improving the ethicality of financial reporting are provided.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA) 1986, Restructuring, Professional Standards to Achieve Professional Excellence in a Changing Environment. New York, NY: AICPA
Baldwin, C. Y., C. E. Bagley and J. Quinn: 2003, M&A Legal Context: Basic Framework for Corporate Governance. Harvard Business School Case Study 9-803-200 (Harvard University, Cambridge, MA)
Batson, N.: 2003, Second Interim Report of Neal Batson, Court-Appointed Examiner, Appendix B (Accounting Standards), United States Bankruptcy Court, Southern District of New York, Case No. 01-16034 (AJG), Chapter 11, pp. 9–12
Beaver W. H. 1998, Financial Reporting: An Accounting Revolution, 3rd Edition. Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River, NJ
Bosco, W.: 2006, Lease Accounting: Separating Myth from Reality. Equipment Leasing Association, White Paper
Botoson C. 1997, Disclosure Level and the Cost of Equity Capital. The Accounting Review, 72, 323–349
Botoson C., M. Plumlee 2002, A Re-examination of Disclosure Level and the Expected Cost of Equity Capital. Journal of Accounting Research, 40, 21–41
Brooks, L. J.: 2004, Business and Professional Ethics for Directors, Executives, and Accountants. (South-Western, Mason, OH)
Byrnes, N.: 2006, ‹You May Be Liable for That Lease; FASB’s Review of Lease Accounting Standards Could Really Hammer Retailers’, Business Week, June 5, 2006
Davis-Friday P. Y., T. J. Frecka: 2002, What Managers Should Know About Earnings Management – Its Prevalence, Legality, Ethicality, and Does It Work? Review of Accounting and Finance, 1, 57–71
DePree, C. M. Jr. and C. T. Grant: 1999, ‹Earnings Management and Ethical Decision Making: Choices in Accounting for Security Investments’, Issues in Accounting Education, No 4, November 1999
Dieter, R.: 1979, ‹Is Lessee Accounting Working?’, The CPA Journal, August 1979, pp. 13–19
Duska R. F., B. S. Duska 2003, Accounting Ethics. Blackwell Publishing, Malden, MA
Eichenwald K.: 2005, Conspiracy of Fools. Broadway Books, New York, NY
Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB): 1976, ‹Accounting for Leases’, Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 13 (Norwalk, Connecticut, FASB)
Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB): 1978, ‹Information Useful in Investment and Credit Decisions’, par. 34, Statement of Financial Accounting Concepts No. 1 (Norwalk, Connecticut, FASB)
Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB): 1985, ‹Concept Statement No. 6’, Norwalk, Connecticut: FASB, http://www.fasb.org/articles&reports/revisiting_the_concepts_may_05.pdf
Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) 2005, Revisiting the Concepts. Norwalk, Connecticut: FASB
Fung, A., D. Weil, M. Graham, and E. Fagotto: 2004, The Political Economy of Transparency: What Makes Disclosure Policies Effective? Ash Institute for Democratic Governance and Innovation, Occasional Paper, OP-03-04, December, 2004
Graham B., D. Dodd 1934, Security Analysis. The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc., New York, New York
Hendrickson E. S. 1977, Accounting Theory. Richard D. Irwin, Inc. Homewood, IL
Imhoff E., R. Lipe, D. W. Wright 1991, Operating leases: Impact of constructive capitalization. Accounting Horizons, 5, 51–63
Imhoff E., R. Lipe, D. W. Wright 1993, The effects of recognition versus disclosure on shareholder risk and executive compensation. Journal of Accounting, Auditing, and Finance 8(4), 335–368
Lim, S. C., S. C. Mann and V. T. Mihov: 2003, ‹Market Evaluation of Off-Balance Sheet Financing: You Can Run But You Can’t Hide’. EFMA 2004 Basel Meetings Paper, Universitat Basel, Basel, Switzerland. December, 2003
Lipe R. 2001, Lease Accounting Research and the G4 + 1 Proposal. Accounting Horizons, 15, 299–310
Lubove, S. and E. MacDonald: 2002, ‹Debt? Who, Me?’ Forbes, February 18, 2002
Powers, W. Jr., R. S. Troubh and H. S. Winokur Jr.: 2002, Report of Investigation by the Special Investigative Committee of the Board of Directors of Enron Corp. (Austin, TX)
Reither C. L. 1998, What are the best and worst accounting standards?. Accounting Horizons 12(3), 293–292
Revsine L., D. W. Collins, W. B. Johnson: 2005, Financial Reporting and Analysis, 3rd Edition. Prentice Hall, Old Tappan, New Jersey
Ryan S. G.: 2002, Financial Instruments and Institutions: Accounting and Disclosure Rules. John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Hoboken, New Jersey
Satava D., C. Caldwell, L. Richards 2006, Ethics and the Auditing Culture: Rethinking the Foundation of Accounting and Auditing. Journal of Business Ethics, 64(3), 271–284
Scott W. R. 1997, Financial Accounting Theory. Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River, NJ
Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC): 1999, ‹Materiality’, Staff Accounting Bulletin No. 99. Washington, DC, SEC
Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC): SEC Securities Act of 1933, Section 2. Washington, DC, SEC
Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC): 2005, ‹Report and Recommendations Pursuant to Section 401 (c) of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 on Arrangements with Off-Balance Sheet Implications, Special Purpose Entities and Transparency of Filings by Issuers’ (Washington, DC, SEC)
Shafer W. E., A. A. Ketchand, R. E. Morris 2004, ‹Auditors’ willingness to advocate client-preferred accounting principles. Journal of Business Ethics 52(3), 213–227. p 213
Sheppard, Mullin, Richter & Hampton LLP: 1998, ‹The Synthetic Lease: Off-Balance Sheet Financing of Real Property’, April 10, 1998
Spacek, L.: 1969, A search for fairness in financial reporting to the public (A. Anderson, Chicago, IL)
Verrecchia R. E. 2001, Essays on disclosure. Journal of Accounting and Economics, 32(1–3), 97–180
Wolk H. I., J. L. Dodd, M. G. Tearney: 2004, Accounting Theory, 6th Edition. South-Western, Mason, OH
Wyatt A. R. and J. C. Gaa: 2004, ‹Accounting Professionalism: A Fundamental Problem and the Quest for Fundamental Solutions’, The CPA Journal 74(3), 22–32, Marc 2004
Acknowledgments
Comments provided by Robert Audi, James Fuehrmeyer, Eugene A. Imhoff, Steven E. Kaplan, Fred Mittelstaedt, Patrick E. Murphy, Thomas F. Schaefer, Ann Tenbrunsel and participants in the University of Notre Dame Institute for Ethical Business Worldwide 2006 Conference on Ethical Dimensions In Business are greatly appreciated.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Thomas J. Frecka is the Vincent and Rose Lizzadro Professor of Accountancy at the University of Notre Dame. He teaches financial reporting and accounting fraud courses.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Frecka, T.J. Ethical Issues in Financial Reporting: Is Intentional Structuring of Lease Contracts to Avoid Capitalization Unethical?. J Bus Ethics 80, 45–59 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-007-9436-y
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-007-9436-y